版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
Distributedon:11/08/202304:01:07GMT
DeutscheBank
Research
Europe
Germany
Spain
Telecommunications
WirelessServices
Industry
EuropeanTelcos
Date
11August2023
ForecastChange
1+1=(O)2.Consolidationcouldbethe
answer.Buy1&1.
+41%relative1&1outperformancevsTEFDEsincecontractswitch
Weupgraded1&1toBuyinMayanddowngradedTEFDEtoHold(seenote),arguingforupsideto1&1anddownsidetoTEFDEfromthepotentialtransferof1&1traffic.1&1hasnowoutperformedTEFDEby+41%since1&1lastweekannounceditwasswitchingitsnationalroamingcontracttoVOD.Inthisnote,weconclude(1)thereislikelystillupsidefor1&1(+43%withanetworkbuild,>230%withconsolidationorwholesale-only);(2)TEFDEshouldseeamaterialhittoEFCF,andwedowngradeourEFCF/shareestimatesby-41%and(3)consolidationbetweenTEFDEand1&1maynowbeevenmoreappealing,whilstunlockingsignificantEFCF/shareaccretionattheTEFDEandTEFlevel.Weexploreapotentialscenariointhisnote.
TEFDE(Hold):EFCFcut-41%andpricetargettoEUR1.6
WereduceourTEFDEEFCFestimatesby-41%andthisdrivesa-56%reductioninourDPSestimates.TEFDE'spoorFCFgenerationnowbecomesmorevisible,withaheadline2026EFCFyieldof6.0%(2.5%onapostspectrumbasis).AsTEFDEseekstorebuildanequitystory,consolidationcouldappearmoreattractive.WepresentascenariowhereTEFDEcouldpurchase1&1forEUR40/share,morethandoublingitsEFCF/shareandallowingTEF(parent)tobenefitfrom+46%EFCF/shareaccretion.For1&1,thiscouldunlockmoreupsidethanwouldbeofferedunderanetworkbuildscenario.PleaseemailusforanExcelfilewhichcanbeflexed.
KevalKhiroya,CFA
ResearchAnalyst
+44-20-754-18164
RobertGrindle,Ph.D.
ResearchAnalyst
+44-20-754-58490
RoshanRanjit,CFA
ResearchAnalyst
+44-20-754-52908
KeyChanges
TargetPrice3.10to1.60
Rating
-
Company
O2Dn.DE
5.00to4.60
-
TEF.MC
Source:DeutscheBank
Companiesfeatured
11AG(1U1.DE),EUR11.92Buy
Hold
TelefonicaDeutschland
(O2Dn.DE),EUR1.79
Telefonica(TEF.MC),EUR3.57Hold
Source:DeutscheBank
1&1(Buy):upsidewithnetworkbuild,wholesale-onlyorconsolidation
1&1hasanumberofoptionsandtheregulator'splansonspectrum(rulesexpected
inQ12024)maybehelpfulinshaping1&1'sthinking.Inthenote,weillustratean
improvingEFCFprofilefor1&1withanetworkbuildwhichdrives+43%upsideto
thecurrentshareprice.Webelievetheupsidecouldbemoresignificantwitheither
ashiftbacktoawholesalemodel(fullorpart),orconsolidation(>230%upside).Our
forecastsimplyaheadlineEFCFyieldof10.0%by2026andwithgrowth.
TEF(Hold):pricetargetfallstoEUR4.6;FCFkeytodebtreduction
WereduceourTEF(TEFDEparent)pricetargettoEUR4.6,reflectingalower
valuationforGermany.AlthoughtheGermanEFCFdowngradesareoffsetbyother
forecastchangesandlowerminoritydividends,theTEFequitystorystillneedsa
strongerFCFbaseandaclearerpathtodebtreduction.SeeourTEFdowngrade
fromFebruaryhere.ConsolidatingGermanycouldunlockthis.
DeutscheBankAG
IMPORTANTRESEARCHDISCLOSURESANDANALYSTCERTIFICATIONSLOCATEDINAPPENDIX1.DeutscheBankdoesandseekstodobusinesswithcompaniescoveredinitsresearchreports.Thus,investorsshouldbeawarethatthefirmmayhaveaconflictofinterestthatcouldaffecttheobjectivityofthisreport.Investorsshouldconsiderthisreportasonlyasinglefactorinmakingtheirinvestmentdecision.MCI(P)097/10/2022.
10-Aug-22
24-Aug-22
07-Sep-22
21-Sep-22
05-Oct-22
19-Oct-22
02-Nov-22
16-Nov-22
30-Nov-22
14-Dec-22
28-Dec-22
11-Jan-23
25-Jan-23
08-Feb-23
22-Feb-23
08-Mar-23
22-Mar-23
05-Apr-23
19-Apr-23
03-May-23
17-May-23
31-May-23
14-Jun-23
28-Jun-23
12-Jul-23
26-Jul-23
09-Aug-23
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
11August2023
WirelessServices
EuropeanTelcos
ExecutiveSummary
1&1lastweekannounceditwillswitchitsnationalroamingagreementfrom
TelefonicaDeutschlandtoVodafone.InourMay2023report,Timeforareversal-
1&1toBuy,TEFDEtoHold,wehighlighteddownsidetoTelefonicaDeutschland
fromapotentialcontractlosstogetherwithupsidefor1&1intheeventthemarket
getsmorecomfortoverthenetworkrolloutorstartstoconsiderotheroutcomes
(switchingbacktoawholesalemodelorconsolidation).Thesharepriceshave
followedthispath(1&1up+14%sincethenews,TEFDEdown-27%).
Wearguethereismoretogoandweexpect1&1tocontinuetooutperformTEFDE.
Whilst1&1hasoutperformedTEFDEby+41%sincetheannouncement,thestock
performanceforbothstocksonaoneyearviewhasbeensimilar.Asweflaggedin
May,thebackdropwasonewherethemarkethaddisproportionatelyrewardedTEF
DEforthestickinessofshort-termwholesalerevenues(ignoringlong-termrisks
andpoorFCFgeneration)whilstpenalising1&1fornear-termnetworkrolloutdrags
(ignoringlong-termupsidefromotherstrategicoptionsortherolloutitself).We
believethemediumtermoutlook(andFCFpath)favours1&1.
Figure1:1&1vsTEFDEshareprice(-1Y)
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
O2D1&1
Source:DeutscheBank
Figure2:1&1offersimprovingFCF,TEFDEdeclines
20.0%
15.0%
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
-5.0%
-10.0%
1&1headlineEFCFyield
TEFDEheadlineEFCFyield
Source:DeutscheBank
Inthisnote,wedowngradeourTEFDEestimatesforthelossofthecontractwhich
drivesanaverageannualEFCFdowngradeof-41%from2026to2028andourprice
targetfallstoEUR1.6.WithTEFDEneedingtorebuildanequitystoryandFCFbase,
whilstcomplex,weargueconsolidationwith1&1couldbealogicalstep.Werecap
onourM&AanalysisandwearguethatTEFDEcouldmorethandoubleitsEFCF/
shareevenwitha1&1take-outpriceofEUR40(currentlyEUR12).Telefonica
(parent)wouldalsobenefitfrompotential+46%EFCF/shareaccretionandapath
tolowerleverageatatimewhenitsstrategyisforFCFtodrivelowerleverage.
1&1meanwhilebenefitsfromarangeoutoutcomes(networkbuild,switchtoa
wholesalemodelorM&A).AnimprovingFCFpathleaves+41%upsideeveninthe
eventofnetworkbuild,whilststrategicactioninvolvingatransitionbacktoa
wholesalemodelorconsolidationcouldleadto>230%upside.
Page2
DeutscheBankAG
Page3
DeutscheBankAG
11August2023
WirelessServices
EuropeanTelcos
Figure3:Summary1&1financialsandcomps(EURm)
202220232024202520262027202820292030
Shareprice(EUR)
11.9
11.9
11.9
11.9
11.9
11.9
11.9
11.9
11.9
Numberofshares(m)
176
176
176
176
176
176
176
176
176
Dilutednumberofshares(m)
176
176
176
176
176
176
176
176
176
Marketcap(EURm)
2,101
2,101
2,101
2,101
2,101
2,101
2,101
2,101
2,101
Reportednetfinancialdebt(AdjustedforLeases)
378
393
361
1,520
1,318
1,137
978
740
498
Leases
71
89
198
373
523
644
765
875
974
Reportednetfinancialdebt(IFRS16)
450
482
559
1,893
1,841
1,780
1,743
1,615
1,472
Adjustednetdebt(AdjustedforLeases)
1,363
1,445
1,485
1,520
1,318
1,137
978
740
498
Adjustednetdebt(IFRS16)
1,435
1,534
1,683
1,893
1,841
1,780
1,743
1,615
1,472
CoreEnterprisevalue(AdjustedforLeases)
3,465
3,547
3,586
3,622
3,420
3,238
3,080
2,842
2,600
CoreEnterprisevalue(IFRS16)
Summaryfinancials
3,536
3,636
3,784
3,995
3,942
3,882
3,844
3,716
3,573
Revenues
3,964
4,041
4,104
4,165
4,226
4,290
4,354
4,415
4,468
AdjustedEBITDA(adjustedforleases)
680
644
651
691
735
762
750
793
810
AdjustedEBITDA(IFRS16)
693
661
687
759
830
879
889
952
987
ReportedEBITDA(companydefinition,IFRS16)
693
661
687
759
830
879
889
952
987
EBIT
535
442
400
426
492
536
540
598
630
AdjustedNetIncome
367
302
274
277
309
344
351
395
422
AdjustedEPS
2.08
1.71
1.56
1.57
1.75
1.95
1.99
2.24
2.40
ReportedDPS
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.30
0.40
0.45
0.50
Capexexcludingspectrum
249
320
455
473
321
321
321
263
263
Capexincludingspectrum
EFCFbreakdown
249
320
455
1,673
321
321
321
263
263
EBITDA
693
661
687
759
830
879
889
952
987
Cashcapex(exspectrum)andincvendorfinancing
-249
-320
-455
-473
-321
-321
-321
-263
-263
Cashinterest
-3
-11
-8
-30
-50
-44
-39
-34
-26
Hybridcoupons(wherenotcapturedininterest)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cashtaxes
-164
-129
-118
-119
-132
-147
-150
-169
-181
Minoritydividendpayments
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Associate/JVdividendincome
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Changeinworkingcapital
-350
-120
-30
-20
-20
-15
-10
-10
-10
Other
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Leasepayments(ifstartingwithIFRS16EBITDA)
-13
-16
-36
-68
-95
-117
-139
-159
-177
TotalEFCF(prepensionandrestructuring)
-87
64
41
50
211
234
229
317
330
Restructuringcosts
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Pensionrepayments
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
TotalEFCF(postpensionandrestructuring)
-87
64
41
50
211
234
229
317
330
Multiples(AdjustedforLeases)
EV/EBITDA
5.1x
5.5x
5.5x
5.2x
4.7x
4.2x
4.1x
3.6x
3.2x
EV/OpFCF(prespectrum)
8.0x
10.9x
18.3x
16.6x
8.3x
7.3x
7.2x
5.4x
4.7x
UnleveredFCFyield
-2.4%
2.0%
1.3%
2.0%
7.2%
8.2%
8.3%
12.0%
13.4%
Reportednetdebt/EBITDA(AdjustedforLeases)
0.6x
0.6x
0.6x
2.2x
1.8x
1.5x
1.3x
0.9x
0.6x
Adjustednetdebt/EBITDA(AdjustedforLeases)
0.6x
0.6x
0.6x
2.2x
1.8x
1.5x
1.3x
0.9x
0.6x
Multiples(IFRS16)
EV/EBITDA
5.1x
5.5x
5.5x
5.3x
4.8x
4.4x
4.3x
3.9x
3.6x
EV/OpFCF(prespectrum)
8.0x
10.7x
16.3x
14.0x
7.7x
7.0x
6.8x
5.4x
4.9x
Reportednetdebt/EBITDA(IFRS16)
0.6x
0.7x
0.8x
2.5x
2.2x
2.0x
2.0x
1.7x
1.5x
Adjustednetdebt/EBITDA(IFRS16)
0.6x
0.7x
0.8x
2.5x
2.2x
2.0x
2.0x
1.7x
1.5x
EFCFyield
-4.1%
3.1%
1.9%
2.4%
10.0%
11.2%
10.9%
15.1%
15.7%
Dividendyield
04%
04%
04%
04%
04%
25%
34%
38%
42%
P/E
5.7x
7.0x
7.7x
7.6x
6.8x
6.1x
6.0x
5.3x
5.0x
AdjustedP/E
5.7x
7.0x
7.7x
7.6x
6.8x
6.1x
6.0x
5.3x
5.0x
Source:DeutscheBank,companydata
11August2023
WirelessServices
EuropeanTelcos
Figure4:SummaryTEFDEfinancialsand
comps(EURm)
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
Shareprice
1.8
1.8
1.8
1.8
1.8
1.8
1.8
1.8
1.8
Numberofshares
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
Dilutednumberofshares
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
2,975
Marketcap
5,304
5,304
5,304
5,304
5,304
5,304
5,304
5,304
5,304
Reportednetfinancialdebt(AdjustedforLeases)
-48
40
47
1,372
1,429
1,471
1,527
1,579
1,580
Leases
3,260
3,300
3,437
3,540
3,644
3,750
3,857
3,966
4,001
Reportednetfinancialdebt(IFRS16)
3,212
3,340
3,483
4,911
5,073
5,221
5,384
5,545
5,581
Adjustednetdebt(AdjustedforLeases)
1,849
1,958
1,985
1,904
1,859
1,792
1,733
1,661
1,662
Adjustednetdebt(IFRS16)
5,109
5,258
5,422
5,443
5,503
5,542
5,590
5,626
5,662
CoreEnterprisevalue(AdjustedforLeases)
6,575
6,704
6,778
6,717
6,682
6,635
6,603
6,569
6,570
CoreEnterprisevalue(IFRS16)
Summaryfinancials
9,835
10,004
10,215
10,257
10,326
10,385
10,460
10,535
10,571
Revenues
8223
8489
8618
8511
8437
8626
8816
9012
9207
AdjustedEBITDA(adjustedforleases)
1900
1901
1961
1756
1603
1635
1654
1681
1711
AdjustedEBITDA(IFRS16)
2540
2596
2683
2499
2367
2420
2460
2509
2546
Restructuringcosts
-17
-36
-36
-36
-36
-36
-36
-36
-36
ReportedEBITDA(companydefinition,IFRS16)
2523
2560
2647
2463
2331
2384
2424
2473
2510
EBIT
240
360
497
363
331
384
424
473
510
AdjustedNetIncome
249
263
359
244
200
236
262
297
324
AdjutedEPS
0.08
0.09
0.12
0.08
0.07
0.08
0.09
0.10
0.11
ReportedDPS
0.18
0.18
0.08
0.08
0.08
0.08
0.08
0.08
0.08
Capexexcludingspectrum
1,209
1,155
1,172
1,157
1,122
1,130
1,155
1,172
1,197
Capexincludingspectrum
EFCFbreakdown
1,209
1,155
1,172
2,557
1,122
1,130
1,155
1,172
1,197
EBITDA
2,540
2,560
2,647
2,463
2,331
2,384
2,424
2,473
2,510
Cashcapex(exspectrum)andincvendorfinancing
-1,209
-1,155
-1,172
-1,157
-1,122
-1,130
-1,155
-1,172
-1,197
Cashinterest
-36
-35
-35
-66
-98
-102
-105
-105
-105
Hybridcoupons(wherenotcapturedininterest)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cashtaxes
-56
-80
-55
-36
-28
-34
-38
-44
-49
Minoritydividendpayments
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Associate/JVdividendincome
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Changeinworkingcapital
-128
-40
-25
-10
0
0
0
0
0
Other
-1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Leasepayments(ifstartingwithIFRS16EBITDA)
-640
-695
-722
-743
-764
-785
-806
-828
-835
TotalEFCF(prepensionandrestructuring)
470
555
637
450
319
334
319
324
324
Restructuringcosts
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Pensionrepayments
0
0
0
0
0%
0
0
0
0
TotalEFCF(postpensionandrestructuring)
470
555
637
450
319
334
319
324
324
Multiples(AdjustedforLeases)
EV/EBITDA
35x
35x
35x
38x
42x
41x
40x
39x
38x
EV/OpFCF(prespectrum)
9.5x
9.0x
8.6x
11.2x
13.9x
13.1x
13.2x
12.9x
12.8x
UnleveredFCFyield
7.8%
8.6%
9.8%
7.4%
5.8%
6.1%
6.0%
6.1%
6.1%
Reportednetdebt/EBITDA(AdjustedforLeases)
0.0x
0.0x
0.0x
0.8x
0.9x
0.9x
0.9x
0.9x
0.9x
Adjustednetdebt/EBITDA(AdjustedforLeases)
0.3x
0.3x
0.3x
1.1x
1.2x
1.1x
1.0x
1.0x
1.0x
Multiples(IFRS16)
EV/EBITDA
3.9x
3.9x
3.8x
4.1x
4.4x
4.3x
4.3x
4.2x
4.2x
EV/OpFCF(prespectrum)
7.4x
6.9x
6.8x
7.6x
8.3x
8.0x
8.0x
7.9x
7.8x
Reportednetdebt/EBITDA(IFRS16)
1.3x
1.3x
1.3x
2.0x
2.1x
2.2x
2.2x
2.2x
2.2x
Adjustednetdebt/EBITDA(IFRS16)
1.5x
1.5x
1.5x
2.2x
2.4x
2.3x
2.3x
2.3x
2.3x
EFCFyield
89%
105%
120%
85%
60%
63%
60%
61%
61%
Dividendyield
10.1%
10.1%
4.5%
4.5%
4.5%
4.5%
4.5%
4.5%
4.5%
P/E
22.9x
23.3x
16.4x
25.6x
32.6x
26.8x
23.8x
20.6x
18.7x
AdjustedP/E
21.3x
20.1x
14.8x
21.8x
26.5x
22.5x
20.2x
17.8x
16.4x
Source:DeutscheBank,companydata
Page4
DeutscheBankAG
11August2023
WirelessServices
EuropeanTelcos
TEFDE'sEFCF&DPShit
TEFDEEFCFandDPSforecastsfallsharplypost1&1trafficloss
Weillustrateourforecastchangesbelow,basedonthetrafficfullymigratingfrom
2026(weassumehalfthecontributionstillremainsin2025).WeexpectTEFDE's
EFCFtofallbyapproximately41%andweexpectalargedividendcut.
nEstimatedEBITDAfalls-12%,EFCFfalls-41%.Weestimatethat1&1todaycontributesEUR450mtoTEFDE'sEBITDA,andwehadassumedmoderatedeclines,leavingalowerstartingpointin2026.ThefullremovalofthisEBITDAstreamleadstoa12%annualEBITDAdowngrade(2026-28)andthecompany'spoorFCFconversionleavesamaterialEFCFimpact(-41%perannum).
nWeassumea-56%DPScutfrom2026.WediscussTEFDE'sleverageinthenextsectionandweassumea56%dividendcutfrom2024,reflectingtheFCFdowngradesandpressureonleverage(onanIFRS16basis).WebelieveTelefonica,theparent,isalsolikelytosupportadividendcutatTEFDEasthishelpsreduceminoritydividendleakage.
nCompensatingforlosttrafficdifficult.Beyondcapexreductiontocapturelowernetworkgrowth,wedonotassumesignificantoffsets.AlthoughTEFDEislikelytowanttorecapturerevenuesthroughitsretailandwholesalebusiness,webelievedoingsocouldprovechallengingwithoutdisruptingthewidermarket(whichinturncouldimpactTEFDE'sownbackbook).Wediscussthisfurtheronpage14.
Figure5:Summaryforecastchanges(EURm)
2025
85118723-2.4%
57845995-3.5%
24992717-8.0%
11571195-3.1%
450 621-27.5%
49115127-4.2%
0.08 0.18-55.6%
2026
84378829-4.4%
56266018-6.5%
2367 2726-13.2%
11221183-5.1%
319 597-46.6%
50735307-4.4%
0.08 0.18-55.6%
2024
861886090.1%
597559670.1%
26832691-0.3%
11721179-0.6%
637 650-2.0%
348334720.3%
0.08 0.18-55.6%
2028
88169132-3.5%
58296145-5.1%
2460 2757-10.8%
11551205-4.2%
319 510-37.5%
53845803-7.2%
0.08 0.18-55.6%
2027
86268966-3.8%
57296068-5.6%
2420 2735-11.5%
11301184-4.5%
334 553-39.7%
52215533-5.6%
0.08 0.18-55.6%
2023
848984840.1%
592859230.1%
259625960.0%
11551167-1.0%
5555530.3%
33403342-0.1%
0.180.180.0%
Newrevenues
Oldrevenues
%change
Newmobileservicerevenue
Oldmobileservicerevenue
%change
NewEBITDA
OldEBITDA
%change
NewCapex
OldCapex
%change
NewEFCF
OldEFCF
%change
NewNetDebt(incleases)
OldNetDebt(incleases)
%change
NewDPS
OldDPS
%change
Source:DeutscheBank
DeutscheBankAG
Page5
Page6
DeutscheBankAG
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
11August2023
WirelessServices
EuropeanTelcos
DivergingFCFpaths
TEFDEfacesadecliningFCFpath;1&1offersgrowth
InourMayreport,wearguedthatTEFDEwasexposedtoadecliningFCFpathand
anexpensiveFCFbasedvaluationwhichwouldbeapparentovertimeas1&1
migratedtraffictoitsownnetwork,leavingadecliningbalanceonnational
roaming.Theshiftofthenationalroamingagreementmeanstheendpointtolower
FCFwillbebetterunderstoodbythemarketandrealisedearlier.Bycontrast,we
expect1&1toseeFCFimprovementsovertime-eveninanetworkbuildscenario,
weseeupsidetoEUR17/sharefor1&1(+43%upside)andwithmorematerial
upsideintheeventofstrategicaction.WeillustratethedivergingFCFtrendsand
valuationsinthechartsbelow.
Figure6:TEFDEand1&1EFCF(EURm)
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
-100
-200
2022
2023
2024
2025
2026
2027
2028
2029
2030
1&1EFCF(prespectrum)
TEFDEEFCF(prespectrum)
Source:DeutscheBank
Figure7:TEFDEand1&1EFCFyields
20.0%
15.0%
10.0%
5.0%
0.0%
-5.0%
-10.0%
1&1headlineEFCFyield
TEFDEheadlineEFCFyield
Source:DeutscheBank
TEFDEfacesadecliningFCFpathandalowEFCFyield
nHeadlineEFCFyieldof6%.WeshowourTEFDEEFCFprojectionsinFigure
8.WhenTEFDE'ssharepricewasoutperformingearlierthisyear,themarketfocusedontheattractiveEFCFofferedin2023and2024.However,aswelookat2026andbeyond,TEFDElikelyoffersaheadlineEFCFyieldofonly6%andwithlimitedroomscopeforgrowth.WhilstwedoassumeEBITDAgrowthoncethe1&1contributionwashesout,wealsoexpectoffsetfromhigherleasecosts,highertaxesandhigherinterest(refinancingandnewdebttocoverspectrum).
nPostspectrumyieldof2.5%.Ifwelookatthevaluationonapostspectrumbasis(asspectrumhasanexpiry,soaportiongetsusedeveryyear),theEFCFyieldisanticipatedtoonlybe2.5%in2026.TEFDEEFCFyieldthereforeeithercallsforimprovedFCFgenerationorsharepricedownside.
nUnleveredFCFyieldalsolow.WeacknowledgethatpartofthepoorFCFconversionisduetotheweightofleasepayment(TEFDEsolditstowers).Thebenefitmeanwhilecomesfromlowerleverage,asTEFDEiscurrentlyclosetoanetcashposition(onaNetDebtALbasis).However,evenwhenwelookatunleveredmetrics,TEFDE'sFCFyieldremainsbelowpeerswitha2026headlineunleveredFCFyieldof5.8%(sector8.5%).
nFCFdrivesdividenddownside.WereducedourDPSforecastsby56%(toEUR0.08fromEUR0.18),toleavethecompanybelowitstargetleverageofatorbelow2.5xnetdebt/EBITDA(includingleases).OurestimatesassumespectrumspendofEUR1.4bnin2025andbalancesheetheadroomwould
450319334319324324
202220232024202520262027202820292030
EBITDA
2,523
2,560
2,647
2,463
2,331
2,384
2,424
2,473
2,510
Cashcapex(exspectrum)
-1,209
-1,155
-1,172
-1,157
-1,122
-1,130
-1,155
-1,172
-1,197
Cashinterest
-36
-35
-35
-66
-98
-102
-105
-105
-105
Cashtaxes
-56
-80
-55
-36
-28
-34
-38
-44
-49
Changeinworkingcapital
-141
-40
-25
-10
0
0
0
0
0
Other
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Leasepayments
-640
-695
-722
-743
-764
-785
-806
-828
-835
TotalEFCF(prespectrum)
441
ImpliedEFCFyield8.3%10.5%12.0%8.5%6.0%6.3%6.0%6.1%6.1%
Annualspectrumcharge(normalised)
-187
-187
-187
-187
-187
-187
-187
-187
-187
TotalEFCF(postspectrum)254368450263131147132137137
ImpliedEFCFyield4.8%6.9%8.5%5.0%2.5%2.8%2.5%2.6%2.6%
ReportedNetDebt/EBITDA(incleases)AdjustedNetDebt/EBITDA(exleases)
1.3x
03x
1.3x
03x
1.3x
03x
2.0x
11x
2.2x
12x
2.2x
11x
2.2x
10x
2.2x
10x
2.2x10x
Source:DeutscheBank
889
-321
-39
-150
-10
0
-139
952
-263
-34
-169
-10
0
-159
759
-473
-30
-119
-20
0
-68
830
-321
-50
-132
-20
0
-95
987
-263
-26
-181
-10
0
-177
879
-321
-44
-147
-15
0
-117
202220232024202520262027202820292030
EBITDA
Cashcapex(exspectrum)Cashinterest
Cashtaxes
ChangeinworkingcapitalOther
Leasepayments
693
-249
-8
-164
-350
5
-13
TotalEFCF(prespectrum)-87644150211234229317330
ImpliedEFCFyield-4.1%3.1%1.9%2.4%10.0%11.2%10.9%15.1%15.7%
Annualspectrumcharge(normalised)
-159
-159
-159
-159
-159
-159
-159
-159
-159
TotalEFCF(postspectrum)-246-95-118-110527570158171
ImpliedEFCFyield-11.7%-4.5%-5.6%-5.2%2.5%3.6%3.3%7.5%8.1%
11August2023
WirelessServices
EuropeanTelcos
behigherintheeventofspectrumprolongationratherthananauction.
However,thecompanywouldstillneedtoplanforspectrumspendafew
yearslater,evenifitdidn'ttakeplacein2025.
Figure8:TEFDE:summaryEFCF,leverageandyields(EURm)
637
555
1&1offersexposuretoFCFgrowthandEFCFyieldimprovements
Weexpect1&1meanwhiletofacetheopposite,withFCFcurrentlyimpactedbythe
networkrolloutbutwewouldexpectatleastsomesavingsfromtrafficmigrating
to1&1'sownnetworkovertime(weassume50%oftrafficison-netby2028).We
illustrateour1&1FCFestimatesinthechartbelowandourestimatesimplythat1&1
isleftonapathtodoubledigitEFCFyieldsonaheadlinebasis(or8.1%by2030on
apostspectrumbasis,whichcomparesto2.6%atTelefonicaDeutschland).
Themarket'smainfocusuntilrecentlyhadbeenonTEFDE'snear-termFCF
generationbutwiththeendtothenationalroamingshiftingthefocustothe
mediumterm,wenoteourforecastsimplythat1&1andTEFDEwillgenerate
similarheadlineEFCFby2029.Thedifferenceinmarketcap(1&1'smarketcapis
60%lowerthanTEFDE's)leaves1&1'sEFCFyieldmoreattractiveandwitha
growinggapbetweenthetwocompanies(Figure7).
Figure9:1&1:summaryEFCF,leverageandyields(EURm)
687
-455
-8
-118
-30
0
-36
661
-320
-11
-129
-120
0
-16
0.8x06x
0.7x06x
ReportedNetDebt/EBITDA(incleases)AdjustedNetDebt/EBITDA(exleases)
0.6x06x
2.0x15x
2.0x13x
2.2x18x
1.5x06x
1.7x09x
2.5x22x
Source:DeutscheBank
DeutscheBankAG
Page7
11August2023
WirelessServices
EuropeanTelcos
Consolidationupside
Positivefor1&1,TEFDEandTEFevenwithalarge1&1premium
Historytellsusthatoperatorswhichhaveembarkedonnewnetworklauncheshave
oftenreevaluatedtheirpositionandpursuedin-marketconsolidation.Forexample,
IliadofferedtobuyVodafoneItalylastyear,Tele2NLcombinedwithT-Mobile,Three
UKisintalkstomergewithVodafoneUKandMasmovilhasreachedagreement
withOrangeinSpain.
WeseesimilarmeritsforapotentialdealinGermany,andinour1&1initiation,Deep
dive:Consolidationcouldbetheanswer(October2022),wearguedanendgame
couldbeaconsolidationbetween1&1andTEFDE(or1&1withanotheroperator).
FromtheTEFDEperspective,thiscouldbeawayofdeliveringmuchneeded
improvementsinEFCF/share(whichisnowevenmoreimportant)andfromthe1&1
perspective,therecouldbeanopportunitytocreatemoreupsidethanwouldbe
achievedbythenetworkrollout.Telefonica(asparentofTelefonicaDeutschland)
wouldalsoseebenefitsfromEFCF/shareaccretionandapotentialpathtolower
leverage.Inthissectionwereviewapotentialdealstructureandbeforelookingat
ascenario,wenotethefollowing:
nSpectrumauctions.Consolidationhasattimeshappenedaheadofspectrumauctions,asthelargeroperatorslikelywanttoavoidcompetitivebiddingintheauctionandsmalleroperatorsmayotherwisefacelargeoutlaysinanauction,unlessspectrumisringfencedforthem.Forexample,Tele2andT-MobileNetherlandsreachedanagreementtomergetheirDutchassetsin2018(oneyearbeforethespectrumauctionwasmeanttotakeplace),andeveninGermany,TEFDEandE-Plusreachedadealin2013(twoyearsaheadofanauction).Intheeventtheregulatoristhinkingaboutanauctionratherthanprolongation,therecouldbeanincentivetoconsiderconsolidationaheadofthis.
nRegulatoryapproval.Regulationhasbeenthekeybarriertoin-marketdealsinEurope,althoughtheT-MobileandTele2Netherlandsdealwasapprovedandwithnoremedies.Thereareunlikelytobeanyobstaclesinfixedbroadband(combinedmarketshareof17%)andintheeventofacombinedmobilemarketshareofover40%beinganissue,TEFDEcouldproposetodisposeofpartofthesubscriberbase.Whilstregulatoryclearanceisbynomeanscertain,TEFDEcouldtryandpersuaderegulatorsbykeepingthe1&1brandandtheexistingpricepoints.Initscurrentform,1&1maybelesslikelytopushlargedatabundlestoitssubscriberbase,andTEFDEcouldarguethatitisinabetterplacetopushthesecustomersupthedatacurve,asgovernmentscareaboutdigitalisation.
nDealstructure.Thereareanumberofwaysinwhich
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 2026年航空货运服务质量评价报告及改进建议
- 2025年郑州电子商务职业学院单招职业技能考试题库答案
- 2026年金融行业客户私域留存与增值服务报告
- 2026年分布式光伏系统成本控制与效益分析报告
- 2026年珠宝首饰行业消费者偏好与市场增长报告
- 2026年舞蹈赛事组织行业分析报告:市场潜力与运营策略
- 2026年能源行业绿色发展报告:政策导向与市场机遇
- 2026年航空业海外商标专利与合规操作指南
- 2026年互联网医疗行业政策环境分析报告及市场潜力预测
- 2026年短视频行业市场潜力分析报告
- 商票电票银行承兑汇票质押借款合同协议10篇
- 2026年秋季开学学科教师家访工作培训课件
- (2026年)成人脑室外引流护理 (1)课件
- 2026年网格员招聘笔试重点题库(350题)
- 时代新声·青年担当-高中学生会干部2026-2027学年度热点主题班会培训讲义
- 学校室外运动场改造工程重难点及应对措施
- 2026年交通规划考试题及答案
- 医德医风警示教育课件
- 2026中国煤炭科工校招面试题及答案
- 《医疗机构危险化学品安全管理规范》T-SHWSHQ 15-2025
- 妇科机器人保留生育功能手术
评论
0/150
提交评论