![欧洲央行-央行数字货币与货币政策实施 Occasional Paper Series -Central bank digital currency and monetary policy implementation_第1页](http://file4.renrendoc.com/view4/M02/07/39/wKhkGGYnG7KAVfsFAABxgOxlN-M143.jpg)
![欧洲央行-央行数字货币与货币政策实施 Occasional Paper Series -Central bank digital currency and monetary policy implementation_第2页](http://file4.renrendoc.com/view4/M02/07/39/wKhkGGYnG7KAVfsFAABxgOxlN-M1432.jpg)
![欧洲央行-央行数字货币与货币政策实施 Occasional Paper Series -Central bank digital currency and monetary policy implementation_第3页](http://file4.renrendoc.com/view4/M02/07/39/wKhkGGYnG7KAVfsFAABxgOxlN-M1433.jpg)
![欧洲央行-央行数字货币与货币政策实施 Occasional Paper Series -Central bank digital currency and monetary policy implementation_第4页](http://file4.renrendoc.com/view4/M02/07/39/wKhkGGYnG7KAVfsFAABxgOxlN-M1434.jpg)
![欧洲央行-央行数字货币与货币政策实施 Occasional Paper Series -Central bank digital currency and monetary policy implementation_第5页](http://file4.renrendoc.com/view4/M02/07/39/wKhkGGYnG7KAVfsFAABxgOxlN-M1435.jpg)
版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
EUROPEANCENTRALBANKEUROSYSTEMEneaCaccia,JensTapking,ThomasVlassopoulosCentralbankdigitalcurrencyandmonetarypolicyimplementationDisclaimer:ThispapershouldnotbereportedasrepresentingtheviewsoftheEuropeanCentralBank(ECB).TheviewsexpressedarethoseoftheauthorsanddonotnecessarilyreflectthoseoftheECB.Abstract2Non-technicalsummary31Introduction62ImpactofaCBDConthedemandforbankdeposits8Box1TheimpactofazeroremunerationofCBDConthedemandforbankdeposits123ThebalancesheetmechanicsofaCBDC153.1TheimpactofaCBDC-induceddepositoutflowonreserves153.2ThemaximumamountofCBDC-induceddepositoutflowstolerablefromamonetarypolicyimplementationperspective21Box2High-leveldesignchoicesofcurrentCBDCinitiativesacrosstheglobe244CBDCandthesmoothimplementationofmonetarypolicy284.1Floorsystem28Box3ModelshowingtheimpactofaCBDContheamountofreservesneededforsmoothimplementationofmonetarypolicy:floorsystem324.2Corridorsystem35Box4ModelshowingtheimpactofCBDContheamountofreservesneededforsmoothimplementationofmonetarypolicy:corridorsystem385Conclusions42Proofsofresults1to444References48AbstractThispaperdiscussestheimpactthataretailcentralbankdigitalcurrency(CBDC)couldhaveontheimplementationofmonetarypolicy.MonetarypolicyimplementationcouldbeaffectediftheintroductionoftheretailCBDCchangesthevolumeofcommercialbankdepositsheldbycustomers,whichwould,inturn,affectcentralbankreserves.WhileitisoftenassumedthatcustomerdepositswoulddecreaseifaCBDCwasintroduced,weprovideargumentswhythisisbynomeansclearcutanddepositscouldevenincrease.Ifbankdepositsdodecrease,bankswouldneedtodrawon,andthereforereduce,theircentralbankreserveholdings.Moreover,uncertaintyastothetimingandextentofanyconversionsofdepositsintoCBDCmightpromptbankstoscaleuptheirdemandforcentralbankreservesinordertoholdlargerprecautionarybuffers.Consequently,centralbanksmightneedtoadjusttheirreservesupplyandotherfeaturesoftheirmonetarypolicyimplementation,depending,forexample,onwhethertheyuseafloororacorridorsystemformonetarypolicyimplementation.Inthespecificcaseofthedigitaleuro,thefeaturesalreadyenvisagedforitsdesignwouldmakeitpossibletominimisetheriskofnegativeconsequencesformonetarypolicyimplementation.JELcodes:E41,E42,E43,E52,E58,G21Keywords:Monetarypolicyimplementation,centralbankdigitalcurrency,centralbankreserves.CentralbanksaroundtheworldhavebeenassessingtheadvantagesanddisadvantagesofCBDCs.ACBDCisanewformofcentralbankmoney.Likebanknotes,itisaclaimontheissuingcentralbankthatcanbeusedtomakepaymentswithinstantsettlement24hoursaday,sevendaysaweek.Butunlikebanknotes,itexistsonlyindigitalform.Ifitisavailabletothegeneralpublic,includinghouseholdsandnon-financialcorporations,itisreferredtoasaretailCBDC.Ifitcanonlybeusedby(financial)institutions,itisreferredtoasawholesaleCBDC.In2022,80outofthe86centralbanksthatrespondedtoasurveyconductedbytheBankforInternationalSettlement(BIS)saidthattheywereengagedinworkontheissueofCBDCs.1AsmallnumberofcentralbankshadalreadyintroducedaretailCBDC(thecentralbanksofNigeria,theBahamas,JamaicaandtheEasternCaribbeanCurrencyUnion)orwereconductingpilottests(China,India).OthercentralbankshaveannouncedconcreteinvestigationsintoaretailCBDC(e.g.theBankofEnglandandtheECB).Inthispaper,wediscussthepotentialimplicationsofaretailCBDCfortheimplementationofmonetarypolicy.Oneofthemainobjectivesofmonetarypolicyimplementationistosteershort-termmarketinterestratestothelevelthatisconsideredappropriateforthemonetarypolicybeingpursued.Formostcentralbanks,thisisachievedby,amongotherthings,controllingtheamountofreservesthatthebankingsectorholdswiththecentralbank.GiventhataretailCBDCcouldhaveanimpactonthestockofreserves,itisanimportantfactortobeconsideredinrelationtomonetarypolicyimplementation.ThispaperlooksatdifferentaspectsoftheintroductionofaretailCBDCandthelikelyimplicationsformonetarypolicyimplementation,focusinginparticularontheimpactonbankdepositsandreserves.Itsfindingscanbesummarisedasfollows:monetarypolicyoperatioThecurrentpaperconsidersagenericretailCBDCbut,whenrelevant,alsodiscusseshowthedesignfeaturesenvisagedforadigitaleurowouldmakeitpossibletoaddresstheriskofnegativeconsequencesformonetarypolicyimplementation.InOctober2021theECBstartedatwo-yearinvestigationintothepossibilityofissuingaCBDCfortheeuroarea:thedigitaleuro.InOctober2023theECBdecidedtolaunchapreparationphaseasanextstepandpublishedareportsummarisingthedesignfeaturesenvisagedforadigitaleuro.2Havingexaminedthosefeatures,thecurrentpaperconcludesthattheywouldreducetheriskofadigitaleurohavingnegativeconsequencesformonetarypolicyimplementation.CentralbanksaroundtheworldhavebeenassessingtheadvantagesanddisadvantagesofCBDCs.ACBDCisanewformofcentralbankmoney.Likebanknotes,itisaclaimontheissuingcentralbankthatcanbeusedtomakepaymentswithinstantsettlementaroundtheclock.Butunlikebanknotes,itexistsonlyindigitalform.Ifitisavailabletothegeneralpublic,includinghouseholdsandnon-financialcorporations,itisreferredtoasaretailCBDC.Ifitcanbeusedonlyby(financial)institutions,itisreferredtoasawholesaleCBDC.3In2022,80outofthe86centralbanksthatrespondedtoasurveyconductedbytheBISsaidthattheywereengagedinworkontheissueofCBDCs.4AsmallnumberofcentralbankshavealreadyintroducedaretailCBDC(thecentralbanksofNigeria,theBahamas,JamaicaandtheEasternCaribbeanCurrencyUnion)orareconductingpilottests(China,India).OthercentralbankshaveannouncedveryconcreteinvestigationsintoaretailCBDC(e.g.theBankofEnglandandtheECB).5Inthispaper,wediscussthepotentialimplicationsofaretailCBDCfortheimplementationofmonetarypolicy.Oneofthemainobjectivesofmonetarypolicyimplementationistosteershort-termmarketinterestratestothelevelthatisconsideredappropriateforthemonetarypolicybeingpursued.Formostcentralbanks,thisisachievedby,amongotherthings,controllingtheamountofreservesthatthebankingsectorholdswiththecentralbank.GiventhataretailCBDCcouldhaveanimpactontheamountofreserves,itisanimportantfactortobeconsideredinrelationtomonetarypolicyimplementation.Therestofthispaperisorganisedintofoursectionsandfourboxes.Section2andBox1discusstheimpactofaretailCBDConthedepositsheldbycustomerswithcommercialbanks,giventhatthisaffectstheamountofcentralbankreservesandthereforemonetarypolicyimplementation.Section3firstanalyseshowaretailCBDCmightinfluencetheaggregatebalancesheetsofthecentralbank,thebankingsectorandthenon-banksector.ItthendiscussestheamountofbankdepositsacentralbankcouldallowcustomerstoconvertintoCBDCgivensomeoftheconstraintsarisingfromtheaggregatebalancesheets.Box2providesanoverviewofthecurrentCBDCinitiativesofcentralbanksworldwide.Section4,togetherwithBoxes3and4,providesadetailedassessment,includingamodel-basedanalysis,oftheconsequencesthataCBDCmighthaveonthewaythatcentralbankscouldimplementmonetarypolicy,distinguishingbetweenfloor-based3Foradetaileddiscussionofthforexample,Section2and34SeeKosseandMandcorridor-basedmonetarypolicyimplementationsystems.Section5concludes.Inthissection,wediscusstheimpactthattheintroductionofaCBDCmighthaveonthedemandforbankdeposits.Weshowthattheimpactis,exante,ambiguous,giventhatseveraloftheCBDC’sinherentfeaturesaswellasdesignchoicesinteractwitheachotherinwaysthatcanoffsettheireffectonthedemandfordeposits.6FollowingtheintroductionofaCBDC,someofthegoodsandservicesthatwerepreviouslypaidforwithcash(banknotesandcoins)orthroughbankdepositswillbepaidforwithCBDC.Currentlythereare,broadlyspeaking,twotypesofmeansofpayment:bankdepositsandcash.7ACBDCwouldbeathirdmeansofpayment.WhiletheintroductionofaCBDCwouldhaverelativelylittleimpactonthetypesandquantitiesofthegoodsandservicespeoplewillwanttobuy,itmayhaveastrongimpactonhowpeoplepayforthosegoodsandservices:someitemsthatwouldhavebeenpaidforwithcashorfrombankdepositswouldbesettledinCBDC.IfindividualswishedtopayforanitemwithaCBDC,theymightneedtoconvertcashorbankdepositsintoCBDCbeforehand.ThiswouldgenerateademandforCBDCandreducethedemandforcashand/orbankdeposits.However,themechanicsofconvertingbankdepositsintoothermeansofpaymentwouldhaveadecisiveimpactondemandforbankdeposits.Togiveasimpleexample,8anindividualinitiallyholdsonlybankdepositsandwouldliketoconducttransactionsforanamountPoneachoftwoconsecutivedays.AssumingthataCBDCisnotavailable,thatindividualwishestomakeacashpaymentofCandapaymentfromabankdepositofD(C+D=P)oneachofthedays.ThesplitofPintoCandDisassumedtobedrivenbytheacceptabilityoftherespectiveformsofpaymentforthetransactionstobemade.SincegoingtoanATMontwoseparatedayswouldbeinconvenient,theindividualdecidestogothereonlyonday1andtowithdraw2.Cincash.Consequently,theindividualpaysonecashamountofConday1andholdstheothercashamountofCovernightfromday1today2.Assumingthatamountspaidtomerchantsincentralbankmoney(cashor,inthefurthercourseofourexample,CBDC)areconvertedintobankdepositsonthesameday,i.e.thesumsarenotheldbythemincashovernight,Cistheportionofthecashwithdrawnfromtheindividual’sdepositsthatremainsincirculationfromday1today2.6PapersthattrytoestimatethedemandforCBDCaCBDConthedemandforbpossiblyhaveapositiveim7Forthepurposesofthisillcreditcardsore-mThissituationissummarisedinthefirstcolumnofTable1.However,holdingcashovernightexposesindividualstophysicalsecurityrisks.Consequently,incaseswherebothcashandbankdeposittransfersareacceptedforpayment,theindividualmayprefertopaythroughabankdepositsothattheamountofcashwithdrawncanbekeptassmallaspossible.Table1Holdingofcash,depositsandCBDCWithdrawals-CD-C--WithdrawalsCD-TheabilitytopayusingCBDCmayincentivisepeopletoholdasignificantamountoftheirfundsinthisformandholdlessinbankdeposits.Takingtheaboveexample,supposethataCBDChasbeenintroducedandisacceptedforsettlingtransactions,someofwhichwerepreviouslymadeincashandsomethroughbankdeposits.Theindividualwouldnowliketomake,oneachofthetwodays,acashpaymentofC*,apaymentthroughbankdepositsofD*andaCBDCpaymentofZ*,whereC*+D*+Z*=C+D=P.Onday1,shenowwithdrawsacashamountof2.C*andconvertsanamountof2.Z*ofdepositsintoCBDC,assumingthatitisalsosufficientlyinconvenienttoconvertbankdepositsintoCBDConeachofthetwodays.Asaresult,shenowholdsanamountofcentralbankmoney(cashplusCBDC)ofC*+Z*overnightfromday1today2.Incontrasttocash,CBDCisnotsubjecttophysicalsecurityrisksandmightthereforebecomethepaymentoptionofchoiceonceadigitalcurrencyisintroduced.Thiscouldleadtolessdemandforbankdeposits,i.e.C*+Z*>CandD*<D,ifaCBDCisintroduced.AsituationinwhichthereisaCBDCbutconvertingbankdepositsintoCBDCisnotstraightforwardissummarisedinthesecondcolumnofTable1.If,however,customersfindconvertingbankdepositsintoandoutofCBDCstraightforwardandaconvenientoption,thentheintroductionofaCBDCmightincreasethedemandforbankdeposits.AgaintakingtheexamplesetoutabovebutnowassumingthattheCBDChasbeendesignedsothatconvertingbankdepositsintoCBDCisstraightforward–meaningthattheconversionisinstantaneous,possibleatalltimes,costlessandeasy–thesituationwouldbeasfollows.Theindividualnowdecidestoconvertonlyasingleamountofz*intoCBDConday1andthesameamountagainonday2.ThisisparticularlylikelyifbankdepositsarebetterremuneratedthanCBDC.Asaresult,theindividualholdsacashamountofC*overnight,butnoCBDCand,giventhatC*<C,theamountheldintheindividual’sbankdepositsovernighthasnowincreasedascomparedwiththesituationinwhichnoCBDCexists.ThisisillustratedinthethirdcolumnofTable1.CBDCdesignfeatures,suchasawaterfallandreversewaterfallmechanism,thatallowtheautomaticconversionofbankdepositsintoandoutofCBDCwouldhaveasignificantimpactintermsofconvenienceandarethereforeparticularlyrelevantforreducingincentivestoaccumulateCBDCratherthanbankdeposits.AwaterfallisamechanismwherebyifCBDCholdingsexceedaprespecifiedthreshold,e.g.becauseofalargeincomingpayment,theexcessamountisautomaticallyandimmediatelytransferredintothepayee’sbankaccount,i.e.convertedintoabankdeposit.AreversewaterfallallowsapayertomakeaCBDCpaymentthatislargerthanthepayer’sCBDCholdings:anyamountneededforthepaymentandnotavailableinthepayer’sCBDCaccountwouldbeautomaticallytransferredfromthepayer’sbankaccountintotheCBDCaccountandpaymentisthentriggeredinstantly.ItshouldbenotedthatthereversewaterfallcanbeseenasatoolthatwouldmaketheconversionofbankdepositsintoCBDCaveryconvenientoption.AnindividualmightdecidenottohaveanyCBDCholdingsatallbutcouldneverthelessmakeCBDCpaymentsgiventhatthereversewaterfallmechanismwouldalwaysconvertanyrequiredamountfrombankdepositsintoCBDCasandwhenneeded.Consequently,aCBDCwithareversewaterfallcouldincreasethedemandforbankdeposits.WidespreadadoptionofCBDCasapaymentinstrumentwouldnotnecessarilyresultinreduceddemandforbankdeposits.Paymenttechnologiesarenetworktechnologies.Ifmanypeopledecidetouseatechnology,manymorewillfollow.9However,thisdoesnotnecessarilymeanthatextensiveadoptionofCBDCasapaymentinstrumentwouldreducedemandforbankdeposits.Asindicatedabove,howstraightforwarditistoconvertintoandoutofCBDCcouldbeexpectedtobeanimportantdriverofadoption,togetherwithgeneralacceptanceamongmerchantsofpaymentsinCBDCandthecreationofasymbioticecosystemalongsideothermeansofpayment.9Foramodel-baseddiscussionofthenetworkeffetal(2022).Whiletheargumentsabovefocusonthepaymentfunction,aCBDCcould,inprinciple,alsobeusedasastoreofvalue.TheextenttowhichaCBDCmightbeusedasastoreofvalueislikelytodependprimarilyonitsremuneration,discussedinBox1,andtheperceivedriskofholdingalternativestoresofvalue,suchasbankdeposits.WithregardtotheinteractionofCBDCholdingsandtheperceivedriskofholdingbankdeposits,theimpactofCBDConthedemandfordepositsislikelytobehighlysituation-specific.CBDCisaliabilityofthecentralbankinitsdomesticcurrencyand,assuch,isnotsubjecttodefaultrisk.Thiscouldmakeitaparticularlyattractiveoptioninabankingcrisis,whendepositorsmaywishtoconvertlargeamountsofbankdepositsintocentralbankmoneyforfearoflosses.ConvertingbankdepositsintoCBDCwouldbeeasierandfasterthanconvertingthemintobanknotes.Furthermore,holdingCBDCwouldnotbesubjecttotherisks,storageandinsurancecoststhatholdinglargeamountsofcashentails.10Assuch,aCBDCmightreducethedemandforbankdepositsinabankingcrisis.11However,holdinglimitsmightbeatoolforpreventinglargeholdingsofCBDCtothedetrimentofbankdepositsinsuchasituation(andmoregenerally),i.e.theymightlimitthepossiblenegativeimpactofaCBDConthedemandforbankdeposits.12TheECBhasannounceditsintentiontoofferwaterfallandreversewaterfallfunctionalitiestoalldigitaleuroend-usersandtoapplydigitaleuroholdinglimits.13Theargumentssetoutabovesuggestthatbyincorporatingthesedesignfeatures,thedigitaleuromightnothaveanegativeimpactonthedemandforbankdepositsinnormaltimesandcouldavoidunduelossofbankdepositsduringabankingcrisis.GiventhataCBDCwhichreducesthedemandforbankdepositsmaybechallengingformonetarypolicyimplementation,wefocusonthisissueinthefollowingsections.Asarguedinthissection,aCBDCcouldincreaseorreducethedemandforbankdeposits,dependingonthefeaturesincorporatedintoit.IfaCBDCweretoreducethedemandforbankdeposits,thebankingsectormayloseanimportantfundingsource.Thiscouldbechallengingformonetarypolicyimplementation.WethereforeanalysethecaseofaCBDCthatreducesthedemandforbankdepositsinthesectionsbelowwithaviewtomotivatingdesignfeaturesthatcouldpreventanysuchreduction.considermovingdepositsawayfaCBDCwalletthattheyuseforwouldthenrequireasecondacfundsintoCBDCwouldthenbeethataCBDCcouldchangethebehaviouroregulatorstherebydecreasingfinancialTheimpactofazeroremunerationofCBDConthedemandforbanTheimpactofaCBDConthedemandforbankdepositswoulddependsignificantlyonthelevelsofremunerationofthesetwoinstruments.IftheCBDCbenefitedfromhigherremunerationthanbankdeposits,peoplemightprefertoholdmoreCBDCandholdlessinbankdeposits,regardlessofwhetherornottheyusetheCBDCforpaymentpurposes.Inordertolimitanylossofdepositsinsuchcircumstances,banksmightreactbyincreasingtheremunerationpaidonbankdeposits.Thisstrategymight,however,beseenbythebanksasbeinglessprofitable,depending,forexample,ontheamountofreservesavailabletothebankingsector,inwhichcasetheymightprefertoacceptthelossofdeposits.InordertoavoidanyremunerationofCBDCinfluencingthedemandforbankdeposits,centralbankscouldconsidervariousstrategies.Theycould,forexample,offerCBDCremunerationatthelevelofthe(average)remunerationonbankdeposits(possiblyminusaconstantspread).Thisapproachmight,however,beconsideredtoocomplicatedforaretailCBDC.Furthermore,attimeswhencentralbankpolicyratesarenegative,theaverageremunerationonbankdepositsmightalsoslipintonegativeterritory.IftheremunerationonCBDCisthenalsosetatanegativelevel,thereputationandacceptanceofCBDCcouldsuffer.Zeroremunerationwouldmirrortheremunerationonbanknotesandistheapproachthatmost,ifnotall,centralbanksconsiderpreferableforaCBDC(seeBox2).Attimeswhenratesonbankdepositsarehigh,forexampleduetohighcentralbankpolicyrates,zeroremunerationofCBDCcouldresultinlowerdemandforCBDC.Whenbankdepositratesarenegative,forexampleduetonegativecentralbankpolicyrates,zeroremunerationofCBDCcouldleadtolowerdemandforbankdeposits.Thismightmakebanksreluctanttoapplynegativeratestobankdeposits,weakeningthetransmissionofnegativecentralbankpolicyrates.However,ifarelativelytightCBDCholdinglimitisapplied,theremunerationofCBDCrelativetothatonbankdepositsmighthaveverylittleimpactonthedemandforbankdeposits.Forinstance,Eurosystemofficialshavementionedadigitaleuroholdinglimitfornaturalpersonsof€3,000to€4,000asanoption.15Inaddition,itisenvisagedtoapplyazeroremunerationtothedigitaleuro.16ThelowestECBpolicyratewas-0.5%(betweenSeptember2019andJuly2022).Letussupposethattheaverageremunerationonbankdepositsfallstothislevel.Zeroremunerationofadigitaleuroandaholdinglimitof€3,000wouldthanmeanthatthelossthatanindividualcouldavoidbyconvertingabankdepositintodigitaleurouptothemaximumholdinglimitwouldbeamere€15peryear.17Evenwithouttightholdinglimits,zeroremunerationofCBDCholdingsbyhouseholdsmighthavelimitedimpactontheirlevelofdemandforbankdepositsgiventhattheremunerationonhouseholdovernightbankdepositstendsto17AsanalternativetoaCBDChCBDCremuneration,i.e.thedeviaterelativelylittlefromzero.TheimplicationsofzeroremunerationofCBDCholdingsonthedemandfordepositsmightdifferforhouseholdsandforcorporations.Startingwithhouseholdsandtakingtheeuroareaasanexample,Chart1showsthataverageinterestratesonovernightbankdepositsofhouseholdsbarelyslippedintonegativeterritoryduringtheperiodwhenmarketinterestratesintheeuroareawerenegativebutinsteadstayedclosetozero.ZeroremunerationofCBDCatthattimewouldnothaveprovidedasufficientincentiveforhouseholdstoconvertbankdepositsintoCBDC.And,whenpolicyratesandmoneymarketinterestrateswererelativelyhigh,ataround4%,in2008,theaverageratesonovernightbankdepositsbarelyexceeded1%,againprovidinglittleincentiveforhouseholdstoconvertsignificantamountsofCBDCintobankdepositsevenifCBDChadbeenremuneratedat0%.18However,thestickinessofinterestratesonbankdepositsat0%whencentralbankpolicyratesandmarketinterestratesturnnegativemaybeundesirablefromamonetarypolicyperspectivegiventhatitmeanslimitedtransmissionofpolicyrates.AndzeroCBDCremunerationwithoutarelativelytightCBDCholdinglimitcouldcementthisstickinessandresultina“reversalinterestrate”,i.e.apolicyratelevelbelowwhichfurtherratecutswouldtendtohaveatighteningratherthanlooseningeffectsontheeconomy,therebycurtailingmonetarypolicyspace.19Chart1Remunerationofovernightbankdepositsheldbyhouseholds%Source:IndividualmonetaryfinanciaNotes:Theblueareaistheshareremuneratedatratesabove0.05%andtheredareashort-termrate.EONIAdenotestheinterbankovernightlendingreplacedwiththe€STR.VWRat
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 北师大版四年级上册《2.3 平移与平行》2023年同步练习卷
- 三年级上册英语导学案-Unit 4 We love animals 第一课时(含练习)-人教pep
- 安全心理课程安全生理与安全心理课程
- 服装企业的设计与产品生产
- 金属废料加工行业的市场营销与销售策略
- 金属加工机械中的电火花加工工艺参数
- 2024工程车运输合同
- 网络安全工作总结(15篇)
- 生物识别技术在医疗健康管理中的创新应用
- 建筑施工现场的扬尘与噪声防控
- 青岛市城阳区卫生健康局所属公立医院及事业单位第二批公开招聘49名工作人员高频考题难、易错点模拟试题(共500题)附带答案详解
- 预防接种工作规范(2023年版)解读课件
- 2024年中铁建昆仑投资集团有限公司招聘笔试参考题库含答案解析
- 反映社情民情范例范文六篇
- 档案整理及数字化服务方案
- 鲁东教师心理健康期末考试复习题及参考答案
- 新型基础测绘与实景三维中国建设技术文件-6 基础地理实体数据采集生产技术规程
- 压力容器年度检查报告(完整版)
- 共享电动自行车入驻县城申请书(范文)模板
- 李居明的《饿命学》五+行+饿+命+改+运+学
- 广东省妇幼保健院进修申请表
评论
0/150
提交评论