版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
HowtowriteareviewTobyWalshDepartmentofComputerScienceUniversityofYorkwww.cs.york.ac.uk/~tw/phd大家好1OutlineWhatisareview?Whyshouldyoureview?Howdoyoureviewapaper?Whatnottodo?Whatarethedilemmas?Casestudy大家好2Whatisareview?“Somethingthatwillruinyourday”AlanBundyEvenifitisgood!ThestampofscientificqualityFeedbackfromyourpeersFuturedirections?Prof.AlanBundy大家好3Whatisareviewnot?Acceptance/rejectionEditors/Programcommitteesaccept/rejectYourecommend!Aplaceforbias,prejudice,personalanimosity,…Thoughitoftenappearstobeso大家好4Whyshouldyoureview?You’dmuchratherenjoyPaphosAndsowouldI!ButsciencewouldgrindtoahaltNotimmediately,ofcourse大家好5ReasonstoreviewDutyFairness2-3reviewswritten/paperwrittenPromotionEducationGoodreviewerswritegoodpapers?大家好6BadreasonstoreviewTosettleoldscoresToadvanceyourowntheories/hinderrivalsTogetlatestresultsUnpublishedpapersarestrictlyconfidential大家好7Howdoyoureview?ReadthepaperReadthereviewformUsefuldimensionstolookatNovelty,Clarity,Importance,Timeliness…ReadthepaperWaitafewdaysReadpaperWritereviewEveryonehastheirownmethod大家好8Howdoyoureview?Putyourselfinauthor’sshoesThinkhowyouwouldliketoreadthisreviewOfferconstructivecriticismDon’tjusttellthemsomethingisinadequate!Tellthemhowtheymightfixit大家好9Whatnottodo?MissthedeadlineWeallhatelatereviewsDisplaypartiality,bias,animosity,…DestructivelycriticizeAlwaysworkoutwhattheywouldneedtodotofixproblems大家好10CollectandsharereviewsLearnifothersagreewithyouropinionsThickenyourskinClearly,theauthorfailstounderstandtheworkofWalshinthisarea…Sincetheymentionnorelatedwork,thispapercannotbeoriginal…Thisideaistoosimplenottoexistalready…ThisworkisgoodbutIdon’tunderstandwhyBundyhasn’tdonethisalready?大家好11EthicaldilemmasYouareworkingonthesameproblemTalktoEditor/ProgramChairYoualreadyreviewedandrejectedpaperLookforchanges大家好12EthicaldilemmasThisjournalsubmissionalreadyappearedataconferenceDoesitextendpreviousappearance?AnalmostidenticalpaperalreadyappearedUnlessitwasataworkshop,informEditor/Chair大家好13Casestudy“StochasticConstraintProgramming”ByTobyWalshBefrank,thefeedbackisgood!Whatdoyouthink?大家好14Whatdidreviewer1think?AppearstolikeitMaincriticisms:RelationshiptoinfluencediagramsAlgorithmperformancePhasetransitiontoopreliminary“Thepaperreadswell.…Ihaveanumberofremarksthough.First,fromaprobabilisticreasoningviewpoint,Iwonderabouttherelationshipbetweenthisframeworkandinfluencediagrams(ordecisiondiagrams).Itappearstomethatwhatyouhavedefinedhereisverycloselyrelated…Second,fromaconstraintsatisfactionviewpoint:yougaveusnoindicationofhowwellthedifferentalgorithmsyoupresentedworkinpractice.…Third,Ithinkthediscussiononphasetransitioncannotbeleftatthislevel.Itisnotsurprisingthatwehaveaphasetransitionhere,butwhatisinterestingisthenatureofthistransition…IthinkthistopicistooserioustosumitupinasmallSection…[it]deservesadedicatedandmorethoroughtreatment.Iwouldhavepreferredtoseethisspacededicatedtoexperimentalresultsontheperformanceofpresentedalgorithms”大家好15Whatdidreviewer2think?AppearstolikeitVeryrelevantModeratelysignificant/originalGoodreadability/EnglishMinimalcommentsTotaloftheirwrittencomments:“ItwouldbenicetoincludetheexactsyntaxofoneSCprogram,asacceptedbyyoursystem(?),say,fortheexampleofSection3.”大家好16Whatdidreviewer3think?AgainappearstolikeitVeryrelevant,veryoriginal,moderatelysignificantMaincriticismsRelationshiptoinfluencediagramsPhasetransitiontoopreliminary“Clearly,onecouldjustaddconstraintstoinfluencediagramrepresentationandextendalgorithmstoexploitthem(mypreferredapproach)buttheapproachhereisstillveryvalidandcouldmotivateresearchersinMDPsandinfluencediagramstotreatconstraintsasspecialcreatures…sothattheirspecial…algorithmscanbeexploited.IthinktheexperimentalportionofthepapershouldhavebeentocomparetheperformanceofthealgorithmswiththeperformanceoftraditionalMDPsorinfluencediagramalgorithmsappliedtothisclassofproblemsandIspeculatethatgaincanbeshown.Idon’tfindthephasetransitionexperimentsofmuchvalueatthisstage.So,theremaybeaphasetransition,sowhat?IrecommendthattheauthorwillcarefullyanalyzetheirmodelagainststandardinfluncediagramsorfactoredMDPsanddiscusstheprosandcons.”大家好17WhatdidtheIJCAIPCthink?PaperwasrejectedAlongwith75%oftheothersubmissionsAlessgoodpaper(myandreviewers’opinions)wasaccepted!Some
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 微波炉用烹饪锅项目成效分析报告
- 前台工作总结解决客户问题的五种思维方式
- 一年级教师工作总结
- 公共广播系统项目成效分析报告
- 木工用圆锯项目成效分析报告
- 聚焦离子束扫描电子显微镜FIB-SEM系统市场调研报告-主要企业、市场规模、份额及发展趋势
- 无线发射器和接收器项目成效分析报告
- 消费者对农产品冷链食品市场物价感知调查问卷
- 旋转凸轮泵项目成效分析报告
- 护理核心制度及护理人员岗位职责
- SuperBench大模型综合能力评测报告
- MOOC 寄生人体的恶魔-医学寄生虫学-南方医科大学 中国大学慕课答案
- 2024年城市轨道交通运营与维护竞赛考试题库(职校用)
- 基于SLP法的仓库布局优化研究
- 新会计准则财务报表-中英文
- 2024年山东省菏泽东明县结合事业单位招聘征集部分普通高等院校本科毕业生入伍高频考题难、易错点模拟试题(共500题)附带答案详解
- 创意改变生活智慧树知到期末考试答案2024年
- 军队文职体检标准
- 智慧楼宇大数据应用建设和运营整体解决方案
- 钢构件(钢煤斗)组装工程检验批质量验收记录(新表)
- 大理石地面拆除方案
评论
0/150
提交评论