版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
PublicDisclosureAuthorizedPublicDisclosureAuthorized
FinancialInclusionandElectricityUptake
GlobalEvidenceandDistrict-LevelMechanisms
PoLICYRESEARCHWoRKINGPAPER11492
Abstract
Evenasgovernmentspushtobuildinfrastructuretoachieveuniversalaccesstoelectricity,demand-sidebarrierscon-strainuptakewhereinfrastructurealreadyexists.Thispaperassesstheimpactofthequasi-experimentalintroductionofmobilemoneyonelectricityadoptionbyhouseholdsLeveragingacross-countrypanelof180non-OrganisationforEconomicCo-operationandDevelopment(OECD)countries,itfirstemploysaheterogeneousdifference-in-differencesestimatortodocumentasignificantandpositiveassociationbetweenmobilemoneyintroductionandelec-trification,particularlyinruralareas.Theglobalanalysisiscomplementedwithagranulardistrict-levelanalysisof33sub-SaharanAfricancountries.Thedistrict-levelanalysis
leveragesdifferentialsub-nationalmobilenetworkcover-ageinadditiontocountry-levelmobile-moneyadoption.Theresultsindicatethatmobilemoneyaccessimprovesdistrict-levelpoweruptakebyaround24%relativetothesimilardistrictswithoutmobilemoneyaccess.Supply-sideinfrastructureexpansionisruledoutastheprimarydriver.Instead,evidencesuggestsdemand-sidechannels,specifi-callyreducedfinancialfrictionsandincreasedremittances,
drivethisrelationship.Theresultshighlighttheenabling
roleofmobilenetworkcoverageand,conversely,thedet-rimentalimpactofmobilemoneytaxesonelectrificationefforts.
ThispaperisaproductoftheDevelopmentResearchGroup,DevelopmentEconomics.ItispartofalargereffortbytheWorldBanktoprovideopenaccesstoitsresearchandmakeacontributiontodevelopmentpolicydiscussionsaroundtheworld.PolicyResearchWorkingPapersarealsopostedontheWebat
/prwp.Theauthors
maybecontactedatmlang@.Averifiedreproducibilitypackageforthispaperisavailableat
http://
,
click
herefordirectaccess.
ThePolicyResearchWorkingPaperSerisdiseminatesthefindingsofworkinprogresstoencournagetheexchangeofideasaboutdevelopmentiszues.Anobjectiveoftheseriesistogetthefindingsoutquicklyevenifthepresentationsarelesthanfullypolished.Thepaperscarythenamesoftheauthorsandshouldbecitedaccordingly.Thefindings,interpretations,andconchusionsexpressedinthispaperareentirelythoseoftheauthors.TheydonotnecessarilyrepresentthevieusoftheInternationalBankforReconstructionandDevelopment/WorldBankanditsafiliatedorganizations,orthoseoftheExecutiveDirectorsoftheWonldBankorthegovernmentstheyrepresent.
ProducedbytheResearchSupportTeam
FinancialInclusionandElectricityUptake:GlobalEvidenceandDistrict-LevelMechanisms
MeganLang*andAlphaLyt
Reproducibilitypackage:
https://reproducibility./catalog/573
AuthorizedfordistributionbyFlorenceKondylis,ResearchManager,DevelopmentResearchGroup,DevelopmentEconomics,WorldBankGroup
*TheWorldBank,DECRG,USA;E-mail:mlang@ENSAI,CREST,France;E-mail:alpha.ly@ensai.fr
2
1Introduction
Electricityaccessratesremainlowthroughoutmanydevelopingregions,particularlyinsub-SaharanAfrica,relativetootherregionsoftheworld.Whilesupply-sideconstraintsexplainlowaccessinremoteareas,electrificationratesoftenremainlowinareasalreadycoveredbythegrid.Lowunder-gridaccessrateshighlighttheimportanceofdemand-sidefactors:householdsmayfacefrictionssuchascreditconstraints,poorinformation,orhightransactioncostsforpayingelectricitybills.Givenlimitedgovernmentbudgets,understandingtowhatextentotherpoliciescangeneratecomplementarygainsinelectrificationisacriticalquestion.
Recentdecadeshaveseenmajorgainsinfinancialinclusion,notablythroughtheintroductionofmobilemoneysolutions.Evidencesuggeststhatmobilemoneycanhelphouseholdssmoothconsumption,lowertransactioncosts,increaseremittances,andpromotesavings.Giventhatmobilemoneylowersfinancialfrictions,isitaneffectivetoolforpromotingelectrification?
Thispapercombinestwodistinctempiricalapproachestoanswerthisquestion.First,weleveragecross-countryvariationinthetimingofmobilemoneyadoptionacross180non-OECDcountriesfrom1990-2021.Usingtheheterogeneousdifference-in-differencesestimatorproposedbyCallawayandSant'Anna(2021),wefindthatmobilemoneyisassociatedwithsignificantincreasesinurbanelectrificationrateswithinoneyearandsignificantincreasesinruralelectrificationratesafterfiveyears.
Second,toaddressidentificationchallengesrelatedtothedifficultyofdisentanglingdemand-sideandsupply-sidebarriers,wezoominonsub-SaharanAfricausingadatasetof2,825districtscombinedwithdemographicandhealthsurveys(DHS).Thesedataallowustoexploitthedistinctionbetweenhouseholdscoveredbythegridandthosenotcovered,aswellaswithin-countryvariationinmobilenetworkcoverage,tobetterunderstandtherelationshipbetweenmobilemoneyandelectrification.Usingentropybalancingtoconstructcomparablecontrolgroupsandaninstrumentalvariablesstrategy,wefindthatdistrictswithmobilemoneyaccesshave24%higherelectrificationratesthancomparabledistrictswithoutmobilemoney
access.
Ourworkbroadlycontributesevidenceondriversofdemandforelectrificationinlow-incomesettings.
Althoughenergyaccessprogramshavesuccessfullyexpandedgridcoverage,manyhouseholdsremainun-electrified(BarryandCreti,2020;SievertandSteinbuks,2020;Ankel-Petersetal.,2025).Muchoftheexistingevidenceexploringthisgapfocusesonspecificdemand-sideconstraints.Forinstance,multiplestudiesconsiderconsumerresponsestochangesinthepriceofelectrification(Chaplinetal.,2017;Leeetal.,2020;Grimmetal.,2020;Burgessetal.,2025;Lang,2026).Othersstudytheroleofinformationfrictions(BernardandTorero,2015;UrpelainenandYoon,2015;AlemandDugouan,2022;Mahade-vanetal.,2023;Blankenshipetal.,2020)ortheanticipatedqualityofelectricity(Kennedyetal.,2019;Bajo-Buenestado,2021;Covilleetal.,2025).However,addressingthesefactorsindividuallyoftenyieldsincompleteuptakebecauselow-incomehouseholdsfaceinterlockingfinancialbarriers.AsDugouaetal.(2017),BlimpoandCosgrove-Davies(2019),andBlimpoetal.(2020)pointout,householdsmustsimulta-neouslynavigatehighupfrontconnectioncostsandwiringcostswhilemanagingregularbillpaymentswithuncertainincomeflows.
Mobilemoneydirectlytargetsfinancialfrictions.Althoughitdoesnotdirectlyreducethecostsas-sociatedwithelectrification,itcanhelphouseholdsnavigatefinancialfrictionslikecreditconstraintsand
3
uncertainincomeflows,andevenleadtoincreasedincomesforhouseholdswhoreceiveregularremittancepayments.OurworkcomplementstwostudiesthatusedatafromtheWorldBank'sMulti-tierFrameworktoquantifytherelationshipbetweenmobilemoneyuseandelectrification(Angelouetal.,2026).First,Mahnetal.(2025)showthatmobilebankingsignificantlyincreaseswillingnesstopayforahypotheticalgridconnectionorahypotheticalsolarhomesystemwhenpaymentsneedtobemadeinfewerthansixmonths,butnotunderlongerpaymenthorizons.Ourworkcomplementstheirresultsbyprovidingevidenceonreal-worldconnectionratesunderdifferentmobilemoneyregimes.Second,MbateandFall(2025)doc-umentthatindividualswithmobilemoneyaccountsinKenyaaresignificantlymorelikelytoconnecttothegridthanthosewithout.¹OurresultsexpandthisanalysisthroughoutAfrica,whichiscriticalgiventheunusuallyhighspeedofadoptionofmobilemoneyinKenya.Mostimportantly,byexploitingtheintro-ductionofmobilemoneynetworksratherthanindividualadoptiondecisions,ourempiricalstrategyavoidstheselectionissuesinherentincomparingmobilemoneyuserstonon-users.Byperformingouranalysisatscaleacrossthecontinentandfocusingonmobilemoneyrolloutsandnetworkcoverage,weproviderobustevidencethatmobilemoneycanhelpdriveelectrification.
Ourresultsalsocontributetoagrowingbaseofevidenceontheimpactsofmobilemoney.Itiswell-establishedthatmobilemoneyleadstoincreasesinremittancesacrosslongdistances,allowinghouseholdstobettermanageshocksandsmoothconsumption(JackandSuri,2014;MunyegeraandMatsumoto,2016;ApiorsandSuzuki,2018;Apeti,2023;Riley,2018).Inaddition,alternativeevidencesuggeststhatmobilemoneymaycontributetoincreasedagriculturalproductivity,movementoutofagriculture,increasedurbanmigration,reductionsinpoverty,andincreasedtaxrevenue(Jacketal.,2013;SuriandJack,2016;SekabiraandQaim,2017;Aron,2018;BatistaandVicente,2020;ApetiandEdoh,2023).Ourresultsprovidenovelevidencesuggestingthatfinancialinclusionandlowertransactioncostsalsocontributetoincreasedelectricityuptake.Notably,wecanshowthattheconverseisalsotrue:increasingtransactioncoststhroughtaxesonmobilemoneyreversesgainsinelectrification.Assuch,ourresultsprovideevidenceaboutwhichtypesofelectrificationpolicygoalsmaybebestsupportedbyconcurrentadvancesinfinancialinclusionandwhichconditionsyieldthegreatestcomplementaryeffects.
2Conceptualframeworkorpotentialmechanisms
Althoughitisclearwhyelectrificationmayleadtoincreaseddemandformobilemoney(andmobilephonesingeneral),thecausallinkfrommobilemoneyaccesstohouseholds'electrificationdecisionsislessob-vious.Inthissection,weoutlinepotentialdemand-sidecausalpathwayslinkingmobilemoneytoelectri-fication.Wearelimitedinourabilitytodistinguishbetweenthesepathwaysempirically,butweprovidesuggestiveevidencewhendiscussingourresults.
Figure1showsthreecausalpathwaysfrommobilemoneyaccesstopoweruptakeatthehousehold
level.Eachpathwayisnotmutuallyexclusive:allthreemayplayarole.
Thefirstcausalpathwayfocusesonincome.Intheory,householdswithmobilemoneyareabletorelyontheeasyandaffordabletransferofmoneyfromfamilyandfriendstohelpsmoothconsumptionacrossnegativeshocks.Smootherconsumptionandthistypeofinformalinsurancemayallowhouseholdstoinvest
inhigherrisk,higherreturnactivities.Permanentflowsofremittancesfromfamilymembersortransfers
'Inthesamevein,Barryetal.(2025)findthatmobilemoneyserviceshaveapositiveeffectonsolarpaneladoptioninTanzania.
Income(remittances,
P2PorG2Ptransfers,
income-generatingactivities)
Saving/Loan(toover-
comeupfrontelectric-ityconnectioncosts)
Payment(electricitybillspaymentconvenience,
pay-as-you-gomodels)
PowerUptake
MobileMoney
Figure1:Conceptualmodeloftheinterrelationshipbetweenmobilemoneyandpoweruptake.
Notes:Mobilemoneyreferstomobilemoneyservicesadoptionbyacountry.Poweruptakereferstoelectricityadoptionbyhouseholdscoveredbyagrid.P2P:Moneytransfersbetweenindividuals.G2P:Governmentpaymentstoindividuals.
fromgovernmentprogramsmaydirectlyincreaseincomelevels.Mobilemoneymayalsoaffectincomebyloweringbarrierstotrade,therebypromotinglocaleconomicactivitiesandfacilitatingincomegrowth.Whenhouseholdshavehigherincomes,theyaremorelikelytobeabletoaffordboththeinitialcostofconnectingtoelectricityandtheongoingcostsofelectricityuse.
Thesecondcausalpathwayhighlightsthatmobilemoneycanalsobehelpfulforfinancialresiliencebecauseitfacilitatessavingandborrowing.Savingsandloanscanhelphouseholdsovercometheupfrontcostsassociatedwithelectricityconnections,installation,andequipment.
Thefinalcausalpathwayfocusesonpaymentconvenience.Althoughconnectingtoelectricityistyp-icallyasingletransaction,thedifficultyofpayingforelectricityonanongoingbasismaydetersomehouseholdsfromconnecting.AsLang,2026shows,consumersinruralareascanfacehightransactioncostsassociatedwithongoingpaymentsforelectricity.Byenablinghouseholdstoeasilypaytheirelectric-itybillsusingmobilemoneywallets,mobilemoneymaysubstantiallyreducesomeoftheongoinghasslecostsassociatedwithhavinganelectricityconnection.Evenifhouseholdsarenotcomfortabledirectlyusingmobilemoneytopayforelectricity,mobilemoneyagentsusuallyserveaswell-distributedpointsforelectricitypayments.Beyondloweringtransactioncosts,prepaidelectricityservicescanbeparticularlybeneficialforlow-incomehouseholdsthatpreferpay-as-you-gomodels.Suchcontractsallowhouseholdstomanagetheirelectricityconsumptionandexpensesmoreeffectively,reducingconcernsaboutinadvertentover-spendingonelectricity.
3Globalevidencefrom180non-OECDcountries
3.1Dataanddescriptivestatistics
Ourfirstanalysisusesabalancedpaneldatasetcontaininginformationoncountry-levelmobilemoneyadoptionandelectrificationratesfrom1990-2021on180non-OECDcountries.Wetakerecordedelec-trificationratesfromtheWorldDevelopmentIndicators(WDI,2023).Weobtaindataonthedateofthe
introductionofmobilemoneyfromtheGSMAdatabase(GSM,2023).²Figure2illustratesthewidevari-ationinthetimingofmobilemoneyadoptionacrossthe180non-OECDcountriesinoursample,whichallowsustoestimatetherelationshipbetweenmobilemoneyadoptionandelectrification.³
AdoptionYear
2012-2016
2002-2010Mon-adoplers
Figure2:Mobilemoneyintroductionacrosscountriesovertime
Notes:Mobilemoneyadoptiondatesbycountry.Thefirstadoptiontookplacein2002.Countriesaregroupedaccordingtotheyearoftheirfirstmobilemoneyservicedeployment:2002-2010,2010-2011,2011-2012,2012-2016,and2016-2021.Darkershades
correspondtomorerecentadoptionwaves,whilelightershadesindicateearlieradopters.Countriesingreyarenon-adopters.
Panels(a)and(b)ofFigure3showthatelectrificationratesaregenerallyhigheramongcountriesthathaveadoptedmobilemoney,bothwhenexaminingelectrificationratesbyincomestatusandbyregion.Pan-els(c)and(d)showsimilarpatternsfortheurban-ruralelectrificationgap:countrieswithmobilemoneyservicestendtohavealowerelectrificationgap,thoughthisisnotuniversallytrue.Althoughpurelycross-sectional,thesepreliminaryfindingshighlightthepotentialsynergiesbetweenmobilemoneyandelectri-fication,bothforincreasingoverallelectrificationandforbridgingthedisparityinaccesstoelectricitybetweenurbanandruralpopulations.
Beyondthesecoredataofinterest,weaugmentourcross-countrypaneltoincludearangeofrelevantcontrolvariablesandoutcomevariablesthatweusetobetterunderstandthemechanismsunderlyingtherelationshipbetweenmobilemoneyadoptionandelectrification.Inkeepingwiththeliterature,wecontrolforpopulationdensity(VanRuijvenetal.,2012;Trotter,2016;Bertheauetal.,2017;Khavarietal.,2021a;Khavarietal.,2021b),households'income(Louwetal.,2008;Jimenez,2017;Aklinetal.,2018;ShibanoandMogi,2020),andinequality(SarkodieandAdams,2020a;SarkodieandAdams,2020b;Aklinetal.,2021;Murshed,2023;Rustagietal.,2024).Weobtaininformationonthenumberofmobilemoneyopera-torsinacountryinagivenyearfromtheGSMAdatabase(GSM,2023).Weexaminepotentialsupply-sideconfoundsusingdatafromtheU.S.EnergyInformationAdministration(EIA)oninstalledcapacityandnetgenerationfromdifferentelectricitysources(EIA,2023).WeusedatafromtheWorldDevelopmentIndicators(WDI)ongovernmentspending,inflation,externaldebt,GDP,andforeigndirectinvestmentto
²FurtherdescriptivestatisticsonourvariablesarereportedinTableAlandTableA2,andthesourcesofourvariablesaredetailedinTableA3.
3TheadoptionyearandthedurationofexposureforeachadopterarereportedinTableA4,andthelistofnon-OECDcountriesthathavenotadoptedisreportedinTableA5.
6
(a)Electrificationrate
bymobiemaneyadophionstabusandbynoomegroup
(c)Electrificationgap
bymobiemoneyadopfionstabusandbynoomegoup
(b)Electrificationrate
bymobilemoneyasoplionstausandbyregion
(d)Electrificationgap
bymobilemaneyadophionstausandbyregion
ifcationooes%toelechicly(%ofpopdaion)
popdaion)
Aooesstoelechicly(%of
L
Uandechifcaion-Rualeect
Figure3:Summarystatisticsontotalelectrificationrateandtheurban-ruralelectrificationgapbymobilemoneyadoptionstatusandoverregions/incomegroups.
Notes:Rawaveragesobtainedfromcombiningdataonmobilemoneyadoptiondateswithdataonelectrificationrates.The
electrificationaveragesarecalculatedbasedonthedistinctionbetweenscenarioswheremobilemoneyisadopted(Mobilemoney=Yes)andscenarioswhereitisnotyetadoptedorneveradopted(Mobilemoney=No).TheclassificationofthecountriesbyregionsandbyincomegroupsisprovidedbytheWorldBank.
checkforpotentialconfoundingpolicychanges.Finally,weusedataonremittanceflowsfromtheWDItocomparethetimingofchangesinelectrificationtochangesinremittanceflowsaftertheadoptionofmobilemoney(WDI,2023).
3.2Empiricalapproach
Toidentifythecausaleffectofmobilemoneyintroductiononelectrificationrates(total,rural,urban,gap),weuseadifference-in-differences(DiD)researchdesign.Wefirstestimatethefollowingtwo-wayfixedeffects(TWFE)regressionspecification:
log(Yi)=γTWFEGi+Xit+θi+μ₁+En(1)
wherelog(Yi)representsthelog-transformedannualelectrificationrates(total,rural,urbanorgap)forcountryiinyeart.Here,welog-transformtheelectrificationvariabletonormalizethewide-rangingandskeweddistributionoftheelectrificationacrosscountriesandtofacilitateinterpretationofthecoefficientinpercentageterms.GiisadummyvariableidentifyingtreatmenttimeperiodsforthetreatedgroupsoγTWFEisthecoefficientofinterestrepresentingtheeffectofmobilemoneyintroductiononelectrificationratesforthetreatedgroup.Xitrepresentscontrolvariablesdescribedinsubsection3.1.θ;representscountryFEsandμrrepresentsthetimeoryearFE.Weclusterallstandarderrorsatthecountrylevel.
RecentworkdemonstratesthatestimatingEquation1canleadtobiaswhenthereareheterogeneous
7
treatmenteffectsacrossgroupsorwhentreatmenteffectsaredynamic(seeCallawayandSant'Anna,2021;DeChaisemartinandd'Haultfoeuille,2020;SunandAbraham,2021).Aswehavemultipleperiodsandmultipletreatmenttimings(2002-2010,2011,2012,2013-2015,2016-2021),wecannotensurethatthetreatmenteffectsarehomogeneousacrossbothgroupsandtime.WethereforemoveforwardwiththeestimatorproposedbyCallawayandSant'Anna(2021).
CallawayandSant'Anna(2021)offerastaggeredDiDframeworktoidentifythecausaleffectoftreat-mentswithvariationintreatmenttiming.Theestimatorhastheabilitytoconductrobustinferenceontreatmenteffectheterogeneityresultingfromthestaggeredexposuretotreatment.Italsoallowsforsimul-taneouscalculationofconfidenceintervalsthatadjustformultiplehypothesistesting.LetGgbeabinaryvariabledenotingthecohortofobservationsfirsttreatedattimeg;andGooisabinaryvariablerepresentingobservationsnottreatedbythelasttimeperiodinourdata.Ifpre-treatmentcovariatesdonotaffecttheidentification,thentheaveragetreatmenteffectonthetreated(ATT)forcohortgattimetiscalculatedas:
ATT(g,t)=E[Y₁-Y₈-1|Gg=1]-E[Y₁-Yg-1|G.=1].(2)
Foreveryg,thefirsttermmeasurestheexpecteddifferencebetweenoutcomeY₁andYg-1(theperiodimmediatelybeforetreatment),conditionalonbeingincohortg.Focusingontwotimeperiods(tandg-1)thuscapturesvariationinthetreatmenteffectresultingfromthedifferencesinfirstexposureandthelengthofexposure.Thesecondtermisthecounterfactual,usingthenevertreatedcohortasthecomparisongroup.4 Factorssuchaspopulationdensity(seeforinstanceVanRuijvenetal.,2012;Trotter,2016;Bertheauetal.,2017;Khavarietal.,2021a;orKhavarietal.,2021b),households'income(e.g.Louwetal.,2008;
Jimenez,2017;Aklinetal.,2018;ShibanoandMogi,2020)oreveninequality(SarkodieandAdams,2020a;SarkodieandAdams,2020b;Aklinetal.,2021;Murshed,2023;Rustagietal.,2024)mightaffectelectrification.Higherpopulationdensitymayresultineasieraccesstoelectricityasitbecomesmorefeasibleforutilitiestoreachalargernumberofconsumerswithinasmallergeographicarea.Incontrast,remoteareaswithlowpopulationdensitymightbehardertoreach,makingeffortstoexpandelectrificationmorechallengingandcostly.Similarly,householdswithhigherincomesaremorelikelytoaffordtheupfrontcostsassociatedwithconnectingtothegridandarebetterpositionedtoaffordregularbillspaymentforelectricityconsumption.Finally,inequalityoftenmanifestsasdisparitiesbetweenurbanandruralareas.Urbanareas,wherehigher-incomepopulationstypicallyreside,tendtohavebetteraccesstomultipletypesofinfrastructurecomparedtoruralandremoteareas,leadingtourban-ruralgapsinelectrificationrates.
Inourcontext,wehaveoptedtoretainthesamecovariatesforbothelectrification(outcomemodel)andmobilemoney(treatmentmodel),giventhatbothareformsofinfrastructure.Althoughwelackex-istingliteratureonthepredictorsofmobilemoneyadoption,wecandrawparallelswithhowpopulationdensitymightinfluenceinvestmentinelectricityinfrastructure.Itstandstoreasonthatpopulationdensitycouldalsoimpactinvestmentinmobilenetworks,withoperatorslikelytoprioritizecountrieswithhigherpopulationdensities.Additionally,householdincomelevelsarepertinentfactorsforoperatorsassessingmarketpotentialanddemand,whetherforelectricityormobileservices.Moreover,inequalitymightin- 4Inourbaselinespecification,thecomparisongroupconsistsofnever-treatedunits,definedasGo=1.Asarobustnesscheck,wealternativelyusethenot-yet-treatedcohortsasthecomparisongroup,definedasunitswithGh=1andh>t,i.e.1(G₁=h)with
h>t.Thesecorrespondtocountriesthathavenotyetadoptedmobilemoneyattimetbutmayadoptinafutureperiod.TheresultingATT(g,t)estimatesandtheiraggregationremainquantitativelyandqualitativelysimilar,confirmingthatourresultsarenotdrivenbythechoiceofcomparisongroup.
8
centivizegovernmentstopursueinclusivepolicies,therebypromotingfinancialinclusionthroughmobilemoneyinitiatives.
Includingthesefactorsastime-varyingcovariatesinourestimatesallowsustoobtainconditionalpar-alleltrends.Withpre-treatmentcovariates,theATT(g,t)iscalculatedusingtheAIPW(AugmentedInverseProbabilityWeighting)estimatoras:
(3)
wheremg(X)=E[Y₁-Yg-1|C=1].Inthiscase,thedoublyrobustestimator(seeSant'AnnaandZhao,2020)usestwocohortsGgandGaowithstabilizedweightsinthedenominatortoensuretheweightsintegrateto1.Thetermp₈(X)isageneralizedpropensityscoremodeledusingalogisticfunctionthatweightstheobservationbytheprobabilitythattheobservationisplacedinthetreatedgroup.ThelastsetoftermsisaDiDwithrecenteredcovariatesusingtheoutcomeregressiononnevertreatedgroups,mg,₂(X),alsocalledtheaugmentedterm.
OurcoefficientofinterestySestimatedusingtheCallawayandSant'Anna(2021)DiDisanaggrega-tionoftheweightedmeanofallATTsdescribedabove.
(4)
whereK=∑g∈GZ=21(t≥8)Pr(G=g|G≤T)ensuresthattheweightsonATT(8,t)sumupto1.ThecoefficientofinterestγCSisaweightedaverageofeachATT(g,t)puttingmoreweightonATT(g,t)withlargergroupsizes.UnliketheestimationofγTWFEintheTWFEspecification,thiscombinationofATT(g,t)toestimateySrulesoutissuesarisingfromnegativeweights.
TocomputethedurationofexposureATTs,lete=t-gbethelengthofexposuretothetreatment.
(5)
Putotherwise,ourcausalidentificationreliesonthefollowingkeyassumptions.First,weshouldnothaveanytreatedcountryinthefirstperiod(in1990inourcase).Thisassumptionisvalidasthefirstadoptionoccuredin2002.Second,werequirecommonsupportforpropensityscores.Third,thetreatmentshouldbeirreversible,whichholdsasweobservenoinstanceofacountrydis-adoptingmobilemoney(oncetreated,alwaystreated).Fourth,weexpectnotreatmentanticipationorlimitedtreatmentanticipationinpre-treatmentperiods.Weshowevidenceofnoanticipationgraphically.Itisalsoworthnotingthatmanyofthemechanismsweconsidersuchasremittances,billpayment,orahighervalueofhavingelectricityarenotconducivetoanticipationeffects.Finally,werequireparalleltrendsconditionalonthecovariatesthatweinclude.Wetestthevalidityandrobustnessoftheparallelpre-treatmenttrendsassumptionusingeventstudyfiguresthatshownoevidenceofpre-trends.However,parallelpre-trendsdonotnecessarilyimplyparallelcounterfactualpost-treatmenttrends.Forinstance,otherpoliciesmightchangeatthesametimeasmobilemoneyisintroduced.Weundertakeaseriesofempiricalteststoensurethatourresultsarenotdrivenbyconcurrentpolicychanges.
9
3.3Results
3.3.1TWFEestimatesversusHeterogeneousDiD
ResultsfromEquation1showthatthereisasignificantandpositivelinkbetweentheadoptionofmobilemoneysolutionsandelectrificationratesaftercontrollingforpopulationdensity,thepercentageofGDPgoingtohouseholdconsumption,wealthinequality,countryFEsandtimeFEs(seeTable1).Ourresultsindicateapositiveandsignificantrelationshipbetweenmobilemoneyadoptionandelectrificationrates(total,rural,andurban)andanegativeandsignificantrelationshipbetweenmobilemoneyadoptionandtheurban-ruralelectrificationgapfrom1990-2021.Theestimatedcoefficientssuggestthat,onaverage,theadoptionofmobilemoneyleadsthetotalelectrificationratetoincreaseby25%,theru
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 三级安全教育考试试题及答案(2025版)
- 护理学穿脱隔离衣试题及答案
- 浙江省衢州、丽水、湖州三地市2026年11月高三教学质量检测历史试题(含答案)
- 江苏省徐州市邳州市2026-2027学年七年级上学期11月期中数学试卷(含答案)
- 2026-2027学年陕西省西安市新城区八年级(上)期中道德与法治试卷(含答案)
- 安徽省宣城市宣州区狸桥中学2027届中考五模物理试题含解析
- 2027届湖南邵阳市城区重点名校中考物理押题卷含解析
- 2027届黑龙江省松北区达标名校中考物理五模试卷含解析
- 重庆市文理院附属中学2027届中考一模物理试题含解析
- 智能体技术构建应用及实践优化方案
- 2026 陕煤集团榆林化学有限责任公司招聘笔试题库(模拟练习·含答案解析)
- 2025年学校校医招聘试题及答案
- 医药购销不正之风治理课件
- 塔吊司索工考试题库及答案2026
- 2026 年秋季开学初三正视模考得失主题班会
- 广东省广州市增城区2025-2026学年七年级上学期期中生物学试题(含答案)
- (2026版)传染病防治自查报告
- 2026年四川省广元市辅警人员招聘考试真题解析含答案
- 广东省江门市2026年重点中学小升初语文考试真题试卷(+答案)
- 2025年兵团新职工考试题及答案
- 2026年中国铁路广州局铁路局校园招聘真题
评论
0/150
提交评论