版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
"Theplaintiffqualificationofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation"Environmentalproblemshavebecomewidespreadconcernintwenty-firstCenturynationalproblem.Peopleinmanyconveniencestoenjoyeconomicdevelopmentprogressofscienceandtechnology,domore,alsobegantoreflectonandevenquestionedthe"grace"topaytheprice.Withtheincreasinglysevereenvironmentalpollution,manyindividualcitizens,socialorganizationshaveaccesstojusticeinordertosolvetheglobalproblem,environmentalpublicinterestlitigationandemergeasthetimesrequire.Asanewtypeoflawsuit,itbreaksthroughthelimitationoftraditionallawsuitplaintiffqualifications,playsavitalroleinProtectenvironment,safeguardingthepublicinterest,hasbeenadoptedbymanycountriesintheworld.Thebasicprincipleandthesystembasedontheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation,someproblemsontheplaintiffqualificationof.Environmentalpublicinterestlitigationreferstotheillegaladministrativeauthoritiesorotherpublicauthorities,companies,enterprisesorotherorganizationsandindividualsoromission,theenvironmentalpublicinteresttosufferinfringeuponoratrisk,thelawpermitsacitizenorgrouptoprotecttheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationtothecourtsystem.SomeAmerica,Britain,thecountrieshaveconfirmedtheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsysteminlegislation.CharacteristicsoftheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationFirstofall,fromthelawsuitpurpose,environmentalpublicinterestlitigationfortheplaintifftoallownoninterestedcourtsandcases,safeguardtheinterestsoftheplaintiffthefootholdisnot,butinpromotingpublicwelfare,environmentalprotectionandpublicinterests,advocatedtoenvironmentalpublicinterestsratherthantheinterestsofprivateenvironment.Secondly,fromthesubjectoflitigation,environmentalpublicinterestlitigationhasbrokenthelimitationbetweentheplaintiffandthecasemusthaveinterest,startingfromtheprotectionofenvironmentalpublicinterestpointofview,toanypersonororganizationinthepublicenvironmentfacingtheriskofharmordamagetothecourttostoporrestrainthedamagetotheright.Environmentalpublicinterestlitigationexpandsthedefinitionoftraditionallitigationsystemoftheplaintiff.Onceagain,fromthefunctionoflitigation,environmentalpublicinterestlitigationhasobviouspreventionfunction,boththerecoveryfunction.Thattheplaintiffcanbesuedinthepossibilityofenvironmentalpublicinterestthereisdamage,requestthecourttoorderthedefendanttostoprelatedbehavior,withouttheenvironmentaldamagehasoccurredasprerequisiteoflawsuit.Finally,lookattheeffectfromthelawsuit,environmentalpublicinterestlitigationinvolvingtheinterestsoftherelationshipwiththepublicandcollective,spreadwidely,thecourtinthislitigationthroughthewritofprohibitionordeclaratoryjudgmenttendtoinfluenceandchangethepublicpolicyenvironment.Thisdecisionnotonlyforthecaseofthepeopleinvolvedinthecasehavebindingforce,butalsoinfluenceandguidetothegeneralpublicisnotinvolvedinthecase.TheconceptofenvironmentalpubliclitigationTheplaintiffqualificationoftheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationreferstotheenvironmentaldamageordamage.Whentheenvironmentalpublicinterestlegal,canstartthejudicialremedyprocedurequalification.Differentplaintiffqualificationandplaintiffstatus,qualificationoftheplaintifffromspecificinfringementhasalreadymade,theplaintiffstatusisthelegalstatusofplaintiffqualificationinpeoplewithpropercourtlaterduringthecourseoflitigationhave.TodeterminethestandardofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationplaintiffqualificationPublicinterestlitigationplaintiffshouldmainlyconsistsofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationpurposeoraimoftheestablishmentofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationtodecide,atthesametimereferenceinterestofotherfactors.Inessence,theproposedsourceofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationintheenvironment,itisthecharacteristicsoftheenvironmentdeterminesthatanyofaresourceoraregionalenvironmentaldamage,willsuffertheentiretyofenvironmentdestruction,anypollutionbehavior,willbeenvironmentalpublicinterestspotentialdamagedirectlyorindirectly.Therefore,todeterminetheplaintiffofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsubjectqualificationoftheenvironmentalpublicinterestmustbeachievedinordertoensuremaximumasthestandard.Relaxationofenvironmentalpubliclitigationlimit,sothatallinterestedinenvironmentalprotectionunitsandindividualshavethequalificationintheformoflitigationinordertoprotecttheenvironmentalpublicinterest.Inordertoachieveenvironmentalpublicinterestmaximumasthestandardtodeterminetheplaintiffinenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsubjectqualification,whichrequiresinthejudicialpractice,mustbefreefromrestrictionsontheplaintiffqualificationoftheexistingprocedure,toasmanypeopleaspossibletoattractpublicenvironmentprotection,toachieveenvironmentalpublicwelfaremaximuminorderto.TheplaintiffinenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsubjectrangeAcitizen,legalperson,otherorganization.Inresponsetotheenvironmentalpollutionandthedestructionofnaturalresourcesoftheaction,havethecapacityforcivilrightsandcapacityforcivilconductcitizens,aslongasheandpollutingtheenvironment,naturalresourcesthedestroyerhascertaininterests,whetherthisrelationisactuallyalreadyexistormayoccurinthefuture,aslongasyoucanprovethisinterest,allhavetherighttobringalawsuit.Giveseverycitizenthepreventionandcontrolofenvironmentalpollutionandthedestructionofnaturalresourcesrights,canbetterpreventhazards,protecttheecologicalenvironmentwelivetogether.Thetwoisapublicbenefitorganizationofenvironmentalprotection.China's"socialorganizationregistersbambooregulations"secondarticle:asmentionedinthisRegulationreferstothesocialgroup,composedofvoluntaryChinesecitizens,inordertoachieveacommonintentionofmember,accordingtothenonprofitsocialorganizationinitsarticlesofassociationactivities.Therefore,theenvironmentalprotectioncommonwealorganizationgeneralsensecanbedefinedastheestablishment,bynongovernmentalorganizations,individualsinaccordancewithlaw.Andtohavetheirownindependentregulation,organization,decision-makingproceduresandindependentsourcesoffundingfornon-profitorganizations,publicwelfareactivitiesmainlyengagedinenvironmentalprotectionassociation.Individualcitizensinenvironmentalprotectionaction,ofteninaweakposition,inthiscase,thevigorousdevelopmentofcivilsocietygroups,environmentalorganizations,andthegovernmentandthemarkettobecomethesecondforce,andbecauseofitspublicwelfare,professional,volunteer,democraticparticipation,multiplebenefitrepresentative,canmoreeffectivelytosolvecomplexenvironmentalproblems.Litigiousrightisthusgivenenvironmentalprotectioncommonwealorganizationenvironmentalpublicinterest,haveapositiveandpracticalsignificance.Thethreeistheprocuratorialorgans.Alwaystheprocuratorialorgansareconsideredtoberepresentativeofthegovernment,isthepublicinterestsmaintenance.Somelocalofficialsinpursuitoftheso-calledachievements,tothelandofchaoschaos,destructionandwasteenvironment.Environmentaladministrativeactionofthegovernmenttomaketheadministrativerelativepersonisveryextensive,althoughtheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsystemtosolvetheindividualcitizensnotbecauseofdirectinterest,maybringalawsuitforpublicinterests,buttheindividualbehavioroflitigationcostistoohigh.Therefore,anumberofpublicbenefitandnobody'sembarrassment.Sotherecoveryofpublicprosecutionsystem,prosecutionbytherepresentativecountrieshastherightofpublicprosecutionasaprosecutor,canberealizedinpublictobalancepublicpurpose.Inthejudicialpractice,alsohasbeenpresentedbytheprocuratoratethecaseonbehalfofthestateownedassetsfiledpublicinterestlitigationcases.OtherissuesofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationplaintiffqualificationTheanimalandnaturalobjectsastheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationproblemsWhetherthegivenanimalandnaturewiththeplaintiff'squalification,Chinesescholarsthink:theanimalandnaturalobjects,theycanbecalledasthemainenvironmentalright,tooearlybuttobecometheplaintiffoftheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation.ButIthink,fromtheperspectiveoflegalrights,notonlyhastherightsofhumanbeings,inanimateobjectsasthelegalrelationshipbetweenpartiesisnotuncommon,suchasship,company,partnership,theirrightsandobligationsandnotbecausehewouldnotspeak,donotexpressandreduced,widespreadcorporateisfurtherevidencethatdoesnotshortcomingsofitsownexpressionabilitywillbecomeanobstacletotheexerciseoftherights,obligations.Inthespecificoperationcanadoptaflexibleway,asspecifiedinthecourtlitigationguardian,execution,protection,defenselawyersasaparty.FuturegenerationsastheplaintiffofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationproblemsScholarshavebeenraised,futuregenerationsshouldbethesubjectsofenvironmentalrights,thereforehavetherighttofileenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation,justiceistheeternalpursuitoflaw,legalproblemsinenvironmentshouldalsoimplementthegist;legaljusticeis"human"and"people"betweentheresourcesandopportunitiesofequilibriumhowever,fortheenvironment,resourcesystem,thisobjectbecauseofthesharedandnonselectivespecialpropertiessuchasfairness,itshouldnotbeconfinedtotherealityoftheexistenceofthepeople,shouldalsotakeintoconsiderationtheinterestsoffuturegenerations,sofuturegenerationscanenjoytheenvironmentalrightsandinterests.TentheabuseoftherighttoconsiderSomeresearchersworryabouttherelaxationofenvironmentalpubliclitigationlimit,reducelitigationthreshold,willlikelyleadto"litigationexplosion","lawsuittide".China's"harmony"ideaingrained,"detestinglawsuit"socialpsychologyexistforalongtime,hobbies,onthecourtisnotthecourtofcommonpeople;andactionisneededtocalculatethecostofeconomicactivities,inadditiontothecaseitselfinvolvedinlitigationcosts,legalfees,appraisalfeeswillalsoisnotasmallexpenditure.Therationaldecisionhewillweightheadvantagesanddisadvantagesfor,willnotbeduetoseekstimulationorimpulsivechoiceaction.Therefore,inourcountry,litigationconditionsrelaxeddoesnotnecessarilycause"litigationtide".Butasasystemdesignshouldmakecorrespondingresponse.Inthisregard,referenceUSA"citizensuit"relatingto"preventtheabuseoflitigation"provisions,formulatecorrespondingmeasurestopreventpossible"lawsuittide".Inshort,inthetreatmentofenvironmentalpubliclitigationissues,weshouldnotsticktothe"directinterestrelationtheory",butalsonotfreetoexpandtheplaintiffofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsubjectqualification,dohaveadefiniteobjectinview.Atthesametime,tohaveobtainedthequalificationofplaintiff'spartyisnecessarytopreventtheabuseoflitigiousrightlimit,orfailstoexercisetherighttoappealbehaviors.EnvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsubjecttheoryOntheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsubjecttheory,canbesummarizedasthefollowingthree:Thefirsttheoryiswidelysubject.Thedoctrinethat,anyunitandindividualcanfileenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation.Itisbasedonthe"environmentalprotectionlaw"sixtharticle:allunitsandindividualsshallhavetheobligationtoProtectenvironment,andhavetherighttoreportandaccusetotheunitsandindividualsforpollutionanddamagetotheenvironment.Wethink,therightofaccusationcannotright,buttherightofcomplaintshouldbearightofappeal.Inordertorealizetherightofappeal,canwithone'ssuit,thecourtaskedtheSupremePeople'sCourtjudicialinterpretation,thenatureoftherighttoappealtotheaccused.Ifthenatureoftherighttoappealagainsttheclear,thenanyunitandindividualcanbebasedontheprovisionsoftheenvironmentalpollutionanddamagesue.Secondkindsoftheoriesarerelatedgroups,says.Accordingtothistheory,andenvironmentalprotectionrelatedsocialgroups,non-governmentalorganizations,departmentsandunitsinhisownnametobringenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation."Friendsofnature"specializinginenvironmentalprotectionwork,canbeusedasaclubtobringenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation;EnvironmentalProtectionBureauasagovernmentagencytofileenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation.But,hasnothingtodowiththeenvironmentalprotectionunits,organizationscannotmentionenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation.Thedoctrineexclusionofindividualscanbringenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation,onereasonisifgiveapersonalfileenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsubjectqualificationwillleadtoabuseoflitigation,andincreasetheworkintensityofjudges.Thethirdtheorycalledthepublicagencysaid.Thedoctrinethatonlyexerciserelatedpublicpowerorganmayfileenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation,forexample,marinemanagementdepartmentmaybringacivilpublicwelfarelawsuitofpollutiondamagetothemarineenvironment;theagriculturalsectormaybefiledpublicinterestlitigationonfisherypollution;procuratorialorganscanbeofanyactsofdestructionoftheenvironmentpublicinterestlitigation.ThepracticeofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationInpractice,inthehomeisconsideredtheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationcasescanbedividedintothefollowingfivecategories:Thefirstcategoryistheenvironmentpublicwelfarelawsuitbroughtbynon-governmentalorganizations.Forexample,inJuly29,2009,thefinancialnetworkreportedwasplacedonfileinthecourtofQingzhenCityofGuizhouprovincethefirstnationalenvironmentaladministrativepublicinterestlitigation,theChinaEnvironmentFederationtotheidentityoftheplaintiffsuedGuizhouQingzhencitylandresourcesbureau.Thecasewasconsideredtobetheenvironmentpublicwelfarelawsuitfiledacivilorganization.Thesecondcategoryistheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationinthenameoftheadministrativeorganto.InApril12,2008,"LegalDaily"to"GuizhouProvince,environmentalpublicinterestlitigationjudgment'sfirstofficerwerethepeoplewin"reportedthatin2007thenewlyestablishedGuiyangCity,HunanandHubeiprovincesaLibraryManagementBureauastheplaintiffoftheenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation,bringthepollutiondamagetotheenvironmentcourtlawsuittoQingzhenCityenvironmentalprotectionrequirementsofcourt,PingbaCountyofGuizhouinachemicallimitedstoppollutiondamage.In2008April,QingzhenCityPeople'sCourtofenvironmentalprotectionincourt,thedefendantinachemicalindustrycompanyinGuizhouintheeffectivedateofthejudgementtoimmediatelystopusingtailingswasteplantforenvironmentaldamage,whichiscomposedofadministrativepublicinterestlitigationcase.Thethirdcategoryistheenvironmentpublicwelfarelawsuitfiledbyprocuratorialorgans.Forexample,inFebruary6,2009,xinhua"Changshafirstwiththeprocuratorialorganasplaintiffpublicinterestlitigationcase"reportedthemanagementbytheWangchengCountyofHunanProvince,thepeople'sProcuratoratethecase,49villagerswereobtainedinacementplantdust,vibration,noisepollutioncompensation,atotalof62538yuanperyear.Inparticularthecaseis,theprocuratorialorgansisnotforthesociety,alsonotforthecountry,onlytothevictimsoftheinterestsofthevillagers,ascivilplaintiffsfiledpublicinterestlitigation.Thefourthcategoryisfiledbythecitizen'senvironmentallitigation.Thiskindofactionisgenerallybasedonpersonalinterestsasthestartingpointtoachievethepurposeofpublicwelfare,forexample,aHanyangcontractorMaChangsongfarms,theMunicipalWaterAffairsBureauandtheenvironmentalprotectionagencyfailstostoppollutionlegalduty,ontwoadministrativeorgansinadministrativeproceedings,requestthecourttojudgethedefendantperformtheirstatutoryduties,totakeimmediateandeffectivemeasures,tostopthedischargeoftoxicandharmfulsewagefactoriesandenterprises,aswellastothesewagetreatmentunithasresponsibilitytostoppollutionbehavior;thedefendantpaybecauseitisnotasaresultoflakepollution,totheplaintiffcausingeconomiclossesof20000yuan.Theplaintiffinadministrativelitigation,thelocalgovernmentcommitmenttocontrolthewaterpollution,bythegovernmenttocompensatetheplaintiff2000000yuanafterthewithdrawal.Althoughthedirectresultofthecaseistheplaintiffreceivedcompensation,butthewelfareeffectrequiresthegovernmenttostopthewholelakepollution.Thefifthcategoryisthefolkpublicwelfareorganizationstohelpbringlawsuits.Forexample,attheChinaUniversityofPoliticalScienceandLawCLAPV'shelp,BeijingCity,Panjiayuan182residentssuedtheBeijingCityPlanningCommission,urgestheBeijingCityPlanningCommissionrevokedtheresidentsinthedenseareaconstructionanimalexperimentalbuildingpermits.Thedirectbeneficiariesofthecaseinthearound182households,buttheobjectiveisfortheentirethecityofBeijingoritsvicinityallresidentsarenotaffectedbypollution,contributetoprotecttheregion'sair.Thelegalaidactisapublicwelfarebehavior.AnalysisofthesubjectofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationlawByanalyzingthefivekindsofcase,canthefollowinganalysisandconclusionontheissueofenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationsubjectqualificationtomake:First,thelawshouldnotstoppeoplecontributetothepublicwelfare.Thelawshouldencourageanyhumansocialwelfarecontributions.Accordingtothisidea,anyunitandindividualcanserveastheplaintiffinpublicinterestlitigation.Inotherwords,ifabehaviorisforthegooddevelopmentofsociety,asthesocialandpublicinterests,so,thelegalsystemshouldencouragethisbehavior.Therefore,anyunitshouldhavethesubjectofpublicinterestlitigation.Second,thedifferentlegalstatus,thelitigationsubjectqualificationshouldbedistinguished,differentsubjectsmaybefiledpublicinterestlitigationdifferent.Duetodifferencesinindividualability,knowledge,andnotallthepeoplefiledpublicinterestlitigationcanplayaimportantroleinmaintainingpublicinterests.Inordertoavoidthewasteofsocialresources,shouldbeonthelitigationsubjectqualificationdiffer.Ithink,candothefollowingtodistinguishlitigationsubjectqualification:oneistheindividualcitizensshouldcombinetheirskillsandconcerns,filedenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationandadministrativepublicinterestlitigationinacertainrange.Forexample,asanenvironmentallawprofessors,canbeusedasthesubjectoflitigationfiledenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation,butthepublicinterestlitigationcannotbringtherealestatefieldortheconsumptionfield.Twoisanon-governmentalenvironmentalprotectionorganizations,socialorganizationscanmattersthearticlesoforganizationandworkwithinthescopeofthefiledenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationandadministrativepublicinterestlitigation,forexample,"Friendsofnature"asthefolkenvironmentalprotectionorganization,youcanmentionenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation;however,mountainclimbingassociationorsportsAssociationwillnotmentionenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation.Third,theadministrativeorganshouldbeintheendofadministrativemeansisstillnotenoughtoprotectthepublicenvironmentalinterestsfiledenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigation.Iftheadministrativeorganfiledenvironmentalpublicinterestlitigationisthefullexerciseoflawsandregulationstotheadministrativepower,exhaustedlegalmeanssuchaspunishment,orderedtoceaseall.BeforeIdidnotapproveoftheadministrativeorganintheabsenceoftheexerciseofitsshouldfulfillthepunishment,orderedtoceasesuchstatutoryduties,thattheclaimsfiledapublicinterestlitigation.Forthereisnodirectvictimsofenvironmentalpollution,theadministrativeorganmayfileforpublicinterestlitigation.Forexample,inriversandlakeswaterpollutioncausesdeathsoffish,don'thaveanyrelationshipwiththeindividual,theagriculturalsectorshouldbefiledpublicinterestlitigation,claimsforcompensationonbehalfofthestate;shipoilspillpollutionofriversandoceans,marinebureaushouldbefiledpublicinterestlitigationclaims.论环境公益诉讼的原告主体资格问题环境问题已经成为21世纪各国普遍关注的问题。人们在享受科技进步、经济发展做带来的诸多便利时,也开始反思甚至质疑这些“恩惠”所付出的代价。随着环境污染的日益严重,不少公民个人、社会组织等纷纷诉诸司法途径以求解决这些全球性的问题,环境公益诉讼于是应运而生。作为一种新型的诉讼,它突破了传统诉讼中对原告资格的诸多限制,在保护环境、维护公共利益方面发挥着至关重要的作用,目前已经被世界上许多国家所采用。本文结合环境公益诉讼的基本原理和制度,对原告主体资格的一些问题进行阐述。环境公益诉讼是指由于行政机关或其他公共权力机构、公司、企业或其他组织及个人的违法行为或不作为,使环境公共利益遭受侵害或有侵害危险之时,法律允许公民或团体为维护环境公共利益而向法院提起诉讼的制度。美国、英国、口本等一些国家已经在立法上确认了环境公益诉讼制度。环境公益诉讼的特征首先,从诉讼目的看,环境公益诉讼允许与案件无利害关系人为原告向法院提起诉讼,其立足点不在于维护原告的权益,而在于促进公益,维护环境公共利益,主张指向环境公共利益而非私人的环境利益。其次,从诉讼主体看,环境公益诉讼打破了原告与案件之间必须具有利害关系的限定,从维护环境公益的角度出发,赋予任何人或组织于环境公益面临损害或损害之虞时向法院提起诉讼制止或抑制损害的权利。环境公益诉讼拓展了传统诉讼体制下原告的界定。再次,从诉讼功能看,环境公益诉讼具有明显的预防功能,兼具补救功能。即原告可以在环境公益存在损害的可能性时就提起诉讼,请求法院判决被告停止相关行为,而不必以环境损害业已发生作为诉讼提起的先决条件。最后,从诉讼判决效力看,环境公益诉讼涉及的利益关系具有公共性和集合性,波及范围广泛,法院在这种诉讼中通过的禁止令状或宣告性判决往往影响和改变环境公共政策。这种判决不仅对本案的涉案人产生拘束力,而且对未涉案的一般公众也产生影响力和引导力。环境公益诉讼原告资格的概念环境公益诉讼的原告资格是指在环境公益遭受损害或有遭受损害之虞时,可以合法启动环境公益司法救济程序的资格。原告资格与原告地位不同,原告资格从受到具体侵害时起就已经取得,原告地位则是具有原告资格的人诉至法院后在诉讼的过程中所拥有的法律地位。环境公益诉讼原告主体资格的确定标准益诉讼的原告应该主要地由环境公益诉讼的宗旨或者建立环境公益诉讼的根本目的来决定,同时参考其他的利益因素。从本质上说,环境公益诉讼问题的提出源于环境的整体性,正是环境的这一特性决定了任何对某一资源或某一区域环境的损坏,都将可能遭致对环境整体性的破坏,任何一个污染行为,都将直接或者间接的损害公众潜在的环境利益。因此,环境公益诉讼原告主体资格的确定必须以最大限度的保证环境公益的实现为标准。放宽对环境公益诉讼原告资格的限制,以便所有有志于环境公益保护的单位和个人均有资格以诉讼的形式实现对环境公益的保护。以最大限度的实现环境公益为标准来确定环境公益诉讼原告的主体资格,这就要求在司法实践中,必须摆脱现有诉讼法中对原告资格的诸多限制,将尽可能多的人吸引到环境公益保护中来,以期能够最大限度的实现环境公益。环境公益诉讼原告的主体范围一是公民、法人、其他组织。在针对环境污染和自然资源破坏的诉讼中,有民事权利能力和民事行为能力的公民,只要他与环境污染者、自然资源破坏者的行为有一定利益关系,不管这种利害关系是实际已经存在还是可能发生在将来,只要能证明有这种利益关系,都有权提起诉讼。赋予每个公民防治环境污染和自然资源破坏的权利,能够更好的防范危害的发生,维护我们共同居住的生态环境。二是环境保护公益组织。我国《社会团体登记竹理条例》第2条规定:本条例所指社会团体,是指中国公民自愿组成,为实现会员共同意愿,按照其章程开展活动的非盈利性社会组织。由此可见,环境保护公益组织一般意义上可以界定为,由民间团体、个人依法建立和参加并有自己独立的章程、组织机构、决策程序和独立资金来源的非赢利性组织,主要从事环境保护的公益性活动的社团。公民个人在环境保护诉讼中,往往处于弱势地位,在这种情况下,民间社会团体的环保组织蓬勃发展,成为与政府和市场抗衡的第二种力量,并因其公益性、专业性、志愿性、民主参与、多元利益代表性等,能更有效的解决复杂的环境问题。因此赋予环保公益组织环境公益的诉权,具有积极的现实意义。三是检察机关。历来检察机关都被认为是政府的代表,是公共权益的维护者。有的地方官员为了追求所谓的政绩,对土地乱批乱建,造成环境的破坏和浪费情况。政府的环境行政行为使行政相对人十分广泛,虽然环境公益诉讼制度解决了公民个人不因直接利害关系,可以为公共利益提起诉讼的权利,但个人行为方式诉讼成本太高。因此会形成一些公共利益受害而无人过问的尴尬场面。因而恢复检察机关公诉制度,由代表国家具有公诉权的检察机关作为起诉人,可以实现以公权来制衡公权的目的。在司法实践中,也己经出现了由检察院代表国家对国有资产流失等案件提起公益诉讼的案例。环境公益诉讼原告主体资格的其他问题动物和自然物作为环境公益诉讼的原告的问题对于是否该赋予动物和自然物以原告资格的问题,我国学者认为:对于动物和自然物而言,他们可以称为环境权的主体,但是要成为环境公益诉讼的原告为时尚早。但我认为,从法律权利主体来看,人类并非权利的唯一拥有者,无生命的物作为法律关系的当事人并不少见,如船舶、公司、合伙等,他们的权利义务并没有因为自己不会说话、不会表达而有所减免,社团法人的广泛存在也进一步证明自身表达能力的缺陷并不必然成为其行使权利、履行义务的的障碍。在具体操作上可以采用灵活方式加以处理,正如诉讼中法院为某一当事人指定监护人、执行人、保护人、辩护律师等。后代人作为环境公益诉讼原告的问题学界不断有人提出,后代人也应该是环境权的主体,因此也有权提起环境公益诉讼,公平是法律永恒的追求,在环境法律问题上也应该贯彻这一要旨;法律追求的公平是“人”与“人”之间资源和机会的均衡分配,然而,对于环境资源系统而言,这种对象由于具有共享性和非选择性等特殊属性,公平就不应该局限于现实存在的人之间,还应该考虑后代人的利益,所以后代人也享有环境权益。关十滥诉的考虑有些学者担心放宽对环境公益诉讼原告资格的限制、降低了诉讼门槛,将有可能引发“诉讼爆炸”、“诉讼潮”。我国“以和为贵”的思想根深蒂固,“厌讼”的社会心理长期存在,打官司、上公堂并非寻常百姓的爱好;何况诉讼是需要计算经济成本的活动,除了案件本身涉及的诉讼费用,律师费用、鉴定费用等也将是一笔不小的开支。人的理性决定他会权衡利弊而为之,绝不会因寻求刺激或一时冲动而选择诉讼。因此,在我国,诉讼条件放宽并不必然引起“诉讼潮”的发生。但作为一种制度设计还是应该就此作出相应的回应。对此,可借鉴美国“公民诉讼”中有关“防止滥诉”的规定,制定相应措施以防止可能发生的“诉讼潮”。总之,在对待环境公益诉讼原告资格的问题上,我们既不能固守“直接利害关系理论”,但也不得随意扩大环境公益诉讼原告主体资格,要做到有的放矢。同时,对于已经获得原告资格的一方也有必要进行必要的限制,以防止其滥用诉权或者怠于行使诉权行为的发生。环境公益诉讼主体的学说关于环境公益诉讼主体的学说,可以概括为以下三种:第一种学说是广泛主体说。该学说认为,任何单位和个人都可以提起环境公益诉讼。其依据是《环境保护法》第6条:一切单位和个人都有保护环境的义务,并有权对污染和破坏环境的单位和个人进行检举和控告。我们认为,检举权可以不算是诉权,但控告权应当是一种诉权。要实现这个诉权,可以通过某人提起诉讼后,由法院请示最高人民法院作出司法解释,来明确控告的诉权性质。如果控告的诉权性质得到明确,那么任何单位和个人都可以依据该条文以环境污染和破坏为由提起诉讼。第二种学说是相关团体、组织说。该学说认为,与环境保护相关的社会团体、民间组织、机关单位可以自己的名义提起环境公益诉讼。“自然之友”专门从事环境保护工作,可以作为社团提起环境公益诉讼;环境保护局作为政府机构可以提起环境公益诉讼。但是,与环境保护无关的单位、组织则不能提起环境公益诉讼。该学说排除了个人可以提起环境公益诉讼,其中一个理由是如果赋予个人提起环境公益诉讼主体的资格会导致诉权滥用,进而增加法官们的工作强度。第三种学说叫公权机构说。该学说认为只有行使相关公共权力的机关可以提起环境公益诉讼,比如,海洋管理部门可以对海洋环境污染损害提起民事公益诉讼;农业部门可以对渔业污染提起公益诉讼;检察机关可以对任何破坏环境的行为提起公益诉讼。环境公益诉讼的实践实践中,在国内被认为是环境公益诉讼的案例可以归纳为以下五类:第一类是由民间组织提起的环境公益诉讼。比如,2009年7月29日,财经网报道了全国首例环境公益行政诉讼在贵州省清镇市法院获得立案,中华环保联合会以原告身份状告贵州省清镇市国土资源管理局。该案被认为是一个民间组织提起的环境公益诉讼。第二类是以行政机关的名义提起的环境公益诉讼。在2008年4月12日,《法制日报》以“贵州省环境公益诉讼案判决首例官告民胜诉”为题报道了2007年新成立的贵阳市两湖一库管理局作为环境公益诉讼的原告,向清镇市法院环境保护法庭提起环境污染损害诉讼,要求平坝县境内的贵州某化工有限公司停止污染侵害。2008年4月清镇市人民法院环境保护法庭判决,被告贵州某化工有限公司在判决生效之日起立即停止使用磷石膏尾矿废渣厂对于环境的侵害,这是由行政机关提起公益诉讼的案例。第三类是检察机关提起的环境公益诉讼。例如,2009年2月6日,新华网以“长沙首起以检察机关为原告的公益诉讼案结案”为题报道的由湖南省望城县人民检察院办理的一起案件中,49户村民获得了某水泥厂灰尘、振动、噪声污染补偿款,共计每年62538元。该案的特别之处在于,检察机关不是为了社会,也不是为了国家,仅仅为了这些受害村民的利益,作为民事诉讼的原告提起公益诉讼。第四类是由公民个人提起的环境诉讼。这类诉讼一般都是以私益为出发点达到公益的目的,比如,某市汉阳渔场养殖承包人马长松,以该市水务局和环保局不履行制止污染的法定职责为由,对两个行政机关提起行政诉讼,请求法院判定被告履行法定职责,立即采取有效措施,制止排放有毒有害污水的工厂企业,以及对生活污水负有处理职责的单位停止污染行为;判决被告赔偿因其不作为导致湖泊被污染,给原告造成的经济损失2万元。原告提起行政诉讼后,当地政府承诺要对湖水污染进行治理,由政府补偿原告200万元后,原告撤诉。虽然该案的直接结果是原告得到赔偿,但是却达到了要求政府制止整个湖泊污染的公益效果。第五类是由民间公益组织帮助而提起的诉讼。比如,在中国政法大学污染受害者法律帮助中心的帮助下,北京市潘家园182户居民起诉北京市规划委,促使北京市规划委撤销了在居民稠密区建设动物实验楼的许可证.该案胜诉后的直接受益者是周围的182户居民,但客观上也为整个北京市或者其附近地区所有居民不受污染影响,为保护该地区的空气做出了贡献。这种法律帮助行为也是一种公益行为。环境公益诉讼主体资格的法律分析通过对上述五类案例的分析,可以就环境公益诉讼的主体资格问题作出以下几点分析和结论:第一,法律不应当阻止人们为社会公益做贡献。法律应该鼓励任何人为社会公益做贡献。按照该理念,任何单位和个人都可以作为公益诉讼的原告。换而言之,如果某行为是为了促进社会的良好发展,为社会公共利益服务,那么,法律制度就应该鼓励该行为。因此,任何单位都应该有公益诉讼主体的资格。第二,法律地位不同,其诉讼主体资格也应有所区分,不同的主体可以提起不同的公益诉讼。因个人能力、知识等方面的差异,并不是所有人提起公益诉讼都能发挥维护公共利益的作用。为避免浪费社会资源,应该对诉讼主体的资格有所区别。本人认为,可以对诉讼主体资格做如下区分:一是公民个人应结合自身的能力和关注点,在一定范围内提起环境民事公益诉讼和环境行政公益诉讼。例如,作为一个环境法专业的教授,可以作为诉讼主体提起环境公益诉讼,但不能提起房地产领域或消费领域的公益诉讼。二是民间环保组织、社会团体可以就其组织章程和工作范围内的事项提起环境民事公益诉讼和环境行政公益诉讼,比如,“自然之友”作为民间环保组织,可以提起环境公益诉讼;但是,爬山协会或者体育协会就没有提起环境公益诉讼的资格。第三,行政机关应在其穷尽行政手段后仍不足以保护公共环境利益时提起环境民事公益诉讼。行政机关提起环境民事公益诉讼的前提是已经充分行使了法律法规赋予的行政权力,穷尽了诸如处罚、责令停产停业等所有的合法手段。本人并不赞成行政机关在没有行使其应当履行的处
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 泰山版小学二年级品德与生活下册《家乡变化大》课件
- 痤疮病例分析与治疗课件
- 降糖药物服用时间表
- 职业医走师考试试题分析
- 甜瓜枯萎病的防治和治疗措施
- 2027年宁夏高考二模物理押题卷及答案解析
- 2027年春季开学考试高二物理培优卷打印版
- 2027年春季开学考试九年级地理复习卷
- 2027年四川省中考适应性考试物理押题卷
- 关于2026年商务合作项目风险评估的催办函6篇
- 死因监测培训考核试题(附答案)
- 江苏省国信集团2026年秋季集中招聘219人笔试备考题库及答案解析
- 2026 陕煤集团榆林化学有限责任公司招聘笔试题库(模拟练习·含答案解析)
- 2025年学校校医招聘试题及答案
- 护理管理工作规范 第5版 护理管理工作制度 2024.03
- 2026 年秋季开学初三正视模考得失主题班会
- 广东省江门市2026年重点中学小升初语文考试真题试卷(+答案)
- 机械制造技术 课件 6机械加工精度
- 2025-2026学年教科版三年级上册科学第二单元“水”测试卷(附参考答案)
- 干货满满的国学常识100道题(含答案),看到就是赚到
- 初探函数的对称性高一上学期数学人教A版(2019)必修第一册
评论
0/150
提交评论