全文预览已结束
下载本文档
版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
WHY PLASTIC SHOPPING BAG BANS AND TAXES DONT WORKThere are no magic bullets or simple answers to product stewardship and protecting the environment. The idea of banning products to protect the environment is a simplistic attempt to find a solution to a very complex problem. They are not based on science or fact and have a number of negative consequences that hurt consumers, retailers and the environment.The issue of plastic bag bans and de facto bans like taxes have been studied intensely around the world. Scotlands all-party Environment and Rural Development Committee (ERDC) spent two years in hearings on the Irish bag tax (de facto ban). They concluded that it had a number of unintended negative consequences that hurt consumers, retailers and the environment and should be rejected. These unintended consequences are what the Rt Hon Ben Bradshaw, UK Environment Minister called “disbenefits” for the environment. “I think the problem here is that although a lot of people are superficially attracted to a plastic bag tax ban when you do what is called a life cycle analysis of the overall environmental impact of such a tax ban, Im afraid it is not as clear cut as some people think.” (4 August 2006)Decisions made in the name of the environment should be based on science and fact, and a full, public discussion and analysis of their intended and unintended consequences can hurt the environment. Experience shows that deselection or limiting consumer choice particularly when it comes to plastic shopping bags not only does not work, but can have a number of unintended consequences that will actually do more environmental harm. There are a full range of questions that need to be examined when looking at bans on plastic bags. Will a bag ban actually extend the life of a landfill? Will a ban on plastic shopping bags lead to consumption of more, not less plastic? Are the alternatives really better for the environment? What do bag bans teach people about personal responsibility and product stewardship? What is the real impact on the local business community? At a minimum, an environmental assessment should be undertaken to prove that the alternatives are not worse and will not create more problems for the environment.Bans/bag taxes have a completely opposite effect from what is intended and will generate more waste as consumers switch to other alternatives. Plastic shopping bags generally are a very small component of landfill; less than one percent. Removing them from landfill has little impact on the volume of solid waste going to landfill. Bans actually result in the consumption of more plastic and paper resulting in more waste going to landfill, not less.In Ireland, after the bag tax was introduced in 2002, consumers switched to different bag options to avoid the tax. They switched to heavy duty plastic bags, like kitchen catchers, for their household garbage. These heavier bags contain 81% more plastic that retail plastic carry bags.The end result was that the amount of plastic used in Ireland actually increased by 21 percent even though the number of plastic shopping bags handed out at check out decreased 90 percent. This resulted in a significant increase in the amount of material going into landfill not less. Bag bans negate traditional 3Rs environmental principles and discourage individual responsibility for reuse and recycling.Product stewardship starts with the individual and how they use their products. Consumers need to use their products wisely to extend the life of the resource as much as possible through reuse and recycling.Bags are an efficient tool to transport goods home from the store and can be used multiple times. Decima Research of Canadians shows that plastic shopping bags are not a single-use item; 80 percent of Canadians reuse their bags two or more times as lunch bags, tote bags, garbage bags, for storage, as kitchen catchers or to stoop and scoop. 73 percent also want the opportunity to recycle their bags. The bags can be recycled over and over again due to advances in technology and the creation of new plastic markets for the used bags. This is why the industry has worked so hard over the past 15 years to build recovery across the country through curbside and in-store programs. In Ontario, Stewardship Ontario data shows that 59.1% of plastic shopping bags distributed in Ontario are reused by consumers, as well as recycling rates of clean bags in the range of 20-30% in municipalities committed to recycling.The alternatives to plastic retail shopping bags reusables and paper - are worse for the environment. Reusables have a higher carbon footprint than plastic bags. Number one they are manufactured in China and have to be shipped thousands of miles to retailers in Canada. And reusables are not recyclable in Canada. They will either have to be shipped back to China for recycling or end up in landfill when they are thrown out by consumers into the garbage. 90% of plastic shopping bags are manufactured in Ontario and are completely recyclable here in Ontario at EFS Plastics in Elmira. Plastic shopping bags offer superior environmental performance to paper bags. A 2004 Ecobilan PwC, Paris Life Cycle Study comparing paper to plastic bags shows that paper bags are 5 to 6 times heavier by weight than plastic shopping bags. The manufacture of paper bags is also more energy intensive requiring 2.2 times more petroleum than plastic shopping bags. The weight and volume of paper versus plastic bags has environmental consequences in their transport because it takes 7 trucks to haul 2 million paper bags while it only takes 1 truck to haul the same number of plastic bags generating far more greenhouse gases. Plastic shopping bags are highly recyclable and are being recycled and remanufactured into new products creating green jobs.Recycling of plastic shopping bags and film is growing in leaps and bounds in Canada because of technology advances. Some parts of the country have had remarkable success on the recovery front; Nova Scotia recovers close to 45 percent of its bags; B.C. and Alberta over 30 percent; PEI 57%. And recycling creates green manufacturing jobs. More and more plastics recyclers are making investments in Canada and a national green infrastructure is emerging. Merlin Plastics located in B.C. and Alberta is the largest plastic bag and film recycler in the country. Inteplast in Atlantic Canada has a bag to bag program that turns used plastic shopping bags right back into new bags. EFS Plastics in Ontario takes plastic bags and film from many municipalities in Ontario and these bags are remanufactured into outdoor patio furniture, water pipes, flooring, office and garden supplies, plastic wood for decks and boardwalks. Torontos beaches boardwalk is made from recycled plastic shopping bags It is a $2 billion business across North America that keeps growing. The supply of recycled plastic film cannot keep up with demand. Bans and bag taxes (de facto bans) have been looked at and rejected by a number of organizations and municipalities in Canada as well as internationally.These include the Association of Manitoba Municipalities, the Federation of Canadian Municipalities , the GVRD (Greater Vancouver Regional District) Waste Management Committee, the City of Charlottetown, the Union of BC Municipalities (UBCM), the City of Sherbrooke, Montreal, Toronto, Hamilton, Sudbury, Sault Ste Marie, Peterborough, Simcoe County, Canmore, Capital Region District of Vancouver Island, Fraser Valley, Greenstone, the Province of Quebec and the Province of Manitoba to name a few. Internationally, they have been rejected by Norway, the U.K., Scotland, the EU, Taiwan and Australia. In fact, Taiwan lifted a plastic bag ban in the fast food industry after 4.5 years because it was a failed policy. The ban had a number of unintended consequences that hurt the environment - creating a “mountain of waste” (mainly paper) as consumers substituted paper for plastic bags. This combined with the increased transport of material resulted in a significant increase in greenhouse gas emissions. In a 2006 survey by the Taiwan Environment Quality Protection Foundation, 59 percent of respondents said that restricted use of plastic bags is a failed policy. Since lifting the ban, Taiwan has aggressively pursued the 3Rs launching in spring 2007 a massive bag recycling drive. A ban on plastic shopping bags will have a devastating impact on local retailers. A ban does not recognize that plastic shopping bags serve a very useful and important function. If bags are banned, consumers will seek alt
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 《婴幼儿心理发展》试卷答案
- 【2025年】职业病危害因素检测试题附答案
- 《医疗器械经营质量管理规范》试卷及答案
- (2025)新版消防设施操作员初级考试题库及参考答案
- (2025年)各高校辅导员考试实务试题及答案
- 《土地利用规划》期末复习题及答案
- 2020《饲料企业》饲料质量安全管理考试卷(含答案)
- 2025 年授权签字人试题及答案
- 执法证年度审验考试题库带答案
- 2026年氯化证考试题库及参考答案
- 2026国家电网公司北京电力医院招聘考试模拟试题及答案解析
- 九师联盟2027届高三11月联考历史+答案
- 体外诊断试剂药品培训试题及答案(新版)
- 湖南雅礼中学2027届高三月考试卷三语文试卷
- 2026-2027学年科粤版九年级上册化学期中测试卷解析版
- 《95128出租汽车电召平台服务规范(征求意见稿)》编制说明
- 2026年选矿工程师试题及答案
- 外协加工工艺统一规范细则
- 中国区域国别学全套教学课件
- 超声造影剂安全使用专家共识(2026版)
- JJG 1189.1-2026 测量用互感器检定规程 第1部分:标准电流互感器
评论
0/150
提交评论