厦工VS柳工VS三一的参数比较.xls

厦厦工工挖挖机机与与柳柳工工 三三一一同同吨吨位位机机型型技技术术参参数数比比较较 挖挖掘掘机机品品牌牌厦厦工工厦厦工工柳柳工工三三一一厦厦工工 挖挖掘掘机机机机型型XG805L XG805L XG806XG806906C906C SY65CSY65C XG808XG808 整整机机重重量量kgkg4600460058505850590059006300630078007800 标标准准斗斗容容m3m30 250 250 220 22 0 280 280 13 0 280 13 0 280 250 250 320 32 0 40 4 发发动动机机 发发动动机机厂厂家家名名称称新新昌昌洋洋马马洋洋马马五五十十铃铃五五十十铃铃 发发动动机机型型号号A498BPG 4A498BPG 44TNV94L SFN4TNV94L SFN4TNV94L4TNV94LCC 4JG1CC 4JG1AA 4JG1TPCAA 4JG1TPC 排排量量L L3 173 173 0523 0523 0543 0543 0593 0593 0593 059 扭扭距距Nm rpmNm rpm192 1680192 1680214 1000214 1000207207188188255 1800255 1800 额额定定功功率率kwkw404035 535 537 437 4404053 8 215053 8 2150 额额定定转转速速r minr min2400240022002200210021002100210021502150 性性能能参参数数 回回转转速速度度r minr min10109 99 59 510 910 91212 行行走走速速度度 高高 低低 km hkm h35 035 04 2km h4 2km h3 7 2 33 7 2 34 7 2 44 7 2 45 1 3 25 1 3 2 爬爬坡坡能能力力度度 34343535353535353535 最最大大牵牵引引力力kNkN212148 548 548 548 548 548 55858 履履带带节节数数 单单侧侧轮轮式式4040404042424444 托托链链轮轮数数 单单侧侧轮轮式式1 11 11 11 1 支支重重轮轮数数 单单侧侧轮轮式式5 55 55 55 5 接接地地比比压压 kPakPa轮轮式式32323232323234 534 5 标标准准动动臂臂 mmmm27802780300030003000300037203720 标标准准斗斗杆杆 mmmm17601760160016001600160016201620 最最大大挖挖掘掘高高度度mmmm5515551557505750579057906930693071607160 最最大大卸卸载载高高度度mmmm3900390041004100413541355145514550805080 最最大大挖挖掘掘深深度度mmmm3145314538203820387538753985398541904190 最最大大垂垂直直挖挖掘掘深深度度mmmm2250225032003200294029403470347035503550 8 8 水水平平面面最最大大挖挖掘掘深深度度2 52 5米米底底宽宽29002900无无34503450 最最大大挖挖掘掘半半径径mmmm5750575061006100625062506160616063306330 地地面面最最大大挖挖掘掘半半径径mmmm 6200 6200 转转弯弯半半径径 6065606561806180 最最小小回回转转半半径径mmmm23252325243024301720172016901690 最最小小回回转转半半径径时时最最大大高高度度mmmm430043004500450056505650 最最小小离离地地间间隙隙mmmm220220360360360360375375360360 主主要要规规格格尺尺寸寸 运运输输长长度度mmmm3335333559005900590059006000600061006100 运运输输高高度度mmmm2710271026302630268526852560256026002600 总总宽宽mmmm2035203519201920190019002160216022252225 上上车车平平台台宽宽度度mmmm1900190017801780182018202040204022202220 下下车车履履带带宽宽度度mmmm轮轮式式192019201900190022002200 司司机机室室高高度度mmmm25502550216021602685268526002600 尾尾部部回回转转半半径径mmmm1715171516501650167716771720172017501750 配配重重离离地地间间隙隙mmmm无无690690705705765765 行行走走机机构构总总长长mmmm无无253025302530253021802180 轮轮距距 轴轴距距 mmmm22102210轴轴距距19901990199019901990199021402140 履履带带接接地地长长度度mmmm轮轮式式25302530253025302180218021402140 履履带带板板宽宽度度 标标配配 mmmm轮轮式式400400400400400400450450 履履带带轨轨距距mmmm轮轮式式15001500150015001680168017501750 铲铲斗斗挖挖掘掘力力 常常压压 增增压压 kNkN27 7 ISO 27 7 ISO 37 7 ISO 37 7 ISO 393949495858 斗斗杆杆挖挖掘掘力力 常常压压 增增压压 kNkN ISO ISO 2828 ISO ISO 27273535 安安全全阀阀设设定定压压力力 增增压压MPaMPa242424242525262631 431 4 工工作作回回路路溢溢流流压压力力MPaMPa21 621 621 621 621 621 621 621 631 431 4 行行走走回回路路溢溢流流压压力力MPaMPa21 621 621 621 621 621 6262631 431 4 回回转转回回路路溢溢流流压压力力MPaMPa2020202017 617 621 621 620 620 6 控控制制回回路路溢溢流流压压力力MPaMPa手手动动控控制制3 93 93 63 63 63 63 93 9 液液压压泵泵最最大大流流量量l minl min60X260X255X2 35 656 5 2 37 256 5 2 37 2149149172172 液液压压油油箱箱容容量量L L8686868682821001006060 燃燃料料油油箱箱容容量量L L100100100100110110130130130130 简简单单评评价价 红红体体字字为为优优势势 1 16吨级挖机 厦工机动力扭矩大 其它优势不明显 三一机挖掘力大 燃油箱较大 2 28吨级挖机 厦工采用五十铃动力 节能高效的优势 厦工挖掘范围大 挖掘力大 回转速度快 作业效率高 液压系统配置和柳工一样 但动力配置比柳工高 3 315吨级挖机 厦工动力配置比柳工高 但厦工作业范围没有优势 4 421吨级挖机 厦工动力配置最高 高可靠低燃耗五十铃原装发动机 卸载高度大 使装卸操作更方便 挖掘范围大 5 522吨级挖机 厦工动力配置最高 高可靠低燃耗五十铃原装发动机 卸载高度大 使装卸操作更方便 挖掘范围大 但挖掘力比柳工小 6 623吨级挖机 厦工比三一挖掘范围大 挖掘力较大 7 725吨级挖机 厦工动力配置比柳工高 高可靠低燃耗五十铃原装发动机 液压泵排量大 作业效率高 8 833吨级挖机 厦工液压油箱大 散热性能较好 斗杆挖掘力大 柳柳工工三三一一厦厦工工柳柳工工三三一一厦厦工工柳柳工工柳柳工工三三一一 908C908CSY75CSY75C XG815LCXG815LCCLG915CCLG915C SY135CSY135C XG821XG821CLG920CLG920CLG210CLG210SY210CSY210C 77007700680068001390013900135001350013500135002050020500203002030021000210002090020900 0 320 320 280 280 45 0 60 45 0 60 550 550 530 530 70 7 0 90 90 850 850 950 950 930 93 康康明明斯斯ISUZUISUZU五五十十铃铃康康明明斯斯五五十十铃铃五五十十铃铃康康明明斯斯三三菱菱 B3 3B3 3CC 4JG1CC 4JG1BB 4BG1TRPBB 4BG1TRP4BTA3 94BTA3 94BG1TRP4BG1TRPAA 6BG1TRPAA 6BG1TRPB5 9 CB5 9 C6D346D34 3 263 263 0593 0594 3294 3294 3294 3294 3294 3296 4946 4945 95 9 292292188 1800188 1800337 6 1600337 6 1600511511337 6337 6550 1600550 1600597 1600597 1600 6060 毛毛功功率率 404070 220070 22008282 毛毛 69 669 6110 2100110 2100108108112112 2200220021002100220022002200220022002200210021002100210019501950 9 59 510 910 911 911 912 412 4121212 512 512 412 411 311 312 512 5 4 2 3 04 2 3 04 2 2 64 2 2 65 0 3 25 0 3 25 5 2 95 5 2 95 3 3 55 3 3 55 1 3 35 1 3 34 6 2 94 6 2 94 6 2 94 6 2 95 5 3 25 5 3 2 3535353535 70 35 70 35 70 35 70 35 70 35 70 3535353535353535 56 456 4102102182182 铁铁39 39 橡橡7474393946464545464646464646 2 21 12 21 12 22 22 2 每每侧侧6 6个个5 57 77 77 77 77 7 37 637 628284040454549 149 149 149 14545 37103710460046004600460056805680 165016502500250025002500291029102 912 912 912 91 715071507070707084808480862086208634863496009600952095209520952093059305 508050805110511060606060618061806167616767806780675067506750675064756475 415041504060406055205520551855185376537666706670663566356635663566306630 3230323034103410494049404770477060506050567556755675567559805980 378537855315531553155315649064906430643064306430 637563756250625082908290832083208320832099109910985098509850985098859885 18151815172017208130813081958195975097509705970597059705 5550555057105710252025202440244035403540340034003400340036303630 75707570 380380375375400400400400450450440440470470 613061306000600076657665772677267700770095009500952595259525952593979397 260026002620262028102810276027602815281529102910297029702970297029562956 2200 23502200 23502220222025002500260026002550255028002800299029902990299029802980 2180218020402040248024802440244026802680275027502750275027102710 2200 23502200 2350220022002490249026002600280028002850285028502850 17201720273027302760276029202920297029702970297030093009 1750175017201720220522052254225427502750275027502750275027502750 780780855855600600101810181018101810181018 284528453838383837593759417041704170417041704170 2230223021702170310031003010301029302930337033703370337033703370 2230223031003100375937593663366333703370337033703370337034453445 450450450450500500600600600600600600600600600600 1750175017501750199019902000200022002200220022002390239023802380 61614949959583 583 592 792 7133133128 140128 140128 140128 140 40 140460 466 166 1999991 9991 9991 9991 99 27 427 4262634 334 331 931 929 4 32 929 4 32 934 334 334 334 334 334 3 27 427 4262631 5 34 331 5 34 331 931 929 4 32 929 4 32 931 431 431 431 4 厦厦工工挖挖机机与与柳柳工工 三三一一同同吨吨位位机机型型技技术术参参数数比比较较 27 427 4262634 334 331 931 932 932 931 431 431 431 434 334 3 20 620 621 621 62525252527 527 525 525 525 525 525 525 5 3 93 93 63 63 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 9 170170149149120 2120 2120 2120 2195 2195 2210 2210 2210 2210 22 2102 210 6060100100130130150150200200160160160160 135135130130310310275275310310335335335335 8吨级挖机 厦工采用五十铃动力 节能高效的优势 厦工挖掘范围大 挖掘力大 回转速度快 作业效率高 液压系统配置和柳工一样 但动力配置比柳工高 22吨级挖机 厦工动力配置最高 高可靠低燃耗五十铃原装发动机 卸载高度大 使装卸操作更方便 挖掘范围大 但挖掘力比柳工小 三三一一厦厦工工柳柳工工 柳柳工工 厦厦工工三三一一 厦厦工工柳柳工工柳柳工工 SY215C 8SY215C 8 XG822LCXG822LCCLG220CLG220 CLG922CLG922 XG823XG823SY230CSY230C XG825LCXG825LCCLG925CLG925925LL925LL 20900209002150021500207000207000219002190023500kg23500kg2290022900255002550023300233002600026000 0 930 930 70 7 1 051 051 11 10 80 8 1 11 11 10 80 8 1 21 21 051 050 50 5 三三菱菱五五十十铃铃进进口口康康明明斯斯进进口口康康明明斯斯五五十十铃铃五五十十铃铃五五十十铃铃康康明明斯斯康康明明斯斯 6BG1TRP6BG1TRP6B5 9 C6B5 9 C6B5 10 C6B5 10 CCC 6BG1TRPCC 6BG1TRP6BG1TRP6BG1TRPCC 6BG1TRPCC 6BG1TRPB5 9 CB5 9 CB5 9 CB5 9 C 6 4946 4945 95 95 95 96 4946 4946 4946 4946 4946 4945 95 95 95 9 582 5 1800582 5 1800597597597597637 9 1800637 9 1800637 9637 9637 9 1800637 9 1800651651651651 114114120 2150120 2150108108108108125 2100125 2100142142125 2100125 2100125125125125 205020502150215021002100210021002100210022002200210021002100210021002100 12 512 512 512 512 412 412 412 411 511 5111111 511 510 810 811 711 7 5 5 3 25 5 3 25 2 3 35 2 3 34 9 2 94 9 2 94 9 2 94 9 2 95 5 3 25 5 3 25 5 3 25 5 3 25 8 3 85 8 3 85 3 3 25 3 3 25 3 3 25 3 3 2 353570707070707035353535353535353535 182182189189189189 4949494949494747515151515151 2 22 22 22 22 22 22 2 8 88 88 88 89 99 99 9 4545434346 546 546 546 550 250 247 647 6484848 248 2 568056806000600060006000 291029102 912 912 912 91296429642964296430903090 93059305960096009540954095409540968096809380938096809680975097501440014400 64756475678067806720672067706770678667866515651567866786670067001198011980 66306630667066706350635066156615694069406920692069406940700070001179011790 59805980605060505655565556555655610061006010601061006100630063001047010470 6490649064306430643064306740674067406740682068201169011690 9885988599109910982098209850985010290102901018010180102901029010390103901567015670 9750975097059705970597051011010110101101011010230102301556015560 363036303540354035303530340034003935393538603860393539353920392054005400 757075702910291029702970297029707760776039203920 450450440440440440460460440440460460445445445445 939793979500950085208520952595251014010140978097801014010140996099601265512655 295629562910291028902890297029703100310031603160292029203040304032363236 298029802990299029902990275027502990299029802980319031902990299033003300 271027102825282527502750275027502825282527102710282528252750275028002800 29902990299029902990299029902990319031903190319033003300 293029302920292019321932193219323020302029302930303530353040304030403040 275027502750275027502750275027502930293028602860293029302990299029902990 10181018101810181055105510851085 44604460445644564456445646404640464046404635463546354635 36603660365036503650365038403840384038403840384038403840 344534453660366036503650365036503840384036403640384038403840384038403840 600600600600600600600600600600600600600600600600800800 238023802390239023902390239023902390239023802380259025902590259025002500 137137145145145145170170159159170170137 150137 15081 381 3 999995959595118118118118104 114104 11456 156 1 34 334 329 4 32 929 4 32 93232323231 5 34 331 5 34 334 334 331 5 34 331 5 34 331 431 431 431 4 29 4 32 929 4 32 93232323231 5 34 331 5 34 331 5 34 331 5 34 331 431 431 431 4 34 334 332 932 93232323234 334 334 334 334 334 331 431 431 431 4 25 525 527 527 525 525 525 525 528 528 525 525 528 528 525 525 525 525 5 3 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 93 9 2 2112 211195 2195 2200200200200235 2235 22 2282 228235 2235 22 2272 2272 2272 227 200200160160160160250250250250160160160160 310310335335335335310310310310450450450450 厦厦工工三三一一三三一一 XG833XG833SY310CSY310C SY330CSY330C 313003130030300303003240032400 1 41 4 1 61 61 41 41 51 5 五五十十铃铃五五十十铃铃 AA 6HK1X