版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
CLIMATECHANGEANDSUSTAINABILITY
HowCompaniesCanFindNewValuein
ExistingMaterials
ByPatrickHerhold,JaniceLee,AlexanderMeyerzumFelde,ArunRajamani,andEleonora
Tieri
ARTICLENOVEMBER11,202612MINREAD
Toooftenseenasanapproachtoend-oflifewastemanagement,circularityisinfactaresource-productivityandvalue-retentionstrategy.Embeddedinproducts,components,andmaterials
alreadyinuseisarichsourceofmaterialsthatliewithincompanies'reach.Iftheseleavethesystemorreturnflowsarenotcontrolled,thisvaluecanbelost.Butthroughcircularity—betterdesign,longeruse,componentrecovery,andeventuallymaterialrecovery—itcanberetainedandmonetized.
◎2026BostonConsultingGroup1
Inmacroeconomicterms,gainscouldbesubstantial.InGermany,forexample,researchby
BCG
andtheFederationofGermanIndustries(BDI)
estimatesthatby2045thecountry’scircular
economy’sgrossvalueadded(GVA)couldbe€130billion,twicetoday’s€65billion.
ForCEOs,atatimeofpricevolatilityandsupplyconstraints—BCGmodelingshowsdemandforcriticalmineralsat120%to250%offorecastsupplythrough2040—circularityoffersincreasedeconomicvalueandenhancedresilienceandstrengthensthebusinessmodel,allowing
companiestoremainclosertoexistingcustomerswhileaccessingnewsegments.Gainsshowupinmorethanrevenue:BCGanalysispointstoabout15%savingsonmaterialsand60%to70%lowermanufacturingcoststhroughrefurbishmentandremanufacturing—addingmorethanfivepercentagepointstomargins.Byidentifyingwherevalueleavesthesystem,controllingreturn
flows,andbuildingmechanismstocaptureit,CEOscanaccessthisvalue,anddosorightnow.
AccessingResourcesAlreadyinUse
Unlikelinearstrategies,whichsourceprimarymaterialsandconsumethemoncebefore
discardingthem,circularstrategiesseektorecovera“hiddenresourcebalancesheet”embeddedinexistingproducts,components,andmaterials.Appliancesandconsumerelectronicsinuse
acrosstheEUprovideagoodillustrationofthisphenomenon.
Circularstrategiesseektorecovera“hiddenresourcebalancesheet”embeddedinexistingproducts,
components,andmaterials.
Theseproductscontaincriticalminerals—copper,aluminum,rareearths,andpreciousmetals
chiefamongthem—collectivelyworthmorethan€65billioninstockacrosstheEU(seeExhibit1).Thegapinthesematerialsflowsisstriking.TheproductsthatreachtheendoftheiruseintheEUeachyearcontainabout€9billionofthatcritical-mineralvalue,morethantheroughly€6
billionofcriticalmineralsEUelectronicsmanufacturingrequireseveryyear.
©2026BostonConsultingGroup2
◎2026BostonConsultingGroup
EXHIBIT1
PreservingProductValueCanOfferFarGreaterReturnsThan
RecoveringMaterialsAlone
AlargestockofcriticalmineralsisalreadyinuseinEUhouseholds...
CRITICALMINERALSVALUEINEUCONSUMERELECTRONICSANDHOMEAPPLIANCES(EBILLION)
…andkeepingproductsinuseoftencreatesmoreeconomicvaluethanrecoveringmaterialsalone
SMARTPHONEEXAMPLE:REVENUEGENERATEDACROSSTHE
Nottoscale
ProductsreachingEUmanufacturingendofuseannualneed
Annualflow
(peryear)
毛300E800additionallife-cyclerevenue
(Fromrepair+refurbishedresale=upto~100%oftheinitialretailvalue)
200-600
100-200
~5
RetailpriceRepairservice
(e.g.,screen,battery)
Additionallife-cyclevalueEnd-of-lifevalue
Refurbishedresaleretains40x-120×
morevaluethanmaterialrecovery
Stock
(inuseatapointintime)
Initialproduct
value
Productscurrentlyinuse
Refurbished
resale
Recovered
material
800-1,100
>65
Sources:BCGanalysis;BCG-BDI“Growth,Competitiveness,andResilience”(2026);BCG-C2CElectronicsInitiative(2026).
Note:SmartphonevaluesareexamplesbasedonBCGmodelestimatesandmayaccruetodifferentmarketparticipants.
Europeimportsmostofitsfinishedelectronics—fewerthan1%ofsmartphonesandfewerthan20%ofvacuumcleanerssoldtherearemadelocally—buttheproductsstayinEuropeuntiltheyreachtheendoftheiruse.Thiscreatesanannualcritical-mineralvaluethatishigherthanwhatisneededtomakenewproductsintheEU.Whereproductionislargelydomestic,thepictureis
clearerstill.ForlargeappliancessoldinEurope—about75%ofwhicharemadedomestically—theend-of-usestreamholdsgreatvalue.Washingmachines,forexample,containabout€0.5
billionincriticalminerals,roughly70%ofthe€0.7billionrequiredbyEUproductioneachyear.
ThishasimportantimplicationsforCEOs.Incertainindustries,whatisrecoveredfromdomesticstockcouldprovideasignificantshareofthematerialsneededtoproducenewgoods.Thiscutscostsbyreducingtheneedtobuyprimarymaterialsanddecreasesrelianceonimports.
Today,onlypartofthisvalueiscaptured.Onlyabout43%ofEuropeane-wasteisformally
collected,againsta65%EUtarget,andcriticalmineralsaccountfor75%ofthevalueinthat
stream.Themissing57%isnotsittinginpeople'shomes.Just13oftheaverage74electrical
itemsinEuropeanhouseholdsareunused,andcollectionratesforlargeappliances,whicharetoobulkyforhouseholdstostore,arehigh.
Instead,theproblemisoftenoneofprocessingratherthancollection.Electronicdevicesand
appliancesareoftenpickedupoutsidetheformalsystem,wherethematerialsaredowncycledratherthanrecoveredatvalue.Forexample,anestimated13%ofEuropeane-wasteisabsorbedbyscrapmetalchannelsthatrecoverbulksteelbutloserefrigerants,plastics,andcritical
minerals;around8%goesintoresidualwaste;andanestimated5%isreportedasillegallyexported.
©2026BostonConsultingGroup4
Capturingmoreofthisvaluemeansfirstidentifyingwhatcanberepairedorrefurbishedand
wherecomponentharvestingandmaterialrecoveryisfeasible.Itthenmeansbuildingthe
reverse
logistics
,ownership,andservicemodelsneededtobringproductsbackintothesystem.
Productdatarequirementssupportcircularity.Forexample,forcertainproducts,theEUis
phasinginitsDigitalProductPassport(DPP)containingdetailssuchasaproduct’sorigin,
materialcomposition,components,andrepairandrecycleinformation.Digitalplatformscan
matchsupplyanddemandforusedassets.Conditiondataallowsreturnstobepricedandroutedautomatically.AndnewdigitaltoolssuchasAI-assistedsortingandgradingwillincreaserecoveryquality.
Circularvaluehasahierarchy:preservingproductlifethroughdesign;thenreuse,resale,repair,refurbishment,and
product-as-a-servicemodels
;andthenthroughcomponentharvesting,
remanufacturingandultimatelyrecycling.Thishierarchymatterseconomically.Forexample,thevalueofasecondhandsmartphoneinsalesisabout€200to€600,comparedwithonlyabout€5foritsrecoveredmaterial.
AsimilarpatterncanbeseeninGermanindustryasawhole.AccordingtotheBCG-BDIresearch,therearefivesegments—mobility,mechanicalengineering,construction,energy,andtextiles,
whichtogetheraccountfor62%ofnationalindustrialvalueadded—inwhichcircularitycan
strengthenresilienceandsecurityofsupply.Forexample,by2045,importdependencyonrare
earthsandstrategicbatterymaterialscouldbereducedby20%and10%,respectively,versusthebaselinescenario,evenafteraccountingforhigherdemand.Andforbothelectronicsandbroaderindustry,theprizeisusuallyaccessiblewithoutrebuildingthesystem.
Enhancedcoordination,infrastructure,andmarketdevelopmentcouldliftcircularGVA.In
Germany,forexample,thiscouldtotalabout€130billionby2045,withroughly€33billionin
investment.Eventoday,however,regulatoryandmarkettrendsmakecircularstrategies
accessible,withanestimated€7billioninone-offinvestmentsgeneratingupto€100billionby2045.
Inotherwords,deepstructuraldisruptionisnotnecessarytocapturevalue.Whilesystemredesignandecosystemcoordinationexpandthepotentialupsideovertime,withtherightstrategies,circularvalueisavailablerightnow.
©2026BostonConsultingGroup5
CapturingValueBothInternallyandExternally
Forbusinessleaders,thegoalistomaximizethevalueofeachproductoveritslife,reducing
materialandsupplyrisk,capturingmoreofitsvalue—andimprovingmargins.Threestrategiesarecritical:preservingitshigh-valuestate,regainingaccesstoit,andmonetizingit.
Topreservethehigh-valuestate,productdesigniskey,determiningwhetherrepair,refurbishment,componentharvesting,andhigh-qualitymaterialrecoverywillbetechnicallyandeconomically
feasible.Forlong-livedproducts,today’sdesigndecisionswillshapetomorrow’ssecondaryresourcestreams.
Thesecondstrategicimperativeisregainingaccesstovaluethroughreturns.Currentreturnflowsareleavingvalueonthetable.Forexample,about60%to70%ofend-of-usewashingmachines
cantechnicallybereusedorrefurbished.Yetonlyaround1%to2%ofcollectedmachinesare
resold.Reverselogistics,trade-ins,take-backs,customerrelationships,ownershipstructures,andproductvisibility(theabilitytotrackaproduct’slifestageandlocation)areallneededto
recapturethisvalue.
Finally,monetizationmakesretainedvaluepriceableandeconomicallyattractive.When
providersretaintheasset,ownershipandservicemodelsturndurability,useability,repairability,andrecoveryfromexternalitiesintoeconomiclevers.
Washingmachinesagainprovideanillustration.Forexample,somecommercialpay-per-use
modelshavemarginsmorethan15percentagepointshigherpermachinethanthoseofone-offsales.Andasashareoflifetimerevenue,theembeddedmaterialvalue(derivedfromreusing
productsmultipletimes)inwashingmachinesisaboutfourtimeslowerasaservicethaninaone-offsale.
Therearetrade-offs,however.Akeychallengeisthatretainingownershipkeepsproductsonthecompany’sbalancesheet,tyingupcapitalandspreadingrevenueovertimeratherthanbookingitupfront.Retained-valuemodelscancannibalizesalesofnewproducts.Toattractincrementalsalesoravoidlostdemand,thismeansdesigningandpricingoffersthattargettherightcustomersegmentsandproducttiers.Nordoallcommercialincentivesfavorcircularity.Forexample,in
manufacturingandretailing,paymentsarefrequentlymadebyunitsshipped,soaproductkeptinuseisonenotsold.Andrecyclersarepaidbytonnageprocessed;thisrewardsrecoveryofbulk
metaloverthatofthecriticalminerals,whichhold75%ofthematerialvalueine-waste.
Circularity’sstartingpointsalsodifferbysector(seeExhibit2).In
mechanicalengineering
,for
example,thepriorityisretainingthehighestvalueoftheinstalledbaseandpreservingcustomerrelationshipsthroughrepairservices,refurbishment,andremanufacturingofcomponents.In
construction,valuesitsateachendofthechain:therenovationandretrofitofexistingbuildings,
whichrequiresfarlessmaterialthannewconstruction,andhigher-qualityrecyclingofconcrete,steel,aluminum,glass,wood,andplastics.
EXHIBIT2
TheHighest-ValueCircularOpportunitySitsataDifferentLife-Cycle
StageinEachIndustry
Largestincrementalcircularopportunity
KEEPPRODUCT/FUNCTIONINUSE
Mechanical
engineering
Construction
Retrofitandadaptivereuse
Mobility
Componentremanufacturing
Energy
Textiles
Reuseandresale
Theoptimalstartingpointissector-specific
EXTEND,REPAIR,ANDUPGRADE
Componentreuseandsecond-lifebatteries
RECOVER
COMPONENTS
Batteryandmaterialrecycling
Componentsremanufacturing
RECOVER
MATERIALS
Criticalmineralsrecycling
Selectivedeconstruction
Repairandaftermarket²
Fiber-to-fiberrecycling
Materialrecycling
Repairservices
Sources;BCG-BDICircularEconomyStudy(2026);BCGanalysis.
Note:Markersshowincrementalvaluepotentialquantifiedformatureeconomies(e.g.,EU,US,Japan);resultsforotherregionsmaydifferduetovaryingmarketconditions,regulatoryframeworks,andinfrastructure;bubblessizeindicatestherelativesizeoftheincrementalvalueopportunitywithineachindustry.
¹ALreadyestablished.
Inthemobilitysector,autorepairandmaintenancealreadymakeupalargeandestablishedaftermarket;theincrementalopportunityliesincomponentremanufacturingandbatteryandmaterialrecovery.Inenergy,functioninginfrastructureandcomponentsofferthehighestvaluethroughlifeextension,componentreuse,andsecond-ifebatteries.Andintextiles,valueis
accessedthroughcontinuedproductuseandreuse(resale,rental,andrepair),andultimatelythroughfibervalue(collectionandsorting,fiber-to-fberrecycling).
Meanwhile,theabilitytoscalecircularity'svaluecapturereliesnotonlyonwhatcompaniescancontrolinternallybutalsoonachainofexternalconditions.Returnedassetscannotbetradedunlesstheirconditioncanbeassessedandpriced,whichrequiressharedstandardssuchas
conditiongradesforelectronics,partspecificationsformachinery,andmaterial-quality
classificationsforbuildingproducts.Datastandards,inotherwords,matteratleastasmuchasphysicalinfrastructure.
AFive-MoveCEOAgenda
◎2026BostonConsultingGroup
◎2026BostonConsultingGroup
Whilethesethreestrategiesfocusonthesourcesofcircularvalue,successfulcaptureofthat
valuemeansimplementingtherightorganizationalstrategies.Fivemovesarekeytomakingthishappen(seeExhibit3).
EXHIBIT3
FiveMovestoTurnResourceStockAlreadyinUseintoaRepeatable
Value-CaptureSystem
VALUECAPTURED
Recurringrevenue
Valuehierarchyandlifetimemargin
Highermargins
Lowermaterialexposure
Greaterresilience
ALIGN&SCALE
Partners,investors,funds,andspending
DATA+AI
Identify,grade,price,andtrackKPls
MAP
Installedbaseandvaluecliffs
OWN
Oneexecutive
forend-to-end
BUILDTHECASE
circularity
Source;BCGanalysis,
Putoneexecutiveincharge.Circularityfrequentlyfailsonorganization,nottechnology.DesignsitsinR&D,returnsinafter-sales,recyclinginsustainability,andmaterialsavingsinprocurement.Butnobodyownsthevaluethatfallsbetweenthem.Toaddressthisproblem,asingleexecutiveshouldbemadeaccountableforcircularity,withamandatethatcoversdesign,service,returns,andsourcing,andanumericaltargettodeliveragainst.Withoutthisleadership,thenextfour
movesarelikelytostall.
Establishthevalueofpriorityproductsandidentifypointswherethisvaluedrops.Valueexistsnotonlyintheinstalledbasebutalsoinmaterials,infrastructure,andbusinessmodels.Foreachpriorityproductandmaterialcluster,companiesneedtoquantifyprimary-supplyexposure,
installed-basevalue,residualcomponentvalue,returnrates,andrecoveryquality;andtheyneedtosizethevaluetiedtotheinfrastructureandbusinessmodelsaroundthem.Thepurposeistolocatethe“cliffs”—pointsatwhichaproduct'sworthcollapsesbyanorderofmagnitude—andtodecidewhichoftheseproductsitmakeseconomicsensetorecover.
Followthevaluehierarchyandbuildtheend-to-endbusinesscase.Takeproductandfunction
lifefirst,thencomponentretention,thenmaterialrecovery.Evaluatetheend-to-endeconomics—includingcapex,feedstockavailability,processingcost,productcannibalization,reducedmaterialuseandcapitalspend,downstreamdemand,andpartnereconomics—andassessitsimpactonproductlifetimemarginsratherthanfirst-salerevenues.Inthenearterm,muchofthereturn
comesfromcostsavings:lowermaterialintake,cheaperrepairusingharvestedparts,andfewerlossesinreverseflows.
MakedataandAItheoperatingbackbone.Retainedvaluecanbepricedonlyifitisvisible.
Integratetraceability,digitalrecordssuchastheDPP,andassetconditiondataintocore
processessothatproductreturnscanbeidentified,graded,priced,androutedforreuse,repair,
refurbishment,remanufacturing,orrecycling.Digitalplatformsthatidentifyrecoverableoridle
assetsacrossaproductgroupofferapositivereturnoninvestmentandenableeveryothermove.UseAIforsorting,grading,andpredictivemaintenancethatextendsassetlife.Thesamedata
foundationmakescircularitymeasurable.TheKPIsthatbestassesscircularity’svalueare
retainedvalueperunitofresource,return-flowcapture,revenuebeyondfirstsale,marginoncircularlines,customerlifetimevalue,andprimary-materialexposureavoided.
Retainedvaluecanbepricedonlyifitisvisible.Digitalplatformsthatidentifyrecoverableoridleassets
acrossaproductgroupofferapositivereturnoninvestmentandenableeveryothermove.
Lineuppartnersandinvestorsandsequencethespending.Circularvalueiscreatedin
ecosystems.Suppliers,logisticsproviders,refurbishers,recyclers,investors,andcustomersall
needtoaccessashareofthisvalue.Thismeansestablishingtheroles,datacontributions,andvaluesplitforeachstakeholderupfront.Earlyinvestmentsshouldfocusonareaswherecurrentregulation,markets,andpublicfundsstrengthenthecase.Public-sectorvehiclesareanunder-usedsource;forexample,thefundsthatadvancedeconomieshaveallocatedtocriticalmineralsreachedabout$65billionin2025,yetlessthan20%havebeenused.System
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 合规风险管理部门绩效考评表
- 小学教资面试道法试讲历年真题题库试卷参考答案
- 事业单位财会岗面试专业面试经典考题必练考题
- 事业单位计算机岗面试2026全真模拟经典考题试卷及答案
- 协调设备安装调试时间确认函(3篇范文)
- 2026初中数学教资面试试讲易错题题库及解析
- 关于项目合同的签订与通知函4篇
- 企业战略风险管理规划与实施方案
- 精算笃行财润新程-财务部年度总结报告
- 客车驾驶员20X4年度工作总结
- 人教版(2024)三年级上册6.6《一个因数末尾有0的乘法》课件
- JGJ52-2006 普通混凝土用砂、石质量及检验方法标准
- 四川省民族地区旅游产业发展综合规划
- 主题班会调整心态缓解压力省公开课一等奖全国示范课微课金奖课件
- 病毒基因组课件
- 2024全国职业院校技能大赛ZZ060母婴照护赛项规程+赛题
- 临床微生物实验室在感控中的角色
- 三年级英语课标解读课件
- 住宅小区安全技术防范系统建设技术规范
- 企业负责人试卷2附有答案
- JJG 882-2019压力变送器
评论
0/150
提交评论