已阅读5页,还剩137页未读, 继续免费阅读
版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
1,Research Methodology and Method in Accounting and Finance,Li Zengquan SUFE/2011,引子:独立董事的价值,2010年度优秀独立董事,证监会是否应该规定公司必须聘请独立董事?,能够监督内部人 能够为公司提供咨询 能够降低监管部门的责任 能够为会计教授提供赚钱机会,不能够监督内部人 不能够为公司提供咨询 不能够降低监管部门的责任 不能够为会计教授提供赚钱机会,他们真的很厉害? 可以抑制掏空、提供咨询、扶贫教授、保护官员?,答案好像是唯一的!,推理可信吗?,事实可靠吗?,以独立董事为例,有人发现,独立董事越多(比例或人数,或有/没有)的公司,价值(会计指标或股价指标)越高。,疑问1:有其他解释吗?,疑问2:穷尽了任何公司的任何时点吗?,疑问3:事实可信吗?(何谓公司价值),该发现可以说明独立董事的价值吗?,以上例子中的方法论问题,研究问题:实证性命题(是什么?为什么)与规范性命题(怎么办?) 检验方法:推理与感知、归纳与演绎 计量方法:内生性,7,Part I: Methodology,8,Chap 1: The Philosophy of finance and accounting research,9,Research Progress,The Research Progress The statement of the research problem or issue to be investigated, or the theoretical explanation to be tested The translation of the abstract ideas in this theoretical explanation into concrete, explicitly identifiable ideas The development of measures of the important variables in the theoretical explanation,10,The development of a research design to guide the inquiry into the research problem The collection of the research data The analysis of this information in the context of the proposed explanation The interpretation of the information, or integration of the findings of the research with the existing knowledge base,11,Some issues on philosophy,What is research? Research is a process of intellectual discovery, which has the potential to transform our knowledge and understanding of the world around us. Research methodological varied with such assumptions about The nature of reality The role of theory The significance of empirical experimentation Why is research methodology important? When a piece of research is characterized by poor technique, a critic may argue that the research is defective, weak or misapplied, however, when a methodological dispute is involved the research is simply labeled as nonsensical”.,12,Research in accounting and finance is generally accepted as being social scientific, as appropriate standards of scientific enquiry are applied to social issues rather than natural phenomena, which is taken to be the domain of the natural sciences and of physics in particular The social scientific is serious affected by Duality within western thought Reality could be characterized by opposites There is an essential duality in all things,13,Individual subject,knowledge,beliefs,perceptions,appearance,reason,External object,14,Epistmology or what is knowledge Empiricism and rationalism: the source of knowledge Socrate and Plato Vs. Aristotle| Descartes, Hegel and Marx Vs. Newton Traditionally, classical empiricists accepted that Certainty of belief in what we know can only be approached through perception Ultimately all knowledge is derived from perception through our senses In the realm of discourse statements are either true or false because of the way the world is or because of some formal properties of the language we used,15,Realism versus idealism: ontology of what we know Realisms hold that reality subsists within objects; idealists hold that it exists within the mind of the subject Hume Vs. Berkeley Kant: Transcendental idealism There is an objective world or experience which we relate and ultimately test our claims to knowledge of what is true or false we can know them by the application of certain transcendent principles relativism,16,Logical positivism and instrumentalism Linguistic derivative of empiricism where the world of meaningful discoursed is controlled by a particular variety of the correspondence theory of truth Hold that: True belief is grounded in what we perceive and that what we perceive is derived from a value-free, independent reality Meaningful statements are only those which can, in principle at least, be verified by appeal to observation,17,Two difficulties The validity of the verification principle itself General laws and theoretical terms Instrumentalism The realism of given theoretical terms is quite irrelevant in determining the validity of any theoretical constructions derived from them or in which they are embedded. E.g., The fact that a theory is unreal is quite irrelevant provided that it works in practice. Friedman(1953) Falsificationism (Popper,1959) Any statement which cannot be demonstrated to be false is meaningless and any theory which cant be falsified is devoid of empirical content,18,Positive economics,Friedman (1953) Alchian(1950) 张五常(2001) Holthausena and Watts (2001),Uncertainty, Evolution and Economic Theory,Armen A. Alchian In Journal of Political Economy 58, no. 3 (June 1950): 211-221,Outline,In this paper, Alchian suggests an approach This approach embodies the principles of biological evolution and natural selection by interpreting the economic system as an adoptive mechanism which chooses among exploratory actions generate by the adaptive pursuit of success or profit This modification incorporate incomplete information and uncertain foresight as axioms, but dispense with profit maximization, and does not rely on the predictable individual behavior The method of use, rather than the usefulness, of economic tools and concepts is affected by this modification,“Profit Maximization” Is Not A Guide To Action,Current economic analysis of economic behavior relies heavily on decisions made by rational units customarily assumed to be seeking perfectly optimal situations (eg. Profit maximization or utility maximization). Attacks on this methodology are widespread, but only Tintners attack has been really damaging. He denies that profit maximization even makes no sense under uncertainty because under uncertainty each action that may be chosen is identified with a distribution of potential outcomes, not with a unique outcome. Using optimum distribution as a substitution still postulate a mode containing certainty,Success Is Based On Results, Not Motivation,The approach suggested treats the decisions and criteria dictated by economic system as more important than those made by the individuals in it. This approach directs attention to the interrelationships of the environment and the prevailing types of economic behavior which appear through a process of economic natural selection Success (survival) accompanies relative superiority It doesnt require proper motivation but may rather be the result of fortuitous circumstances,Chance or Luck Is One Method of Achieving Success,Two substantial elements in determining the situation selected and its appropriateness or viability Chance or luck Conscious adapting The survivors may appear to be those having adapted themselves to the environment, whereas the truth may well be that the environment has adopted them Eg. The travelers and gasoline station,Chance Does Not Imply Nondirected, Random Allocation of Resources,The implication of sheer chance model Individual random behavior does not eliminate the likelihood of observing appropriate decisions Individual behavior according to some foresight and motivation doesnt necessarily imply a collective pattern of behavior that is different from the collective variety of actions associated with a random selection of actions,Chance Does Not Imply Nondirected, Random Allocation of Resources,A chance-dominated model does not mean that an economist cannot predict or explain or diagnose The prediction will not assert that every firm necessarily changes its characteristics Empirical investigations via questionnaires methods are incapable of evaluating the validity of marginal productivity analysis,Individual Adapting Via Imitation and Trial and Error,Two forms of conscious adaptive behavior Imitation Trial and error Imitation and innovations Imitation affords relief from the necessity of really making decisions and conscious innovations. The willingness to abandon it at the right time and circumstances accounts for success when conditions have changed Innovation is also accounted for by imitation,Individual Adapting Via Imitation and Trial and Error,Trial and profit maximization Two conditions for convergence from trial to profit maximization A trial must be classifiable as a success or failure Continual rising toward some optimum optimorum without intervening descents The above convergence conditions do not apply to a changing environment, for there can be no observable comparison of the result of an action with any other Success is discovered by the economic system through a blanketing shotgun process, not by the individual through a converging search,Conclusions,Observable patterns of behavior and organization are predictable in terms of their relative probabilities of success or viability if they are tried Using the present analytical tools developed in the analysis of the firm under certainty, can predict the more adoptable or viable types of economic interrelationships that will be induced by environmental change even if individuals themselves are unable to ascertain them Does this paper indicate that the present tools for the diagnosis of the operation of economic system are also for the internal business behavior of each firm?,The Methodology of Positive Economics,Milton Friedman In , 1953, Chicago U. Press,Outline,In this paper, Friedman will discuss the relationship between positive and normative economics The target and elements of positive theory The role of assumptions of positive theory,The Relationship Between Positive and Normative Economics,John Neville Keynes (1891) A positive science is a body of systematized knowledge concerning what is A normative or regulative science is a body of systematized knowledge discussing criteria of what ought to be An art is system of rules for the attainment of given end Normative economics cannot be independent of positive economics the currently in US differences about economic policy among disinterested citizens derive predominantly from the prediction consequence of such policy, which is the question of positive economics, rather than from fundamental differences in basic values, which is the bases of normative economics Eg. Minimum-wage legislation,Positive Economics,The ultimate goal of a positive science is the development of a theory or hypothesis that yields valid and meaningful predictions about phenomena not yet observed Such a theory is a complex intermixture of two elements A language designed to promote systematic and organized methods of reasoning. A body of substantive hypotheses designed to abstract essential features of complex reality,Positive Economics,Viewed as a language, theory has no substantive content, it is a set of tautologies. The criteria by which it is to be judged are those appropriate to a filing system. the valid of this element can be shown by logical and factual consideration. Eg. The term of Supply and Demand Viewed as a body of substantive hypotheses, theory is to be judged by its predictive power for the class of phenomena which it is intended to explain. Only factual evidence can show whether it is valid,Positive Economics,The choice among alternative hypotheses must to some extent be arbitrary, though simplicity and fruitfulness is the general agreed criteria A theory is simpler the less the initial knowledge needed to make a prediction within a given field of phenomena It is more fruitful the more precise the resulting prediction, the wider the area with which the theory yields predictions, and the more additional lines for further research it suggests,Positive Economics,The characters of empirical evidence The necessity of relying on uncontrolled experience rather than on controlled evidence makes it difficult to produce dramatic and clear cut evidence to justify the acceptance of tentative hypotheses. Empirical evidence is vital at two different stages: in constructing hypothesis and in testing their validity,The role of assumptions,A theory cant be tested by the realism of its assumptions, but by the prediction of the theory The relationship between the significance of a theory and the realism of its assumptions is opposite Eg. S=1/2 gt2 The density of leaves around a tree The maximization of returns hypothesis,The role of assumptions,The assumptions of a theory play three different positive roles An economic model of describing or presenting a theory The assumptions is the conceptual world of abstract model simpler than the real world, and containing only the forces that the forces that the hypothesis asserts to be important. There is no place in the model for, and no function to be served by, vagueness, maybes, or approximations. The rules for using the model cant be abstract and complete Facilitate and indirect test of the hypothesis by its implications A convenient means of specifying the conditions under which the theory is expected to be valid,Conclusions,A positive economics is concerning what is, and can be an input of normative economics A positive theory is a complex intermixture with a language and a body of substantive hypothesis. The hypothesis is made of two parts: the assumptions and the rules. The valid of positive theory cant be judged by the realism of assumptions, but the prediction of this theory Could a theory be improved by modifying the assumptions?,科学的方法,张五常 摘自经济解释卷一科学说需求,2001,香港花千树出版社,提纲,在本文中,张五常将要讨论 主观感情对经济研究的影响 科学方法的几个原则 科学理论的现实性 核心论点 科学不是求对,也不是求错;科学所求的是“可能被事实推翻”。可能被事实推翻而没有被推翻,就算是被解释了,人与科学,人的感情往往与理智混淆,这样科学上的推断可能被感情左右,搞得拖泥带水,但也可以精彩绝伦,使人觉得妙不可言。 科学可以有艺术的美。但是,科学的本质不是艺术,而是以解释现象为主旨。科学的著作可以将客观分析与主观感情相结合、并用,但二者要分得清楚 主观感情与客观分析的清楚划分比较困难,但并非说不能做到,而是比自然科学困难。,现象必有规律,不管是大自然还是人的行为,都有规律可循(寻) 科学的形成是基于三个重要的信念,是任何对科学感兴趣的人都要遵守的 主观的现象要被客观的认同,共信 所有被众所认同的现象都是有迹可循,有规律的 假若现象没有规律,那么就不能被系统的解释 任何规律的发生都是有原因的,事实不能解释事实,解释现象需要非事实的抽象理论 这是因为事实的规律不能不言自明,自我解释 若用事实解释事实,会存在以下两个困难 世界上的现象规律何其多也,从而理论就会汗牛充栋,各不相同,从而毫无一般性的解释能力 有规律的现象,在不同的情况下,其规律可能会改变,事实不能解释事实,几位名人观点 事实不能以事实作解释(K. Brunner) 事实的规律是要被解释的(M. Friedman) 这些争议的经验告诉我们,除非经过理智的考究与解释,我们不可能从事实中学到些什么。这也教训了我们,使我们知道最鲁莽而又虚伪的,是那些公开声言让事实自作解释的理论家,而或者无意识地,自己在幕后操纵事实的选择与组合,然后提出如下类的推论:在这之后所以这就是原因。(A. Marshall),特殊理论与套套逻辑,任何科学理论,若被事实推翻,我们总可以多加条件来挽救的,但挽救理论是须付代价的,所谓特殊理论(ad hoc theory) 就是特殊到只能解释一个现象的理论 例:温度重量/风/斜坡/海拔 所谓套套逻辑(tautology),是指一些言论,在任何情况下都不可能是错的 例如,四足动物有四只脚,争取个人最大化利益与跳楼 套套逻辑并非不可能是一个重要的概念。假若我们能把范围加以约束、收窄,有时可以促成一个有内容的理论,例如,科斯定理 大有可取的,足以解释世事的理论是处于两者之间的,可能被事实推翻的重要性,在整个科学方法的结构中最重要的一点是,理论的推测一定要可能 被事实推翻 不可能被事实推翻的理论之所以没有解释力,是因为这样的理论不能被事实验证 假若一个理论被事实推翻了,我们有两个选择 放弃 设法附加验证条件 验证一个理论含意的唯一办法,是以事实反证, A-B, 等价于,NOT B-NOT A. 而非NOT A-NOT B 例如 Lester通过调查雇主如何确定司机工资的方法来推翻边际理论是错误的 白痴建加油站, 说明NOT A 并非推出NOT B. 天狗吃月亮来推断月食,被现代时刻理论取代的原因并非天狗不会吃月亮,而是后者具有更强的一般性,几种不能被事实推翻的情况,套套逻辑 模糊不清 概念或分析模糊不清,不可能清楚地错,所以也不能清楚地被事实推翻 例子 马克思的“剩余价值” Pigou的福利经济学 Richardo的资本与成本概念 凯恩斯的通论 Bentham的功用 Knight的风险与不确定性的区分,几种不能被事实推翻的情况,没有意义 没有意义并非空洞,而是因为言论互相矛盾,逻辑上前后不一致,例如,以自私人为前提,但推论却否定之 非事实 验证含意的事实性并不否认理论构建中的抽象 无限制 无论验证时所牵涉的现象怎样多,一个限制是必需的 不均衡可解作推断的现象没有限制,理论的真实性,因为事实不能解释事实,以理论解释现象,在某种程度上一定是抽象的。抽象的思想当然不是事实,要说理论非真实也是可以的 但有解释力的理论的非真实性,起码有四种含意 理论本身必定有抽象的成分 所有事实或观察的描述,一定要简化 为了便于处理而简化事实 验证条件的非真实性 但无论怎样简化,也一定要与真实世界的情况大致吻合,结论,科学方法论牵涉到哲学上的逻辑学和知识理论,是人类文化历史上最湛深的学问 但是科学的成就往往与此学问无关 不懂科学方法论的科学高手屈指难算 科学方法论的高手很少是有成就的科学家 由于中国人的文化传统,往往大谈仁义道德,缺乏科学精神,对科学辩证的本质有根深蒂固的误解,我认为,科学方法论对中国人比对其他民族更为重要,The relevance of the value-relevance literature for financial accounting standard setting,Robert W. Holthausena, Ross L. Watts In Journal of Accounting and Economics 31 (2001) 375,Outline,This paper will discuss Whats the underlying theory of value-relevance literatures? Why they are not descriptive? What should we do?,the underlying theory,What is the value-relevance literature? papers investigate the empirical relation between stock market values (or changes in values) and particular accounting numbers for the purpose of assessing or providing a basis of assessing those numbers use or proposed use in an accounting standard.,the underlying theory,Three types (24-53-7/62) Relative association studies compare the association between stock market values (or changes in values) and alternative bottom-line measures. Incremental association studies investigate whether the accounting number of interest is helpful in explaining value or returns (over long windows) given other specified variables. Marginal information content studies investigate whether a particular accounting number adds to the information set available to investors,the underlying theory,Theories underlying such studies In direct valuation theory accounting earnings is intended to either measure, or be highly associated with, equity market value changes or levels (via permanent income). Given direct valuation theory, standard setters would be interested in the results of a study of the relative stock price associations of alternative accounting earnings or book value of equity measures.,the underlying theory,In inputs-to-equity valuation theory, accountings role is to provide information on inputs to valuation models that investors use in valuing firms equity. Under an inputs-to-equity valuation theory standard setters are more likely to be interested in a study that suggests investors could use an accounting number or a potential accounting number in their valuation models.,the underlying theory,In both cases, earnings would measure, or be highly associated with equity market values or changes in equity market values, and equity book values would measure, or be highly associated with, equity market values. Essentially value-relevance studies imply accountings role is to provide estimates of equity market values or linear transformations of equity market values (direct equity valuation).,Why are the theories not descriptive?,The GAAP Statement The practice of accounting The valuation model,FASB statements and value-relevance theories,three assumptions made by value-relevance studies that are inconsistent with FASB statements users and uses of financial reporting Whether do the stock prices adequately represent equity investors use of information in valuing equity securities Whether do the stock price- based tests of relevance and reliability measure relevance and reliability as defined by FA
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 高中数学三角函数图象与性质综合复习教学设计
- 小学三年级综合实践活动教学设计:侦察家庭垃圾的分类与减量实践
- 小学四年级心理健康教育课程我坚持我成功教学设计
- 初中心理健康八年级《人际交往-如果我们换一换》教学设计
- 小学三年级上学期家长会主题班会教案:家校同心话成长携手共育好习惯
- 高中信息技术必修1 教学设计 电子公告板与在线游戏的协同构建与社会化运维
- 小学二年级德育主题班会教学设计《家校同心 护航成长》
- 中小学反诈工作计划
- CN119538342A 基于深度学习的傅里叶变化光谱仪结构设计方法及系统 (山东非金属材料研究所)
- 2026事业单位工勤技能-新疆-新疆假肢制作装配工五级(初级工)历年参考题库含答案详解
- 入额法官责任制度
- 木头下脚料收购协议书
- 贵州国企招聘2025贵州贵阳产业发展控股集团有限公司招聘27人笔试历年参考题库附带答案详解
- 铁路概论课件
- 患者拒绝或放弃医学治疗(或抢救)告知书
- 保险消费者权益保护培训
- DGTJ08-2248-2017 等厚度水泥土搅拌墙技术规程
- 2026届山东省聊城莘县联考化学九年级第一学期期中达标检测试题含解析
- 绒用山羊饲养管理技术
- (高清版)DB11∕T 1557-2025 能效对标实施规范
- GB/T 9237-2017制冷系统及热泵安全与环境要求
评论
0/150
提交评论