版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
RICHARDDANZIG
Settlementand
GovernanceBehind
theAIFrontier
ThisworkwasindependentlyinitiatedandmadepossiblebyRAND’sownresources,includingincomefromoperations,unrestrictedgiftsfromRANDsupporters,anddistributionsfromitslong-terminvestmentfund.
October2026
ExpertInsights
PERSPECTIVEONATIMELYPOLICYISSUE
v
Contents
AboutThisPaper iii
SettlementandGovernanceBehindtheAIFrontier 1
1.ThePowerIntelligenceGainsfromBeinginaMachine 4
TheForkintheRoad:IntelligenceEmbeddedinMachines 4
TheSixMachineCharacteristicsThatAmplifyIntelligence 5
2.Software:ASiliconThinker’sLessAppreciatedParent 11
3.DistributedSuperintelligenceandDrexler’sProgression 13
ArtificialGeneralIntelligenceandSuperintelligence 14
RecursiveSelf-Improvement 16
4.Oozing 20
5.Governance 24
TheU.S.Government,FrontierModels,andDataCenters 24
AddressingAIRequiresThinkingAboutChallengesBeyondAI 25
GovernanceBeyondGovernment 27
TheRadicalRenovationofU.S.PoliticalLife 28
Conclusion 32
Abbreviations 33
References 34
AbouttheAuthor 40
PE-A5380-1
Formoreinformationonthispublication,visit
/t/PEA5380-1.
AboutRAND
RANDisaresearchorganizationthatdevelopssolutionstopublicpolicychallengestohelpmakecommunitiesthroughouttheworldsaferandmoresecure,healthierandmoreprosperous.RANDisnonprofit,nonpartisan,andcommittedtothepublicinterest.TolearnmoreaboutRAND,visit
.
ResearchIntegrity
OurresearchintegrityisgroundedinRAND’scorevaluesofqualityandobjectivity.Rigorousqualityassuranceprocedures,conflictofinterestscreening,andtransparencyinfundingensurethateverystudyisobjectiveandnonpartisan.Learnmoreat
/integrity.
RAND’spublicationsdonotnecessarilyreflecttheopinionsofitsresearchclientsandsponsors.
PublishedbytheRANDCorporation,SantaMonica,Calif.
©2026RANDCorporation
RANDeisaregisteredtrademark.
LimitedPrintandElectronicDistributionRights
Thispublicationandtrademark(s)containedhereinareprotectedbylaw.ThisrepresentationofRANDintellectualpropertyisprovidedfornoncommercialuseonly.Unauthorizedpostingofthispublicationonlineisprohibited;linkingdirectlytoitswebpage
on
isencouraged.PermissionisrequiredfromRANDtoreproduce,orreuseinanotherform,anyofitsresearchproductsforcommercialpurposes.Forinformationonreprintandreusepermissions,visit
/about/publishing/permissions.
iii
AboutThisPaper
Althoughformidablefuturecapabilitiesoffrontiermodelsareattractingregulatoryproposals,I
argueinthispaperthatopen-weightmodelsandagents“behindthefrontier”presentclearandpresentdangersthatdemandmuchmoreattentionandadifferentmindset◆
Thepowerofopen-weightmodelsandagentsderivesnotfromextraordinaryintelligencebutfromamplificationofordinaryintelligenceembeddedinmachines◆Theimportantqualitiesofmachines—theartificialinartificialintelligence(AI)—arespeedofdissemination,diversification,replicability,
operationalspeed,extraordinarymemory,andlowmarginalcost◆Withoutthesecharacteristics,AIwouldbejustavaluedtool;withthem,AIisatransformativeforce◆
Behindthefrontier,thisforceissubjecttomisuse,accidents,andlossofcontrol◆Userscanremoveguardrailsfromopen-weightmodelsandoperatethemwithoutoversightorevenvisibility◆Agents
operatewithlimitedoversightbutgreatcapacityforduplicitouscollectiveaction◆AIisashape-shiftingswarm:anarrayofthousandsofmodelsandmillionsofagentswithcharacteristicsthatunpredictablyvaryandevolve◆
GovernanceisfurthercomplicatedbecauseAIaffectspoliticaltrustanddiscourse◆Moreover,althoughAIisimmenselydangerousifnotcontrolledbygovernment,governmentsareimmenselydangerousiftheycontrolAI◆
ThechallengesfortheU◆S◆governmentareparticularlygreatbecauseitrequiresconsensusina
systemofdividedpowerandchecksandbalances◆Weareabouttodiscover—and,ifweareforward-thinking,toshape—whathappenswhenanirresistible,multifaceted,21st-centuryforcemeetsaslow-moving,complex,18th-centuryobject◆
CenterfortheGeopoliticsofArtificialGeneralIntelligence
RANDGlobalandEmergingRisksisadivisionofRANDthatdeliversrigorousandobjective
publicpolicyresearchonthemostconsequentialchallengestocivilizationandglobalsecurity◆This
workwascommissionedbythedivision’sCenterfortheGeopoliticsofArtificialGeneralIntelligence(AGI),whichiscommittedtohelpingdecisionmakersunderstand,anticipate,andpreparetonavigatethenationalsecurityandgeopoliticalimplicationsofAGI◆Thecenterconvenesleadingtechnologists,strategists,economists,politicalscientists,andoutsideexpertstoconsiderthefeasibilityand
effectivenessofprospectiveAGI-enabledcapabilities;thedomesticandinternationalimplicationsoftheiruse;andthestrategiesandpoliciesthatgovernments,businesses,andcivilsocietycouldadopttorespondtonewrealities◆Formoreinformation,visit
www◆rand◆org/geopolitics-of-agi◆
iv
Funding
ThiseffortwasindependentlyinitiatedandmadepossiblebyRAND’sownresources,includingincomefromoperations,unrestrictedgiftsfromRANDsupporters,anddistributionsfromitslong-
terminvestmentfund◆Acompletelistofdonorsandfundersisavailableat
www◆rand◆org/about/how-
we-are-funded
◆RANDclients,donors,andgrantorshavenoinfluenceoverresearchfindingsor
recommendations◆
Acknowledgments
ChristineFox,JimGosler,andJimMillerattheJohnsHopkinsUniversityAppliedPhysics
Laboratorywereexceptionallyencouragingandhelpfulasthispaperwentthroughmany(toomany!)drafts◆AtRAND,JimMitre,JoelPredd,andGopalSarmawereremarkablysupportive◆PeterLevin(AmidaTechnologySolutions)readandimprovedanunconscionablenumberofdrafts◆Iam
especiallygratefultothesesevenindividualsandtoEmmaBorden,BrianDau,andSeanMintusforpreparingthispaperforpublication◆IamalsothankfulforveryhelpfulcommentsfromSalman
Ahmed,BebaCibralic,RichGirvin,BillMarcellino,MichaelRich,andTobiasSytsmaatRANDandfromJamesAdams(DemocracyProject),JohnBarry(TulaneUniversity),AndrewBurt
(Luminos◆AI),HopeDancy(UniversityofChicago),TeoDimov(YaleUniversity),MiekeEoyang
(CarnegieMellonUniversity),TomFreedman(FreedmanConsulting),CraigFields(formerly
DefenseScienceBoard),KathleenFisher(Aria),EliMcGraw(IndianaUniversity),EmmyProbasco(CenterforSecurityandEmergingTechnology),HelenToner(CenterforSecurityandEmerging
Technology),AdamWilkins(HumboldtUniversity),andBobWork(JohnsHopkinsUniversity
AppliedPhysicsLaboratory)◆Anthropic’sClaudeplayedtheroleofavaluedseniorcolleague,
commentingondrafts,suggestingsources,andofferingeditorialsuggestions◆Obviously,responsibilityforthispaperismine◆
vi
1
SettlementandGovernanceBehindtheAIFrontier
FrederickJacksonTurnerrecognizedin1893thatthephysicalfrontiershapedAmericanthoughtandthattheresultingwaysofthinkingwouldoutlastthefrontieritself◆AfterChatGPTappearedinNovember2022,frontierlabssimilarlycapturedthemindsetofleadersinU◆S◆corporations,policy
institutes,academia,andgovernment◆
1
Aclusterofideasisassociatedwiththisfocusonthedigitalfrontier◆Theyareasfollows:
•Thepowerofartificialintelligence(AI)islargelydeterminedbymaximizingintelligence◆
•Theprimarymeanstothisendisthroughtheaggregationandintegrationoflargenumbersofsemiconductorsprocessingverylargedatabases(scalinglaws)◆
•Aphasechangeincapabilitycouldbereachedbyachievingartificialgeneralintelligence
(AGI),artificialsuperintelligence(ASI),orrecursiveself-improvement(RSI);thefirstnationorcompanytoreachthesestageswillbeabletodominatetrailingcompetitors◆
•TheU◆S◆governmentshouldsupport,oratleastnotimpede,progresstowardthesestages,anditshoulddirectitsplanningandregulatoryeffortstowardtheanticipatedphasechange◆
•ThechallengeofgovernancerequiresthattheU◆S◆governmentmonitortheprogressof
frontierlaboratoriesastheyimproveAIandpossiblydevelopasuperintelligenceandrequiresthatthegovernmentrespondwithastrategysomewhereonthespectrumfromlaissez-fairetonationalization◆Thatstrategywouldusetheresourcesofthegovernmentandofcoursebe
updatedorrevisedasexperiencerequires◆
Thesefiveideasarecredibleanduseful◆Theyworktogetherlikethefingersofahand,enablingustograspaspectsofarevolutionarytechnology◆
However,fiveotherideasarealsorequiredtocomprehendwhatishappening—particularlyas
enterprisesareproliferatingand“settling”behindthefrontier◆Eachoftheseideasisdiscussedina
separatesection◆Thefirstfoursectionsareanalytic;thefifthandlongestsectionispredictive,radicallyprescriptive,andraisesmoreissuesthanitresolves◆Thesectionsmaybesummarizedasfollows◆
Inthefirstsection,Iassertthatwhileintelligenceisthedefiningcharacteristicofwhatis,afterall,artificialintelligence,muchofthepowerofAIcomesfromtheartificial:thatis,fromtheemergenceofintelligencenotasafreestandingentityorasanamplifierinhumansbutinmachines◆Idescribethe
paththatledtothisresultandthenuseNewton’ssecondlaw—forceisaproductofmasstimes
acceleration—asananalogyforunderstandingthepoweroflargelanguagemodels(LLMs):AnLLM’sforceisaproductnotonlyofitsmassofintelligencebutofthatmassmultipliedbyahalfdozen
accelerantsandamplifiersthatarisefromembeddingintelligenceinmachines◆Theseaccelerantsare
1ThisdiscussionisfocusedontheUnitedStates,buttheimplicationsextendinternationally.
2
speedofdissemination,diversification,replicability,operationalspeed,extraordinarymemory,andlowmarginalcost◆Withoutthem,AIwouldbeonlyavaluedaid◆Withtheseattributes,AIisa
transformativeforce◆
Thefactthattheaccelerantsareoftenassociatedwithsoftwarepointstoanimportantgeneral
proposition,discussedinthesecondsection◆Hardware(semiconductors)isfoundationalforAI,butasecondparent—software—powerfullyshapesAI’scharacter,development,andfuture◆AIfitshandinglovewithaworldstructuredaroundsoftware◆ThefinancialandlabormarketsthatpowerAI
originatedinthesoftwarerevolutionthatbeganinthe1990s◆Asoftwarecreation(theinternet)
providesthedatathatfuelLLMs◆Asystembuiltforsoftware—millionsofmilesoffiber-opticcableleftdarkduringthedot-combubble—positionsAIdevelopersasHenryFordwouldhavebeenifacontinentalnetworkofpavedhighwayshadexistedbeforethemassproductionofautomobiles◆
Softwaretoolsareusedtodesignandredesignthemachinesthemselves◆Formany,the
contributionofalgorithmswillbenosurprise,butthe“bitterlesson”that“scaling”hardwareanddatadriveAI’sprogressstillleadstorecurringunderestimationofthepowerofsoftware◆Forexample,AI’sdisseminationhasbeencomparedtoelectricity,butsoftwarediffusioncanbenearlyinstantaneous,
anditsabsorptioncanbeacceleratedbytheflexibilitywithwhichuserscanadaptit◆Similarly,whiletherapidriseofunicornscouldmarkanAIbubble,
2
theyarealsoanaturalattributeofsoftware-
drivenenterprises:High-speedproduction,quickdistribution,andlowcostsofcapitalandlaboraresteroidsforstart-ups◆Inathirdexampleoftheunderestimationofsoftware,Chinesecompanieshavestayedclosertothefrontierthanmanywouldhaveexpectedevenwithlimitedaccesstocutting-edgesemiconductors◆
Mostsignificantly,AI’sdiffusionassoftwareempowersuserstoreprogramopen-weightmodelsandconsequentlymultiplyAIopportunitiesandrisks◆Forexample,largepharmaceuticalcompanies,academics,andstart-upsallovertheglobecanremoveguardrailsastheyracetocreateandtestnew
biologicalentities◆AdvocatesofapauseintheprogressofAIorofmoreregulationoffrontiermodelstoconstrainbiologicalterrorismmustrecognizethatsoftwarediffusionhasalreadycreateddiversified,low-visibility,widelydistributed,andirreversiblerisksfromwell-intendedactors◆Herdsofhorses
havealreadyleftthebarnsthataretheintensefocusofpublicdebate◆
Third,assuggestedbelow,AGI,ASI,andRSImayneverbeachievedasnowenvisioned◆But,
evenifthatwereso,thesteadyadvancetowardthesegoalsthroughincreasedautomationofsoftwarewilllikelybetransformative,as,analogously,theheatingofwaterhasconsiderableconsequences
beforeitreaches(andevenifitneverreaches)thephasechangeofboiling◆Theresultingpowerof
LLMsisnowmanifestinamannerdifferentfromtheunifiedsingleintelligenceofAGI:throughthedivision,delegation,andcoordinationofagentsoperatingthroughsoftware,sometimesdeceptivelyandcollectively◆Thiscollectivesuperintelligenceisalreadyhere;itisjustwidelydistributed◆
Fourth,becauseAI’sextraordinarypowerisnotlikelytobecapturedinasingledominantmodel,AIisbestunderstoodasashape-shiftingswarm◆Itisalargearrayofthousandsofmodels,millionsofagents,andinnumerableharnessesandapplications—withcharacteristicsthatvary,evolve,and
competewithoneanotherinever-changingandunpredictableways◆Incombination,thisecosystem
2Unicornreferstoaprivatecompanyvaluedatmorethan$1billion.
3
achievesemergenteffectsthatarefeltnotonlydramaticallybutalsosubtly—asaseriesoftsunamis,butalsobyoozing,asteadypermeationofnearlyallaspectsofhumaninteraction.
Thispermeationpushesadifferentsetofriskstothefore.Althoughthepriorityrisksatthe
frontierarenationalsecurity,cybersecurity,biosecurity,andcontrolofrunawaysystems,behindthefrontiertheserisksareovershadowedbynear-termconcernsover,forexample,jobdisplacement,
environmentalandenergycosts,andsuicideorwithdrawalbyyoungusers.Furtherinthefuture—butatpresenttoolittleconsidered—arelikelydebatesaboutthewaysinwhichAImayshapepublic
understanding,renderingpoliticaldiscourse,forexample,moreorlesstrusted,moreorlessfragmented,andmoreorlessconducivetohumanparticipation.
Fifth,thepreviousobservationsshouldalertusthatgovernmentscannotsimplyplanforfutureevents.Theneedforgovernanceisclearandpresent.Thepossibilityofalaterphasechangeyieldingstrategicsupremacycannotdistractusfromimmediaterisksandopportunities.
SeveralinvestmentsurgentlyneedtobemadetoextendthecapabilitiesoftheU.S.governmenttocomprehend,channel,andcontrolAIsystems.AIsystemsthemselvesmustbeusedtothisend.
Amongotherthings,theU.S.governmentshouldroutinelyreviewAImodelsbeforedistributionand,moreradically(incasesoflargemodelimprovement),shouldnotpermitthereleaseofanymodeluntilasuperiorversionofthatmodelisinhand.
Theseimprovementslargelytargetthefrontier,however.Eveniftheyareachieved,theU.S.
governmentwillnotbeabletokeeppacewiththespeedofautomateddevelopmentanddisseminationorwiththemagnitude,variety,andglobaldistributionofopen-weightmodelsandderivativeagents.Innumerablehigh-speedinteractionsbetweenhumanandsiliconthinkerswillrequireawebof
governancebroaderthangovernmentregulation.Thiswebwillresemblethemixofcommerciallaw,insurancerequirements,standards,norms,andreputationalconsiderationsthatshapetheglobal
economymorethananysingleregulatoryscheme.And,aswiththeglobaleconomy,competition—usingmultiplesystemstocheckandcounterbalanceoneanother—islikelytobeamoreeffective
constraintthantop-downcontrol.
Experiencewiththeglobaleconomyshouldbeinstructiveinanotherway.AIgovernancewillbemuchmorethanatwo-partyinteractionbetweengovernmentsandcorporations:Constituenciesthataredamagedorsimplylessfavoredwilldisrupttheplansofboth.
FocusingontheUnitedStates,thediscussionsketcheshowAIwillintensifypreexistingproblems:forexample,inthesocialsecurity,healthcare,andtaxsystemstiedtoanormoffull-timeemployment.TheseproblemswillintertwinewiththechallengesofAIitself.Ashortlistofchallengesprovidedherelooksoverwhelming.PresentdiscussionsofAIregulationarenarrowandinadequatewhencomparedwiththemagnitudeoftheseproblems.TherevolutionwroughtbyAIwillalsoaffecttrustinpoliticaldiscourse.AllthesefactorssuggestthatAIwilldemandarevolutioningovernance.Thatrevolution
willhavetograpplewithhardtruths.Foremostamongthem:AIisimmenselydangerousifuncontrolledbygovernment;governmentisimmenselydangerousifitcontrolsAI.
4
1.ThePowerIntelligenceGainsfromBeinginaMachine
TheForkintheRoad:IntelligenceEmbeddedinMachines
EarlyvisionsofAIdividedalongafundamentalaxis◆Onetradition—exemplifiedbyLicklider’s“Man-ComputerSymbiosis”andEngelbart’saugmentationresearchatSRIInternational—conceivedAIasaprostheticfortheintellect◆
3
Justaseyeglassesextendvisionandcochlearimplantshelpwith
soundperception,computationaltoolswouldamplifyhumanreasoningwhileleavingthehumanat
thecenter◆Theothertradition,associatedwithfourleaderswhoorganizedtheseminal1956
DartmouthworkshoponAIandwiththesymbolicAIprogramattheMassachusettsInstituteof
Technology,pursuedmachineintelligenceasanindependentsimulationofthehumanmind◆Decadeslater,thescaledsystemsthatemergedweresystemsofthesecondkind:notamplifiersofparticular
humanmindsbutautonomousreasonerstrainedontheaggregateoutputofhumanthought◆
Philosophically,thinkingmachineschallengetheconceptionofhumansasuniquelyendowedtocomprehendandreshapetheworld;thesemachinesundermineapremiseoftheEnlightenmentthatfosteredtheircreation◆Onereactionistodenythatwhatthesemachinesdois“thinking◆”Anotheristoanthropomorphizemachines◆
Formostpurposes,thekeyfactisoperational,notontological◆
4
Regardlessofhowsiliconthinkersdifferfromhumanthinkers,theoutcomesthatsiliconthinkersproduceperformfunctionscommonlydescribedasthinking◆
Whennewinstrumentsachieveadesiredendbymeansthatarenovel,thatfactattractsour
attention◆Butquickly,asnewmechanismsbecomefamiliar,wegivelittleemphasistohowtheywork◆Wedefineamedicaloperationbyitsfunction,regardlessofwhetherasurgeonusesalaserorascalpel◆Proponentsofsundialswouldstrikeusastroglodytesiftheydeniedthatapendulumkeepstime
becauseitworksdifferently,requireswinding,andissubjecttocharacteristicerrors◆Apendulumandsundialarebothtimemeasurers;alaserandscalpelarebothsurgicalinstruments◆
HumansandLLMsarenowboththinkersbecausetheybothperformfunctionsweregardas
thinking◆ApredictionAlanTuringmadein1950—“Ibelievethatattheendofthecenturytheuseofwordsandgeneraleducatedopinionwillhavealteredsomuchthatonewillbeabletospeakof
machinesthinkingwithoutexpectingtobecontradicted”
5
—hascometopass,evenifaquartercenturyorsobehindhisschedule◆Hisfamoustest—couldamachinebedistinguishedfromahumanwhen
bothansweredquestionsbehindacurtain?—hasbeenmet◆
6
Incarefullycontrolledfive-minuteexperiments“[w]henpromptedtoadoptahumanlikepersona,GPT-4◆5wasjudged[byahuman
3Grudin,“AIandHCI,”tracesthisdivergence,notingthatLinklaterandothersthoughtoftheirworkason“human-computerinteraction◆”Foramoreextendeddiscussion,seeMarkoff,MachinesofLovingGrace◆
4Inthisconsequentialistapproach,IfollowDanielDennett(see,e◆g◆,Dennett,TheIntentionalStance)◆Idefinethinkingasreasoningfromapremiseoraproblemtoanobservationorhypothesisforactionthatislikelytofurtherstatedpriorities◆
5Turing,“ComputingMachineryandIntelligence,”p◆442◆
6Turing,“ComputingMachineryandIntelligence◆”Turingbeganhisessaybysaying,“Iproposetoconsiderthequestion,íCanmachinesthink?’”butconcludedthatadefinitionalapproachwouldbeunrewarding◆Heproposedhistestinstead◆
5
interrogator]tobethehuman73%ofthetime:significantlymoreoftenthaninterrogatorsselectedtherealhumanparticipant◆”7
Mostrelevanttopolicymakers,millionsofpeopleareusingLLMstoprovideideas,critiques,andadvice(evencompanionship!)thatwerepreviouslyexclusivelysoughtfromhumanthinkers◆The
singlemostimportanttechnologicalfactatthestartofthesecondquarterofthe21stcenturyisthis:
Silicon,aswellascarbon,thinkersarenowwidelyemployedtoperformtasksthat,formillennia,wehavecalledthinking◆
Thisnewworlddeservesanewacronym:CAST(CarbonandSiliconThinkers)◆Theacronymcanalsoserveasametaphor◆Anexpandedensembleofcharacters—CarbonandSiliconThinkers,orCAST—isperformingonthegreatstageoftheearth◆8Thisperformanceopensimmense
opportunitiesforbigger,better,andquitedifferentproductions;multipletheaters;greatlyreducedcosts;andmagicaleffects◆9Forhumansasconsumers,itiswonderful◆Butforhumansasproducers,directors,andactors,itischallenging,disruptive,anddisorienting◆
TheSixMachineCharacteristicsThatAmplifyIntelligence
Theideathatsiliconhasacapacityforthoughtissoastonishingthatwedevotemostofour
attentiontotheintelligenceinartificialintelligenceandundervaluehowmuchofAI’spowerderives
fromitsartificiality—thefactthatitisembeddedinmachines◆ButAImaybethoughtofasaforce
generatedbyanequationlikeNewton’ssecondlaw:Forceequalsmasstimesacceleration◆Themassinathinkingmachineisitsintelligence—acapabilitybroughtintobeingbysemiconductors,energy,
data,andtraining◆Givencomputationalcapacity,10ahalfdozenotherfactorsoperateasaccelerants,amplifyingthatcapability◆11
7JonesandBergen,“LargeLanguageModelsPasstheTuringTest,”p.1.Amongseveralinformativeinsights,JonesandBergen
foundreasonclasseswhichweremostcorrelatedwithaccurateverdicts.Reasonsfocusedonquestion
handling(e.g.“WitnessBalwaysasksquestionback”)andlackofknowledge(“Theydidn’tknowsomethingthatanyAIshouldknow.”,“IchoseWitnessBbecausetheymadeanerror,whichmadeWitnessBfeelmorehuman.”)tendedtobethemostaccurate.ThelatterhighlightsthecomplexityoftheTuringtestformodernLLMs,whichmustappeartofeignignoranceontopicsmostpeoplearenotknowledgeableabout.”(JonesandBergen,“LargeLanguageModelsPasstheTuringTest,”p.7)
8And,increasingly,inspace.
9DavidAutoradmirablyremindsus,
Thegoalofmachinesshouldnotbetojustdowhatpeopledoslightlybetter.Ourtoolsarevaluabletous
becausetheyallowustodothingswecan’tdo.Somanytechnologiesenablecapabilitiesthatwesimplydon’tpossess.Poweredflightdidn’tautomatethewayweusedtofly.Wejustdidn’tfly.
Andthat’strueformostofmoderntechnologies.They’reimportantandconsequential,notbecausetheydothesameoldthingbetter,cheaper,faster,butbecausetheyenableustodothingswecouldn’tdo,
telecommunication,flight,fightingdiseasewithpenicillin,seeingtheinsidesoftheinteriorsofsubatomic
particles,designing,computingthingsthatwecouldneverinalifetimecompute.(AutorandFrueh,“HowIsAIShapingtheFutureofWork?”)
10Despiteimmenseinvestments,thedemandforcomputationalcapacitystillexceedsthesupply,forcingthosewhocontrolcapacitytorationitbetweenalternativeusesandusers.
11Andthemassofintelligencehasnoneoftheinertialresistancethatmustbeovercometosetphysicalobjectsinmotion.
6
Theseaccelerantsarespeedofdissemination,diversification,replicability,operationalspeed,
extraordinarymemory,andlowmarginalcost.Withoutthem,machineintelligencewouldbejustanaid.Withthem,itisaformidableforce.
SpeedofDissemination
Softwareisunprecedentedasameansofdistribution:ItcannearlyinstantaneouslyplaceAIinthehandsofuserswhileremainingconnectedtostorageandupdatingcapabilitiesprovidedbyamodel’svendororthroughathird-partycloud.ComparisonsofAItothespreadofelectrificationorcell-
phonedisseminationundervaluethespeed,ease,andeconomyofthismodeofdistribution.ChatGPThad1millionusersinaweek;
12
100millionuserswithinaboutsixtydays;and,byearly2025,500
millionweeklyusers.
13
Microsoftconcludedin2025that“roughlyoneinsixpeopleworldwide[is]nowusinggenerativeAItools.”
14
HalfofallAmericansqueriedinJuly2026saidtheyusedAIthatmonth.
15
Thisconnectivityfacilitatesupdates,subscriptionrevenue,usagemonitoring,and
decentralizedadaptationandassimilation.
Speedofdisseminationhasayetmoresignificantconsequence.Ithasbeenobservedthatas
scienceprogresses,thespeedofscienceprogresses.Thespeedofdisseminationthroughmachines
permitsrapidlytranslatingcutting-edgeprogressintoapplications:Settlements,sotospeak,quickly
followandareclosetothefrontier.Proliferationofthesesettlementsamplifiesdisruptiveeffects,
outracesgovernmentabilitiestoregulate,andstrainsinventors’abilitytoforeseeandmanageusesandabuses.
Diversification
Twoorthreeyearsago,itwasplausibletoarguethatmachineintelligencewouldremain
concentratedinahandfuloffrontierlabsproducingasmallnumberofdominantmodels.Thatclaimisalreadydated.Acarefullymeasured2025forecastanticipatedthat,bytheendof2028,therewouldbe45to148models(themedianpredictionwas81models)exceedingthecomputethresholdthat
triggeredexistingU.S.exportcontrols;againstthemorerestrictiveEUthreshold,therangewas103to306(median:165).Theresearchersnotedthatthisgrowthisnotmerelylargebutacceleratingyear
12ClayShirkyputsitwell:
TakeyourmindbacktoThanksgivingdinnerof2022andimagineoneoftheguestsaskingthetablewhenanAIyoucouldtalktowouldgettoamillionusers.Theguessesmighthavecoveredtheusualrange—widely
adoptedAImightbetwoyears
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 市场策略执行与销售成果绩效评定表
- 网络游戏开发团队产品交付率绩效指标表
- 事业单位计算机岗专业面试2026强化训练试卷及答案
- 事业单位文秘岗2026面试全真模拟题库及解析
- 事业单位护理岗面试结构化问答2026经典考题全真模拟试卷及答案
- 事业单位财会岗面试易错题2026专项考题试卷及解析
- 事业单位文秘岗2026面试结构化问答试卷及解析
- 事业单位财会岗面试2026面试高频考题题库及答案
- 初中生物教资面试试讲历年真题题库及解析
- 事业单位财会岗面试历年真题题库及答案
- (一模)宁波市2026~2027学年第一学期高三高考模拟考试物理试卷(含答案)
- 2026-2027学年度秋季统编版语文五年级上册第五单元素养测评卷(含答案)
- 教育信息化与教育技术发展应用方案
- 我是自律小达人 小学生自我管理课件
- 初级日语(N5水平)综合测试题(含详细答案解析)
- 高三语文二轮复习复合文本观点互证评析专题教学设计
- GB/T 11091-2024电缆用铜带箔材
- 组织员述职报告
- 第四章 戏曲与曲艺 《音乐鉴赏》大学音乐课件
- 中国华电集团公司材料费检修费限额标准
- YY/T 0003-1990病床
评论
0/150
提交评论