版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH
StateofADAS,Automation,andConnectivity
NaseebSouweidane
BrettSmith
March|2023
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH2
TABLEOFCONTENTS
4
4
5
5
5
7
7
8
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
13
14
14
15
16
16
AbouttheAuthorsAcknowledgmentsIntroduction
AdvancedDriverAssistSystems(ADAS)Overview
CrashReductionandSafetyRegulation
ADASNamingConventionsDriverEducation
DriverMonitoring
BusinessCaseandConsumerAcceptanceGoingForward
AutomatedVehicles(AV)
Overview
TimelineEvolution
FromADAStoAV:SkippingaStep
KeyIssuesHoldingBackDeployment
Consumer:AdoptionandRiskToleranceBusinessCase
Modality
OperationalDesignDomainsCondition
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH3
TABLEOFCONTENTS
17
18
19
20
20
21
21
22
23
23
24
25
26
26
27
28
28
29
29
31
ScalingTowardAutomation:TestingvsPilotsvs
Launches
Infrastructure
PolicyandRegulation
Liability
Technology:HardwareandSoftwareCyber/Data
Maintenance
GoingForward
Connectivity
Overview
DSRCvs.CV2X
StatusofRegulation
InternationalScopeofRegulationDataPrivacy
AlternativesintheMarket:CloudComputingBusinessCaseforConnectivityandtheCostElementsfromOEMs
BusinessCaseforConnectivityinAutomationGoingForward
Conclusion
WorksCited
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH4
ABOUTTHEAUTHORS
TheCenterforAutomotiveResearchisanindependentnon-profitthatproducesindustry-drivenresearchandfostersdialogueoncriticalissuesfacingtheauto-
motiveindustryanditsimpactontheU.S.economyandsociety.CARresearcherscloselytrackcurrentandfutureglobalautomotiveindustryandtechnologytrendsandassesstheirimpacts.CARresearchersalsostudyinternationalcollaborationsandstayabreastofchangesininternationaltradeandregulatoryenvironments,thedevelopmentoftechnologystandards,andthedeploymentofnewvehicle
technologies.
Acknowledgements
TheauthorswouldliketothankShaunWhitehouse,previousDirectorofMarket-ingandEventsatCAR,CarolynMozheev,SeniorMarketing&AffiliatesProgram
ManageratCAR,BrianEstenberg,CorporateRelations,Research&StrategicPart-nershipsatCAR,EdgarFalerSeniorIndustryAnalystatCAR,andJuliaBush,Indus-tryAnalystatCAR,fortheirassistanceinresearching,writing,andpreparingthisdocument.
Forcitationsandreferencetothispublication,pleaseusethefollowing:
Souweidane,N.,Smith,B.(2022).StateofADAS,Automation,andConnectivity.CenterforAutomotiveResearch,AnnArbor,MI.
CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH
880TechnologyDrive,SuiteC|AnnArbor,MI48108|
CAR’smissionistoproduceindependentresearch,convenestakeholders,and
analyzecriticalissuesfacingthemobilityindustryanditsimpactonthe
economyandsociety.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH5
Introduction
Vehiclesarecurrentlyinanewstageofevolutionthatincludesadvanceddriverassist,connectivity,andautomation.Duetotheevolvingnatureofthetechnolo-gyandshiftingconsumerpreferences,thetimingandpathwayforimplementa-tionofthesetechnologiesisstilluncertain.Whilethesenewtechnologiesarestillevolving,anunderstandingofthecurrentautomotivelandscapemayhelppro-videaviewtofuturedevelopments.
TheCenterforAutomotiveResearchiscommittedtoinformingthepublicaboutthecurrentstateofvehicletechnologies.In2017,2019,and2020,CARpublishedroadmapsdescribingthecurrentandlikelyfuturestateofvehicletechnologies.ToensuretheinformationforecastedbyCARremainedcurrentandreflectedthelatestinvehicletechnologies,trends,andexpectations,CARconductedongo-
ingresearchandmoderatedindustryroundtables.Industryroundtableexpertsincludedautomanufacturers,partssuppliers,technologyproviders,dataprovid-ers,autonomousplatformsproviders,andtechnologyinvestors.Followingthe
roundtables,CARdevelopedanupdatedroadmapandreportreflectingindustrytrendsandexpectations.Thispapersummarizescriticalissuesinvolvingthede-velopmentanddeploymentoftechnologyinadvanceddriverassistancesystems(ADAS),autonomousvehicles(AV),andvehicleconnectivity.
AdvancedDriverAssistSystems(ADAS)
Overview
Advanceddriverassistancesystems(ADAS)havethepotentialtoreducecrash-
esandminimizetrafficinefficienciesbyeliminatinghumanerrorandproviding
real-timedataabouttrafficconditions.ThetechnologiesincludedinADASincludeautomaticemergencybraking,adaptivecruisecontrol,lane-keepingassist,self-
park,andvaryingautomaticemergencybrakingsystems.
ThereislittledisputeaboutthepotentialbenefitsofADAS.Eliminatinghuman
errorandsimplifyingdrivingmakeADASanattractivevisionforthefuturestateofautomotivetechnology.However,ADASarestillintheirdevelopmentalstage,andahandfulofhighlypublicized-andsometimesfatal-crasheshaveraisedcon-
cernsaboutthesafetyofthetechnology.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH6
Thereisagenerallackofdataandinformationtodrawrobustconclusionsaboutthenatureandcauseofthesecrashes,butnevertheless,thenegativeheadlineshavetemperedenthusiasmforthistechnology.
ADAStechnologies,popularforthelasttwodecades,haveadvancedinfourdis-tinctwaves:aidfeatures,warnfeatures,driverassistfeatures,andautomateddriv-ingfeatures.
1.Aidfeaturesaretechnologiesthatenhancedrivervisionthroughcamerasandlights.Popularizedintheearly2000’s,aidfeatureshavesincebecomecom-
monplace.
2.Warnfeaturesincludealertsystemsthatutilizesensorsandsoundstowarn
driversofhazards.Thesefeaturesareregainingfocusastheyhelpshapedrivermonitoring.
3.Driverassistfeaturesaretechnologiesthathelpsituationallycontrolthevehi-cle.Thesetechnologieshavebeenaroundfordecadesbutadvancedsignifi-cantlyinthelate1990s.Sincethen,newfeatureshaveconsistentlybeenintro-ducedtoprovideasophisticatedlevelofdriverassistance.Whichmayserveasthebridgetoautomateddrivingfeatures.
4.Automateddrivingfeaturesserveasamoreadvanceddriverassist,whichtakesresponsibilityandhelpsdrivethevehicleinspecificcircumstances.
Figure1:DriverAssistTechnologyEvolution
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH7
CrashReductionandSafety
ADASandautomatedtechnologiesaretoutedassolutionsforcrashesandroad-waysafetybecausetheiradvancedtechnologycaneliminatehumanerror.The
NationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration(NHTSA)hasreportedthat“94%
ofseriouscrashesareduetohumanerror,”supportingtheinherentpromiseof
automatedandassisteddriving(NHTSA,2016).Statisticslikethisarecentraltothevisionpromotingfull-scaledeploymentofautomationanddriverlessvehicles.
However,thestatisticsprovidedbyNHTSAthatarecoretoADASadoptionare,insomeways,anoversimplifiednarrative(Muelleretal.,2020).IssuesthatmayarisefromADASincludetechnologyfailures,hacking,overrelianceontechnologyto
performbeyondintendeduse(humanerror),unreliableplatooningtechnology
thatleadstomoreseverecrashes,aninabilitytodetectvulnerableroadusers,anddecreasinglevelofinvestmentsinADAStechnologies.
Despitethesepotentialtechnologicalshortcomings,recentstudiespredictthat
ADAStechnologycouldreduceupto34percentofcrashes.Somestudiessug-
gestthispercentagecouldbeevenhigherifthetechnologycouldeliminatetrafficviolations(Mueller,2020).Reducingautocrashesbyjust10%wouldreducetrafficfatalitiesbythousands.
AtrendtoconsiderfurtheristhepotentialforADAStoincreasetraveldemand,
evenifproportionallyloweringcrashrates,whileraisingthenumberofaggregatecrashesduetotheincreaseddemandfromfleets.
Regulation
WhiletherehasbeennocongressionalactiongoverningADAStechnologyin
automobiles,NHTSA,whoseregulatoryframeworkremainsprimarilyweightedtowarddriver-focusedsafetystandards,hasstartedamendingitsstandardsandissuinggeneralorderstoregulateADAS.AstandinggeneralorderwasissuedbyNHTSAthatrequiredcompaniestoreportacrashifLevel2ADAStechnologywasin“useatanytimewithin30secondsofacrashandthecrashinvolvedavulner-ableroaduserorresultedinafatality,avehicletow-away,anairbagdeployment,oranyindividualbeingtransportedtoahospitalformedicaltreatment”(NHTSA,2021).Thestandingorderaimstoevaluatevehicletechnologiesandservesasa
measureofADASassessmentabsentincurrentFMVSSandNCAP.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH8
ADASNamingConventions
TherearecurrentlynofederallymandatedstandardstoensureconsistentuseofterminologyforreferencingADASfeatureslikeadaptivecruisecontrol,highway
pilot,andautomatedparking.ADAStechnologyhaslargelybeenpromotedand
describedinvaryingwaysbythecompaniesthatdevelopandadoptthetechnolo-gyintheirvehicles(Williams,2022).
Withoutuniversallyacceptednomenclature,companiesmaypromotetheirADASfeaturesandtechnologiesusingterminologythatmaynotaccuratelydescribethetechnologysuiteintheirvehiclesandmaynotbecommonlyunderstoodbycon-sumers.Tesla,forexample,referstoitsADASas“FullSelf-Driving,”yetitonlylandsonthesecondleveloftheSAEsfiveautomationlevels.Thislackofconsensushasledtoalevelofconsumermisunderstandingandfalseexpectationsofthetech-
nology’struecapability.
AAAledaworkinggrouptostandardizeADASfeaturesandtechnologiesto“clearconfusion”surroundingADAStechnology(AAA,2022).Theworkinggroupsoughttoprovideindustry-widedefinitionsofADAStechnologysuitestoimproveunder-standingandtransferabilityofterminology.Whiletherewasnotuniformagree-mentontheimportanceofadoptingastandardizednomenclature,theprevailingviewisthatstandardizationwillbeacriticalfactorinpromotingandunderstand-ingADAStechnologies.Standardizationwillalsobeanimportantfactorindrivereducationandtechnologyknowledgetransferability.
DriverEducation
EducatingdriversontheproperuseofADAStechnologiesisanessentialstepinfullyrealizingthebenefitsofADAS.Misuseandhumanerrormaycausecrash-
esthatwereotherwisepreventablethroughADAStechnology.Withoutaproperunderstandingofwhenandwheretechnologycanbedeployed,humanerrorcanleadtoADASfailures.Atrainingprogramtoadvancetheunderstandingofthe
ADAStechnologyusedwithinavehiclecanreducemisunderstandingandmisuseofADAS.
Somecompaniesimplementtrainingstandardsfordriversbeforetheyareprovid-edaccesstocertainADASfeatures(Mayhew&Robertson,2021).Thesemandatoryinstructionalstandardsensurethatdriversbetterunderstandthecapabilitiesandlimitationsofthetechnologyintheirvehicle.Forexample,adrivertrainedonTes-la’sADASsuitewouldlearnthat“FullSelf-Driving”requiresdriverengagement
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH9
andisnotfullyautomated.However,fewcompaniesmandatethistypeofeduca-tion(Stafford,2022).
Despitethepotentialbenefitoftrainingprograms,consumersappearunwillingtospendtimelearninghowtouseADAS.Additionally,thelowdegreeoftrans-ferabilitybetweenmanufacturersoftechnologysuitesmeansaninvestmentinlearningonemanufacturer’stechnologymaynotbeparticularlyhelpfulforadif-ferentmanufacturer.
DriverMonitoring
DrivermonitoringisanothermechanismthatcanmitigatetherisksassociatedwithmisusingADASbyensuringdriversaremorefullyengagedwhiledriving.
Therearevaryingdegreesofdrivermonitoringrangingfromperiodicalertsto
requiredengagement(Barry,2022).Theproblemwithastrictdrivermonitoring
mandateisthatitmayremovetheincentivetofullyembracethetechnology.If
driversfeelmonitoringrequirementsoverlyrestricttheirautonomy,theymayfindlittlebenefitandvalueintheADAS.Assuringfocusthroughdrivermonitoringisabalancingactthatcompaniesandgoverningbodiesarecurrentlyattempting
tomanage.BotharetryingtoensureappropriatecustomeruseofADASwhile
notannoyingthedriver.Higher-enddrivermonitoringmayresultinbacklash
fromconsumersoveraperceivedinvasiveviewandincreasedpotentialforcyberthreats.
Additionally,falsepositivealertsgeneratedbythedrivermonitoringsystemmaycreateatechnologicalchallengethatdiscouragescompaniesfromenteringthismarket(Mehmedetal.,2020).Arecurringfalsepositiveratecouldfuelconsumermistrustandmisunderstandingofthevehiclewhichcannegativelyaffectcon-sumeradoptionandwillingnesstobuy.
Roundtablediscussionsonmonitoringsystemsalsohighlightedthecomplexityofmonitoringconsumerdistractioninlightofadvancementswithin-vehiclefea-turespresentedthroughphoneconnectivity.
TheEuropeanNewCarAssessmentProgramme(EuroNCAP)iscurrentlythelead-erinevaluatingdrivermonitoringstandardsthroughaseriesoforders(McManus,2022).EuroNCAPstandardshavebeeninstrumentalinestablishingdrivermoni-toringstandards.Intime,morejurisdictionswillimplementsimilarstandards.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH10
BusinessCaseandConsumerAcceptance
ThebusinesscaseforADASiscurrentlyunclearduetolowconsumptionlevels.
Pricingmodelsaredifficulttoestablishasmanyconsumersremainskepticalandunwillingtopayforthetechnology(Stigloeetal.,2022).AbetterunderstandingofhowmanyconsumersshutofftheADASfeaturesintheirvehiclesisneededtoappropriatelymodelthebusinesscaseforpriceysubscriptionmodels.
Asefficiencyofthesetechnologiesimprovesoverall,adoptionratesareexpectedtoincrease(Heinekeetal.,2022).Thereisabeliefwithintheindustrythatasthesetechnologiesgainaccesstomoreinformationanddata,theircapabilitieswillvast-lyimprove.Inturn,thebusinesscasesforsituationslikelongdrives,andconsum-erslookingforreliefinarduouscommuteswillimprove.However,standardization,lowerprices,andtechnologicalimprovementswilllikelybenecessaryforADAStoovercomeconsumeruncertainty.
GoingForward
ADAStechnologies’penetrationofseveralmarketsprovesthereisasolidnear-termbusinesscase.However,consumerswillrequirenear-term,pronouncedim-provementsinADASforcontinuedmarketpenetration.
Whenimplementedcorrectly,ADAScanprovideanattractiveincentivetocon-
sumers.However,adoptionofADASwillnotsolelycomefromtheexcitementsur-roundingthetechnology.ConsumerswillneedtobelieveinthepracticalbenefitsofADAS.
Safetyisapivotalsellingpoint,butADASmustalsoproveitcanmakethedrivingexperiencemoremanageableandlessburdensome.Thatproofcanonlyoccur
whenconsumersproperlyunderstandthebenefits,whichmeansclearlyunder-
stoodandconsistentnamingconventionsforADAStechnologies.Unfortunately,standardizationinnamingconventionsislikelyunrealisticinthenearterm,but
namesmorereflectiveoftherespectivetechnology’sabilitymayenhancethecon-sumer’sabilitytounderstand.
Drivereducationcanbridgethegap.Ifcompaniesarewillingtohelpconsumerscorrectlylearntheirvehicle’scapabilities,ADASusecouldbecomemorecommon-place,andlessofafeatureconsumersforgettouse(orintentionallyturnoff).
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH11
Drivermonitoringwillbeanessentialpieceofregulationtolimitthemisuseof
ADAS.Still,ifdrivermonitoringregulationrequiresafocussimilartothatofdrivingatraditionalvehicle,there’slittleincentivetouseADASfeatures.
HigherADASadoptionwilllikelybelimitedtoconditionsandspeedsthatpose
lessofathreatwhenthedriverisdisengaged.EvenifADASprojectstobelimitedinitson-roadapplications,companieswillstillintroducethesetechnologies.IfthecostsofADASremainhigh,consumersstillhaveachoiceintheirvehicletechnolo-gies,andtheapplicationsremainlimited,themarketwillbenarrow.Alternatively,ifcostsdropandapplicationsincrease,standardizationispossiblebytheendof
thedecade.
AutomatedVehicles(AV)
Overview
Vehicleautomation,definedasSAELevel4andLevel5technology,isthenextphaseofautomotivedrivingtechnologies(SAE,2021).WhileADASrepresents
technologiesthatpartiallyremovedriverresponsibility,AVsrepresentthecom-pleteshiftincontrolfromdrivertovehicle.TherationaleforfocusingonLevels4and5asdistinctlyautonomousisthatAVsremovethedriver.
Inthemid-2010’snumerousforecastspredictedthatLevel5wouldarrivesome-timethisdecade.Butastheyearshavepassed,few,ifanycompaniesorstudiesareprojectingfullautonomyandunrestrictedoperationaldesigndomains(ODD).
SimilartoADAS,AVshavebeentoutedasasolutionforsafety.Numerouscom-
paniesandstudieshavealsolistedAVsasasolutionforloweremissions,reducedtravelcosts,increasedproductivity,anddecreasedcongestion.Whilevarying
degreesofautomationareavailable,highautomationforwidespreadcommercialuseiscurrentlyunavailable.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH12
Figure2:SAELevelsSource:SAE.(2021,May3)
TimelineEvolution
Differingprojectionsfromconsultants,industrystakeholders,andacademiawerereflectedinCAR’slasttwoiterationsoftheTechnologyRoadmap,butsincethen,alltimelinesandprojectionshaveshifted.
Around2017,whenfundingforAVwasatanall-timehigh,manyconsultants,re-searchers,andindustrystakeholdersprojectedAVdeploymentandmarketpen-etrationby2020(Hawkins,2021).Inhindsight,theseprojectionswerebullish,andmanymissedthemark.Reportswithprojectionsarenowrare,andcurrently,mostconsultantreportsrefertotechnologicalbarriersandbreakthroughs,withfew
datesanddeadlines.OEMs,technologycompanies,suppliers,andotherstake-
holdersareprojectingmilestonesinthenearterm,manyofwhichareincremen-talandachievable.
Whileacademicresearchwasmoreconservativethanconsultantsandindustrystakeholders,theyalsomissedsomeoftheirprojectionsandforecasts.Conse-
quently,projectionshavebecomelessfrequentandfocusedprimarilyonbarrierstodeployment.
Alloftheseprojectionsdifferintheirlevelsofautomation,baseyear,rateofmar-ketpenetration,andODDcapability.Duetothesediscrepancies,theaggregationofforecastsisnowlessstraightforwardthanithadbeeninthepast.Whiletime-linesmaybedifficulttoproject,asummaryoftheissuescanprovidearoadmapfordeployment,andthebarriersstandingintheway.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH13
Industrystakeholdersattheroundtableacknowledgedthesemissedprojectionsandgaveinsightintothemostrealisticcurrentusecases.Withtheseinsightsandtheaggregationofcurrentstudies,itiseasiertounderstandtheAVdeploymentroadmapandobstacles.
Figure3:AggregateAVProjections
FromADAStoAV:SkippingaStep
WhenAVoptimismwasatitspeak,manycompaniespledgedtogofromLevel2toLevel4,skippingLevel3(Stathousis,2020).However,skippingLevel3hasprov-entobedifficult,inpartbecauseintherealworld,scalingisthebesttraining.
Ahandfulofcompanieshavestucktothatscalingmodel.Overthelasttwoyears,Mercedes-BenzandHondahaveintroducedLevel3technologiesintheirhomecountries(Sigal,2022).Thesecompaniesareconsideredindustryleaders,andthefirsttoofferahigherlevelofADASandAVtechnologytotheirconsumersforpri-vateuse.
TheseearlyinnovatorsofLevel3technologycouldtriggerwidespreadofferingsofLevel3(asnotedbyindustryparticipantsattheroundtable),ortheycouldremainoutliersifcompaniesareunwillingtoassumeliability.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH14
Othersintheindustrypointtoaten-yeartransitiontoLevel3,andtheissuesthatmayarisealongtheway.Level3hasalsobeenconsideredmuchmorecostlyto
develop,evenatalowerrate,makingconsumeradoptionmuchlesslikely.The
expertsonthepanelpushedagainsttheideathatLevel3willbehardtoachieve,butnotedthatbarrierslikethecostsofadditionalcomputingandsensortechnol-ogymustbeovercome.ForthesereasonstheprevailingsentimentisthatLevel2stillhasthestrongestbusinesscase.
KeyIssuesHoldingBackDeployment
Figure4:DeploymentBarriers
Consumer:AdoptionandRiskTolerance
ConsumerskepticismtowardAVsishigh.Theindustrymustaddresssafetyis-
suesbeforeconsumersconsiderthemaviablesolution(Stigloeetal.,2022).Whilecrashratesmaynotbehigherthanatraditionalvehicle,consumermistrustofAVs,stokedbypublicizedcrashesandmisuseofthetechnology,hasremainedcon-
sistentlyhighovertheyears.ConsumersneedtounderstandandbelieveAVsaresafebeforeanysignificantadoptioncanoccur.
However,itisunrealistictothinkofAVsasinfallibleand100percentsafe,socon-sumerswilleventuallyhavetoacceptsomelevelofriskandunderstandthelim-itationsoftheirvehicle(Litman,2022).Atthispoint,itisuncertainwhatlevelof
safetyisneeded(e.g.,10percentfewercrashes?1,000fewercrashespermiledriv-en?)beforeconsumersandregulatorsareconvincedthattherisksassociatedwithAVsarejustifiedandacceptable.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH15
BusinessCase
SafetyisnotnecessarilythesolesalespitchforAVs.Theyarealsotoutedasawaytoreducecongestion,lowercosts,maximizeefficiency,andincreaseproductivity(Litman,2022).
MaximizingefficiencyfacesanuphillbattleaslongasAVshavetosharetheroadwithtraditionalvehicles.Anall-AVscenariowouldlikelyoperateefficiently,buttherealityisthattheywillneedtoperformwithtraditionalvehiclesfortheforeseeablefuture.
IntheearlystagesofAVdevelopment,therewasoptimismthatAVswouldrelievetrafficcongestion.However,furtheranalysisofmodality,demand,andvehicle
milestraveled(VMT)projectionsnowchallengethisvision(Litman,2022).Ifin-
creasedadoptionofAVsresultsinmorevehiclesbeingontheroad,congestion
couldactuallyincrease.Forexample,aprivateorfleetvehiclemayopttocontinuedrivingbetweendrop-offpointsinsteadofparkingtoawaitthenexttransaction.Vehiclestallingwithoutariderisanotherpotentialissuethatcouldleadtocon-
gestion.
AsellingpointforAVsistheirapplicationsinridesharingwhichcouldcreatelowercostscomparedtoprivatevehicleownership(Heinekeetal.,2022).AVride-shar-ingshouldalsobecheaperthanatraditionaltaxibecauseoftheloweroperatingcosts.
AnothersellingpointofAVscomesfromconsumers’abilitytofocusonother
tasks.Freedfromtheresponsibilityofdriving,theycannowusetheirphones,eat,orpartakeinothertaskswhiletraveling.
RoundtableparticipantsalsonotedthattrucksandfleetsinageofencedareamaynowbethemostattractiveusecaseforAVs.
WhileAVsholdthepossibilityofprovidingconvenienceandefficiencybenefits,itremainstobeseenwhethertheseanticipatedbenefitssufficientlyoutweighini-tialsafetyconcernsininfluencingconsumeradoption.
©CENTERFORAUTOMOTIVERESEARCH16
Modality
VariousprojectionsofAVshavebeenpresentedasridesharingvs.privateowner-ship.However,forecastsregardingtheseconsumerpatternshavebeendifficulttoquantifywithareasonabledegreeofcertainty.Variablesinfluencingaconsumershiftfromownershiptoridesharingarecomplicated.Vehicleownershipiscultur-allyingrainedintheU.S.,makingmodelslikeridesharingamorecomplexsellingpoint(Mohammadzadeh,2021).
WhilemanyprojectionsforAVpricingsuggestAVswillbemorecostlythantra-
ditionalvehiclesandsoldatpricepointsoutsidethepricerangeofcomparable
consumersegments,therearequestionsaboutconsumers’willingnesstoditch
ownershipofAVsandsharevehicles.Sincethepandemic,adecreaseintheuseofridesharingsuggeststhatitstillfacessomeadoptionchallenges.However,ifthepriceissufficientlyenticing,potentialusersofridesharingservicesmaybemore
inclinedtousesuchaservice.ThelowoperatingcostsassociatedwithusinganAVforridesharingmayleadtomorefavorablepricing,shiftingconsumerpreferencestowardridesharingandawayfromprivateownership.
OperationalDesignDomainsCondition
AsAVtestinghasprogressed,ithasbecomeclearthatAVs’capabilitieswillbeaf-fectedbythedomaininwhichtheyoperate.OperationalDesignDomains(ODDs)limittheconditionsthataspecifictypeofAVtechnologycanbeused(Berman,
2019).TechnologycanbefullyautonomousinanODDbutprohibitedfromoperat-ingincertain,outsideconditionsorenvironments.ThedifferencebetweenlimitedODDs(Level4)andunlimitedODDs(Level5)isthatlimitedODDsprescribesa
specificgeographicalboundaryorasetofweatherconditionsforAVtechnologyoperation,whileunlimitedODDshasnosuchconstraints-geographicaloroth
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 快消品企业销售经理业绩达成率考核表
- 建筑项目安全管理与质量控制绩效考核表
- 便利店食品冷藏存储规范指引
- 酒店客房服务质量与服务环境细节管理考核表
- 远程教育智能交互平台操作指引
- 申请组建跨部门危机处理小组函(4篇)
- 2026企业 AI 智能体研究报告:就绪度、落地现状与阻碍The Rise of Agentic AI From Experimentation to Enterprise Readiness
- 供应原材料合同签订通知函(4篇)
- 合作方2026年度预算调整事宜确认函(3篇)
- 电商节日营销流量放大方案手册
- 农村污水处理工程施工组织设计
- 雨课堂学堂在线学堂云《信息检索与科技写作( 理大)》单元测试考核答案
- 概念验证中心运营细则
- 期末考试质量分析报告写作模板
- 银行绿色信贷宣传课件
- 大学版画教学课件
- 食品生物技术专业教学标准(高等职业教育专科)2025修订
- 住院患者沐浴管理制度
- T/CADBM 51-2021室内装饰用竹木纤维集成墙板应用技术规程
- 妊娠合并下肢静脉血栓护理
- PowerSurfacing-威力曲面-中文教程
评论
0/150
提交评论