经济学人-信息不对称之柠檬市场理论与效应(上)(DOC)_第1页
经济学人-信息不对称之柠檬市场理论与效应(上)(DOC)_第2页
经济学人-信息不对称之柠檬市场理论与效应(上)(DOC)_第3页
经济学人-信息不对称之柠檬市场理论与效应(上)(DOC)_第4页
经济学人-信息不对称之柠檬市场理论与效应(上)(DOC)_第5页
已阅读5页,还剩2页未读, 继续免费阅读

下载本文档

版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领

文档简介

经济学人:信息不对称之柠檬市场理论与效应(上)Economics

brief:

six

big

ideas.经济概要:六大经济思想。Information

asymmetry:

Secrets

and

agents信息不对称:秘密和代理George

Akerlof's

1970

paper,“The

Market

forLemons”,

is

a

foundation

stone

of

informationeconomics,

the

first

in

our

series

on

seminaleconomic

ideas.六大经济思想之一,乔治·阿克洛夫1970年的论文——《柠檬市场》,它是信息经济学的一块基石。In

2007

the

state

of

Washington

introduced

a

new

rule

aimed

at

making

the

labour

marketfairer:

firms

were

banned

from

checking

job

applicants'

credit

scores.2007年,华盛顿州引入了一项旨在让劳动力市场更公平的新法律:企业被禁止核查求职者的信用得分。Campaigners

celebrated

the

new

law

as

a

step

towards

equality—an

applicant

with

a

lowcredit

score

is

much

more

likely

to

be

poor,

black

or

young.发起这项运动的人欢呼庆祝,认为这是通向平等的一步——信用得分低的求职者极有可能是穷人、黑人或者年轻人。Since

then,

ten

other

states

have

followed

suit.自那以后,又有十个州如法炮制。But

when

Robert

Clifford

and

Daniel

Shoag,

two

economists,

recently

studied

the

bans,

theyfound

that

the

laws

left

blacks

and

the

young

with

fewer

jobs,

not

more.但是,日前,当两位经济学家——罗伯特·克利福德和丹尼尔·绍格——研究了这些禁令时,他们发现,这些法律带给黑人和年轻人的工作更少了,而不是更多。Before

1970,

economists

would

not

have

found

much

in

their

discipline

to

help

them

mull

thispuzzle.放在1970年之前,经济学家是不会在这门学科中找到太多的东西来帮助他们仔细思考这个迷的。Indeed,

they

did

not

think

very

hard

about

the

role

of

information

at

all.实际上,他们当时根本就没有很努力地去思考信息的作用。In

the

labour

market,

for

example,

the

textbooks

mostly

assumed

that

employers

know

theproductivity

of

their

workers—or

potential

workers—and,

thanks

to

competition,

pay

themfor

exactly

the

value

of

what

they

produce.例如,那时的教科书大都假设,在劳动力市场中,雇主知道他们的工人——或者潜在的工人——的生产率,而且,由于竞争,是按照工人所生产的东西的价值给他们开工资的。You

might

think

that

research

upending

that

conclusion

would

immediately

be

celebrated

asan

important

breakthrough.人们可能认为,颠覆这一论断的研究立即会被誉为一项重大突破。Yet

when,

in

the

late

1960s,

George

Akerlof

wrote

“The

Market

for

Lemons”,

which

did

just

that,and

later

won

its

author

a

Nobel

prize,

the

paper

was

rejected

by

three

leading

journals.然而,当乔治·阿克洛夫于上世纪60年代末期写出恰恰实现了这种突破并为作者赢得了诺贝尔奖的《柠檬市场》时,这篇论文曾遭到三家主要期刊拒绝。At

the

time,

Mr

Akerlof

was

an

assistant

professor

at

the

University

of

California,

Berkeley;

hehad

only

completed

his

PhD,

at

MIT,

in

1966.那时,阿克洛夫是加州大学伯克利分校的一名助教;仅于1966年在麻省理工完成了博士学位。Perhaps

as

a

result,

the

American

Economic

Review

thought

his

paper's

insights

trivial.也许是因为这个原因,《美国经济评论》认为他的论文的观点微不足道。The

Review

of

Economic

Studies

agreed.《经济研究评论》同意了这个看法。The

Journal

of

Political

Economy

had

almost

the

opposite

concern:

it

could

not

stomach

thepaper's

implications.《政治经济学杂志》有着几乎完全相反的担忧:它可能消化不了这篇论文深远意义。Mr

Akerlof,

now

an

emeritus

professor

at

Berkeley

and

married

to

Janet

Yellen,

the

chairman

ofthe

Federal

Reserve,

recalls

the

editor's

complaint:“If

this

is

correct,

economics

would

bedifferent.”如今已是伯克利分校名誉教授并同美联储主席珍妮特·耶伦成婚的阿克洛夫还记着那位编辑的不满:“如果这是正确的,经济学会截然不同。”In

a

way,

the

editors

were

all

right.从某种程度上来说,这些编辑当时都是对的。Mr

Akerlof's

idea,

eventually

published

in

the

Quarterly

Journal

of

Economics

in

1970,

was

atonce

simple

and

revolutionary.最终于1970年在《经济学季刊》上发表了的阿克洛夫的思想即是简单的,也是革命性的。Suppose

buyers

in

the

used-car

market

value

good

cars—“peaches”—at

$1,000,

and

sellers

atslightly

less.假设,二手车市场中的买方给好车——“桃子”——估价1000美元,卖方要稍微少一点。斯彭斯指出,顶层的工人或许会以收集荣誉——如大学学位——的行为为信号,向企业展示自己的才华。Crucially,

this

only

works

if

the

signal

is

credible:

if

low-productivity

workers

found

it

easy

toget

a

degree,

then

they

could

masquerade

as

clever

types.关键是,这只有在信号是可信的时候才管用:如果低生产力的工人发现得到学位很容易,他们就可能把自己装扮成聪明之人。This

idea

turns

conventional

wisdom

on

its

head.这一思想彻底颠覆了传统的智慧。Education

is

usually

thought

to

benefit

society

by

making

workers

more

productive.一般认为,教育之有益于社会,是因为它让工人变得更高效。If

it

is

merely

a

signal

of

talent,

the

returns

to

investment

in

education

flow

to

the

students,who

earn

a

higher

wage

at

the

expense

of

the

less

able,

and

perhaps

to

universities,

but

not

tosociety

at

large.如果它仅仅是才华的一个象征,教育投资的所得就会流向学生,使他们以才华较少之人为代价获得更高的工资;或者也可能是各个大学,但不是整个社会。One

disciple

of

the

idea,

Bryan

Caplan

of

George

Mason

University,

is

currently

penning

a

bookentitled

“The

Case

Against

Education”.这个思想的一位信徒——乔治梅森大学的布莱恩·卡普兰目前正在撰写一本名为《反对教育之种种》的书。(Mr

Spence

himself

regrets

that

others

took

his

theory

as

a

literal

description

of

the

world.)(斯彭斯本人后悔的是,被人把他的理论当成是对这个世界的一种文字描述。)Signalling

helps

explain

what

happened

when

Washington

and

those

other

states

stopped

firmsfrom

obtaining

job-applicants'

credit

scores.信号行为有助于解释华盛顿等州在阻止企业获得求职者信用得分时所发生了的事情。Credit

history

is

a

credible

signal:

it

is

hard

to

fake,

and,

presumably,

those

with

good

creditscores

are

more

likely

to

make

good

employees

than

those

who

default

on

their

debts.信用历史是一个可信的信号:它难以造假,而且,可以假定,信用得分良好的人比债务违约的人更有可能成为好雇员。Messrs

Clifford

and

Shoag

found

that

when

firms

could

no

longer

access

credit

scores,

theyput

more

weight

on

other

signals,

like

education

and

experience.克利福德先生和绍格先生发现,当企业不再能得到信用得分时,会把重点放在其他信号上面,如教育和资历。Because

these

are

rarer

among

disadvantaged

groups,

it

became

harder,

not

easier,

for

themto

convince

employers

of

their

worth.因为这些信号在弱势劣群体中较为少见,因而,对他们而言,让雇主相信自己的价值就变得更难,而不是更容易。1.nolonger不再例句:Afteraboutthreemonths,Iwas

nolongeraddictedtonicotine.

温馨提示

  • 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
  • 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
  • 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
  • 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
  • 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
  • 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
  • 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。

评论

0/150

提交评论