BP辩手职责及评分标准.doc

BP辩手职责及评分标准Speaker辩手 Role and Responsibility角色及职责 Prime MinisterorLeader of the Government“首相”或“正方领袖” The first speakers responsibility is to represent a case supporting the motion.The primary role of Opening Proposition ream,initiated in this speech,is to establish the foundation for meaningful debate on the motion.第一个发言选手的职责是展开辩题。对于整个辩论的前半部分起着至关重要的作用。所以合理的角度、适当的陈述都可以为整个辩论开个好头。 Leader of the opposition“反方领袖” The Opening Oppositions primary team role is to counter the first Proposition teams case through direct or indirect refutation and/or provide substantive argument against the motion.反方开篇陈述的目的在于，直接或间接地驳斥正方提出的案例，或通过提出确凿的论据，反驳辩题。 Deputy Prime Minister“副首相” This speaker should refute the leader of the Oppositions speech,and further develop the Opening Proposition teams case.辩手应该驳斥反方领袖的发言，并进一步加强“首相”提出的内容。 Deputy Leader of the Opposition“反方第二领袖” This speaker supports his or her teammate,answering objections from the other side and introducing additional arguments or support.辩手应支持他/她的队友，答复对方辩手提出的疑问并且在驳论中添加新论点。 Member of the Government“正方成员” This speaker should support the position developed by the Opening Proposition team by introducing an extension. A successful extension will develop a distinct argument identity for the Closing Proposition team.The Member of the Proposition may also refute the arguments made by the Deputy Leader of the Opposition. 辩手应该通过引入一个延展案例来支持正方开篇陈述队伍的立场。一个有力的延展案例应该提出一个与正方一、二辩手完全不同的自己的理论，同时此理论也对其产生支持。正方选手也可以反驳反方第二领袖提出的观点。 Member of the Opposition“反方成员” This speaker should support the position developed by the Opening Opposition ream and must also introduce an extension.As with the Member Proposition,the Member Oppositions extension will be most successful if it establishes a unique argument identity that distinguishes the Closing from the Opening Opposition while continuing the general direction of argument initiated by the Opening Opposition.The member Opposition may also directly or indirectly refute the arguments of the Member Proposition.辩手应该支持反方一、二辩手的立场，并且必须引入新的延展。与正方辩手一样，反方辩手独特的延展案例应与反方一、二辩手提出的完全不同，但同时仍然在大方向上与他/她们的观点一致。反方辩手同样也可以直接或间接地反驳正方辩手的论述。 Government Whip“正方党鞭” This speaker summarizes the Proposition.s arguments and summarizes the refutation of the Opposition side.With the exception of refuting the Member Oppositions extension,the speaker should not introduce positive (new) matter.辩手应该总结正方的论述和反方的反驳，除非是要反驳反方辩手的论述，否则正方总结不应再提出新的立论点。 Opposition Whip“反方党鞭” This speaker summarizes opposition to the extension and makes reply to each teams position in the debate,This speaker should not introduce positive(new) matter.辩手应该总结反方的延展案例并且对整场辩论中每支辩论队的立场做出回应。反方总结不能提出新的立论点。 Points 得分Meaning 表现90 - 100Excellent to flawless.The standard of speech you would expect to see from a speaker at the Grand Final level of the tournament.This speaker has many strengths and few,if any,weaknesses.完美，无懈可击。很可能在决赛脱颖而出。此辩手优点很多，几乎没有弱点。80 - 89Above average to very good.The standard you would expect to see from a speaker at the semi finals level or in contention to make the finals.This speaker has clear strengths and minor weaknesses.中上到非常出色之间。你所希望在半决赛看到的选手水平。此辩手优势明显，略有弱项。70 - 79Average.The speaker has strengths and weaknesses and roughly proportions.平均水平。此选手优缺点并存，数量相当。70 - 79Poor to below average.The team