[毕业设计精品论文]电子商务对企业财务内部控制制度的影响和对策 外文原文

ETHICALISSUESINOUTSOURCINGACCOUNTINGANDTAXSERVICESROBERTWMCGEEBARRYUNIVERSITYPRESENTEDATTHE17THANNUALMEETINGOFTHEINTERNATIONALACADEMYOFBUSINESSDISCIPLINES,PITTSBURGH,PAAPRIL710,2005ABSTRACTOUTSOURCINGHASBEENCRITICIZEDASAPRACTICETHATDESTROYSJOBSANDPRAISEDASAWAYTOCUTCOSTSANDREMAINCOMPETITIVETHEACCOUNTINGPROFESSIONHASUTILIZEDOUTSOURCINGTOAVAILITSELFOFEXPERTISETHATISNOTAVAILABLEWITHINTHEFIRMANDTOCUTTHECOSTOFOFFERINGAVARIETYOFACCOUNTINGANDTAXSERVICESTHEPRACTICEHASRAISEDSOMEETHICALQUESTIONSABOUTINTEGRITY,OBJECTIVITY,DISCLOSUREANDCLIENTCONFIDENTIALITYTHEAICPAPROFESSIONALETHICSEXECUTIVECOMMITTEEHASISSUEDTWONEWETHICSRULINGSANDREVISEDATHIRDETHICSRULINGTOADDRESSTHESEISSUESTHENEWRULESTAKEEFFECTJULY1,2005THISPAPERDISCUSSESTHESERULINGSANDTHEEFFECTTHEYWILLHAVEONACCOUNTINGPRACTICESINTRODUCTIONOUTSOURCINGHASBEENINTHENEWSALOTINRECENTYEARSTHEGENERALTHRUSTOFTHENEWSREPORTSISTHATOUTSOURCINGISATHREATTODOMESTICJOBSANDTHEDOMESTICECONOMYREPORTERSANDPOLITICIANSAREQUICKTOPICKUPONTHETHEMEBUTTHATBELIEFTHATOUTSOURCINGDESTROYSJOBSANDWEAKENSTHEECONOMYISNOTCOMPLETELYACCURATEOUTSOURCINGISLITTLEMORETHANANEXTENSIONOFTHEDIVISIONOFLABOR,ASECONOMISTSAREOFTENQUICKTOPOINTOUTINTHEMOVETOWARDINCREASEDEFFICIENCY,ITISPARTOFTHENATURALECONOMICPROCESSTOTRYTOFINDBETTER,MOREEFFICIENTANDLESSCOSTLYWAYSTODOTHINGSOUTSOURCINGISJUSTONETECHNIQUETHATCOMPANIESSOMETIMESUSETOCUTCOSTSANDINCREASEEFFICIENCYITISAGENERALRULEINECONOMICSTHATINORDERFORANECONOMYTOGROW,OLDJOBSMUSTBEDESTROYEDSOTHATNEWJOBSCANBECREATEDJOSEPHSCHUMPETER1984REFERREDTOTHISPROCESSASCREATIVEDESTRUCTIONOUTSOURCINGISJUSTONEMANIFESTATIONOFTHISPROCESSWHENOUTSOURCINGISAPPLIEDTOTHEPROVISIONOFACCOUNTINGANDTAXSERVICES,ANEWFACETOFTHESUBJECTMUSTBEEXAMINEDACCOUNTANTSUSEOUTSOURCINGTOAVAILTHEMSELVESOFEXPERTISETHATTHEIRFIRMDOESNOTPOSSESSANDTOCUTTHECOSTOFPROVIDINGCERTAINBASICSERVICESLIKEDATAPROCESSING,BOOKKEEPINGANDTAXPREPARATIONBUTWHENTHEYDOTHATTHEYTURNOVERCONFIDENTIALCLIENTINFORMATIONTOOUTSIDERSTHATRAISESSOMEETHICALISSUESTHEAICPASPROFESSIONALETHICSEXECUTIVECOMMITTEEEXAMINEDTHEEFFECTTHATOUTSOURCINGOFACCOUNTINGANDTAXSERVICESHASONINTEGRITY,OBJECTIVITY,COMPLIANCEWITHSTANDARDSANDCONFIDENTIALCLIENTINFORMATIONANDISSUEDANEXPOSUREDRAFTINEARLY2004ITRECEIVED49COMMENTLETTERSTOTHATEXPOSUREDRAFTASARESULTOFTHEFEEDBACKITRECEIVEDITMADESOMEMINORMODIFICATIONSTOTHEEXPOSUREDRAFTANDISSUEDITSFINALETHICSRULINGSONOCTOBER28,2004THESENEWPRONOUNCEMENTSTAKEEFFECTFORALLPROFESSIONALSERVICESPERFORMEDONORAFTERJULY1,2005THEYDONOTAPPLYTOPROFESSIONALSERVICESTHATAREPERFORMEDPURSUANTTOAGREEMENTSTHATAREINEXISTENCEONJUNE30,2005THATARECOMPLETEDBYDECEMBER31,2005THISPAPERSUMMARIZESTHOSERULINGSANDDISCUSSESTHEETHICALISSUESINVOLVEDETHICSINTERPRETATIONSANDRULINGSPROMULGATEDBYTHEAICPADONOTHAVETHEFORCEOFLAWATMOST,THEYAREBINDINGONLYONAICPAMEMBERS,ANDEVENTHENANAICPAMEMBERISFREETODISREGARDETHICSINTERPRETATIONSANDRULINGS,PROVIDEDTHEYCANCARRYTHEBURDENOFJUSTIFYINGTHEIRDEPARTUREINADISCIPLINARYHEARINGHOWEVER,THEYDOPROVIDESOMEGUIDANCEFORETHICALCONDUCTANDMANYACCOUNTANTS,WHETHERAICPAMEMBERSORNOT,AREOFTENHESITANTTOBLATANTLYDISREGARDSUCHAICPAPRONOUNCEMENTS2INTEGRITYANDOBJECTIVITYRULINGNO112UNDERRULE102INTEGRITYANDOBJECTIVITYADDRESSESTHEISSUEOFUSINGATHIRDPARTYPROVIDERTOASSISTANAICPAMEMBERINPROVIDINGPROFESSIONALSERVICESATISSUEISWHETHERANAICPAMEMBERINPUBLICPRACTICEWHOUSESTHESERVICESOFATHIRDPARTYPROVIDERTOASSISTINPROVIDINGPROFESSIONALSERVICESSUCHASBOOKKEEPING,TAXPREPARATION,CONSULTINGORATTESTSERVICESFORCLIENTSMUSTDISCLOSETHEUSEOFTHEPROVIDERTOCLIENTSRULING112HOLDSTHATSUCHDISCLOSUREISNECESSARYRULE102ETSECTION10201ANDARTICLEIIIETSECTION54REQUIRESMEMBERSTOBEHONESTANDCANDIDAICPAMEMBERSMUSTDISCLOSETHEFACTTHATTHEY“MAY”USETHESERVICESOFATHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERTOTHEIRCLIENTPRIORTOTURNINGOVERCONFIDENTIALCLIENTINFORMATIONTOTHEPROVIDERPRIORDISCLOSUREWILLPUTTHECLIENTONNOTICETHATCONFIDENTIALCLIENTINFORMATIONMAYBESHAREDWITHANOUTSIDEPARTYCLIENTSTHENHAVETHEOPTIONOFOBJECTINGTOTHEUSEOFATHIRDPARTYPROVIDERIFACLIENTOBJECTS,THEAICPAMEMBERHASTHEOPTIONOFEITHERPROVIDINGTHESERVICEWITHOUTTHEUSEOFATHIRDPARTYORDECLININGTHEENGAGEMENTTHEREQUIREMENTTOINFORMCLIENTSOFTHEPOSSIBLEUSEOFTHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERSDOESNOTEXTENDTOALLSERVICES,HOWEVERNOTIFICATIONNEEDNOTBEGIVENIFTHIRDPARTIESAREUSEDTOPROVIDEADMINISTRATIVESUPPORTSERVICESSUCHASRECORDSTORAGEORSOFTWAREAPPLICATIONHOSTINGSERVICESTHEUSEOFOFFSHORETHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERSHASBEENACAUSEFORCONCERNCREDITCARDSERVICESHAVEBEENOUTSOURCEDTOTHECARIBBEAN,INDIAANDOTHERLOWCOSTJURISDICTIONSINTHECASEOFINDIA,PROFESSIONALSERVICESSUCHASTAXPREPARATIONHAVEALSOBEENOUTSOURCEDPOTENTIALSECURITYPROBLEMSMAYRESULTWHENCONFIDENTIALCLIENTINFORMATIONISGIVENTOFIRMSOR3INDIVIDUALSINOTHERJURISDICTIONSWHENAMERICANLAWSDONOTAPPLYTHATHASBEENACAUSEFORCONCERNANDITWASTHOUGHTTHATITISABSOLUTELYESSENTIALTOINFORMCLIENTSWHENSUCHPROVIDERSMAYBEUSEDSOTHATCLIENTSCANBEFULLYINFORMEDABOUTTHESERVICETHEYAREPAYINGFORSOMECRITICISMSHAVEBEENMADEOFTHEAICPASETHICSRULINGALTHOUGHDISCLOSUREISREQUIRED,ITISAPPARENTLYNOTNECESSARYTOGOINTOSPECIFICSFOREXAMPLE,ACPAMAYBEETHICALLYREQUIREDTODISCLOSETOCLIENTSTHEFACTTHATTHEWORKMAYBEOUTSOURCEDBUTTHEREISAPPARENTLYNOREQUIREMENTTODISCLOSETHEFACTTHATITMAYBESENTOVERSEASANDTHATTHETAXRETURNORWHATEVERMAYBEPREPAREDBYANONUSCERTIFIEDPUBLICACCOUNTANTMINTZ2004SUCHINFORMATIONMAYHAVEVALUEFORCLIENTSITISONETHINGTOSENDTAXRETURNINFORMATIONACROSSTHESTREETORACROSSTOWNANDQUITEANOTHERTOSENDITTOANOTHERCONTINENTWHERETHECULTUREANDLAWSAREMUCHDIFFERENTISITREALLYHONESTTOALERTACLIENTTHATTAXINFORMATION“MAY”BESENTTOATHIRDPARTYPROVIDER,WHENINFACTITISTHEFIRMSPOLICYTOALWAYSORUSUALLYSENDCLIENTTAXINFORMATIONTONONCPASWORKINGININDIAISDISCLOSUREREALLYFULL,ORADEQUATE,IFSUCHFACTSAREOMITTEDPROPONENTSOFTHECURRENTPOLICYMIGHTBEQUICKTOPOINTOUTTHATTHEDOMESTICFIRMWOULDNOTRETAINTHESERVICESOFANINDIANFIRMTHATISNOTQUALIFIEDTODOTHEWORK,WHICHMAYORMAYNOTBETRUEALSO,ITCOULDBEPOINTEDOUTTHATTHEINDIANACCOUNTANTSAREUSINGTHESAMETAXSOFTWARETHATAMERICANFIRMSUSEANDTHATITDOESNOTMAKEMUCHDIFFERENTWHETHERTHEINDIANACCOUNTANTPREPARINGTHERETURNISSITTINGINANOFFICEININDIAORISARECENTIMMIGRANTSITTINGINANOFFICEINNEWYORKORKANSASTHEARGUMENTMAYBEMADETHATTHEREISNONEEDTOINFORMCLIENTSASLONGASTHECPAMAINTAINSCONTROLANDREVIEWSTHERETURNBEFOREITISSENTTOIRSHOWEVER,FROMANETHICALPERSPECTIVE,ITMAYBEAPPROPRIATETOGIVECLIENTSTHESEDETAILSEVENIFTHEAMERICANCPATHINKSTHATITDOESNOTMAKEMUCHDIFFERENCEINTERMSOFQUALITYTERMSBECAUSETHECLIENTMIGHTHAVEANOTHERVIEW4COMPLIANCEWITHSTANDARDSRULINGNO12UNDERRULE201GENERALSTANDARDSANDRULE202COMPLIANCEWITHSTANDARDSADDRESSESTHEISSUEOFWHATRESPONSIBILITYANAICPAMEMBERINPUBLICPRACTICEHASFORCOMPLYINGWITHGENERALANDTECHNICALSTANDARDSWHENUSINGATHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERTOPROVIDEPROFESSIONALSERVICESTHERULINGHOLDSTHATUSINGSUCHAPROVIDERDOESNOTRELIEVETHEAICPAMEMBEROFTHERESPONSIBILITYOFCOMPLYINGWITHTHEREQUIREMENTSOFRULES201AND202THUS,MEMBERSREMAINRESPONSIBLEFORPROVIDINGADEQUATEOVERSIGHTFORALLSERVICESPERFORMEDBYTHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERSANDFORENSURINGTHATALLSERVICESAREPERFORMEDWITHPROFESSIONALCOMPETENCEANDDUEPROFESSIONALCAREFURTHERMORE,MEMBERSMUSTADEQUATELYPLANANDSUPERVISESUCHSERVICESANDOBTAINSUFFICIENTRELEVANTDATATOSUPPORTTHEWORKPRODUCTANDCOMPLYWITHALLTECHNICALSTANDARDSAPPLICABLETOTHEPROFESSIONALSERVICESTHERULINGGOESONTOSTATETHATSUCHAREQUIREMENTDOESNOTEXTENDTHEAICPAMEMBERSRESPONSIBILITYFORPLANNINGANDSUPERVISINGTHETHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERSWORKBEYONDTHEREQUIREMENTSOFAPPLICABLEPROFESSIONALSTANDARDSONEQUESTIONTHATARISESREGARDINGTHISRULINGINVOLVESTHEPREPARATIONOFTAXRETURNSBYTHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERSINPLACESLIKEINDIA,WHEREAWHOLEINDUSTRYHASDEVELOPEDINRECENTYEARSALTHOUGHMANYINDIANSARETRAINEDINTHEPREPARATIONOFUSTAXRETURNS,ITISNOTALWAYSEASYFORANAICPAMEMBERRESIDENTINTHEUNITEDSTATESTODETERMINEINADVANCEWHICHINDIANTHIRDPARTYTAXRETURNPREPARERSARESUFFICIENTLYCOMPETENTONEWAYTOOVERCOMETHISPROBLEMWOULDBETOSETUPABRANCHININDIAANDTOSUPERVISEITHOWEVER,SUCHANAPPROACHAPPARENTLYISNOTREQUIREDUNDERTHISRULETHEREAREOTHERWAYSTOCHECKANDVERIFYTHECOMPETENCYOFSUCH5OFFSHORESERVICEPROVIDERS,SUCHASLOOKINGATTHEIREDUCATIONANDEXPERIENCE,CLIENTREFERENCES,ETCONEETHICALPROBLEMACCOUNTINGFIRMSFACEISEXERCISINGDUECAREINTHEPERFORMANCEOFSERVICESIFTHOSESERVICESAREOUTSOURCEDTOANOTHERCOUNTRYANOTHERETHICALPROBLEMISDETERMININGWHETHERADEQUATEPLANNINGANDSUPERVISIONCANBEHADWHENTHEWORKISDONEONANOTHERCONTINENTMINTZ2004ARGUESTHATITISDIFFICULTTOSEEHOWTHESEREQUIREMENTCANBEMETIFTHEWORKISOUTSOURCEDOVERSEASTHEARGUMENTCANBEMADETHATTHEREVIEWANDAPPROVALPROCESSMAKEITPOSSIBLETOSATISFYTHISETHICALREQUIREMENT,BUTITISDIFFICULTTOARGUETHATSTAFFCANBEADEQUATELYSUPERVISEDWHENTHEINDIVIDUALSPREPARINGTHETAXRETURNSARENOTSTAFFBUTARETHIRDPARTYPREPARERSLIVINGTHOUSANDSOFMILESAWAYTHEREISNOWAYTOEXERCISEONSITESUPERVISION,SOTHECPAFIRMMUSTRELYONTHEASSURANCESOFTHETHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERANOTHERETHICALPROBLEMOCCURSWHENTHEINFORMATIONPROVIDEDTOTHEEXTERNALSERVICEPROVIDERISINCOMPLETE,INCORRECTORINCONSISTENTITISDIFFICULTTOSEEHOWTHEAMERICANCPACANDEALWITHSUCHCASESUNLESSTHEINFORMATIONISEVALUATEDBEFOREITISTRANSMITTEDTOTHEEXTERNALSERVICEPROVIDERCONFIDENTIALCLIENTINFORMATIONETHICSRULINGNO1UNDERRULE301CONFIDENTIALCLIENTINFORMATIONADDRESSESTHEUSEOFATHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERTOPROVIDEPROFESSIONALSERVICESTOCLIENTSORADMINISTRATIVESERVICESTOTHEAICPAMEMBERATISSUEISWHETHERANAICPAMEMBERMUSTOBTAINACLIENTSPERMISSIONBEFOREDISCLOSINGCONFIDENTIALCLIENTINFORMATIONTOATHIRDPARTYTOASSISTINTHEPROVISIONOFPROFESSIONALSERVICESSUCHASBOOKKEEPING,TAXRETURNPREPARATION,CONSULTINGORATTESTSERVICES,INCLUDINGRELATEDCLERICALORDATAENTRYFUNCTIONS,ORADMINISTRATIVESUPPORT6SERVICESSUCHASRECORDSTORAGE,SOFTWAREAPPLICATIONHOSTINGSERVICESORAUTHORIZEDEFILETAXTRANSMITTALSERVICESRULINGNO1HOLDSTHATITISNOTNECESSARYTOOBTAINACLIENTSCONSENTPRIORTOTURNINGOVERSUCHINFORMATION,PROVIDEDTHEAICPAMEMBERFIRSTENTERSINTOACONTRACTUALAGREEMENTWITHTHEPROVIDERTOMAINTAINCONFIDENTIALITYOFTHEINFORMATIONTHEMEMBERMUSTALSOBEREASONABLYASSUREDTHATTHEPROVIDERHASAPPROPRIATEPROCEDURESINPLACETOPREVENTTHEUNAUTHORIZEDRELEASEOFCONFIDENTIALINFORMATIONTOOTHERSTHENATUREANDEXTENTOFTHEPROCEDURESNECESSARYTOOBTAINSUCHREASONABLEASSURANCEDEPENDONTHEFACTSANDCIRCUMSTANCESOFEACHCASEIFNOSUCHAGREEMENTISENTEREDINTO,SPECIFICCLIENTCONSENTSHOULDBEOBTAINEDBEFOREANYCLIENTINFORMATIONISDISCLOSEDTOTHETHIRDPARTYPROVIDERWHENEVERCONFIDENTIALFINANCIALINFORMATIONSUCHASSOCIALSECURITYNUMBERS,BANKACCOUNTANDBROKERAGEACCOUNTNUMBERSANDINFORMATIONARETRANSMITTEDELECTRONICALLYTHEREISACHANCETHATTHEINFORMATIONCOULDFALLINTOTHEWRONGHANDSIDENTITYTHEFTISONEPOSSIBLEOUTCOMETHEFTANDFRAUDAREOTHERSTHEFACTTHATTHECPAHASTHEINFORMATIONENCRYPTEDANDTHATTHEFIRMCONTROLSTHESOURCEDOCUMENTSMAYREDUCETHEPOSSIBILITYOFSUCHTHINGSFROMHAPPENINGBUTTHEYDONOTREDUCETHEPROBABILITYTOZEROBECAUSETHEPERSONONTHERECEIVINGENDCANSTILLUSETHEINFORMATIONFORFRAUDULENTPURPOSESCLIENTSHAVEARIGHTTOKNOWWHETHERTHEIRSENSITIVEFINANCIALINFORMATIONISBEINGTRANSMITTEDTOANOUTSIDERREGARDLESSOFWHETHERTHEMODEOFTRANSMISSIONORTHERECIPIENTCANGENERALLYBETRUSTEDTHEISSUEBECOMESMOREIMPORTANTWHENTHERECIPIENTRESIDESINAJURISDICTIONOTHERTHANTHEUNITEDSTATES,SINCEUSLAWDOESNOTAPPLYINFOREIGNJURISDICTIONS7CONCLUDINGCOMMENTSMINTZ2004RAISESSOMEETHICALQUESTIONSABOUTTHESERULINGSHUNDREDSOFTHOUSANDSOFTAXRETURNSAREPREPAREDBYFOREIGNTHIRDPARTYSERVICEPROVIDERS,ACCORDINGTOSOMEESTIMATESTHEATTRACTIVENESSOFUSINGSUCHPROVIDERSISOBVIOUSTHEWORKCANBEDONEFORUPTO50PERCENTLESSANDUSINGOUTSIDERSMAKESITPOSSIBLETOGETTHEWORKDONEWITHOUTADDINGPEOPLETOEXISTINGSTAFFINFORMATIONCANBETRANSFERREDELECTRONICALLYTOPROVIDERSININDIAORELSEWHEREWHOAREEDUCATEDANDTRAINEDINUSTAXLAWETHICALPROBLEMSAREREDUCEDIFTHEUSFIRMINTERVIEWSTHECLIENTSANDPREPARESTHEINFORMATIONFORTRANSMISSIONTOTHEFOREIGNSERVICEPROVIDERIFTHEPREPARERSARECHARTEREDACCOUNTANTS,WHICHARETHEEQUIVALENTTOCPAS,THERISKOFGIVINGDATATOINCOMPETENTINDIVIDUALSISSUPPOSEDLYMINIMIZED,ALTHOUGHITISAFALSEASSUMPTIONTHATCERTIFIEDACCOUNTANTSAREBETTERABLETOPREPARETAXRETURNSTHANARENONCERTIFIEDACCOUNTANTS,ACCORDINGTOSEVERALMONEYMAGAZINESTUDIES,WHICHFOUNDTHATAMERICANCPASALMOSTALWAYSMAKEATLEASTONEMISTAKEONTAXRETURNSANDOFTENMAKESERIOUSMISTAKES,PRESUMABLYBECAUSEOFTHECOMPLEXITYOFTHETAXLAWSMCGEE19992004ITMAYBEANUPHILLARGUMENTTOCONVINCECLIENTSTHATINDIANCERTIFIEDACCOUNTANTS,WHICHDONOTHAVEACCESSTOTHESAMETAXEDUCATIONASUSACCOUNTANTS,AREEQUALLYQUALIFIEDTOPREPARETAXRETURNSHOWEVER,ITISENTIRELYPOSSIBLETHATTHEYAREEQUALLYQUALIFIED,ATLEASTTOPREPARESTANDARDRETURNS,SINCETHEYUSETHESAMETAXSOFTWARETHATAMERICANCPASUSEITMIGHTALSOBEPOINTEDOUTTHATTHEUSFIRMTHATEMPLOYSFOREIGNSERVICEPROVIDERSISSUPPOSEDTOREVIEWALLTHEIRWORKBEFOREFINALIZINGTHERETURNANDSUBMITTINGITTOIRSWHETHERSUCHREVIEWISDONEINANADEQUATEMATTERISANOTHERQUESTION,BUTATLEASTTHATISTHEETHICALREQUIREMENT8OUTSOURCINGHASOTHERBENEFITSINADDITIONTOCOSTSAVINGSTURNAROUNDTIMECANBE48HOURSORLESS,ANDREDUCINGAFIRMSTAXWORKLOADCANFREEUPSTAFFTOPERFORMOTHERSERVICESMINTZ2004THELEGALRAMIFICATIONSOFOUTSOURCINGAREUNCLEARWHOGETSSUEDINTHEEVENTOFNEGLIGENCEWHICHCOURTSYSTEMDETERMINES