论文申辩的心得分享 论文申辩的心得分享 黄迪靖.pdf

論文申辯的心得分享論文申辯的心得分享論文申辯的心得分享論文申辯的心得分享 黃迪靖黃迪靖黃迪靖黃迪靖 ihiiDo not upset or panic when your manuscript is rejected It is common that papers are rejected in the first run Re LF10693 Charge orbital ordering in magnetite measured by resonant soft x ray scatteringx ray scattering by D J Huang H J Lin J Okamoto K S Chao H T Jeng et al DD HDear Dr Huang The above manuscript has been reviewed by one of our referees A critique drawn from the report is enclosed On this basis we judge that the paper is not appropriate for Physical Review Letters but might be suitable for publication in another journal possibly with some revision Therefore we recommend that you submit your manuscript yyp elsewhere Yours sincerely Yours sincerely Samindranath Mitra Associate EditorAssociate Editor Physical Review Letters Email prl ridge aps org F631 591 4141Fax 631 591 4141 http prl aps org Do not upset or panic when your manuscript is rejected It is common that papers are rejected in the For example less than 35 of submitted It is common that papers are rejected in the first run For example less than 35 of submitted papers have been finally accepted for publication in Physical Review Letterspublication in Physical Review Letters Read the referee report carefully and dispassionately Approach the report with an open mind the referee might be helping you hdf Why is your paper rejected Who rejects your paper editor or referee Officially the editors reject your paper In fact Oc a y t e ed to s eject you papeact Writing the rebuttal Clearly response to all recommendations and criticisms of the referee Point by point responses are strongly suggested It is not wise to say the referee is wrong I would say incorrect if the referee were wrong Examples and references are helpful Supplement materials such as derivations or graphic illustrations are useful graphic illustrations are useful Consult your colleagues Revising the manuscript lddhf d Properly address the referee s question and clarify any ambiguity Put yourself in the position of a reader which is exactly the position of a good referee Resubmitting the manuscript Cover letter Summary of changes Reply to the referee Explain which changes have been made and Convince the editors to s