森林火灾立法外文文献_第1页
森林火灾立法外文文献_第2页
森林火灾立法外文文献_第3页
森林火灾立法外文文献_第4页
森林火灾立法外文文献_第5页
已阅读5页,还剩3页未读, 继续免费阅读

下载本文档

版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领

文档简介

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Ecological Indicators journal homepage Forest fi re legislation Reactive or proactive Paulo Reis Mouraoa V tor Domingues Martinhob aDept Economics Huntsinger et al 2017 Indeed the discussion about forest fi res legislation seems simple and the meaning of terms like proactive reacts early and focused on fi re prevention or reactive reacts to an action focused on focused on fi re suppression and forgetting the sources of the problem seems clear and easily understandable in a quick search in internet where they are terms considered in some cases as antagonistic Tedim et al 2015 However these diff erences between these two concepts are not un derstood in the same way by the several stakeholders related with the forest fi re In any case our perspective is that a reactive forest fi re legislation cannot be considered also as proactive because it is a re action to solve anything that already happened It would be proactive if the catastrophic fi res do not occur again or if at least the reactive leg islation reduces the risks of new fi re occurrences however the reality does not highlight this desirable context This question about the re activity and proactivity related with the forest fi re was also explored by a document from the Government of British Columbia 2010 In this framework in a perspective of contributing to greater un derstanding of forest fi re legislation to clarify our perspective and to highlight what the international literature says about this topic the objective of this work is to review the literature available about this subject About sixty works were considered retrieved from the Web of https doi org 10 1016 j ecolind 2019 04 080 Received 1 October 2018 Received in revised form 27 April 2019 Accepted 28 April 2019 Corresponding author E mail addresses paulom eeg uminho pt P R Mourao vdmartinho esav ipv pt V D Martinho Ecological Indicators 104 2019 137 144 Available online 04 May 2019 1470 160X 2019 Elsevier Ltd All rights reserved T Table 1 Summary about the literature related with the forest fi re legislation topic AuthorCountries of analysisObjectives MethodologiesLegislation relationshipsReactive or proactive legislation or both Article Conference Comment V tkov et al 2017 Central Europe Austria Czech Republic Germany Hungary Lichtenstein Poland Slovakia Slovenia and Switzerland Analyse the literature about the Robinia pseudoacacia The legislation infl uence the landscape distribution of the Robinia pseudoacacia where the fi re has its impacts Article Fernandes et al 2017 PortugalPoint of view about Mourao and Martinho 2016 The legislation is a response to large fi res but also with proactive instruments Reactive and proactive legislationComment Mourao and Martinho 2016 PortugalAnalyse the Portuguese legislation about forest fi re among 1980 and 2013 considering time series econometric methodologies The legislation is a response to the consequences of great forest fi res Reactive legislationArticle Santos et al 2016 Northwest IberiaEvaluate the implications on the land use and on the biodiversity from the socioeconomic changes namely in the rural zones The expansion of fast growing trees must be limited by the legislation preventing big fi res Need of more proactive legislationArticle Robles et al 2016 Pontevedra Spain Analyse woodlands and identify fi re risks for the nearby buildings considering spatial models Sometimes the legislation namely that related with distance among the forest areas and the buildings is not complied Need more proactive instruments to implement the available legislation Article Durigan and Ratter 2016 Cerrado Brazil Analysis about the prescribed fi reSometimes the legislation available is not implemented Need more proactive instruments to implement the available legislation Article Althoff et al 2016 Brazil Simulate the climate changes on fi rewood and soil conservation The legislation must promote the sustainability on native tropical dry forests Need of more proactive legislationArticle Perez 2015 Spain Analyse the modifi cations in the legislation related with forest fi res Changes in the legislation appeared as consequence of large fi res Reactive legislationArticle Badia and Valldeperas 2015 Understand the conditions of the populations in the wildland urban interfaces Understand the impact of the legislation in the vulnerability of the populations in the wildland urban interfaces Article Ramcilovic Suominen and Epstein 2015 GhanaAnalyse the compliance of the legislationThe legal reforms must take into account the social framework of local populations Need of more adjusted legislationArticle Mor n et al 2015 Investigate the use of biomass in small scale boilers Lack of information and legislation about the biomass use Article Ch vez and Coss o 2014 PeruExamine the consequences of changes in the forest management namely concession to private forest fi rms The implementation of forest legislation depends on several factor Need a more accompaniment in the legislation implementation Article Fisher et al 2014 Western Australia Assess relationships between environment fi re fl ora and fauna The legislation infl uence the forest dynamicsArticle Carreiras et al 2014 Portugal and Spain Compare forest fi re strategies and policiesThe actual legislation and policies are yet in an evolutionary framework The forest fi res become a problem when occurred Need of more proactive legislationArticle Isaev and Korovin 2013 RussiaInvestigate the new perspectives for the Russian forest Ineff ective forest fi re legislationNeed of more stable legislationArticle Bennett and Kruger 2013 South AfricaExamine the debate about the exotic plantationsSometimes the forest legislation has its own history Article Carmenta et al 2013 Brazilian AmazonAnalyse the practice implementation of the forest policies Often the practices do not compliance the legislation Need of more adjusted instruments to implement the legislation Article Anand et al 2013 North AmericaReview of the forest legislation and policies intricacies Sometimes de legislation is laggedThe forest legislation is an important instrument Article Etheridge and Kayahara 2013 CanadaAnalyse scenarios of forest management using a wood supply model Forest legislation is interrelated with the forest management Article Bradshaw et al 2013 AustraliaOptions of land management for the carbon sequestration Legislation is interrelated with the forest management In some cases the legislation is outdated Article Montiel Molina 2013 European Union Analyse the forest fi re legislation The forest fi re legislation is reactive to large fi res in place to be proactive Reactive legislationArticle Ascoli and Bovio 2013 Italy Literature review about the prescribed fi reLack of adjusted legislation at national level and great heterogeneity at regional level Need of more proactive and adjusted legislation Article continued on next page P R Mourao and V D MartinhoEcological Indicators 104 2019 137 144 138 Table 1 continued AuthorCountries of analysisObjectives MethodologiesLegislation relationshipsReactive or proactive legislation or both Article Conference Comment Kleeman et al 2013 United States of AmericaCompare air quality evolutionRelationships among the legislation and the climate change Need of more proactive and adjusted legislation Article Schultz et al 2012 Analyse forest restoration programsLegislation is interrelated with the forest management Article Ramcilovic Suominen and Hansen 2012 GhanaExamine the legislation compliance through interviews to the farmers The legal reforms must take into account the social framework of local populations Need of more adjusted legislationArticle van Wilgen et al 2012 South Africa Review of fi re management practices and strategies Sometimes there are confl icts among the instruments of the legal framework and these rules are not always well understood Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Dunn and Freeman 2011 United KingdomReview about the greenhouse gas emissions legislation namely those related with the peatlands The legislation has an important role in the relationships among several factors as the fi res and the greenhouse gas emissions Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Suring et al 2011 United States of AmericaAnalyse the distribution and sustainability of the wildlife populations The forest management legislation has infl uence in other fi elds Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Mamut 2011 CroatiaAnalyse of regional dynamics where the forest fi res has its infl uence Forest fi res and legislationNeed of more proactive legislationArticle Wilkie et al 2011 Tropical countriesRelationships between the hunting and the forest areas evolution Legislation and forest managementNeed of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Ribeiro and Freitas 2010 BrazilAnalyse changes in the forest legislationRelationships among the forest legislation changes the biodiversity and the agricultural productions Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Braby 2010 Australia Assessment of the butterfl y evolutionThe legislation should be protective to disturbances where the fi re has its importance Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Badia et al 2010 SpainIdentify potential vulnerable zones in the interface with the urban areas The forest fi re legislation need to be more eff ectiveNeed of more proactive legislationArticle van t Sant et al 2009 NetherlandsHighlight risk plansThe legislation is a crucial instrument to prevent risk situations Conference Negr n et al 2008 United States of AmericaHighlight the partnerships for the forest researchThe research as an important base for the legislation design Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Egan 2007 America WestSynthesis several papers presented in a workshop related with forest fi res The legislation has its impact on the relationships among the forest and the related ecosystems Need of more adjusted instrumentsGuest Editorial Murphy et al 2007 United States of AmericaSynthesis about forest interactions The legislation and its infl uence in the forest ecology and function Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Vosick et al 2007 Synthesis about forest policy and managementThe legislation may be an interesting base for the forest management Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Fearnside 2007 BrazilExamine the environmental impact of human decisions and their impacts on the forests The legislation sometimes it is not fulfi lledNeed of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Nepstad et al 2006 BrazilExamine the Amazon forest transformationsThe legislation compliance sometimes depend on adjusted approaches from the public institutions Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Tacconi and Ruchiat 2006 Indonesia Analyse the fi re management The forest fi re legislation is inappropriateNeed of more adjusted instrumentsArticle Leimgruber et al 2005 Review about Landsat applications The legislation has infl uence in the land management Article Partel et al 2005 EstoniaGroup species with similar needs of conservationThe legislation is important for the biodiversityNeed of better legislationArticle Stephens and Ruth 2005 United States of America Present new proposals for the forest fi re legislation The available research is an important base for the design of adjusted policies Need of better legislationArticle Varmola et al 2004 FinlandReview about the forest managementThe legislation is one of the important factors for the forest sustainability Article Hoare 2004 Thailand Analyse about the smoke and forest fi res problems The forest fi res legislation promote antagonismsNeed of more adjusted instrumentsArticle McCarter and Smith 2004 United States of AmericaExplore the pressures developed by interest groups in the approved legislation The forest fi re legislation and the interest groupsNeed of impartial legislationConference Barlow and Peres 2004 Brazil Review about the tropical forest fi res The legislation may support a more effi cient forest fi re management Need of more adjusted instrumentsArticle continued on next page P R Mourao and V D MartinhoEcological Indicators 104 2019 137 144 139 Science platform main database about forest fi res legislation This is a signifi cant issue with strong impacts on the forest and socioeconomic dynamics Mour o and Martinho 2014 It is important to clarify the discussion about these fi elds and inform public institutions about the need for more proactive forest fi re legislation rather than reactive Shaba 1999 In fact the recurring consequences of the forest fi res around the world shows that there is as yet much work to do in this direction Changing the paradigm namely in terms of prevention will allow several savings of lives among the population Viegas 2017 2 Material and methods This analysis considered as base about sixty documents articles comments and presentations in conferences available in the Web of Science over the period 1997 to 2017 for the following topic forest fi re legislation All articles com ments and presentations in conferences found in the Web of Science for this topic and over the period 1997 2017 were considered These documents were previously explored and systematized in the Table 1 From this previous analysis it was possible to fi nd the main subtopics highlighted by these studies These subtopics were presented and ex plored deeper in the subsections of the section 3 In fact considering that the main objective of this study is to contribute to the debate about this topic namely in terms of whether forest fi re legislation is reactive or proactive it is determinant to analyze these documents here pre sented It is possible to consider other online platforms such as Scopus or RePEc http repec org and other to pics besides rural fi res legislation However the number of works available in the Web Science for the topic proposed seemed to us suf fi cient to contribute to a discussion about the legislation associated with the fi res that every year devastate forests around the world However it will be important considering the study here presented as base to explore other topics and compare the results obtained by the diff erent online platforms Web of Science Scopus and RePEc In any case some of the scientifi c documents consulted are also available in the Scopus and RePEc platforms and the analysis based on the works found in the Web Science was complemented with other works namely those published by or related to international organi zations such as the United Nations The approach taken into account to develop this literature survey about this topic could proceed in several diff erent ways as shown for example by Anand et al 2013 or Moskwa et al 2016 However the most important for us taking into account the previous analysis of the documents it was to clarify the discussion about the questions related with the reactivity or proactivity of the forest fi re legislation the re lationships between the several legal instruments and the relations with the greenhouse gas emissions We consider that a serious discussion about these questions may bring interesting insights that can be considered by the several stake holders in the design of future policies and legislative instruments 3 Literature review s results Forests have important social economic and environmental con tributions for the sustainability of regions and countries but are fre quently subject to several pressures some from natural occurrences fi res diseases pest and others from the human activity anthro pogenic fi res construction The related forest legislation may have a proactive role preventing negative impacts for the woodlands or a re active one responding to catastrophic occurrences Mourao and Martinho 2016 About the debate related to forest fi re legislation there are many documents in the literature as those summarized in Table 1 and de veloped in the following subsections These subsections were defi ned considering the several subtopics highlighted in the consulted litera ture The subtopics explored in the next subsections are the following Table 1 continued AuthorCountries of analysisObjectives MethodologiesLegislation relationshipsReactive or proactive legislation or both Article Conference Comment Mielikainen and Hynynen 2003 FinlandAnalyse the forest managementThe legislation the biodiversity and the forest multifunctionality Article Ganz and Moore 2002 Analyse forest fi res around the worldThe legislation has being to become more proactive Needs of more proactive forest fi re legislation Conference Huff et al 2002 United States of AmericaExplore GIS frameworks to assess landscape changes The legislation is an important support for the forest and land management Article Morgan et al 2002 United States of AmericaExamine old growth pine standsThe legislation is an important support for the forest and land management Article Caetano et al 2001 PortugalPresent methodologies to control the forest legislation compliance Forest legislation complianceConference Juspan 2000 Indonesia Examine causes and impacts of forest fi resThe forest legislation may considered for a more eff ective fi res control Need of more adjusted instrumentsConference Paul et al 2000 PortugalMethodologies to control the forest legislation compliance Forest legislation complianceConference Santos et al 1999 PortugalMethodologies to control the forest legislation compliance Forest legislation complianceConference Shaba 1999 Analyse forest fi res around the worldThe legislation has being to become more proactive Needs of more proactive forest fi re legislation Meeting Kokorin 1997 RussiaAnalyse forest carbon sequestrationThe legislation should improve the carbon sequestration Need of more adjusted instrumentsConference P R Mourao and V D MartinhoEcological Indicators 104 2019 137 144 140 Reactive or proactive forest fi re legislation Forest and land manage ment legislation and forest fi res

温馨提示

  • 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
  • 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
  • 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
  • 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
  • 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
  • 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
  • 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。

评论

0/150

提交评论