陈逸飞离世十周年后的怀念与争议.doc

关于追忆陈逸飞文章与陈逸鸣先生指责的回应在微信中逐渐看到徐佳和女士的陈逸飞辞世十周年，合作画家追忆往事这篇文章。起初我也没有在意，看了全文，觉得她转呈俞中保的表述没有大问题。我并不知道她会发表这篇文章，发表前我也没看过。在5月7日，我们的老朋友石建邦先生陪同徐佳和女士到工作室访问。1996年俞中保的作品佛光在香港佳士得拍卖，当时建邦兄是上海佳士得办事处代表，我们因此机缘相识，建立了相互信任的关系。他陪同徐女士到画室来，希望了解一些俞中保在陈逸飞工作室工作的情况。俞中保向他们所说的都是真实客观的，没有任何不实夸大！俞中保是个挚爱艺术，又独立低调、踏实的艺术家。他出生在上海一个自民国时期以来即有影响的家族，他的祖父经营的是上海最早的拍卖行之一：瑞和洋行，海上绘画全集的编年史上有著录：1900年5月，瑞和洋行拍卖外国名人绘画和油画两次，拍卖中国名人字画一次。他的表姨父是国民政府国防部长顾祝同。虽然他有此身世，但他从不愿意以此示人，他也不允许我多讲。在那些困难的年月，中保父亲坚持培养他学习艺术，希望他将来以艺立足。俞中保就是有坚定的信念：人是可以用艺术表达人生的。当年遇到陈逸飞老师，他非常高兴能在名师门下学艺。这是20多年前的事了。我六叔赵志权是上海芭蕾舞团的著名舞蹈家，在芭蕾舞剧白毛女中演莫仁智。当年白毛女的全国轰动是早于陈逸飞老师出名以先的，他们是小学同学，关系非常密切。陈逸飞老师经常到我家做客。我记得他为我五叔结婚画一幅海景，大家都围坐在他旁边。我父母都是上海交通大学的高材生，父亲是船舶系，母亲是电机系，在当时也是北京东路外滩老大楼里的佼佼者。陈逸飞老师还欣然为我父母画了结婚像，这是很难得的友谊。我称陈逸飞老师为叔叔。我当年并不认识陈逸鸣先生，俞中保在陈逸飞老师工作室时我也从来没有见到过陈逸鸣先生，是后来才认识的，但我也很尊重他。这次在微信上看到他的表述，我感到非常震惊！陈逸飞老师刚到上海的工作室只有俞中保和韦强（但他不是画家，也是他的邻居，帮忙做些事），确实是因为工作量太大难以为继，俞中保才希望让陈老师再找人，等工作过渡完善了，俞中保才请辞的。我们也认识黄英浩老师，他总是温和无声地陪在陈逸飞老师身旁，在拍电影过程中，黄英浩老师和陈逸飞老师一起确实付出了极大的努力，立下了汗马功劳。当时陈逸飞老师在上海时，有很多人帮助他，其实不应该忘记。我2002年从上海人民美术出版社（十二年的资深美术史编辑，得过国家图书奖）进入拍卖行从事中国现当代艺术的专家工作，2008年担任阳光艾德拍卖总经理，组织举办了中国第一场使用法国ARTCURIAL拍卖品牌的中国当代艺术专场。当年我努力将陈逸飞老师的最后一幅具有里程碑意义的自画像，拍卖出了陈逸飞先生拍卖纪录排名第二的成绩。由于太劳累了引起带状疱疹到眼角膜，差点瞎了一个眼睛。我说这些不是为了要功，也不是为了抬高自己，也不是要谁来说对或不对，而是这是历史！是我们这代人真真实实走过来的。陈逸飞老师是国际公认的伟大的中国当代艺术家，他是垦荒牛，开拓者！他的艺术成就是实实在在的，无论用何种创作方法都无法磨灭他的前瞻性！真的假不了，假的真不了！有真诚的心是难能可贵的！1987年俞中保获得国际交流展一等奖的时候，（这个展览是中国最早的国际艺术展之一）他还没有遇到陈逸飞老师，1992年郎静山先生为俞中保题写：俞中保油画集，那时俞中保还没有遇到陈逸飞老师。一个人一生的路是一步一步走过来的。当年，凡代克在鲁本斯工作室学艺，德加在安格尔门徒工作室学艺，毕加索向德加学艺，这都没有什么羞愧的，不应该用那样俗气，那样污秽的语言来指责，那是不文明的，是有辱斯文的，是难为情的。在我们心目中，我们和陈逸飞老师的感情是纯洁的，清澈的。俞中保是一个温和宽容的人，我看到这个微信，我觉得陈逸鸣先生是被名利得失充满了，有失学术的正确态度。很难过！我给俞中保看微信，他只淡淡地说：随他去吧。（而且不允许我写文章。）但我认为这是非同小可的事，我想：上帝是公义的，我不惹事也不怕事。陈利（收藏界人士）：回忆陈逸飞澎湃新闻刊发纪念陈逸飞辞世十周年的往事回忆，让我想起一些点滴往事。我与陈逸飞相识于他请刘海粟大师吃饭时，后来经常在机场碰到他和不同的模特在一起，也经常在一起参加各种活动和吃饭，他没追到的女孩还主动来跟我谈朋友。平时他都是笑嘻嘻的，但他在博物馆开画展时我和忘年至交施南池教授一起去，施老以为他不认识我，介绍道陈利是嗯（我）好朋友，那时他脸上闪过一丝不高兴，后来才知道原因我变成他“长辈”了！施老是培养少年调皮的陈逸飞走上绘画人生的启蒙老师。我和陈后来还一起去北京参加时装周。施老去世后我打电话给他，他推掉别的事很早就来了！他去世后，生平中也专门提到受施南池老师启蒙开始绘画，说明他和他的家人还是很感激施老改变了他的人生！他没钱，我是一向知道的，有一年他还叫我们一起做镜框出口生意，我嫌小没兴趣做。他的工作室里有个哑巴据说画得不错！郭庆祥：陈逸飞部分作品是哑巴助手代画的陈逸飞的作品虽然现在受市场热捧，我与陈逸飞上世纪90年代就相识，但我并不认为他是艺术家：首先是其作品的艺术价值含金量不高，模拟性的写实技巧也是人家西方的东西，没有自身的独立思想；其次是我与他的一次交往，让我更加确定他的创作和艺术没有关系。1997年我有事去他的工作室，他有一张画刚刚勾好线条，内容是三个女人和两个鸟笼。我们交谈后约定半个月后再在其画室见面，因为第二天他要去美国。半月后我们见面，我惊奇地发现，那张油画已完整地呈现在我们面前。原来画室有个哑巴帮他完成了全部的“创作”。2010年4月10日，上海美术馆，观众欣赏陈逸飞先生的美术作品。 视觉中国 资料2010年4月10日，上海美术馆，观众欣赏陈逸飞先生的美术作品。 视觉中国 资料曹可凡：代笔一说纯属痴人说梦陈逸飞早年在美国画音乐题材及之后一些老上海题材工笔画时，的确像伦勃朗画室那样，有助手为其做辅助工作。或许也听到些许风言风语，千禧年前后，陈逸飞开始舍弃过往风格，转向相对粗犷一路，以大笔触描摹人物和风景，绘画周期大为缩短，而且更显大气，买家反而愈加追捧，这更让逸飞信心大增。那段时间，画家常常7、8幅画同时开工，因油画需层层描绘，但油彩未干又不能继续，故几幅画一起画可节省时间，画家基本功又扎实，作品照样大气厚实。那时，确有一聋人助手协助工作，常在画室见他，他仅做些最基础工作。工作之余，他也画些小画送到画廊去卖，水平相当一般，根本无法承担“代笔”重任。所谓代笔，就是完全假他人之手完成作品。早期陈逸飞画音乐题材和老上海由助手为其做辅助工作，但也绝非代笔。所以，那些人如俞中保之流顶多算助手，代笔一说纯属痴人说梦。（本文引自微信“可凡倾听”）陈逸鸣：他们只是想炒作自己文章（陈逸飞辞世十年，合作画家追忆往事）中被釆访的所谓陈逸飞的“合作者”在抵毁、玷污陈逸飞名誉上早已是前科累累的惯犯，陈逸飞在世时他们就干过此类事情。如今更是胡编乱造，信口雌黄，借追忆往事之名行贬低逸飞，抬高自己之实，争当陈逸飞的“亲密战友”。他们与那些扒光衣服，露出残肢，捧着破碗要饭的乞丐有何二致！陈逸飞生前曾说，我不会去追究，放他们一条生路，因为他们只是想炒作自己，唬弄唬弄买画的，赚点钱养家。可怜！可耻！可悲啊！On the recall of Chen Yifeis article and the response of Mr. Chen YimingIn WeChat gradually saw the ten anniversary of Xu Jia and Lady Chen Yifei died, cooperative remembrance of this article the painter. At first I did not care, see the full text, think she turned to Yu Zhongbaos statement no big problem.I didnt know she was going to publish this article. I didnt read it before. In May 7th, our old friend, Mr. Shi Jianbang, was accompanied by Xu Jia and ms. 1996 Yu Zhongbao works Buddhist Christies auction in Hong Kong that brother state is representative of Shanghai Christies office, we therefore opportunity met established mutual trust relationship. He accompanied Ms. Xu to the studio, want to know some of Yu Zhongbao in the Chen Yifei studio work situation. Yu Zhongbao to what they are saying is true and objective, there is no real exaggeration!Yu Zhongbao is a love of art, but also an independent low-key, pragmatic artist. He was born in a Shanghai since the period of the Republic of China is influential family. His grandfather is one of Shanghais first auction: Rui and Matheson, the chronicles of the complete works of sea painting with a record: in May 1900, Swiss and Matheson auction foreign celebrity painting and oil painting of two times, auction of celebrity calligraphy and painting in China once. His uncle is the national government table defense minister Gu Zhutong. Although he had this life experience, but he never wanted to show people, he also does not allow me to say. In those difficult years, the father insisted that his father insisted on training him to study art, hope he will be based on the future of art. Yu Zhongbao is a firm belief that people can use art to express life. When Chen Yifei met the teacher, he is very happy to have the teacher apprenticeship under the door. This was 20 years ago.My six uncle Zhao Zhiquan is a famous ballet dancer in Shanghai, Mo Renzhi played in the ballet white haired girl. When white haired girl the sensation is early in the famous teacher Chen Yifei before they are primary school students, the relationship is very close. Chen Yifei often went to my house. I remember him as my uncle married to paint a picture of the sea, everyone sitting beside him. Both of my parents are Shanghai Jiaotong University student. My father is a ship, the mother is the Department of electrical engineering at that time is Beijing Tung Road Waitan old building leader. Chen Yifei teacher is also pleased to draw a marriage for my parents, this is a very rare friendship. I call my uncle Chen Yifei.I didnt know Mr. Chen Yiming, and I had never met Mr. Yu Zhongbao in the studio of Chen Yifei, but I did not know it, but I also respected him. I was shocked to see him in the micro channel!Chen Yifeis teacher just to Shanghai studio only Yu Baohe Wei Qiang (but he is not a painter, is one of his neighbors to help to do something), is indeed because of too much work is unsustainable, Yu Zhongbao wanted to let Mr. Chen to find people, transition to improve, Yu Zhongbaocai resignation. We also know Huang Yinghao teacher, he always gentle silently accompany beside Chen teacher, in making movies. Huang Yinghao teachers and Chen Yifei teacher together really paid a great effort, made a contribution. When the teacher in Shanghai, Chen Yifei, a lot of people to help him, in fact, should not forget.I in 2002 from Shanghai Peoples fine arts publishing house editor (twelve years of senior art history, National Book Award) into the auction house in Chinese modern and contemporary art expert working, 2008 served as the sun ed auction general manager, organized by the China first use French ARTCURIAL auction brand China contemporary art special.When I tried to be the last piece of Chen Yifeis landmark self portrait, the auction of the Chen Yifei auction record ranking second of the results. Due to overwork caused by herpes zoster to cornea, almost blind in one eye. I say that these are not to work, nor to raise themselves, nor is it to who is right or wrong, but this is history! Its the one we really have to come.Teacher Chen Yifei is internationally recognized as a great Chinese contemporary artist, he is the pioneer of reclamation of cattle! His artistic achievemen