SCI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板大全

1、SCI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板大全修改稿回答审稿人的意见（最重要的部分）List of ResponsesDear Editors and Re vie we rs:Thank you for your letter and for the re vie we rscomments concerning our manuscriptentitled Taper Title55（ID:文章稿号）.Those comments are all valuable and very helpful forrevisingand improving our paper, as well as the

2、 importantguiding significance to our researches.We have studied comments carefully and have made correction which we hope meet withapproval. Revised portion are marked in red in the paperThe main conections in the paper andthe responds to the re vie we r comments are as flowing:Responds to the re v

3、ie we r5s comments:Reviewer #1:1. Response to comment:,（简要列出意见，）Response: xxxxx2. Response to comment:,（简要列出意见，）Response: xxxxx逐条意见回答，切忌一定不能有遗漏 针对不同的问题有下列几个礼貌术语可适当用用We are very sorry for our negligence ofWe are very sorry for our incorrect writingIt is really true as Reviewer suggested thatWe have m

4、ade correction according to the Re vie wers commentsWe have re - writte n this part according to the Re vie wers suggestionAs Reviewer suggested that .Considering the Reviewer，ssuggestion, we have最后特意感谢一下这个审稿人的意见：Special thanks to you for your good commentsRe vie wer #2:同上述Re vie wer #3:xxxxxxOther

5、changes:1. Line 6061, the statements of“.” we re corrected as “.2. Line 107,u.” was added3. Line 129,“.” was deletedxxxxxxWe tried our best to improve the manuscript and made some changes in themanuscript. These changes will not influence the content and framework of thepaper. And here we did not li

6、st the changes but marked in red in re vis e d paper.We appreciate for Editors/Re viewers warm5work earnestly, and hope that the correctionwill meet with approval.Once again, thank you very much for your comments and suggestions以下是审稿人意见和本人的回复。与大家分享。从中可以看出，这位审稿人认真读了文章，提出很多宝贵的意见。这些意见 分布在文章的各个地方。我很诧异有人

7、真正读了我的文章。看到这些意见， 我觉得很感激，不是因为接收文章的原因，而是这些意见能真正有助于提高 文章的质量。从中还看出，回答审稿人问题的“技巧”。对于回答问题，有的人就是一味反驳，却不加改进。记得ACS Style Guide里面说，当审稿人问到问题的，哪怕是他理解错误， 也说明作者这么写，其他读者也会理解错误，引起歧义。因此，作者就是要 修改句子，使表达不引起歧义。因此：有时间一味反驳，还不如指出具体改进在第几页、第几段。Reviewers comments:Re vie wer #3: While re vis ing the script, it is to be suggeste

8、d that author should clearlyindicate the aim & scope of the study and while making conclusion, it is to be mentioned howthe study is useful for the practical purposesIn addition the following are the fewsuggestions/comments, which may be included while re vis ion.1. Introduction part first para

9、last line, author must avoid to write ambiguousstatement i.e., much work is still ahead, may indicate properly.8. Pages 14 through 17: the observed reactivity of various solvents for adsorbed2. Author could not demonstrate the reason why, to select the organic compound such asethyl pyruvate for this

10、 study?3. Experimental part: It is difficult to understand the in-situ RAIRS experiments withhomemade liquid-solid RAIRS cell. More detailed information may be useful for the othersthose who are working in the area. Photograph of the assembled cell may be included4. The description given for the exp

11、erimental set up (page 4) can be presented by flowdiagram instead, as an ease to understand the set up.5. Re sluts Part (Page 6): CO adlayers with identical monolayer coverages, themonolayer coverage, is it been performed with some adsorption model? Further, it wassuggestedthat CO-saturated Pt surfa

12、ce, but not mentioned about the saturation experimentsIsit obtained after 60 min of CO bubbling?6. Page 12, 2nd para: The displacement of EtPy by CC14 flushing, is it confirmed by theEtPy peaks? If so, it has to be mentioned clearly in the para. Also in the same para, authorreferred for Fig. 7a and

13、7b but in the figures, it didnt appear, only figure 7 appearedI住el itrefers for figure 7, portion A and B, to be corrected. Similarly, inthe text referred the fig 2a, 2betc but on the figure sheet it is mentioned as 2A, 2Betctobe corrected.7. Page 14, 1st para: contamination of the Pt surface by cor

14、rosion of o-rings in highconcentration EtPy；but the statement has not been supported by other evidence /lite ra tu reCO onthe Pt surface (figs3 &4)has tobediscussed more pre cisel y.This revie we r isunable to followthe reason why they showed different reactivity, is it principally due to the or

15、ganic moieties, or due to theimpurities of commercially available chemicals or a mixed effect. It has to be c le a rly demonstrated, howe ve r, the only experiment performed with CO/water? CC14 would difficult to describe it in detail9. The author try to restrain with repeated arguments in the text

16、e.g., page 3 para1: It was generalized that., also appeared on page 21 first para10. Captions of the figures are too long, the detailed description a heady given in the text, hencewould not be included here. Captions should be short and crispy.Dear Editor,I quite appreciate your favorite considerati

17、on and the re vie we rJinsightfulcommentsNow I have re vis e d the JCIS06247 exactly according to the re vie we r scomments, and found these comments are ve ry helpful. I hope this re vis ion can make my paper moreacceptableThe re vis ions were addressed point by point below.general The objective of

18、 this research was added at the beginning of the third paragraph ofIntroduction. How the study is useful for practical purposes was added at the end of Conclusion as oneparagraph.1 Ambiguous statement i.e.,“ much work is still ahead” was deleted.2 Ethyl pyruvate was used here as a typical compound (

19、containing two carbonyl groups) todemonstrate the feasibility of using our diagnosing tool to detect low-cove rage CO (coming from decarbonylation of EtPy) at the liquid-solid interfaceEtPy is a reactant usedin liquid-phase chiral catalysis, and slight decomposition of EtPy to adsorbed CO was report

20、ed to influencethe catalytic performanceIn addition,by studying that, we can diiectly compare our resuIts with previous studiesMore details in the firstparagraph of Section 3.2.3 The IR cell was designed according to the IR cells used by many electrochemical worke rsReferences we re added. A photo w

21、as given in the Supporting Information.4 A flow diagram of the experimental setup was given in the new Fig1.5The CO adsorption experiments were performed in the same adsorption mode, by bubbling COthrough a clean Pt surface in different days to achieve the samesaturation coverage of CO. Initial expe

22、riments indicated that given the CO bubbling rate was 0.85cm3/min, CO can saturate on Pt after 30-45 min. We bubble CO for 60 min to guarantee the same CO coverageIf we bubble CO for more time, or if we increase the CO flowing rate several times, the COsaturation coverage doesntchange, indicating 60

23、 min is already enough. A figure showing the CO uptake as a function of bubblingtime was given in the Supporting Information.6J The displacement of EtPy by CC14 was confirmed by the removing of EtPypeaks. The mention of Fig. 7a and 7b etc. throughout the te xt we re all corrected.7It is known that s

24、ome solvents such as acetone can corrode the Viton o-ring.We saw the damage of o-ring after using highconcentnition EtPyA reference to theViton o-ring information was given.8The observed reactivity trend is due to a combination of both effects, withthe accumulation of organic moieties on Pt surface

25、during numerous flushing cyclesthe more important reason. A few proper sentences we re added to clarity this point.9The repeated arguments in the first paragraph in Section 4.3 were deleted.10 The too-long captions were significantly shortened.In all, I found the re vie we rs comments are quite help

26、ful, and I re vis e d my paperpoint-by-point Thank you and the re vie w again for your help!结果:/10.1016/j.jcis .2006.09.005欢迎浏览：Organic Che mis try on Solid Surfaces (Review)乙Ma, F. Zaera* Surface Scence Reports 61 (2006) 229-281.ScienceDiiect TOP25 Hottest Article s in Che mis tryht

27、tp:/dx.doi.Org/10.1016/i.surfirep.2006.03.001CI修改稿回答审稿人意见范文模板修改稿回答审稿人的意见（最重要的部分）List of ResponsesDear Editors and Re vie we rs:Thank you for your le tter and for the re vie wers comments concerning our manuscript entitledPaper Title （ID:文章稿号）.Those comments are all valuable and very helpful for revi

28、sing andimproving our paper, as well as the important guiding significance to our researchesWe have studiedcomments carefully and have made correction which we hope meet with approval. Revised portion aremarked in red in the paperThe main corrections in the paper and the responds to the re vie we r commentsare as flowing:Responds to the re vie we r s comments:Reviewer #1:1. Response to comment:,（简要列出意见,）Response: X x X X X2. Response to comment:,（简要列出意见，）Response: X x X X X逐条意见回答，切忌一定不能有遗漏针对不同的问题有下列几个礼貌术语可适当用用:We are