案例分析答题模板样题STDPPT课件.ppt

ContractLaw CaseAnalysis 1 ModuleCaseofIRAC 1 AlanboughtafieldfromBill afterBilltoldhimthatitwasbigenoughfor6horses Billhadneverkepthorsestherehimself however Infactitwasonlybigenoughfortwohorses 2 ModuleCaseofIRAC 1 Issue misrepresentationIscontractvoidbecauseofmisrepresentation Rule setoutthelaw Thisquestionisaboutmisrepresentation Amisrepresentationisastatementoffactwhichisamaterialinducementtoenterintoacontract Itmaymakeacontractvoidable ItmustbeastatementofFact notopinion BissetvWilkinson crucialcase 3 ModuleCaseofIRAC 1 ApplicationofLaw Inthiscase Billisonlyexpressinganopinionashehasneverkepthorsesinthefieldhimself sothisisnotrepresentationofafact Conclusion Alancannotclaimmisrepresentation thecontractisvalid 4 TrainingofIRAC 2 Fact TonyofferedtosellhislaptoptoGinafor 500 Ginasaidshewouldbuyitifshecouldraisethemoney TonysaidhewouldwaituntilSundaytoallowhertofindthemoney However onFridayStaceyofferedTony 600forthelaptopandTonyacceptedStacy sofferandsoldittohim TonytriedtoringGinatotellherthetablehadalreadybeensoldsoshecouldnotbuyit Gina ssisteransweredthephoneandtookthemessage butforgottotellGina OnSundayGinaarrivedatTony sflatwiththemoney Issue offerandacceptanceistherecontractbetweenpartiesbecauseofaneffectiveacceptancefromGina 5 TrainingofIRAC 2 Rule Theofferorcanwithdraw revoke anofferatanytimebeforeitisaccepted DickinsonvDodds 1876 p71Acceptanceis Afinalandunconditionalacceptanceofthetermsoftheoffer Tobelegallybinding threerulesmustfulfil 1 mustbeamirrorimageoftheOffer2 mustbefirm absolute municatedtotheofferor Anoffercanbeaccepteduntilitisrevoked butapromisetokeepanofferopenuntilacertaindateisnotbindingunlessitissupportedbyconsideration RoutledgevGrant 1828 offercanberevokedatanytimebeforeacceptance butrevocationisnoteffectiveuntilitiscommunicatedtotheofferee 6 TrainingofIRAC 3 Application a InthiscasethereisanofferbyTonytosellGinahislaptopfor 500 WhenGinasaysshewillbuyifitshecanraisethemoney thisisnotanacceptance becauseitisconditional notabsoluteandunqualified TonypromisestokeeptheofferopenuntilSunday butheisnotboundbythispromiseasGinahasgivennoconsiderationforit Sohecouldrevoketheofferbeforetheacceptanceiscommunicatedtohim 7 2020 3 21 8 TrainingofIRAC 4 Application b TonyisthereforeentitledtorevoketheofferonFriday buttherevocationisnoteffectiveuntilitiscommunicatedtoGina Gina ssisterfailedtopassonthemessagebecausesheforgotandthereforeGinadidnotreceivenoticeoftherevocation Sotherevocationnoticeofofferisfailed SowhensheturnedupatTony sflatwiththemoney shewasacceptingtheoffereffectively 9 TrainingofIRAC 5 Conclusion Therefore thereisabindingcontractbetweenTonyandGina 10 Case1 Fact GinapaidanEnglishlanguageexpertTony 750toimproveherEnglishvocabularyreadyforanexaminationshewasgoingtotakelaterintheyear Ginawasverykeentopass andafortnightbeforetheexamshesaidtoTony IfIpasstheexamIwillpayyouanextra 250asabonus GinadidpasstheexambutisrefusingtopayTonythe 250 11 Rationale Issue considerationRule considerationis thepricebywhichonepartyboughttheotherparty sactorpromise DunlopvSelfridge 1915 Acontractisonlylegallybindingifthereisconsideration Apromisetocarryoutexistinglegalobligationsdoesnotamounttoconsideration CollinsvGodefroy asyouareonlydoingwhatyouarelegallyobligedtodoanyway 12 application GinapaidanEnglishlanguageexpertTony 750toimproveherEnglish bothpartieshadcreatedthecontractofservice Gina ssubsequentpromiseofadditionalpaymentisnotabi