版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
MICHIGAN
LAWREVIEW
MoralDiscourseandtheTransformationofAmericanFamilyLaw
Author(s):CarlE.Schneider
Source:MichiganLawReview,Vol.83,No.8(Aug.,1985),pp.1803-1879
Publishedby:TheMichiganLawReviewAssociation
StableURL:/stable/1288953
Accessed:07/12/201001:16
YouruseoftheJSTORarchiveindicatesyouracceptanceofJSTOR'sTermsandConditionsofUse,availableat
/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp.JSTOR'sTermsandConditionsofUseprovides,inpart,thatunless
youhaveobtainedpriorpermission,youmaynotdownloadanentireissueofajournalormultiplecopiesofarticles,andyou
mayusecontentintheJSTORarchiveonlyforyourpersonal,non-commercialuse.
Pleasecontactthepublisherregardinganyfurtheruseofthiswork.Publishercontactinformationmaybeobtainedat
hllp:〃/aclion/showPublisher7publisherCode=mlra.
EachcopyofanypartofaJSTORtransmissionmustcontainthesamecopyrightnoticethatappearsonthescreenorprinted
pageofsuchtransmission.
JSTORisanot-for-profitservicethathelpsscholars,researchers,andstudentsdiscover,use,andbuilduponawiderangeof
contentinatrusteddigitalarchive.Weuseinformationtechnologyandtoolstoincreaseproductivityandfacilitatenewforms
ofscholarship.FormoreinformationaboutJSTOR,pleasecontactsupport@.
TheMichiganLawReviewAssociationiscollaboratingwithJSTORtodigitize,preserveandextendaccessto
MichiganLawReview.
MORALDISCOURSEANDTHE
TRANSFORMATIONOFAMERICAN
FAMILYLAW
CarlE.Schneider*
Familylawhasundergonemomentouschangeinrecentdecades.In
thisArticle,ProfessorSchneiderproposesthatthetransformationinfam
ilylawcanbeunderstoodasadiminutioninthelaw'sdiscourseinmoral
termsabouttherelationsbetweenfamilymembersandasatransferof
moraldecisionsfromthelawtothepeoplethelawonceregulated.Profes
sorSchneideridentifiescountertrendsandlimitstothechangeshede
scribes,andtheninvestigatesthereasonsforthechanges.Hehypothesizes
thatfourforceshelpedchangefamilylawandmoraldiscoursewithin
familylaw:thelegaltraditionofnoninterferenceinfamilyaffairs;the
ideologyofliberalindividualism;Americansociety9schangingmoralbe
liefs;andtheriseof^psychologicman,“whichisashorthandwayof
describingahostofchangesinthewaylawandsocietyviewhumansand
humanrelationships.UsingRoev.Wadeasacasestudy,heexploresthe
consequencesofthesefourforcesfarfamilylaw.Finally,Professor
Schneidersuggestsfruitfulavenuesthroughwhichthechangescouldbe
furtherinvestigated.
TABLEOFCONTENTS
I.INTROIT1805
A.TheSubject:FamilyLawandMoralThought1805
B.TheHypothesis1807
II.THESTATEMENTOFTHETHEME1808
A.TheTransformationofFamilyLaw1808
1.TheLawSurroundingDivorce1809
2.TheLawSurroundingSupportObligations1812
3.TheLawSurroundingNonmaritalRelations1814
•AssociateProfessorofLaw,UniversityofMichigan.B.A.1970,HarvardUniversity;J.D.
1979,UniversityofMichigan.—Ed.
Aversionofthispaperwaspresentedatthefirstsummersymposiumonthelegalhistoryof
theAmericanfamilysponsoredbytheLegalHistoryProgramoftheUniversityofWisconsin
LawSchool.1amgratefultothemembersofthatsymposiumfortheirhelpfulcomments.I
wouldalsoliketothankthefollowingpeopleforreadinganearlierdraftofthispaper:Francis
A.Allen,DavidL.Chambers,EdwardH.Cooper,ThomasA.Green,HendrikA.Hartog,James
WillardHurst,YaleKamisar,RobertH.Mnookin,JosephL.Sax,CarlJ.Schneider,Dorothy
Schneider,JoanW.Schneider,ChristopherD.Stone,LeeE.Teitelbaum,ChristinaB.Whitman,
andJamesB.White.IowethankstoRichardO.Lempert,FrederickF.Schauer,andMarisA.
Vinovskis.Last,buthardlyleast,IwishtothanktheAmericanCouncilofLearnedSocietiesfor
agrantwhichhasmademuchoftheworkonthisarticlepossible.
1803
1804MichiganLawReview[Vol.83:1803
4.TheLawSurroundingAbuseofChildren1815
5.TheLawSurroundingSexualRelationsand
Reproduction1817
6.Conclusion1819
B.TwoAmplificationsoftheHypothesis1819
C.SomeComplexitiesandSomeDefinitions1822
1.SomeComplexities1822
2.SomeDefinitions1826
III.THETHEMEINVERTED:TWOCOUNTER-TRENDSAND
THEIRLIMITATIONS1828
A.TheCounter-Trends1828
B.LimitstotheCounter-Trends1830
IV.VARIATIONSONTHETHEME:SOMEOBSERVATIONSON
THECAUSESOFTHETREND1833
A.TheLegalTraditionofNoninterferenceinthe
Family1835
B.TheTraditionofLiberalIndividualism1839
C.Society'sChangingMoralBeliefs1842
D.TheRiseofPsychologicMan1845
1.TheSocialChange1845
a.Thecomplexitiesoftheshift1846
b.Frommoralstomedicine:theroleofhuman
happiness1847
c.Antinomianism,pragmatism,andnonbinding
commitments1848
d.Thesearchforselfandthepsychologicviewof
humannature1849
e.Thepsychologicviewofprivacy1850
f.Acasestudy1851
2.TheLegalConsequencesoftheRiseofPsycho-
logicMan1852
a.Frommoralstomedicine1852
b.Nonbindingcommitments1855
c.Thesearchforself1860
d.Removingfalseconstraints1861
e.Thepsychologicviewofhumannature1862
f.Thenatureofprivacy1862
g.Aconcludingcomparison1863
3.ACaseStudy:Roev.Wade1863
E.ABriefSpeculationontheFutureoftheTrend1870
V.RECAPITULATION:WHATNEXT?1875
VI.CODA1879
August1985]MoralDiscourseinFamilyLaw1805
I.INTROIT
Tocomplainoftheagewelivein,tomurmuratthepresentpossessorsof
power,tolamentthepast,toconceiveextravaganthopesofthefuture,
arethecommondispositionsofthegreatestpartofmankind....
—EdmundBurke
ThoughtsontheCause
ofthePresentDiscontents(1770)
A.TheSubject:FamilyLawandMoralThought
Americanfamilylawhasbeentwicetransformed.Thefirsttrans
formationoccurredinthenineteenthcentury,whenafamilylawan
sweringanarrowrangeofquestionsaboutthelegal(primarily
property)relationsofhusbandsandwiveswasgraduallyreplacedbya
familylawthatincreasinglyorderedrelationsbetweenhusbandand
wife,thatincreasinglydealtwiththeterminationofthoserelations,
andthatincreasinglyspoketotherelationsbetweenparentandchild
andbetweenthestateandthechild.Thebreadthofthisfirsttransfor
mationmaybeseenintheextraordinaryrangeoffamily-lawsubjects
thateitheroriginatedorwerewhollyreformedinthenineteenthcen
tury:thelawgoverningmarriageformalities,divorce,alimony,mari
talproperty,thedivisionofmaritalproperty,childcustody,adoption,
childsupport,childabuseandneglect,contraception,andabortion.1
Familylaw'ssecondtransformationhasoccurredprimarilyinthe
lasttwodecades,althoughitsrootsrundeep.Howthistransforma
tionmightbecharacterizedispartofthesubjectofthispaper,butthat
familylawhasonceagainbeentransformedcanhardlybedoubted.
Withthepossible(anduninteresting)exceptionofthelawgoverning
marriageformalities,everyoneoftheareaslistedintheprecedingpar
agraphhaschangedorischangingsignificantly,andfurtherareas,like
familytortsandimmunities,mightbeaddedtothelist.
Dramaticasthistransformationis,itresistsdescription.Inwhat
terms,throughwhatlens,mightonebegintoanalyzeit?Itmight,for
example,usefullybeseenasashiftawayfrompublicstandardsto
privateordering.2Itmight,forexample,beunderstoodasaresponse
tochanginggenderrolesandthewomen*smovement.Theseand
otherapproachesareworthwhile,andwill,Ihopeandexpect,soonbe
1.Thefirsthistoryofnineteenthcenturyfamilylawhasonlyrecentlybeenpublished.Itis
M.GROSSBERG,GOVERNINGTHEHEARTH:LAWANDTHEFAMILYINNINETEENTHCEN
TURYAMERICA(1985).
2.Cf.Mnookin,ThePublic/PrivateDichotomy:PoliticalDisagreementandAcademicRepu
diation.130U.PA.L.REV.1429(1982)(exploringthepublic/privatedichotomyinAmerican
politicsandacademicthought).
1806MichiganLawReview[Vol.83:1803
pursued.34Inthispaper,however,Iproposeasafruitfulareaofgener
alizationtherelationshipbetweenmoralsandfamilylaw,forfewap
proachesoffersoclearaninsightinto“theendswhichtheseveral
rules[offamilylaw]seektoaccomplishMor“thereasonswhythose
endsaredesired.,,4Thisistrueforseveralreasons.
First,whilemoralsandlawneednotcoincide,anylawmustcope
withthewaythepeopleitregulatesregardtheirmoralrelations.This
isparticularlytrueoffamilylaw:moralissuesarecentraltofamily
lifeandfamilyself-governance,andhencecentraltothecontextin
whichfamilylawoperates.Indeed,“morality“initsnarrowestmean
ingbutcommonestusageconnotesexclusivelyoneaspectoffamily
morality—sexualmorality.Moralissuesarisespeciallyofteninthe
family,wheretheireffectcanbespeciallymomentousandtheirresolu
tionspeciallyhard.Forinmarryingwetakeresponsibilitiesforthe
welfareandhappinessofsomeonewho,trustingourassurances,has
trustedthatwelfareandhappinesstous;andinhavingchildren,we
takeresponsibilitiesforthewelfareandhappiness—eventheexist
ence—ofpeoplewhomusttrustthatwelfareandhappinesstous.No
moralityislearnedsoearlyandinsocompellingasituationasthe
moralityoffamilylife,andthusnoothermoralityseemsasaxiomatic,
isfeltaspassionately,sofixesthebehaviorweexactofourselvesand
expectofothers.Yethardlyanyothermoralitycontendswithcon
traryimpulsesandtemptationssostrong,soingenious,soinsistent.
Norarethefamily'smoralproblemswhollyinternal:thefamilyasa
basicsocialinstitutiontakesresponsibilitiesfbrthenurture,education,
andprotectionofsociety'snewmembers(anditsold).
Second,whilemoralsandlawneednotcoincide,themoralviews
ofcitizensandoflawmakersshape,properly,theiropinionsaboutthe
law.Onceagain,thisisspeciallytrueoffamilylaw.Becausepeople
havetenaciousandpassionatebeliefsaboutfamilymorals,because
manypeoplebelievethatlawshouldvindicaterightinmatterssoim
portant,moralprinciplesaredeliberatelyandexpresslyincorporated
instatuteandcaselaw.Andfbrthesesamereasons,moralsentiments
influencelawmakersunawares.
Third,moralissuescommandspecialattentionfromfamilylaw
becausethelawtypicallyintervenesinthefamilypreciselywhenpress
ingmoralproblemsarise.Furthermore,familylawisoneoftherare
areasoflawthattries-inchild-custodydecisions,fbrinstance—to
takeintoaccountpeople'sentiremoralpersonalities.Andfamilylaw,
3.SeeSchneider,TheNextStep:Definition,Generalization,andTheoryinAmericanFamily
Law,18U.MICH.J.L.REF.1039(1985).
4.O.W.HOLMES,ThePathoftheLaw.inCOLLECTEDLEGALPAPERS198(1920).
August1985]MoralDiscourseinFamilyLaw1807
morethanmostlaw,encounterscripplingproblemsofenforcement
whenitsrulesmismatchpopularmorals.
Fourth,therelationshipbetweenmoralsandfamilylawmeritsat
tentionbecauseAmericanviewsaboutmorals,especiallyfamily
morals,havechangedabundantly.Weneedtoknowhowthorough
goingthosechangesareandhowtheyhaveinfluencedourthinking
andourfamilylaw,inorderthatwemayeventuallyaskhowdesirable
thosechangesareandhowfartheyshouldaffectfamilylaw.
Finally,letmeputthecasefbrstudyingfamilylawandmoraldis
coursefromasomewhatdifferentperspective.Legalscholarshiphas
lostitsmethod;or,tobemoreaccurate,itisoverwhelmedbyanem
barrassmentofmethods.Manyofthesemethods—principallythe
“lawandsM—attractusbecausetheyofferfreshpicturesofhowlaw
worksandnewtoolswithwhichtostudyit.Butaswewalktoward
theblessingofmoreparticularunderstandings,wewalkawayfrom
theblessingofmoregeneralones.Thereis,ofcourse,atraditionof
synopticwritingaboutsociety,atraditionthatattemptstounderstand
howandtowhatendsociety'spartsdoandshouldfittogether.5Ev
eryoneisdeterredfromwritinginthattraditionbecausenooneis
competentineveryareaofsocialinquiry.Butlawishistory,itisthe
regulatorofmarkets,itistheveryproductofpolitics,itistheobjectof
philosophy,itisanexpressionofsocietyandasocialinstitutionitself.
Iftobealegalacademicistobeanamateurhistorian,politicalscien
tist,philosopher,sociologist,andanthropologist,weneedmanageable
waysofdoingtheunmanageable.That,Ibelieve,isavirtueofstudy
ingmoraldiscourseinfamilylaw:itisanarrowwindowthrough
whichtoglimpselawinitsbroadestcontext.
B.TheHypothesis
Wecomenowtothefirstformulationofmyhypothesis.Four
forcesinAmericaninstitutionsandculturehaveshapedmodemfam
ilylaw.Theyarethelegaltraditionofnoninterferenceinfamilyaf
fairs,theideologyofliberalindividualism,Americansociety's
changingmoralbeliefs,andtheriseof^psychologicman.”These
forceshaveoccasionedacrucialchange:adiminutionofthelaw's
discourseinmoraltermsabouttherelationsbetweenfamilymembers,
5.Amodemexampleavowedlyinthattradition,anddirectlyrelevanttothesubjectofthis
article,isR.BELLAH,R.MADSEN,W.SULLIVAN,A.SWIDLER&S.TIPTON,HABITSOFTHE
HEART:INDIVIDUALISMANDCOMMITMENTINAMERICANLIFE(1985)[hereinaftercitedas
HABITSOFTHEHEART].TheAppendix,SocialScienceandPublicPhilosophy,at297-307,de
scribesanddefendsthattradition.Thebookwaspublishedjustasthisarticlewascompleted.
Haditbeenpublishedearlier,Iwouldhavereliedonitoften,forittreatsablymanyofthe
themesIdiscusshere.
1808MichiganLawReview[Vol.83:1803
andthetransferofmanymoraldecisionsfromthelawtothepeople
thelawonceregulated.Idonotmeanthatthischangeiscompleteor
willeverbecompleted.Idonotsupposethatitisoccurringinevery
aspectoffamilylaw,oreverywhereinthecountrywithequalspeed.I
emphasizethatthereareothertrends,andthatthereisaconsidered
andconsiderablereactiontothetrendimpelledbyarevivedconserva
tismandapoliticizedfundamentalism.ButIdosuggestthatthe
changeiswidespreadjurisdictionally,institutionally,anddoctrinally;
thatitisdeep-seated;andthatitistransformingfamilylaw.
Inthispaper,Iwillinitiallydescribethatchangeinorderto
demonstrateitsstrengthanditsscope.Then,sincenoareaoflaw
flowsinasingleuninterruptedstream,Iwilldescribesomeoftheed
diesandcross-currentsaffectingmoraldiscourseinfamilylaw.Next,
Iwillexploresomeofthereasonsforthepresentcourseoffamilylaw,
hopingthatthatexplorationwillalsoyieldarichersenseofthetexture
andcomplexityofthechange.Iwill,however,postponetoalater
paperthemanytroublingquestionsthatfamilylawmustanswerin
assessingthewisdomofthechangeandindeliberatingonresponsesto
it.
Beforewebegin,letmewarnagainsttwopossible(andrelated)
misreadingsofmyhypothesis.Thefirststemsfromthefactthat,as
thewordisusedcolloquially,“morality”isagoodthing,andmore
moralityisabetterthing.Therefore,tosaythatthelawisbecoming
quantitatively“lessmoral“seemstoimplythatthelawisbecoming
qualitativelylessgood.Insomewaysthisisperhapstrue,butforrea
sonsthatareimmediatelyobvious,orwillshortlybecomeso,itisin
otherwayssurelyfalse.
Thesecond,closelyrelated,misreadingofmyhypothesisiswhat
mightbecalledthe“Otempora,omores”problem.Thereisatradi
tionmillenniaold—andlonghonoredinthiscountry—ofjeremiads
againstafailingmoralorderandexhortationstoareturntothevirtu
ouspast.Inlightofthattradition,todescribeachangingmoralorder
risksimplyingawishtorestorethestatusquoante.Idonotwishto
doso:Idoubtthatyoucangohomeagain,andevenifyoucould,I
doubtyouwouldenjoyit.
II.THESTATEMENTOFTHETHEME
A.TheTransformationofFamilyLaw
Nowandthenitispossibletoobservethemorallifeinprocessofrevis
ingitself,perhapsbyreducingtheemphasisitformerlyplaceduponone
oranotherofitselements,perhapsbyinventingandaddingtoitselfa
August1985]MoralDiscourseinFamilyLaw1809
newelement,somemodeofconductoroffeelingwhichhithertoithad
notregardedasessentialtovirtue.
—LionelTrilling
SincerityandAuthenticity(1972)
Ihavesaidthatthetendencytowarddiminishedmoraldiscourse
andtransferredmoralresponsibilityinfamilylawiswidespread,andI
willnowattempttoprovethatpropositionbybrieflysurveyingfamily
law.Thesurveywillrevealthat,invirtuallyeveryareaoffamilylaw,
thistendencyhasmadeitselffelt;thatinmostareas,thetendencyisa
considerableone;andthatinmanyareas,itisprepotent.
1.TheLawSurroundingDivorce
DivorceisamongtheclearestexamplesofthechangeIdiscern.
Foroveracentury,divorcelawreflectedandsoughttoenforcesoci
ety^senseofthepropermoralrelationsbetweenhusbandandwife.
Indeed,thelawofdivorcewasvirtuallytheonlylawthatspokedi
rectlyorsystematicallytoanidealofmaritalrelations.6Thatideal
includeddutiesoflife-longmutualresponsibilityandfidelityfrom
whichaspousecouldberelieved,roughlyspeaking,onlyuponthe
seriousbreachofamoraldutybytheotherspouse.Inthelasttwo
decades,however,everystate7hasstatutorily8permittedsomekindof
no-faultdivorce.ThesereformsexemplifythetrendIhypothesizebe
cause(1)theyrepresentadeliberatedecisionthatthemoralityofeach
divorceistoodelicateandcomplexforpublic,impersonal,andadver
sarialdiscussion;(2)theyrepresentadecisionthatthemoralstandard
oflife-longfidelityoughtnolongerbepubliclyenforced;and(3)they
representadecisiontodiminishtheextentofmutualspousalresponsi
bilitythatwillbegovernmentallyrequired.
Itis,ofcourse,truethatno-faultdivorcerestsinpartonamoral
viewabouttherelationsofpeopletoeachotherandabouttheproper
scopeofgovernmentinfluenceoverpeople'slives.ThusIamfarfrom
suggestingthatthedecisiontoadoptno-faultdivorcewasitselfamoral
6.Ofcourse,moststatesimposeadutyofspousalsupport,eitherthroughthedoctrineof
necessaries,family-expensestatutes,or,occasionally,thecriminallaw.VA.CODE§§20-61
(1983).Theseprovisionsare,however,generallyuselesstotheunsupportedspouseandofinter
estprimarilytocreditors.SeeNote,TheUnnecessaryDoctrineofNecessaries,82MICH.L.REV.
1767(1984).Norwillcourtsgenerallyenforcethesupportobligationintheabsenceofanactual
separation.McGuirev.McGuire,157Neb.226,59N.W.2d336(1953).Insofarasthisareaof
lawhasrecentlychanged,ithasbeeninthedirectionofgenderneutrality.
7.1985SurveyofAmericanFamilyLaw,11FAM.L.REP.(BNA)3015(1985)[hereinafter
citedas1985Survey].
8.Cf.FigueroaFerrerv.CommonwealthofPuertoRico,107P.R.Dec.250(1978),4FAM.
L.REP.(BNA)2744,whichholdsthatthe**rightofprivacyorintimacy^^protectedbythe
PuertoRicanconstitutionguaranteesaccesstono*faultdivorce.
1810MichiganLawReview[Vol.83:1803
orimmoral.Rather,mypointisthat,beforeno-faultdivorce,acourt
discussedapetitionfordivorceinmoralterms;afterno-faultdivorce,
suchapetitiondidnothavetobediscussedinmoralterms.Beforeno
faultdivorce,thelawstatedaviewofthemoralprerequisitestodi
vorce;afterno-faultdivorce,thelawisbestseenasstatingnoviewon
thesubject.Beforeno-faultdivorce,thelawretainedforitselfmuchof
theresponsibilityforthemoralchoicewhethertodivorce;afterno
fault,mostofthatresponsibilitywastransferredtothehusbandand
wife.910
Theavailabilityofno-faultdivorcedoesnoteliminateallthepossi
blemoralquestionstoberesolvedwhencouplesseparate;judicialde
cisionsconcerningalimonyormaintenance,marital-propertydivision,
andchildcustodyandsupportallmayraisesuchquestions.Theten
dencyineachofthoseareasislikewisetowarddiminishedmoraldis
course.Thistrendinalimonylawisinpartcausedbyasignificant
changedescribedintheprecedingparagraph—namely,thedeclinein
thebeliefthateachspouseassumeslifelongresponsibilityforthe
other.Thischangehasstrengthenedthedisinclinationofbothcourts
andlegislaturestoawardalimonyforlife(oruntiltheremarriageof
therecipient),mayhaveledtoanincreaseddisinclinationtoaward
alimonyatall,andhasledtoapreferencefor“rehabilitative“alimony
(i.e.,toawardingalimonyonlyfor“thetimenecessarytoacquiresuffi
cienteducationortrainingtoenablethepartyseekingmaintenanceto
findappropriateemployment.')。Further,justaslegislaturesrelieved
courtsoftheresponsibilityofevaluatingthemoralrelationshipofpeti
tionersfordivorce,soaretheyincreasinglyrelievingcourtsofthat
responsibilityforpetitionersforalimony.11Evenwhenlegislatures
havenotexpresslydoneso,manycourtshaveinferredfromtheir
state'sno-faultdivorcestatutealegislativeintenttoeliminateconsid
erationsofmaritalfaultinsettingalimony.12Ananalogousmovement
9.SeePartII.C.infraforfurthertreatmentoftheargumentthat,becauseamoralbasisfor
thechangesdescribedinthisPartcanbefound,moraldiscourseinthelawcannothavedimin
ished.SeePartIV.infraforanextendeddemonstrationthatthechangesIdescribeherecannot
comfortablybesubsumedunderanysinglenewmoralviewoffamilylife.
10.UNIF.MARRIAGEANDDIVORCEACT§3O8(bX2),9AU.L.A.160(1979).
11.1985Survey,supranote7,at3015,3017(1985).TheUniformMarriageandDivorce
Act,forexample,providesthatmaintenance“shallbeinamountsandforperiodsoftimethe
courtdeemsjust,withoutregardtomaritalmisconduct...UNIF.MARRIAGEANDDIVORCE
ACT§308(b),9AU.L.A.160(1979).
12.See,e.g.,InreMarriageofWilliams,199N.W.2d339(Iowa1972).Thisinferencemay
revealsomethingaboutjudicialaswellaslegislativeattitudes,sincetheinferenceissurelynot
compelled.Faultwaseliminatedasabasisfordivorcepartlybecauseitwasthoughtthatpeople
couldnotusefullybemadetolivetogetheriftheydidnotwantto,whatevertheirmoralrelation
ship.However,indecidingwhatfinancialobligationsthepartiescontinuetohavetoeachother
afterthemarriageisended,enforcementproblemsbecomelesssevereandthemoralrelationship
maywellberelevant.Indeed,thatrelevanceseemstobeconcededbytheusualdirectiontothe
August1985]MoralDiscourseinFamilyLaw1811
maybeseeninthetreatmentofmaritalpropertyupondivorce;both
statuteandcaselawincreasinglyrequirecourtstoignoremarital
fault.*13
Inchild-custodylaw,moraldiscoursehasbeenreducedbytheleg
islativeandjudicialerosionasproperbasesfbrdecisionofvariousis
suesofmorality,particularlysexualmorality,suchasnonmarital
cohabitation14andhomosexuality,15161718whichwereoncethoughtrele
vant.ThustheUniformMarriageandDivorceAct(a“barometerof
enlightenedlegalopinion^^),6provides,<4Thecourtshallnotconsider
conductofaproposedcustodianthatdoesnotaffecthisrelationshipto
thechild.'"AstheCommissioner'sNoteexplains,“Thisprovision
makesitclearthatunlessacontestantisabletoprovethattheparent's
behaviorinfactaffectshisrelationshiptothechild(astandardwhich
couldseldombemetiftheparent'sbehaviorhasbeencircumspector
unknowntothechild),evidenceofsuchbehaviorisirrelevant.'"8
Further,legislaturesandcourtshave,bylimitingdiscussiontothe
psychologicalwell-beingofthechild,triedtocloseofftheconsidera
tionofmoralsandvaluesthatthe“bestinterestsofthechild”stan
dardonceseemedtoinvite.ThustheUniformMarriageandDivorce
Act,whilerequiringacourtdeterminingchildcustodyto“considerall
relevantfactors,Mexpresslymentions(besidesthewishesofthechild
andhisparents)thechild's^interactionandinterrelationship^with
anyrelevantpersons,thechild's^adjustmenttohishome,school,and
community/*andthe"mentalandphysicalhealth0ofallconcerned.19
courttomakewhateverdistributionofpropertyandincome
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 初中八年级道德与法治暑假安全主题班会教学设计
- 高中英语人教版必修第二册Unit3 The Internet Project教学设计
- 掘金智能家居以旧换新下沉市场:小镇青年的消费潜力挖掘
- 技术平权时代 知识付费新品赛道 2026年珠三角知识付费新品牌A+轮融资创业计划
- 智慧养老监护赛道 2026年西南智慧养老监护内部创业孵化商业计划
- 关于广东省碳足迹管理SaaS项目A+轮融资商业计划
- 2026年日本移动应用趋势报告
- 专业售后服务反馈声明4篇范本
- 智慧农业传感器网络安全方案
- 对年度销售目标的达成确认函7篇范文
- 农村污水处理工程施工组织设计
- 雨课堂学堂在线学堂云《信息检索与科技写作( 理大)》单元测试考核答案
- 概念验证中心运营细则
- 期末考试质量分析报告写作模板
- 银行绿色信贷宣传课件
- 大学版画教学课件
- 食品生物技术专业教学标准(高等职业教育专科)2025修订
- 住院患者沐浴管理制度
- T/CADBM 51-2021室内装饰用竹木纤维集成墙板应用技术规程
- 妊娠合并下肢静脉血栓护理
- PowerSurfacing-威力曲面-中文教程
评论
0/150
提交评论