刑法论文-试论法院判决的既判力——对一起历经十年的刑事案件的评析.doc

刑法论文试论法院判决的既判力对一起历经十年的刑事案件的评析内容摘要一起刑事附带民事案件，历时十年，经过基层、中级到高级三级法院七次审理，这场马拉松式的刑事诉讼才终审。在经历三级七审过程中，被告人所受到的刑事处罚是“步步高升”。基层法院判决生效后又被再次起诉并被判以更重的刑罚，其中一名被告人先被基层法院判处13年有期徒刑，后被中级法院判处15年有期徒刑，最后高院终审被判处无期徒刑。本文通过对这一案件的剖析，探讨我国刑事判决的既判力问题。关键词刑事判决既判力TRYTODISCUSSTHEFORCEOFMATTERADJUDGEDOFTHETRIALONCOURTDISCUSSACRIMINALCASEWHICHLASTSFORTENYEARSABSTRACTLASTINGFORTENYEARS,UNTILAFTERTHEBASICUNIT,ASINTERMEDIATESEVENTIMETRIESASTHESENIORTHREELEVELSOFCOURTS,AMARATHONLIKECASEOFCIVILJUDGMENTCOLLATERALTOCRIMINALPROCEEDINGSCOMETOFINALPROCEEDINGSINEXPERIENCINGCRIMINALPROCEDUREFORTHREELEVELSANDSEVENTIMES,THECRIMINALPUNISHMENTFORTHEACCUSEDPERSONRECEIVEDMAYBEREGARDASMAKINGSTEADYPROGRESSAFTERTHEBASICUNITCOURTDECISIONBECOMEEFFECTIVE,WHICHWASSUEDONCEMOREANDWASSENTENCEDBYAHEAVIERPENALTY,WASCONDEMNEDFIRSTBYTHEBASICUNITCOURTFOR13YEAR’SSETTERMOFIMPRISONMENT,LATTERTHEACCUSEDPERSONWASCONDEMNEDBYTHEINTERMEDIATECOURTFOR15YEAR’SSETTERMOFIMPRISONMENT,FINALLYWHICHWASCONDEMNEDTOTHELIFEIMPRISONMENTBYHIGHCOURTTHISARTICLEWILLTHROUGHTHECASEA