已阅读5页,还剩21页未读, 继续免费阅读
版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
Part I Conflicting Interests -25-Chapter 5 Why a Cod Fishery Collapsed8/9/05Outline5.1 A Widely Recognized Problem Hard to Fix5.1.1 Our Example The Collapse of the Northern Cod Fishery5.1.2 Gordons idea in a Nutshell5.1.3 The Road Ahead5.2 Positive Analysis (About What Is)5.2.1 The Yield Curve5.2.2 Diminishing Returns of Economic Benefits5.2.3 Open Access within the Fishery5.2.4 Constant Costs5.2.5 Open Access into the Fishery and Its Opportunity Cost5.2.6 The Nash Equilibrium5.3 Normative Analysis (About Goals and Values)5.3.1 Maximizing Sustainable Yield as the Social Goal5.3.2 Maximizing Sustainable Net Social Benefit as the Social Goal5.4 Seeing the Externality5.5 The Search for Policy Remedy5.5.1 Licenses5.5.2 Aggregate Catch Limits5.5.3 Marketable Individual Quotas5.5.4 Landing Taxes5.6 Big Questions5.7 SummaryDefinitions and ConceptsDiscussion QuestionsAnalytic QuestionsFiguresFigure 5.1 A Network of Policy Analysis for the Fisheries ProblemFigure 5.2 Sustainable YieldFigure 5.3 Total Benefit, Average Benefit, and Individual BenefitFigure 5.4 Total Cost, Average Cost, and Individual CostFigure 5.5 The Nash EquilibriumFigure 5.6 Social Goals and the Nash EquilibriumFigure 5.7 Seeing the ExternalityFigure 5.8 The Policy QuestionChapter 5 Why a Cod Fishery CollapsedRuin is the destination toward which all men rush, each pursuing his own best interest in a society that believes in the freedom of the commons.-Garett Hardin (Science, 1968)5.1 A Widely Recognized Problem Hard to FixMarine biologists and environmental economists have warned for decades that increasing harvests from the worlds great fisheries were increasingly stressing the fisheries, with increasing risk of collapse. Then it happened, large scale and world-wide, sobering in its evidence that human activities could affect global ecosystems. In some ways this environmental problem is very different from the more homely traffic congestion problem, yet it also shares commonalities with it: open access to a resource with limited carrying capacity and the “natural tendencies” of individual self-interest that led in the presence of externalities away from social goals of efficiency and fairness. In fact, there is a strong parallel between Pigous traffic congestion model and a Canadian economists model of fisheries depletion.In this chapter we study fisheries collapse, on its own terms. To bring out the parallel between the two models, I will use the same organization as the previous chapter, of positive analysis, normative analysis, and policy choice and implementation. But since we went through a detailed algebraic analysis in studying Pigous traffic congestion problem, I will be more brief in the algebraic analysis of the fisheries problem.5.1.1 Our Example The Collapse of the Northern Cod FisheryThe northern cod fish is the source of livelihood, directly or indirectly, for most people in Newfoundland, Canada. At least it was, until July, 1992, when the Canadian government closed the Newfoundland cod fishery. The first reaction in the fishing families was anger upon hearing the announcement a group of fishermen tried to storm the local hotel where the Canadian Minister of Fisheries and Oceans outlined the planned moratorium. They were not so much angry with the moratorium maybe that was necessary but the governments plan for unemployment benefits seemed unfair to them. The population of cod had sharply declined over several decades and perhaps something had to be done. Perhaps the fishing stocks would recover. A few years previously, there had been a movement among the fishing families to organize a moratorium, but it had come to nothing.Was the moratorium the right policy decision? The right decision depends of course on the right diagnosis of the problem. Was the depletion of the fishery caused by the local fishermen, fishing with their net traps, which collected fish by the tons? Or was it caused by the otter trawlers which dragged much larger nets across the bottom, a marine equivalent to clear cutting a forest? Or was it not so much differences in technology as just the larger market pressures of too many people trying to buy too many fish? Or was the source of the problem changes in the currents caused by greenhouse gases and chlorofluorocarbins (CFCs) or by natural climate changes? Or was the cause natural shifts in current or the population dynamics of the cod? In the midst of these uncertainties, one thing stands out. The collapse of the cod population is not just a matter of natural short-term fluctuations. Over 100 years, there have been fluctuations in the population with a downward trend leading to the recent collapse. Marine biologists were still arguing about the causes of the collapse, and they were surprised when it came, sooner, sharper, deeper than their models were predicting. This was a serious matter, because the Newfoundland fishery was one of the most productive and economically important fisheries in the world.Georges Bank, another of the worlds great fisheries, was partly closed two years later. The moratorium was imposed on Georges Bank (which is just off Cape Cod a few hundred miles south of the Newfoundland fishery) for the same reason severe depletion of cod, haddock and flounder. Traditionally Georges Bank and the Newfoundland fishery, like other fishing grounds, have been open access and anyone could fish them, not just Canadian and U.S. fishermen, but fishermen from all over the world. But as these fisheries became more depleted, disputes increased and there were increased efforts to limit access to the resource. A few years before the closures, both the Canadian and the U.S. governments extended national jurisdictions from 12 to 200 miles offshore to conserve the fisheries by limiting access, but then the U.S. government subsidized American fishermen so that they could buy bigger boats and the Canadian government provided similar subsidies for their fishermen. For a few years there was a bonanza for the U.S. and Canadian fishermen, then the bonanza was over.The New England Fishery Management Council, which finally recommended the U.S. moratorium, is composed of representatives of New England fishermen. The council is an important policy making group, and the U.S. Commerce Department, which ordered the closure, often follows its management advice. In representing the industry, the council was caught between two powerful interests: protecting the current incomes of the fishermen, which suggested delay in conservation action, and protecting the future incomes of the fishermen, which suggested immediate strong conservation action. Caught between the short-term and the long-term goals, the council had temporized for years, until imminent collapse forced action in 1994. Marine biologists worry that the present depletion might not be reversible, because other species might move into the cods niche, preventing the cods recovery. The moratoriums of the early 1990s, likely to have been effective a decade earlier, might prove ineffective by the time they were agreed upon and implemented. The lag between the environmental signal and the institutional response appears to have led to a mismatch between last decades remedy and this years problem. Cushman, John (1994). “Panel Recommends Virtual End To Fishing Fleet in Georges Bank,” New York Times, Oct. 27, p. A1Decades earlier in 1954 Scott Gordon, the Canadian economist, published his analysis of the fisheries problem and his policy recommendations. Gordon developed his analysis for fisheries in general and applied it to the fisheries along the Pacific in the Seattle-Vancouver region, long before the problems on the Grand Bank of the Newfoundland fishery and Georges Bank became acute. Gradually over the years Gordons analysis has become accepted by economists and marine biologists as a general way of understanding the fisheries problem. But unfortunately, understanding the nature of an environmental problem does not mean that it will then be easily remedied; the same incentive structures that led to the problem may also make it resistant to remedy, including redesigning the institutional processes and modifying the incentives.5.1.2 Gordons Idea in a NutshellIn summing up his idea, Gordon wrote that since the oceans and their fish belonged to everyone, they belonged to no one. Each fisherman would harvest counting his own benefits, but not the costs of a depleted fishery borne by the others (these costs are the depletion externality). He would continue doing so until the marginal costs to himself of his own effort just matched his private benefit from his harvest. The external costs of depletion were not internalized in Gordons time, and he identified this as the cause of overfishing, leading to too much stress on the fisheries. Adding to the stress in fisheries world wide, the private costs of harvesting fish were declining, with larger and faster boats, larger nets, and longer fishing lines. Gordon predicted that incentives to overfish would continue until there would be collapses of fisheries.He made this prediction at a time when many people were asserting that cod fish were like cockroaches; you could never exterminate them or keep up with their reproductive success. In its essentials, Gordons model is very simple and much like Pigous traffic congestion model, and somewhat like Garritt Hardins “tragedy of the commons” published 14 years later. There are some differences, for example by taking into account the costs of fishing, Gordon did not predict “ruin” was the “destination toward which all men rush” in all commons problems (see Hardins epigraph). Hardins analysis may have been his own discovery for himself. I asked him if he had read of Pigous traffic congestion analysis, and he said he hadnt. As it turned out, Gordons simple model predicted better than more elaborate models constructed at the time and later.5.1.3 The Road AheadFigure 5.1Figure 5.1 provides a map of an integrated policy assessment of the fisheries problem. It is like what we had for the congestion problem, except it differs in its specifics. Remember though, that as we go through the map sequentially, each part influences the others, back and forth.Before you read further, to appreciate what Gordon did, ask yourself how you would analyze the fisheries problem and put the pieces together, to make a coherent diagnosis and policy recommendation.Now, after you have given yourself a moment to sketch your own analysis about these things, we are ready to see how Gordon did it. I will modernize his analysis, making it more game theoretic, to bring out the parallel with Pigous congestion problem. I will also add some things that became more prominent after Gordons time, such as marketable (or transferable) quotas and fish farming.5.2 Positive Analysis (About What Is)The primary goal of this main section is to identify a Nash equilibrium. Recall that a positive concept is about what is, or predicts what will be.5.2.1 The Yield CurveIn any fishery, if the number of fishermen increases past a certain point, the total fishing yield begins to decline from overfishing. Yield is the harvest, in pounds or tons, over some unit of time. For convenience we will take our unit of time to be a year. From a biologists point of view, humans are just one more of the many predators of a fish population. With a stable environment, including predators and sources of nutrients, a fish population tends to fluctuate around a stable level. When the environment changes, for example when climate changes or fishing effort increases, it takes some time for the fish population to adjust, but eventually it does and fluctuates around a new stable level (the fluctuations can be pretty large).“Fishing effort” is a term used by marine biologists to take into account the combined effect of fishermen, the capabilities of the boats, and effectiveness of the equipment. For our purposes, we will interpret “fishing effort” to be a “package” of a fisherman working for a year with his boat, equipment, and fuel. We will call the number of such units of fishing effort n. We will take these units of effort to be comparable in their size and skill. Marine biologists draw diagrams similar to Figure 5.2, showing the characteristic relationship between fishing effort and the sustainable yield (or harvest). Diagrams like Figure 5.2 differ depending on the species, the fishing grounds, and other factors. The process of estimating sustainable yield curves can be quite complex. But the idea is simple enough. To interpret Figure 5.2 for some particular species, like cod fish, think of some particular level of fishing effort which remains constant long enough for the cod population to adjust to it. Then the diagram shows the sustainable yield Y for each such possible, fixed level of effort.Figure 5.2The diagram shows that when there are no fishermen fishing there is no harvest. When there is a steady state of a small number of fishermen fishing, say 100 fishermen, the fish population is high, the average size of the fish caught is large, but since there are few fishermen the steady state total harvest of Y1 pounds is low. When there are very many fishermen every year, say 900, the fish population is depleted and low, the average size of the fish caught is small and fish are often caught before they have time to mature and reproduce, and since there are few fish to catch the annual total harvest is low, at Y3. When there is a moderate number of fishermen, the fish population is between these extremes, the fish have time to mature and reproduce, and the total sustainable harvest is larger. The diagram shows the maximum sustainable yield at Y2 pounds per year, with 500 fishermen. This number strikes a balance between preserving the resource base and having enough fishermen to harvest a lot of fish each year. When the fishing effort is sustained at a level of 1000, the fishery entirely collapses.Gordon implicitly modeled the yield curve as a parabola. This allows us to highlight the main ideas while keeping the math simple. The parabolaTB(n) = n(1000 n)where n is the number of (steady state) fishermen in the fishery and TB(n) is the sustained yield or the Total Benefit with the n fishermen. Note that when n = 0, the harvest is 0. When n = 1000 is the steady state number of fishermen, the fishery collapses to a 0 harvest. So far the equation of the parabola and the diagram agree. But it is convenient to add one more feature to the parabola, a feature that adjusts for the height of the parabola. For our illustration, we will use the parabolaTB(n) = (200)(n)(1000 n)(1)Multiplying by 200 makes the illustration in rough agreement with the incomes of fishermen in Canada, when the fishery is managed efficiently. We will see this rough agreement later.In empirical studies of fisheries, the estimated yield curves are upside-down shaped curves, but not exact parabolas. Of course there are more or less random fluctuations year to year, and when the fishing effort gets close to a complete collapse, a few years of bad conditions for fish “recruitment” (the fishs reproduction) can tip the system over into collapse. But once you understand Gordons model, you can understand more complicated models, some of which are developments of Gordons model and some are quite different.5.2.2 Diminishing Returns of Economic BenefitsFigure 5.2 illustrates an essential biological characteristic of the fishery the adjustment between the steady state population and the amount of predation. A key part of this relationship is diminishing returns. In the diagram, diminishing returns doesnt begin with 500 fishermen, the number that maximizes the sustainable yield. In the diagram, diminishing returns starts with the first fisherman. Beginning with the first fisherman, as fishing effort increases, the sustainable yield also increases, but at a diminishing rate.The sustainable yield is measured in pounds (or tons) of harvest in a year. It is a physical, biological concept. When the fishermen sell their catch, they translate the physical pounds of fish into their income, which is an economic benefit for themselves. For simplicity, suppose that fish sell for $1 a pound at the dockside. Then the sustainable physical yield in pounds is the same as the sustainable total gross income to all the fishermen (gross income is the income before the fishermens costs are subtracted off). The gross income is the fishermens total benefit. When the fishermens total costs are subtracted off, the result is their total net income, which we call the net social benefit NSB, the total net benefit for the society of fishermen. In this model, we abstract from the fact that fishing is a way of life, valued for its challenges and time at sea (we also abstract from the risks and costs of fishing to the fishermens families). Taking these values into account would add to the policy goal of preserving the worlds natural fisheries. We abstract from other net benefits, like the employment opportunities to the truckers that haul the fish and the benefits of eating fresh fish. These benefits are also part of the fisheries value.With these simplifications, sustainable yield translates to the fishermens total benefit. And just as there are diminishing returns to the fishermens efforts in producing a yield, there are also diminishing returns of their total benefit from their fishing efforts. The reason for diminishing returns to the sustainable yield as the fi
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 2026年教育行业成本控制报告及信息化建设分析
- 2026年人工智能行业深度学习技术发展及应用前景报告
- 江苏省无锡市锡山区2024年小升初英语毕业水平测试卷(含答案)
- 《软件工程理论与实践》课件第7章 软件项目管理概述
- 2026初中地理教资面试题库及参考答案
- 2026年吉林省集安市辅警招聘考试模拟题题库及答案
- 2026高中生物教资面试题库及参考答案
- 2026年cpa考试题库及参考答案
- 初中历史教资面试往年真题题库及参考答案
- 2026初中生物教资面试近年考题试卷及解析
- 黑龙江省龙东十校联盟2027届高三上学期11月期中质量测试语文试卷(含答案)
- GB/T 7251.3-2026低压成套开关设备和控制设备第3部分:由一般人员操作的配电板(DBO)
- 欧盟电池护照EU2023-1542数据架构全解:唯一标识访问权限与数据更新合规指南
- 钢筋弯曲机使用安全要求培训
- 2026年秋季开学时间管理课:做时间的主人课件
- 考研政治马克思主义基本原理核心知识点系统梳理框架
- ISO 14001-2026《环境管理体系 要求和使用指南》变化与应对行动说明表(雷泽佳编制-2026A0)
- (物理)2027版高中《基础自测小纸条》必修2(默写+背诵版)
- 上海市徐汇区名校2027届数学八上期末综合测试试题含解析
- 2026年河北省中考英语试卷(含答案)
- 低压电缆头制作安装施工方案及技术措施
评论
0/150
提交评论