版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
AISafetyandGovernanceinBanking2026
WhyOperationalizingGovernanceGivesBanksanAdvantagein"ScalingAl
November2026
ByAnneKleppe,MatteoCoppola,ThomasPfuhler,EikeDreusicke,KirillKatsov,ReginaEckhardt,andMaxSchleritzko
FrontierAlmodelsarebecomingmorecapableofexecutingtasks
autonomouslyoverincreasinglylongtimehorizons,yetthedepthandscaleofagenticAldeploymentinbankingremainrelativelylimited.GrowingconcernsaboutAlsafetymaybeonereason.AsAlbecomesmoreautonomous,itraisestheprospectofnewrisksthatbanksareonlybeginningtounderstandandgovern.Meanwhile,incidents
involvingsystemsalreadyinproductionshowthattheseconcernsarealreadymaterializingintherealworld.
AgenticAlillustratesboththechallengeandtheopportunity.UnlikeGenAl,whichprimarilygeneratescontentormakes
recommendations,agenticsystemscanplanandexecute
multisteptaskswithgreaterautonomy.Assuch,thesesystemscantakeactionsandadjustcoursewithoutrequiringhuman
inputateverystep.Ouranalysisfindsthat73%ofbankspermitagenticAlinproductionforselectedusecases,but
deploymentremainsshallow.At88%ofinstitutions,agents
makeup10%orlessoftheAlportfolio.AgenticAlhasarrived,butithasn'tscaled,indicatingthatexecutivesseetheneedtohavetherightgovernanceinplacebeforetheyfeelcomfortablescalingitfurther.
Alriskpolicies,however,areonlythefoundation.Banksneedtotranslatethesepoliciesintoanoperatingcapabilitythatcanbeappliedconsistentlyacrossagrowingandincreasingly
complexAlportfolio.Thattaskbecomesmorecomplexasbankspermitselectedagenticuses,technologyproviders
embedAlintoexistingservices,andbusinessusersbuildorconfiguretheirownagentsonapprovedplatforms(apracticeknownas"citizendevelopment").
Tounderstandhowpreparedbanksareforthisnextphase,
BCG'sAISafetyandGovernanceinBankingbenchmark
assessed26globalanddomesticsystemicallyimportantbanks(G-SIBsandD-SIBs).Drawingonthisanalysis,weexplore
whereAlgovernanceisprovinghardesttoputintopracticeandwhatCEOsandCROsshouldprioritizeasAlcapabilitiesand
adoptionadvance.
BOSTONCONSULTINGGROUPAISAFETYANDGOVERNANCEINBANKING2026(
AIIsScalingandtheRisksAreScalingWithIt
AIhasmovedwellbeyondexperimentationandintobanks’
productionenvironments.Themajorityofbanksalreadyoperatemorethan100AIsystemsinproduction,spanningfunctions
acrosstheorganization.SoftwareengineeringandIToperationsremaintheleadingareasofuse,followedbycustomerservice,backoffice,andoperations.
AlthoughAIuseisspreadingacrossmorefunctions,GenAI
andagenticAIareatverydifferentstagesofadoption.46%
reportthatGenAIalreadyaccountsforatleastaquarterof
theirproductionAIsystems,whileagenticAIstillrepresentsarelativelysmallshareofbanks’AIportfolios.
AsAIhasbecomemorewidelyused,problemshavebeguntosurface.About46%ofbanksreportedanAI-relatedissueor
incidentduringtheprevious12months.Acrossindustries,theMITAIIncidentTrackerrecordedabout50%morereported
real-worldAIincidentsin2025thanin2024.Andoutright
incidentsareonlypartoftheconcern.Morethanone-quarterofinstitutionsreportAIsystemsfallingbehindtheirpromisedbusinesscase,underscoringthatthedownsideofAIcan
includelostvalueevenwhenitdoesnotresultinamajorriskevent.(SeeExhibit1.)
AIexposurealsoextendsbeyondsystemsbanksbuild
themselves.Existingthird-partyproviderscanchangethemodelstheyuse,howdataishandled,thefunctionalitythesemodels
provide,orwhereprocessingtakesplace,potentiallychanginga
bank’sriskexposureovertime.Relianceonasmallnumberof
modelandcloudproviderscanalsocreateconcentrationand
resiliencerisksthatcanemergeandevolvewellafteracontractissigned.YetbankstendtoapplygreaterscrutinywhenselectingandonboardingAIprovidersthantheydooncethoseprovidersareinuse.At92%ofinstitutions,duediligencefornewAI
providersismeasurablystrongerthantheongoingcontrols
neededtomanagetherelationship,includingconcentration
limits,exitstrategies,andfallbackplans.Thiscreatesapotentialblindspotasthird-partyprovidersmaychangeorexpandtheirAIcapabilitiesovertime,withouttriggeringanewreview.
AnotherhiddenAIchallengeisemerginginsidebanks
themselves.At58%ofinstitutions,businessuserscanalreadybuildorconfiguretheirownAIagentsonapprovedplatforms.Insomecases,thiskindofcitizendevelopmentislimitedto
selectedteams,butinotherbanksit’sallowedmorebroadlyacrosstheorganization.Thatcanaccelerateinnovation,butitalsoexpandsAIdevelopmentbeyondtraditionaltechnology
teamsandincreasestheimportanceofknowingwhatisbeingbuiltandwhereitisbeingused.
ThelevelofoversightshoulddependonwhattheAIsystemcando,whereandhowitisused,andtherisksitcreates.Banks
shouldconsiderfactorssuchasasystem’slevelofautonomy,itsaccesstodataandtools,itsauthoritytoact,howlongitcanoperatewithoutintervention,whetheritsactionscanbe
reversed,anditspotentialimpactoncustomersandthebank.
EXHIBIT1
AI’sDownsideExtendsBeyondIncidentstoUnrealizedBusinessValue
~50%
increaseinAIincidentsfrom2024to2025
~27%
reportAIsystemsfalling
behindtheirpromised
businesscase
~46%
ofbanksreportedan
AI-relatedissueorincident
inthepast12months
MITAIIncidentTracker
BCG’sAISafetyandGovernanceinBankingbenchmark
BCG’sAISafetyandGovernanceinBankingbenchmark
Sources:BCGanalysis;MITAIIncidentTracker.
BOSTONCONSULTINGGROUPAISAFETYANDGOVERNANCEINBANKING20263
BOSTONCONSULTINGGROUPAISAFETYANDGOVERNANCEINBANKING20264
FormalGovernanceIsAheadofScalableOperationalControl
MostbankshaveputthebasicstructuresforAIgovernanceinplace.77%haveadedicatedAIpolicy,andalmostall(96%)
manageAIrisksthroughtheirexistingriskframeworksratherthantreating“AIrisk”asaseparatecategory.73%have
definedtheirappetiteforAIrisk,upfrom57%in2025.The
largestbankshavegonefurtherinformalizingownership.AllG-SIBsinourbenchmarkplaceprimaryownershipofAIriskpolicywiththesecondlineofdefense,comparedwith60%ofotherfinancialinstitutions.
SothebasicarchitectureforAIgovernance—policy,risk
classification,riskappetite,andownership—isbroadlyinplaceatmostinstitutions.ButformalgovernancedoesnotbyitselfenablesafescalingofAIacrosstheorganization.Thisscaling
requiresclearpathwaysbasedonthelevelofrisk,reusable
controlsbuiltintohowAIisdevelopedanddeployed,evidencethatthosecontrolshavebeenapplied,ongoingmonitoring,
anddefinedthresholdsforescalationandmanagementaction.
Fewerthanhalfoftheinstitutionssurveyedhaveacentralized,tool-basedAIinventory,andnonehaveacomprehensive
human-oversightframeworkthatisconsistentlyimplemented
acrossAIsystems.Comprehensive,standardizedmonitoring
andcontrolframeworksthatexplicitlycoveragenticAIare
especiallyrare,andthatgapwillbecomemoreconsequential
asagenticusegrows.Together,thesegapsshowthatimportantcapabilities,fromknowingwhereAIisbeingusedtomonitoringsystemsconsistentlyanddefiningwhenhumaninterventionisrequired,arenotyetembeddedacrossmanybanks.
LookingatAIadoptionalongsideAIriskmaturityrevealsfourbroadpatterns(seeExhibit2):
•Start-upphaseinstitutionsarestillbuildingthefoundationsofAIriskmanagementandhaverelativelylimitedadoption.
•Cautiousbuildershavedevelopedstrongerrisk-managementcapabilitiesbutremaincautiousinscalingAI.
•Adoption-ledscalershavemovedmorequicklyonAIwhilestillbuildingelementsoftheirriskframeworks.
•Controlledadopterscombinerelativelyhighadoptionwithmorematureriskmanagement.
EXHIBIT2
BCG’sAIRiskMaturityMatrixRevealsFourDistinctAdoptionandMaturityProfiles
AIRiskMaturity/AgenticRiskReadinessScore
1.00
0.80
0.60
0.40
0.20
0.00
CautiousbuildersControlledadopters
Adoption-ledscalers
Start-upphaseinstitutions
0.000.200.400.600.801.00
AIAdoptionScore
AIriskmaturityscoreAgenticriskreadinessscoreMedian
Source:BCGanalysis.
BOSTONCONSULTINGGROUPAISAFETYANDGOVERNANCEINBANKING20265
WefoundthatbankswithhigherlevelsofAIadoptionalso
tendtobebetteratapplyingAIgovernanceinpractice.Thoseinthetopthirdformorematureriskmanagementwere2.5
timesaslikelytobeadvancedAIadoptersasthoseinthebottomthird.
Thisinsightchallengestheassumptionthatgovernanceand
speednecessarilysitonoppositesidesofatradeoff.ThebanksscalingAImostextensivelyaremorelikelytohavedeveloped
thepracticalcapabilitiesneededtogovernit.Banksusing
standardized,previouslyapprovedpatternsforlower-riskAI
applicationsarenearlytwiceaslikelytomovethose
applicationsfromideatoproductioninundersixmonths.(SeeExhibit3.)Ratherthanrepeatingthefullgovernanceprocessforeveryapplication,thesebankscanreusepreapprovedAI
patternsthatarealreadygovernedthroughestablishedrisk-
managementrequirements.Bystandardizingwhatrepeatsandreservingdeeperreviewfornovelandhigher-riskuses,banks
canmakegovernancemorescalable.
Bystandardizingwhat
repeatsandreserving
deeperreviewfornovel
andhigher-riskuses,bankscanmakegovernance
morescalable.
Thepicturechanges,however,wheninstitutionsareassessedspecificallyontheirreadinesstomanageagenticAI.AgenticAIriskmaturityisgenerallylowerthanoverallAIriskmaturity,
includingatsomebankswithrelativelyhighadoption.
EXHIBIT3
PreapprovedAIPatternsCanHelpBanksMoveLower-RiskAIintoProductionFaster
%MOVINGTOPRODUCTIONINUNDERSIXMONTHS
100
50
77
0
44
18
Low-risksystems
High-risksystems
WithpreapprovedpatternWithoutpreapprovedpattern
Source:BCGanalysis.
BOSTONCONSULTINGGROUPAISAFETYANDGOVERNANCEINBANKING20266
NowIstheTimetoGet
AgenticAIGovernanceRight
ForCEOsandCROs,agenticAIcreatesanimportantshiftin
accountability:namely,whathappenswhenanAIsystemgainsgreaterauthoritytoactontheorganization’sbehalf?
Banksareonlybeginningtoconfrontthisquestion.AgenticAIisalreadyreachingproduction,butitsbroaduseremainslimited.92%ofinstitutionsarepilotingorpermittingagenticAI,and
73%permitagentsinproductionforselectedusecases.Nonepermitbroadproductionuse,andnoinstitutionreportsthat
agentsaccountformorethanone-quarterofitsAIportfolio.
Indeed,at88%ofinstitutions,agenticAIaccountsfor10%orlessoftheAIportfolio.Thiscombination—agenticAIhas
reachedproductionatmostbanksbutstillrepresentsonlya
smallshareoftheirAIportfolios—createsawindowtoputtherightgovernanceinplacebeforetheuseofagenticAIexpands.
Banksarebeginningtoestablishexplicitboundariesaround
agenticAI.54%havedefinedrestrictionsorprohibitionsonitsuseintheirrisk-appetiteframeworks,butsettingboundariesisdifferentfromhavingthecapabilitiestomonitorandcontrol
agentsinoperation.Only8%ofinstitutionsreporthavingacomprehensive,standardizedmonitoringandcontrol
frameworkthatexplicitlycoversagents.
Thegapisevidentacrossseveralspecificcapabilities.Banksvaryintheirapproachestoidentifyingagentsandcontrollingtheirpermissions,settingboundariesontheactionstheycantake,monitoringtheirbehaviorinrealtime,interveningor
deactivatingthemwhennecessary,maintainingevidenceoftheiractions,andrespondingtoincidents.Thesecapabilitiesbecomeincreasinglyimportantasagentsgaingreater
autonomyandauthoritytoact.
HowtoOperationalizeScalableAIGovernance
ThefirstphaseofAIgovernancewaslargelyaboutestablishing
therules:definingriskpolicies,assigningaccountability,
determininghowAIfitsintoexistingriskframeworks,andsettingbroadboundariesforitsuse.Thenextphaseisaboutbuilding
thecapabilitiestoapplythoserulesconsistentlyatscale.
Ourresearchpointstofourpriorities:
•Standardizewhatrepeats.Createrisk-basedpathways,reusablecontrols,andapprovedpatternssothatlower-
riskAIusescanfollowestablishedapproachesratherthanrequiringafullreviewfromscratch.Thisallowsbanks
tofocusmoreintensivereviewonnovelandhigher-riskapplications,makinggovernancemorescalablewithoutweakeningcontrol.
•Developtoolsforcontinuoustestingandmonitoring.
AsAIbecomesembeddedinmorebusinessprocesses—andasagentsbegintakingactionswithgreaterautonomy—
banksneedgreatervisibilityintohowsystemsbehave
aftertheyenterproduction.15ofthe26institutionswe
assessedidentifyinadequatetoolingforAImonitoring,
testing,andriskreportingasacurrentchallenge.The
concernisparticularlypronouncedamongG-SIBs,with
82%identifyingitasachallengeversus40%ofotherbanks.Ratherthanindicatingweakercapabilities,thefindingmayreflectgreatervisibilityintothedemandsofgoverningAI
asadoptionandrisk-managementmaturityincrease.Thatchallengeintensifiesassystemsoperatecontinuously,makeinterconnecteddecisions,andactatmachinespeed.The
objectiveshouldbetoestablishclearboundariesforwhatsystemscando,monitorwhethertheyremainwithinthoseboundaries,andcreateescalationmechanismswhentheydonot.
•Strengthenoversightofthird-partyAI.Bankstypicallyconductextensiveduediligencewhenselectingnew
AIproviders,buttheyapplylessscrutinyoncethose
providersareinuse.Third-partyvendorscanaddor
modifyAIcapabilitiesoverthelifeofaproduct,potentially
changingabank’sexposurewithoutthebankmaking
anexplicitdecisiontodeployanewAIsystem.Although
58%ofsurveyedinstitutionsrequirenotificationora
newriskassessmentwhenanexistingproviderchanges
itsAIcapabilities,only23%haverightstoreviewortest
thosechangesbeforetheygolive.Banksthereforeneed
tomanagethird-partyAIriskthroughouttheprovider
relationship.ThatincludesconsideringconcentrationamongAIproviders,thepotentialforservicedisruption,where
dataisstoredandprocessed,andwhetherthebankhas
workablefallbackarrangementsandacrediblewaytoexittherelationshipifnecessary.
•Establishsafeguardsforcitizendevelopment.Giving
businessuserstheabilitytobuildAIonapprovedplatformscanaccelerateinnovation,butitalsointroducesnew
governancechallenges.Banksneedvisibilityintowhatis
beingbuiltandusedacrosstheorganization,supportedby
up-to-dateinventoriesandappropriatesafeguards,includingrole-basedtrainingorcertification,clearpermissions,
approvedconnectionstodataandsystems,reusablepatterns,andmonitoring.Withouttheseguardrails,
citizendevelopmentcancreate“shadowAI”agents
andapplicationsthatoperateoutsidethevisibilityandgovernanceoftheorganization.
Thechoicesbanksmakenowwillshapenotonlyhowmuch
Alrisktheycarrybutalsohowmuchvaluetheycan
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 上海2026年9月高三数学联考试卷及答案
- 2026年9月高中教师资格笔试综合素质模拟卷及答案
- 2026年9月小学教师资格笔试综合素质真题卷及答案
- 2026年12月初中教师资格面试体育答辩真题及答案
- 2026年炸药及火工产品制造行业市场深度调研报告及未来五至十年技术路径与产业化前景
- 干眼症的护理措施课件
- 2026年瓶装液化石油气行业洞察报告及未来五至十年发展趋势报告
- 2026年工业冷却塔行业洞察报告及未来五至十年发展趋势报告
- 2026年刮膜蒸发器行业洞察报告及未来五至十年发展趋势报告
- 2026年特殊作业机器人制造行业深度研究报告及未来五至十年市场规模与增长潜力评估
- 2026年消防设施操作员(初级)实操考核试题及答案
- 七年级(上)历史63个核心必背考点
- 《CSCO胰腺癌诊疗指南(2026)》更新要点解读
- 儿童情绪调节量表
- 基于核心素养的小学语文大单元教学设计与实施指南
- 学校校务公开及信息发布管理办法
- 预制管桩雨季施工方案
- 人教版川教版 三年级上册《生命生态安全》简述式教案
- SLT 336-2025水土保持工程全套表格
- 2026年前程无忧性格测试题目及答案
- 初中语文“阶梯式”整本书阅读教学研究
评论
0/150
提交评论