毕业设计电气工程及其自动化专业外文翻译.doc

外文翻译（原文）袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆羈节薁羁袄芁蚃螄膃芀莃薇聿莀蒅螃羅荿薈薅袁莈芇螁袇莇蒀蚄膅莆薂衿肁莅蚄蚂羇莄莄袇袃蒄蒆蚀膂蒃薈袆肈蒂蚁虿羄蒁莀袄羀肇薃螇袆肇蚅羂膅肆莅螅肁肅蒇羁羇肄蕿螃袃膃蚂薆膁膂莁螂肇膁薄薄肃膁蚆袀罿膀莆蚃袅腿蒈袈膄膈薀蚁肀膇蚂袇羆芆莂虿袂芆蒄袅螈芅蚇蚈膆芄莆羃肂芃葿螆莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆衿肃薅袅羁芈蒁袅肃肁蒇袄袃莇莃蒀羅腿艿葿肈莅薇蒈螇膈蒃蒈袀莃荿薇羂膆芅薆肄罿薄薅螄膄薀薄羆羇蒆薃聿芃莂薂螈肅芈薂袁芁薆薁羃肄蒂蚀肅艿莈虿螅肂芄蚈袇芇膀蚇聿肀蕿蚆蝿莆蒅蚆袁腿莁蚅羄莄芇蚄肆膇薆螃螆羀蒂螂袈膅莈螁羀羈芄螀螀膃艿螀袂肆薈蝿羅节蒄螈肇肅莀螇螇芀芆袆 A Comparison of Power Flow by Different Ordering Schemes Wenbo Li, Xueshan Han, Bo ZhangThe School of Electric EngineeringShandong UniversityJinan, ChinaEmail:liwenbo_1984AbstractNode ordering algorithms, aiming at keeping sparsity as far as possible, are widely used today. In such algorithms, their influence on the accuracy of the solution is neglected because it wont make significant difference in normal systems. While, along with the development of modern power systems, the problem will become more ill-conditioned and it is necessary to take the accuracy into count during node ordering. In this paper we intend to lay groundwork for the more rationality ordering algorithm which could make reasonable compromising between memory and accuracy. Three schemes of node ordering for different purpose are proposed to compare the performance of the power flow calculation and an example of simple six-node network is discussed detailed. Keywordspower flow calculation; node ordering; sparsity; accuracy; Newton-Raphson method ; linear equationsI. INTRODUCTIONPower flow is the most basic and important concept in power system analysis and power flow calculation is the basis of power system planning, operation, scheduling and control 1.Mathematically speaking, power flow problem is to find a numerical solution of nonlinear equations. Newton method is the most commonly used to solve the problem and it involves repeated direct solutions of a system of linear equations. The solving efficiency and precision of the linear equations directly influences the performance of Newton-Raphson power flow algorithm. Based on numerical mathematics and physical characteristics of power system in power flow calculation, scholars dedicated to the research to improve the computational efficiency of linear equations by reordering nodes number and received a lot of success which laid a solid foundation for power system analysis.Jacobian matrix in power flow calculation, similar with the admittance matrix, has symmetrical structure and a high degree of sparsity. During the factorization procedure, nonzero entries can be generated in memory positions that correspond to zero entries in the starting Jacobian matrix. This action is referred to as fill-in. If the programming terms is used which processed and stores only nonzero terms, the reduction of fill-in reflects a great reduction of memory requirement and the number of operations needed to perform the factorization. So many extensive studies have been concerned with the minimization of the fill-ins. While it is hard to find efficient algorithm for determining the absolute optimal order, several effective strategies for determining near-optimal orders have been devised for actual applications 2, 3. Each of the strategies is a trade-off between results and speed of execution and they have been adopted by much of industry. The sparsity-programmed ordered elimination mentioned above, which is a breakthrough in power system network computation, dramatically improving the computing speed and storage requirements of Newtons method 4.After sparse matrix methods, sparse vector methods 5, which extend sparsity exploitation to vectors, are useful for solving linear equations when the right-hand-side vector is sparse or a small number of elements in the unknown vector are wanted. To make full use of sparse vector methods advantage, it is necessary to enhance the sparsity of L-1by ordering nodes. This is equivalent to decreasing the length of the paths, but it might cause more fill-ins, greater complexity and expense. Countering this problem, several node ordering algorithms 6, 7 were proposed to enhance sparse vector methods by minimizing the length of the paths while preserving the sparsity of the matrix.Up to now, on the basis of the assumption that an arbitrary order of nodes does not adversely affect numerical accuracy, most node ordering algorithms take solving linear equations in a single iteration as research subject, aiming at the reduction of memory requirements and computing operations. Many matrices with a strong diagonal in network problems fulfill the above assumption, and ordering to conserve sparsity increased the accuracy of the solution. Nevertheless, if there are junctions of very high and low series impedances, long EHV lines, series and shunt compensation in the model of power flow problem, diagonal dominance will be weaken 8 and the assumption may not be tenable invariably. Furthermore, along with the development of modern power systems, various new models with parameters under various orders of magnitude appear in the model of power flow. The promotion of distributed generation also encourage us to regard the distribution networks and transmission systems as a whole in power flow calculation, and it will cause more serious numerical problem. All those things mentioned above will turn the problem into ill-condition. So it is necessary to discuss the effect of the node numbering to the accuracy of the solution.Based on the existing node ordering algorithm mentioned above, this paper focus attention on the contradiction between memory and accuracy during node ordering, research how could node ordering algorithm affect the performance of power flow calculation, expecting to lay groundwork for the more rationality ordering algorithm. This paper is arranged as follows. The contradiction between memory and accuracy in node ordering algorithm is introduced in section II. Next a simple DC power flow is showed to illustrate that node ordering could affect the accuracy of the solution in section III. Then, taking a 6-node network as an example, the effect of node ordering on the performance of power flow is analyzed detailed in section IV. Conclusion is given in section VI.II. CONTRADICTION BETWEEN MEMORY AND ACCURACYIN NODE ORDERING ALGORITHMAccording to numerical mathematics, complete pivoting is numerically preferable to partial pivoting for systems of liner algebraic equations by Gaussian Elimination Method (GEM). Many mathematical papers 9-11 focus their attention on the discrimination between complete pivoting and partial pivoting in (GEM). Reference 9 shows how partial pivoting and complete pivoting affect the sensitivity of the LU factorization. Reference 10 proposes an effective and inexpensive test to recognize numerical difficulties during partial pivoting requires. Once the assessment criterion can not be met, complete pivoting will be adopted to get better numerical stability. In power flow calculations, partial pivoting is realized automatically without any row-interchanges and column-interchanges because of the diagonally dominant features of the Jacobin matrix, which could guarantee numerical stability in floating point computation in most cases. While due to rounding errors, the partial pivoting does not provide the solution accurate enough in some ill-conditionings. If complete pivoting is performed, at each step of the process, the element of largest module is chosen as the pivotal element. It is equivalent to adjust the node ordering in power flow calculation. So the node relate to the element of largest module is tend to arrange in front for the purpose of improving accuracy. The node reordering algorithms guided by sparse matrix technology have wildly used in power system calculation, aiming at minimizing memory requirement. In these algorithms, the nodes with fewer adjacent nodes tend to be numbered first. The result is that diagonal entries in node admittance matrix tend to be arranged from least to largest according to their module. Analogously, every diagonal submatrices relate to a node tend to be arranged from least to largest according to their determinants. So the results obtained form such algorithms will just deviate form the principle follow which the accuracy of the solution will be enhance. That is what we say there is contradiction between node ordering guided by memory and accuracy.III. DIFFERENCE PRECISION OF THE SOLUTION USING PARTICAL PIVOTING AND COMPLETE PIVOTINGIt is said that complete pivoting is numerically preferable to partial pivoting for solving systems of linear algebraic equations. When the system coefficients are varying widely, the accuracy of the solution would be affect by rounding errors hardly and it is necessary to take the influence of the ordering on the accuracy of the solution into consideration. Fig.1 DC model of Sample 4-node networkAs an example, consider the DC model of sample 4-node system shown in Figure 1. Node 1 is the swing node having known voltage angle; nodes 2-4 are load nodes. Following the original node number, the DC power flow equation is:To simulate computer numerical calculation operations, four significant figures will be used to solve the problem. Executing GEM without pivoting on (1) yields the solution 2,3,4T=-0.3036,-0.3239,-0.3249T, whose components differ from that of the exact solution 2, 3,4T=-0.3,-0.32,-0.321T. A more exact solution could be obtained by complete pivoting: 2,3, 4T=-0.3007,-0.3207,-0.3217T, and the order of the node after row and column interchanges is 3,2,4. So this is a more reasonable ordering scheme for the purpose of getting more high accuracy.IV. THE INFLUENCE OF NODE REODERING ON THE PERFORMANCE OF NEWTON-RAPHSON POWER FLOW METHODFig