影评：屋顶上的小提琴手与阿灵顿公路对比

1、.WarrenProfessor Mark KingAdvanced Writing25 November 2012Comparison and Contrast between Whit Carver andYour HonorWhit Carver is an FBI and he is also the leading role Michael Faradays friend andMichaels deceased wifes colleague. Your Honor is a constable in Russia and a friend of theleading role T

2、evye. They have something in common because of their occupation and socialstatus. They are different because of their background and personalities.Although Whit Carver and Your Honor seem similar because both of them are policeofficer and have a high social status, they actually are different becaus

3、e of their backgroundand personalities. The most important difference is the role they played in the film.Just as I mentioned above, Whit is an FBI and Your Honor is a constable in Russia,both of them have a high social status, both of them are the leading roles friends in the film.Though both of th

4、em appeared a short time in the film, we can still find out that they have ahigh social position. In the film “Fiddler on the Roof”all the people in the small villagerespectYour Honor.After Tevye and Lazar Wolf shake hands and call it a match, Tevyeencounter Your Honor, Tevye bows to Your Honor, fro

5、m this detail we can conclude that YourHonor has a high position in the village. Whit has his own office and he can give orders to theentrance guard to make sure that nobody dangerous enters the building, so we can concludethat Whit also has a high position in the FBI.Both of them are the leading ro

6、lesfriend, are kind and helpful. Your Honor tells;.Tevye something bad will happen to Jew. Heisn twilling to carry out the orders, at thewedding he stops the others destroying, and says“Orders are orders”. So we can concludeYour Honor is a kind and helpful man. Although Whit says he canthelp Michael

7、 run thename of Oliver Lang, but when he meet Michael in the square he tells something he checkedabout Oliver Lang. So we can say he is a kind and helpful man.Though they have something in common, they are two quite different people. Firstlytheir backgrounds are different. Your Honor lives in Russia

8、 in 19 century, while Whit lives inAmerica in 1990s. Second, their personalities are different, though both of them are kind andhelpful. Your Honor is solemn, though he smiles several times in the film, but his smiles arequite unnatural. At other times his facial expression is quite solemn, especial

9、ly when he tellsTevye the bad news and transmits the order which force the Jews into leaving their home inthree days to the Jews. On the contrary, Whit is humorous. When he meets Michael atArlington National Cemetery, he doesntdirectly ask how is Michael doing, he says “How ishis (Michael sson) dad

10、doing? When” Michael requires him to run the name of Oliver Lang,he says if Michael asked his wife Leah to do that, she will refuse as well. And he says“I loveyou baby, but that, I cannot do”.In a feminine way as if he was Leah.As far as I am concerned the biggest difference between them is the role

11、s they playedin the film. Both of them have a dual-identity, a police officer and friend of the leading role.But their functions are quite different in the film. Your Honor is just a messenger; the ordersare not drawn up by him, he must carry out the orders to force the Jew into leaving theirhome al

12、though he isntwilling to do that. He cantchange the Jewsfate, because his poweris limited. While Whit is a very important role in the film, if he doesntknow Michael, the;.explosion will not occur. Because he is Michaels friend, after Michael knows Oliver Langwants to destroy the office building of F

13、BI, Michael comes to the building wants to stop theexplosion. But Michael was set up by Oliver Lang, so the explosion happens. Because of theroles they played in the film are different, they also have different endings. Your Honor is stilla constable in Russia, but Whit died in the explosion.From those above we can find out