英文道德论争与美国家庭法的转型_第1页
英文道德论争与美国家庭法的转型_第2页
英文道德论争与美国家庭法的转型_第3页
英文道德论争与美国家庭法的转型_第4页
英文道德论争与美国家庭法的转型_第5页
已阅读5页,还剩73页未读, 继续免费阅读

下载本文档

版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领

文档简介

MICHIGAN

LAWREVIEW

MoralDiscourseandtheTransformationofAmericanFamilyLaw

Author(s):CarlE.Schneider

Source:MichiganLawReview,Vol.83,No.8(Aug.,1985),pp.1803-1879

Publishedby:TheMichiganLawReviewAssociation

StableURL:/stable/1288953

Accessed:07/12/201001:16

YouruseoftheJSTORarchiveindicatesyouracceptanceofJSTOR'sTermsandConditionsofUse,availableat

/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp.JSTOR'sTermsandConditionsofUseprovides,inpart,thatunless

youhaveobtainedpriorpermission,youmaynotdownloadanentireissueofajournalormultiplecopiesofarticles,andyou

mayusecontentintheJSTORarchiveonlyforyourpersonal,non-commercialuse.

Pleasecontactthepublisherregardinganyfurtheruseofthiswork.Publishercontactinformationmaybeobtainedat

hllp:〃/aclion/showPublisher7publisherCode=mlra.

EachcopyofanypartofaJSTORtransmissionmustcontainthesamecopyrightnoticethatappearsonthescreenorprinted

pageofsuchtransmission.

JSTORisanot-for-profitservicethathelpsscholars,researchers,andstudentsdiscover,use,andbuilduponawiderangeof

contentinatrusteddigitalarchive.Weuseinformationtechnologyandtoolstoincreaseproductivityandfacilitatenewforms

ofscholarship.FormoreinformationaboutJSTOR,pleasecontactsupport@.

TheMichiganLawReviewAssociationiscollaboratingwithJSTORtodigitize,preserveandextendaccessto

MichiganLawReview.

MORALDISCOURSEANDTHE

TRANSFORMATIONOFAMERICAN

FAMILYLAW

CarlE.Schneider*

Familylawhasundergonemomentouschangeinrecentdecades.In

thisArticle,ProfessorSchneiderproposesthatthetransformationinfam­

ilylawcanbeunderstoodasadiminutioninthelaw'sdiscourseinmoral

termsabouttherelationsbetweenfamilymembersandasatransferof

moraldecisionsfromthelawtothepeoplethelawonceregulated.Profes­

sorSchneideridentifiescountertrendsandlimitstothechangeshede­

scribes,andtheninvestigatesthereasonsforthechanges.Hehypothesizes

thatfourforceshelpedchangefamilylawandmoraldiscoursewithin

familylaw:thelegaltraditionofnoninterferenceinfamilyaffairs;the

ideologyofliberalindividualism;Americansociety9schangingmoralbe­

liefs;andtheriseof^psychologicman,“whichisashorthandwayof

describingahostofchangesinthewaylawandsocietyviewhumansand

humanrelationships.UsingRoev.Wadeasacasestudy,heexploresthe

consequencesofthesefourforcesfarfamilylaw.Finally,Professor

Schneidersuggestsfruitfulavenuesthroughwhichthechangescouldbe

furtherinvestigated.

TABLEOFCONTENTS

I.INTROIT1805

A.TheSubject:FamilyLawandMoralThought1805

B.TheHypothesis1807

II.THESTATEMENTOFTHETHEME1808

A.TheTransformationofFamilyLaw1808

1.TheLawSurroundingDivorce1809

2.TheLawSurroundingSupportObligations1812

3.TheLawSurroundingNonmaritalRelations1814

•AssociateProfessorofLaw,UniversityofMichigan.B.A.1970,HarvardUniversity;J.D.

1979,UniversityofMichigan.—Ed.

Aversionofthispaperwaspresentedatthefirstsummersymposiumonthelegalhistoryof

theAmericanfamilysponsoredbytheLegalHistoryProgramoftheUniversityofWisconsin

LawSchool.1amgratefultothemembersofthatsymposiumfortheirhelpfulcomments.I

wouldalsoliketothankthefollowingpeopleforreadinganearlierdraftofthispaper:Francis

A.Allen,DavidL.Chambers,EdwardH.Cooper,ThomasA.Green,HendrikA.Hartog,James

WillardHurst,YaleKamisar,RobertH.Mnookin,JosephL.Sax,CarlJ.Schneider,Dorothy

Schneider,JoanW.Schneider,ChristopherD.Stone,LeeE.Teitelbaum,ChristinaB.Whitman,

andJamesB.White.IowethankstoRichardO.Lempert,FrederickF.Schauer,andMarisA.

Vinovskis.Last,buthardlyleast,IwishtothanktheAmericanCouncilofLearnedSocietiesfor

agrantwhichhasmademuchoftheworkonthisarticlepossible.

1803

1804MichiganLawReview[Vol.83:1803

4.TheLawSurroundingAbuseofChildren1815

5.TheLawSurroundingSexualRelationsand

Reproduction1817

6.Conclusion1819

B.TwoAmplificationsoftheHypothesis1819

C.SomeComplexitiesandSomeDefinitions1822

1.SomeComplexities1822

2.SomeDefinitions1826

III.THETHEMEINVERTED:TWOCOUNTER-TRENDSAND

THEIRLIMITATIONS1828

A.TheCounter-Trends1828

B.LimitstotheCounter-Trends1830

IV.VARIATIONSONTHETHEME:SOMEOBSERVATIONSON

THECAUSESOFTHETREND1833

A.TheLegalTraditionofNoninterferenceinthe

Family1835

B.TheTraditionofLiberalIndividualism1839

C.Society'sChangingMoralBeliefs1842

D.TheRiseofPsychologicMan1845

1.TheSocialChange1845

a.Thecomplexitiesoftheshift1846

b.Frommoralstomedicine:theroleofhuman

happiness1847

c.Antinomianism,pragmatism,andnonbinding

commitments1848

d.Thesearchforselfandthepsychologicviewof

humannature1849

e.Thepsychologicviewofprivacy1850

f.Acasestudy1851

2.TheLegalConsequencesoftheRiseofPsycho-

logicMan1852

a.Frommoralstomedicine1852

b.Nonbindingcommitments1855

c.Thesearchforself1860

d.Removingfalseconstraints1861

e.Thepsychologicviewofhumannature1862

f.Thenatureofprivacy1862

g.Aconcludingcomparison1863

3.ACaseStudy:Roev.Wade1863

E.ABriefSpeculationontheFutureoftheTrend1870

V.RECAPITULATION:WHATNEXT?1875

VI.CODA1879

August1985]MoralDiscourseinFamilyLaw1805

I.INTROIT

Tocomplainoftheagewelivein,tomurmuratthepresentpossessorsof

power,tolamentthepast,toconceiveextravaganthopesofthefuture,

arethecommondispositionsofthegreatestpartofmankind....

—EdmundBurke

ThoughtsontheCause

ofthePresentDiscontents(1770)

A.TheSubject:FamilyLawandMoralThought

Americanfamilylawhasbeentwicetransformed.Thefirsttrans­

formationoccurredinthenineteenthcentury,whenafamilylawan­

sweringanarrowrangeofquestionsaboutthelegal(primarily

property)relationsofhusbandsandwiveswasgraduallyreplacedbya

familylawthatincreasinglyorderedrelationsbetweenhusbandand

wife,thatincreasinglydealtwiththeterminationofthoserelations,

andthatincreasinglyspoketotherelationsbetweenparentandchild

andbetweenthestateandthechild.Thebreadthofthisfirsttransfor­

mationmaybeseenintheextraordinaryrangeoffamily-lawsubjects

thateitheroriginatedorwerewhollyreformedinthenineteenthcen­

tury:thelawgoverningmarriageformalities,divorce,alimony,mari­

talproperty,thedivisionofmaritalproperty,childcustody,adoption,

childsupport,childabuseandneglect,contraception,andabortion.1

Familylaw'ssecondtransformationhasoccurredprimarilyinthe

lasttwodecades,althoughitsrootsrundeep.Howthistransforma­

tionmightbecharacterizedispartofthesubjectofthispaper,butthat

familylawhasonceagainbeentransformedcanhardlybedoubted.

Withthepossible(anduninteresting)exceptionofthelawgoverning

marriageformalities,everyoneoftheareaslistedintheprecedingpar­

agraphhaschangedorischangingsignificantly,andfurtherareas,like

familytortsandimmunities,mightbeaddedtothelist.

Dramaticasthistransformationis,itresistsdescription.Inwhat

terms,throughwhatlens,mightonebegintoanalyzeit?Itmight,for

example,usefullybeseenasashiftawayfrompublicstandardsto

privateordering.2Itmight,forexample,beunderstoodasaresponse

tochanginggenderrolesandthewomen*smovement.Theseand

otherapproachesareworthwhile,andwill,Ihopeandexpect,soonbe

1.Thefirsthistoryofnineteenthcenturyfamilylawhasonlyrecentlybeenpublished.Itis

M.GROSSBERG,GOVERNINGTHEHEARTH:LAWANDTHEFAMILYINNINETEENTHCEN­

TURYAMERICA(1985).

2.Cf.Mnookin,ThePublic/PrivateDichotomy:PoliticalDisagreementandAcademicRepu­

diation.130U.PA.L.REV.1429(1982)(exploringthepublic/privatedichotomyinAmerican

politicsandacademicthought).

1806MichiganLawReview[Vol.83:1803

pursued.34Inthispaper,however,Iproposeasafruitfulareaofgener­

alizationtherelationshipbetweenmoralsandfamilylaw,forfewap­

proachesoffersoclearaninsightinto“theendswhichtheseveral

rules[offamilylaw]seektoaccomplishMor“thereasonswhythose

endsaredesired.,,4Thisistrueforseveralreasons.

First,whilemoralsandlawneednotcoincide,anylawmustcope

withthewaythepeopleitregulatesregardtheirmoralrelations.This

isparticularlytrueoffamilylaw:moralissuesarecentraltofamily

lifeandfamilyself-governance,andhencecentraltothecontextin

whichfamilylawoperates.Indeed,“morality“initsnarrowestmean­

ingbutcommonestusageconnotesexclusivelyoneaspectoffamily

morality—sexualmorality.Moralissuesarisespeciallyofteninthe

family,wheretheireffectcanbespeciallymomentousandtheirresolu­

tionspeciallyhard.Forinmarryingwetakeresponsibilitiesforthe

welfareandhappinessofsomeonewho,trustingourassurances,has

trustedthatwelfareandhappinesstous;andinhavingchildren,we

takeresponsibilitiesforthewelfareandhappiness—eventheexist­

ence—ofpeoplewhomusttrustthatwelfareandhappinesstous.No

moralityislearnedsoearlyandinsocompellingasituationasthe

moralityoffamilylife,andthusnoothermoralityseemsasaxiomatic,

isfeltaspassionately,sofixesthebehaviorweexactofourselvesand

expectofothers.Yethardlyanyothermoralitycontendswithcon­

traryimpulsesandtemptationssostrong,soingenious,soinsistent.

Norarethefamily'smoralproblemswhollyinternal:thefamilyasa

basicsocialinstitutiontakesresponsibilitiesfbrthenurture,education,

andprotectionofsociety'snewmembers(anditsold).

Second,whilemoralsandlawneednotcoincide,themoralviews

ofcitizensandoflawmakersshape,properly,theiropinionsaboutthe

law.Onceagain,thisisspeciallytrueoffamilylaw.Becausepeople

havetenaciousandpassionatebeliefsaboutfamilymorals,because

manypeoplebelievethatlawshouldvindicaterightinmatterssoim­

portant,moralprinciplesaredeliberatelyandexpresslyincorporated

instatuteandcaselaw.Andfbrthesesamereasons,moralsentiments

influencelawmakersunawares.

Third,moralissuescommandspecialattentionfromfamilylaw

becausethelawtypicallyintervenesinthefamilypreciselywhenpress­

ingmoralproblemsarise.Furthermore,familylawisoneoftherare

areasoflawthattries-inchild-custodydecisions,fbrinstance—to

takeintoaccountpeople'sentiremoralpersonalities.Andfamilylaw,

3.SeeSchneider,TheNextStep:Definition,Generalization,andTheoryinAmericanFamily

Law,18U.MICH.J.L.REF.1039(1985).

4.O.W.HOLMES,ThePathoftheLaw.inCOLLECTEDLEGALPAPERS198(1920).

August1985]MoralDiscourseinFamilyLaw1807

morethanmostlaw,encounterscripplingproblemsofenforcement

whenitsrulesmismatchpopularmorals.

Fourth,therelationshipbetweenmoralsandfamilylawmeritsat­

tentionbecauseAmericanviewsaboutmorals,especiallyfamily

morals,havechangedabundantly.Weneedtoknowhowthorough­

goingthosechangesareandhowtheyhaveinfluencedourthinking

andourfamilylaw,inorderthatwemayeventuallyaskhowdesirable

thosechangesareandhowfartheyshouldaffectfamilylaw.

Finally,letmeputthecasefbrstudyingfamilylawandmoraldis­

coursefromasomewhatdifferentperspective.Legalscholarshiphas

lostitsmethod;or,tobemoreaccurate,itisoverwhelmedbyanem­

barrassmentofmethods.Manyofthesemethods—principallythe

“lawandsM—attractusbecausetheyofferfreshpicturesofhowlaw

worksandnewtoolswithwhichtostudyit.Butaswewalktoward

theblessingofmoreparticularunderstandings,wewalkawayfrom

theblessingofmoregeneralones.Thereis,ofcourse,atraditionof

synopticwritingaboutsociety,atraditionthatattemptstounderstand

howandtowhatendsociety'spartsdoandshouldfittogether.5Ev­

eryoneisdeterredfromwritinginthattraditionbecausenooneis

competentineveryareaofsocialinquiry.Butlawishistory,itisthe

regulatorofmarkets,itistheveryproductofpolitics,itistheobjectof

philosophy,itisanexpressionofsocietyandasocialinstitutionitself.

Iftobealegalacademicistobeanamateurhistorian,politicalscien­

tist,philosopher,sociologist,andanthropologist,weneedmanageable

waysofdoingtheunmanageable.That,Ibelieve,isavirtueofstudy­

ingmoraldiscourseinfamilylaw:itisanarrowwindowthrough

whichtoglimpselawinitsbroadestcontext.

B.TheHypothesis

Wecomenowtothefirstformulationofmyhypothesis.Four

forcesinAmericaninstitutionsandculturehaveshapedmodemfam­

ilylaw.Theyarethelegaltraditionofnoninterferenceinfamilyaf­

fairs,theideologyofliberalindividualism,Americansociety's

changingmoralbeliefs,andtheriseof^psychologicman.”These

forceshaveoccasionedacrucialchange:adiminutionofthelaw's

discourseinmoraltermsabouttherelationsbetweenfamilymembers,

5.Amodemexampleavowedlyinthattradition,anddirectlyrelevanttothesubjectofthis

article,isR.BELLAH,R.MADSEN,W.SULLIVAN,A.SWIDLER&S.TIPTON,HABITSOFTHE

HEART:INDIVIDUALISMANDCOMMITMENTINAMERICANLIFE(1985)[hereinaftercitedas

HABITSOFTHEHEART].TheAppendix,SocialScienceandPublicPhilosophy,at297-307,de­

scribesanddefendsthattradition.Thebookwaspublishedjustasthisarticlewascompleted.

Haditbeenpublishedearlier,Iwouldhavereliedonitoften,forittreatsablymanyofthe

themesIdiscusshere.

1808MichiganLawReview[Vol.83:1803

andthetransferofmanymoraldecisionsfromthelawtothepeople

thelawonceregulated.Idonotmeanthatthischangeiscompleteor

willeverbecompleted.Idonotsupposethatitisoccurringinevery

aspectoffamilylaw,oreverywhereinthecountrywithequalspeed.I

emphasizethatthereareothertrends,andthatthereisaconsidered

andconsiderablereactiontothetrendimpelledbyarevivedconserva­

tismandapoliticizedfundamentalism.ButIdosuggestthatthe

changeiswidespreadjurisdictionally,institutionally,anddoctrinally;

thatitisdeep-seated;andthatitistransformingfamilylaw.

Inthispaper,Iwillinitiallydescribethatchangeinorderto

demonstrateitsstrengthanditsscope.Then,sincenoareaoflaw

flowsinasingleuninterruptedstream,Iwilldescribesomeoftheed­

diesandcross-currentsaffectingmoraldiscourseinfamilylaw.Next,

Iwillexploresomeofthereasonsforthepresentcourseoffamilylaw,

hopingthatthatexplorationwillalsoyieldarichersenseofthetexture

andcomplexityofthechange.Iwill,however,postponetoalater

paperthemanytroublingquestionsthatfamilylawmustanswerin

assessingthewisdomofthechangeandindeliberatingonresponsesto

it.

Beforewebegin,letmewarnagainsttwopossible(andrelated)

misreadingsofmyhypothesis.Thefirststemsfromthefactthat,as

thewordisusedcolloquially,“morality”isagoodthing,andmore

moralityisabetterthing.Therefore,tosaythatthelawisbecoming

quantitatively“lessmoral“seemstoimplythatthelawisbecoming

qualitativelylessgood.Insomewaysthisisperhapstrue,butforrea­

sonsthatareimmediatelyobvious,orwillshortlybecomeso,itisin

otherwayssurelyfalse.

Thesecond,closelyrelated,misreadingofmyhypothesisiswhat

mightbecalledthe“Otempora,omores”problem.Thereisatradi­

tionmillenniaold—andlonghonoredinthiscountry—ofjeremiads

againstafailingmoralorderandexhortationstoareturntothevirtu­

ouspast.Inlightofthattradition,todescribeachangingmoralorder

risksimplyingawishtorestorethestatusquoante.Idonotwishto

doso:Idoubtthatyoucangohomeagain,andevenifyoucould,I

doubtyouwouldenjoyit.

II.THESTATEMENTOFTHETHEME

A.TheTransformationofFamilyLaw

Nowandthenitispossibletoobservethemorallifeinprocessofrevis­

ingitself,perhapsbyreducingtheemphasisitformerlyplaceduponone

oranotherofitselements,perhapsbyinventingandaddingtoitselfa

August1985]MoralDiscourseinFamilyLaw1809

newelement,somemodeofconductoroffeelingwhichhithertoithad

notregardedasessentialtovirtue.

—LionelTrilling

SincerityandAuthenticity(1972)

Ihavesaidthatthetendencytowarddiminishedmoraldiscourse

andtransferredmoralresponsibilityinfamilylawiswidespread,andI

willnowattempttoprovethatpropositionbybrieflysurveyingfamily

law.Thesurveywillrevealthat,invirtuallyeveryareaoffamilylaw,

thistendencyhasmadeitselffelt;thatinmostareas,thetendencyisa

considerableone;andthatinmanyareas,itisprepotent.

1.TheLawSurroundingDivorce

DivorceisamongtheclearestexamplesofthechangeIdiscern.

Foroveracentury,divorcelawreflectedandsoughttoenforcesoci­

ety^senseofthepropermoralrelationsbetweenhusbandandwife.

Indeed,thelawofdivorcewasvirtuallytheonlylawthatspokedi­

rectlyorsystematicallytoanidealofmaritalrelations.6Thatideal

includeddutiesoflife-longmutualresponsibilityandfidelityfrom

whichaspousecouldberelieved,roughlyspeaking,onlyuponthe

seriousbreachofamoraldutybytheotherspouse.Inthelasttwo

decades,however,everystate7hasstatutorily8permittedsomekindof

no-faultdivorce.ThesereformsexemplifythetrendIhypothesizebe­

cause(1)theyrepresentadeliberatedecisionthatthemoralityofeach

divorceistoodelicateandcomplexforpublic,impersonal,andadver­

sarialdiscussion;(2)theyrepresentadecisionthatthemoralstandard

oflife-longfidelityoughtnolongerbepubliclyenforced;and(3)they

representadecisiontodiminishtheextentofmutualspousalresponsi­

bilitythatwillbegovernmentallyrequired.

Itis,ofcourse,truethatno-faultdivorcerestsinpartonamoral

viewabouttherelationsofpeopletoeachotherandabouttheproper

scopeofgovernmentinfluenceoverpeople'slives.ThusIamfarfrom

suggestingthatthedecisiontoadoptno-faultdivorcewasitselfamoral

6.Ofcourse,moststatesimposeadutyofspousalsupport,eitherthroughthedoctrineof

necessaries,family-expensestatutes,or,occasionally,thecriminallaw.VA.CODE§§20-61

(1983).Theseprovisionsare,however,generallyuselesstotheunsupportedspouseandofinter­

estprimarilytocreditors.SeeNote,TheUnnecessaryDoctrineofNecessaries,82MICH.L.REV.

1767(1984).Norwillcourtsgenerallyenforcethesupportobligationintheabsenceofanactual

separation.McGuirev.McGuire,157Neb.226,59N.W.2d336(1953).Insofarasthisareaof

lawhasrecentlychanged,ithasbeeninthedirectionofgenderneutrality.

7.1985SurveyofAmericanFamilyLaw,11FAM.L.REP.(BNA)3015(1985)[hereinafter

citedas1985Survey].

8.Cf.FigueroaFerrerv.CommonwealthofPuertoRico,107P.R.Dec.250(1978),4FAM.

L.REP.(BNA)2744,whichholdsthatthe**rightofprivacyorintimacy^^protectedbythe

PuertoRicanconstitutionguaranteesaccesstono*faultdivorce.

1810MichiganLawReview[Vol.83:1803

orimmoral.Rather,mypointisthat,beforeno-faultdivorce,acourt

discussedapetitionfordivorceinmoralterms;afterno-faultdivorce,

suchapetitiondidnothavetobediscussedinmoralterms.Beforeno­

faultdivorce,thelawstatedaviewofthemoralprerequisitestodi­

vorce;afterno-faultdivorce,thelawisbestseenasstatingnoviewon

thesubject.Beforeno-faultdivorce,thelawretainedforitselfmuchof

theresponsibilityforthemoralchoicewhethertodivorce;afterno­

fault,mostofthatresponsibilitywastransferredtothehusbandand

wife.910

Theavailabilityofno-faultdivorcedoesnoteliminateallthepossi­

blemoralquestionstoberesolvedwhencouplesseparate;judicialde­

cisionsconcerningalimonyormaintenance,marital-propertydivision,

andchildcustodyandsupportallmayraisesuchquestions.Theten­

dencyineachofthoseareasislikewisetowarddiminishedmoraldis­

course.Thistrendinalimonylawisinpartcausedbyasignificant

changedescribedintheprecedingparagraph—namely,thedeclinein

thebeliefthateachspouseassumeslifelongresponsibilityforthe

other.Thischangehasstrengthenedthedisinclinationofbothcourts

andlegislaturestoawardalimonyforlife(oruntiltheremarriageof

therecipient),mayhaveledtoanincreaseddisinclinationtoaward

alimonyatall,andhasledtoapreferencefor“rehabilitative“alimony

(i.e.,toawardingalimonyonlyfor“thetimenecessarytoacquiresuffi­

cienteducationortrainingtoenablethepartyseekingmaintenanceto

findappropriateemployment.')。Further,justaslegislaturesrelieved

courtsoftheresponsibilityofevaluatingthemoralrelationshipofpeti­

tionersfordivorce,soaretheyincreasinglyrelievingcourtsofthat

responsibilityforpetitionersforalimony.11Evenwhenlegislatures

havenotexpresslydoneso,manycourtshaveinferredfromtheir

state'sno-faultdivorcestatutealegislativeintenttoeliminateconsid­

erationsofmaritalfaultinsettingalimony.12Ananalogousmovement

9.SeePartII.C.infraforfurthertreatmentoftheargumentthat,becauseamoralbasisfor

thechangesdescribedinthisPartcanbefound,moraldiscourseinthelawcannothavedimin­

ished.SeePartIV.infraforanextendeddemonstrationthatthechangesIdescribeherecannot

comfortablybesubsumedunderanysinglenewmoralviewoffamilylife.

10.UNIF.MARRIAGEANDDIVORCEACT§3O8(bX2),9AU.L.A.160(1979).

11.1985Survey,supranote7,at3015,3017(1985).TheUniformMarriageandDivorce

Act,forexample,providesthatmaintenance“shallbeinamountsandforperiodsoftimethe

courtdeemsjust,withoutregardtomaritalmisconduct...UNIF.MARRIAGEANDDIVORCE

ACT§308(b),9AU.L.A.160(1979).

12.See,e.g.,InreMarriageofWilliams,199N.W.2d339(Iowa1972).Thisinferencemay

revealsomethingaboutjudicialaswellaslegislativeattitudes,sincetheinferenceissurelynot

compelled.Faultwaseliminatedasabasisfordivorcepartlybecauseitwasthoughtthatpeople

couldnotusefullybemadetolivetogetheriftheydidnotwantto,whatevertheirmoralrelation­

ship.However,indecidingwhatfinancialobligationsthepartiescontinuetohavetoeachother

afterthemarriageisended,enforcementproblemsbecomelesssevereandthemoralrelationship

maywellberelevant.Indeed,thatrelevanceseemstobeconcededbytheusualdirectiontothe

August1985]MoralDiscourseinFamilyLaw1811

maybeseeninthetreatmentofmaritalpropertyupondivorce;both

statuteandcaselawincreasinglyrequirecourtstoignoremarital

fault.*13

Inchild-custodylaw,moraldiscoursehasbeenreducedbytheleg­

islativeandjudicialerosionasproperbasesfbrdecisionofvariousis­

suesofmorality,particularlysexualmorality,suchasnonmarital

cohabitation14andhomosexuality,15161718whichwereoncethoughtrele­

vant.ThustheUniformMarriageandDivorceAct(a“barometerof

enlightenedlegalopinion^^),6provides,<4Thecourtshallnotconsider

conductofaproposedcustodianthatdoesnotaffecthisrelationshipto

thechild.'"AstheCommissioner'sNoteexplains,“Thisprovision

makesitclearthatunlessacontestantisabletoprovethattheparent's

behaviorinfactaffectshisrelationshiptothechild(astandardwhich

couldseldombemetiftheparent'sbehaviorhasbeencircumspector

unknowntothechild),evidenceofsuchbehaviorisirrelevant.'"8

Further,legislaturesandcourtshave,bylimitingdiscussiontothe

psychologicalwell-beingofthechild,triedtocloseofftheconsidera­

tionofmoralsandvaluesthatthe“bestinterestsofthechild”stan­

dardonceseemedtoinvite.ThustheUniformMarriageandDivorce

Act,whilerequiringacourtdeterminingchildcustodyto“considerall

relevantfactors,Mexpresslymentions(besidesthewishesofthechild

andhisparents)thechild's^interactionandinterrelationship^with

anyrelevantpersons,thechild's^adjustmenttohishome,school,and

community/*andthe"mentalandphysicalhealth0ofallconcerned.19

courttomakewhateverdistributionofpropertyandincome

温馨提示

  • 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
  • 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
  • 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
  • 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
  • 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
  • 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
  • 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。

评论

0/150

提交评论