国贸经济管理类毕业论文-基于外部效益的电子政务项目综合评估方法研究

?CR4WFJ0JA1 ?z)|o%o8Bk#cy+kUz|6kg%goGzBnkQ$%kGJz)o4+z)s;MkY9zzJuMoWzYCkz|z|o)z)sW9h)k5+)Wek|_oz)%MoKK,QkWik4R_$k%S+)|_oy4z)B|_6C_ckUJu6FB|Juo+6g_ckJ4)C)c+z)gskw4%Oyoe*kYkU+)Juo KdB z)B| 6 C)c?CR4WFJ0JA2AbstractE-government project is a series of investment behavior for the realization ofhighly effective, transparent, standardized electronic inter-office, the coordinationwork and service, in order to enhance the government competitive power. Inaccordance with e-government project investigation and research statistics showsthat one thirds of US e-government project are failure, the figures are higher indeveloping countries. So e-government project assessment is particularlyimportant, in order to against problems of redundant low-level development, lowuse of finished project system and low benefit of e-government.E-government project assessment at present excessively concerned withtechnical performance, but lack of benefit appraisal after project construction.Since e-government project be as a social project of relating to everybody, wemore need a appraisal for project benefit besides technical evaluation.It establishes the e-government project external benefit appraisal targets andevaluation method in the text, proposing with the comprehensive level index toreflect its external benefit level. Among the comprehensive assessment methodsfor major indicators, we adopts the AHP which is fairly well developed fore-government project assessment, and get a series of quantitative analysis resultsand level standards. Finally, we summing up experience from the exampleanalysis, in order to enhances to the project management level. Key Words E-government Project External Benefit Index SystemAnalytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)?CR4WFJ0JA3-$ 1 0 41.1 .D0)( . 41.2 .D0?y . 52 +eoN-(&FGx,F 52.1 +eoN-,(& . 52.2 +eoN-,FGx, . 53 +eoN-FGx,A773+ 83.1 A77,F9I . 83.2 773+AA . 94 +eoN-5,8A# 104.1 777F . 104.2 r!Q6#*6 . 114.3 r!Q6#XN-A,+X . 145 6 165.1 FP1.Le . 165.2 A15,8Al . 165.3 5AAA . 166 5B 1763) 198$ BR 20?CR4WFJ0JA4*FGx,+eoN-5,8A#.D01 01.1 .D0)( Standish Groupzn/j5- 2002 p9,o1J,_N-aN17-9& ”3Z77F|AW4929 %1_, 22 %,N-#,N-7-B$_G6=7-9:F Z7768-X 2003 4qD,+eo ” ,z)*3+eo,B3.D4#4,-+eoN-aCU,)E 60 %80 %Q 16|ANA7-00;AdG=*AQ+eoCtH,+Xx)N-)v_-+eoN-,NAE#N-8D,_W7-6pV,x,A+eo_0Z3+5=rDN-XNA8Av*AX3+57-3+55/nJV,x,1yMOK9-(W,D/p+eoN-FM0)F|*5,8A-F)+eoN-*A,.D0+JA6|A*.p),)FLg3+5,G#q0;F0;3+580;j0477*A773+A7-oGL-;N-,5,8d.N-,_;a)8)N-F|iFv_y_A6,+eoN-F|x,A=7-P*x,d7-)*_dx,_3W-(F,$,x,?*$,_v,_=0JV$,x,9N-x,j-7VN-_,JN-CtH,-WWW?7-N-*A5$x)$Q$7-+eoN-KOpx,)N-F|A$98*6W0W5,:pF +eoN-j0NG?,-(,/nJ0;L?_AF$M0?0ZJ)N-x,A72 +eoN-(&FGx,F 2.1 +eoN-,(&+eoN-a_j)QxF?93,+eFG|,03+GCt+eoN-908F*AN-=-1dQ|ox)Fo1F?F!+eoN-9N-,(pBCN-FJh_+ao*Ct*,=vJY#j*F-r6f,-;0Z+eoN-XFGWF_!2N-,0n:(&9o,*-7,-;AJ+eoN-7-/nJf,/nJ=08$,)B5-4# J.E.2AjFGW_Fg0/&5FV4FFP ),6COFGW!FGW_70/4#k5FGFP0ECx+XFAFGx,I_7N-)/nJ*CQ)6|jkFZp9,9j*,!FGWk?+a;ZM2.2.1 4#x,FJhy:,4#x,_708CtN-)Ct4#|jk6|jkF,4#|jkp9,L$W4#x,4#|jk_Z_j,G6F1Jj,+eoN-*AVJ,j+eoN-,FG4#x,L!FF9;F4#x, 67-A-0faJA-X#0M,0#qa-(UG6H0;,*A)jF0f-1-CRofMUG?,+XXD%n:x9M,A-10OH00; 22sF|,10aJf0!nE 250sH0; “+e#3+5,F3ww,LND#99wx&xlXFA8-1L|o4Ci_*5A 19928# 19965-oFJEF+eoL$A 247LF 2000ZA0_ ll8075s+aA-+eo,d 1992,5-(=ZWwAZA-jF+eo6&,5-W-(,BIACRo,4 50763o)1J=,_V9x6-$3+1JX-Lu-TZ2j:1,7-FZ?y:B$+eoj1JG,=L-p0,4#x,2.2.2 /nJx,+eoN-j=A,N-FGx,L9:F ,4#x,F$k?,_)X/nJx, 6FJ.D0XZ- 80:,oGL)F- 3000J79 60GG5 A1jA7I PCK0G0Na6E250079wA1E 1000s9.&E&L$GA18E&2jG6E 250sT658AZ|M3+52j,kG6E 1250sX3+53+5551*6E&LbpE&Lb&CR1*6E&|JfE&462jo|J,GCNwX 13:+aoGL)?r,(!WXLb&2jop-NQE 18+a5#0X,oGL,J22EW!X|JfE&2jopQE 15 2+a!?o,E.&M0r6)A-J,CW,+XF_+XqOL$-+eo*A,0Zk?-7_7507-M,o55!+ev,_LN+XLNAALN1yAJLNF?+eoL+Xjk,0+eo*AX-+eo+X/j930;B&N-LMB*A+eo*.p*A4E0J,4M!*5AJ1yX,+eo3+5!F-+eo,?B8Ct$*0#0L$*68fCt$?4#G&FJCt$3+5?4#1*6HH0HCRHHH-./nJLHHdHCX1y 12ZJ3+56j+ev1JFF,|J)9F4|4J+X_Xj1JuA,=M5-6Fo, 200Zp.0 3000J,=7 31000JN,4/?FJE55o#qAoj-$,!QWW8-11J+XgoF&L$?CR4WFJ0JA8Qx)QA3PCX+eo*ANA1j55Aj8Q+eo*A,x,8n6|)AQF6djA3PCX69Fg7-9xU+eo,W+Xp+eo*A04F7-QA3PCXjA=A1j=.F:5a#oXxg|4JF,5+ev+e/nj,C-p/j93+X!Q+eo*A0/,-!+eo*A6-iMofEo6|7-Qo1*6W1CX3PCXF#qFJY+X1yQo,7-/nJWA0;i-N,?%)0no0oj/nJ-oF?joF+|,63+FoAG,D/F03+GF,)047-j-5,8Q-Lu1w-Lu3 +eoN-FGx,A773+3.1 A77,F9IP5773+,77F9#=B3N-COCS,k?MN-D,WCX1yM,9+X6B365/jB35/(4)r!QWpF977?P3+5,!0ZM9r!QW?rr$!(5)EWI6F99?3PjAx,77F77X=/j_7+eoN-FGx,X-7r;*00ZFZEj,6-7IrIr0477B5/nJx, ( 1B 4#x, ( 2B 5,8x, ( 3B Ir (B+a$j,N-77477 C4/nJx, ( 1B +a)G=,i( 1C F ITJ, ( 2C F_+X ( 3C QA3PCX 4C 4#x, ( 2B _7+aN-,5,1JuAV,=x,+a) ITJA7_M0r 5C A-0a 6C A|o4Ci_* 7C w1J1 8C 45,8x, ( 3B +aF4|JF ( 9C of,i ( 10C 477r (C I+a,77 (D+a!*,+eoN-FGx,773+ 3.1pG?CR4WFJ0JA10n 3.1 z)B|s60477%477&77F )G=,i 1C w=0.35 =CXGx)uA1J%?F ITJ, 2C w=0.25 .&A,iFE&,iFF_,+X 3C w=0.25 3+5,*A1JF0;/nJx, 1B w=0.5QA3PCX 4C w=0.15+e7A55,JdFJuA,+e7A.A0;ITJA7_M0rG, 5C w=0.3 .&A7M0rGE&M0rGA-0a 6C w=0.3 -0f#A|o4Ci_* 7C w=0.25 o,AA7,A4#x, 2B W=0.35w1J1 8C w=0.15 1J1*6,j1Jx,iF4|JF 9C w=0.7 +ev,+e/nj,5,8x,3B W=0.15 of,i10C w=0.3o6|7-1*6Wo7-#!Z/j477sG4 +eoN-5,8A#J)+eoN-FGx,(&A773+,X)J77F|5,8A#:9r!Q6# Q25,8A#k66Lb931y12XFGAG+XEj,r!Q6#)+eoN-F|A4.1 777F)+eoN-FGx,F|A&Ox?F|77,h1i=|7F4*6p977lEFG4G4,76fF|1+a#,77#9W77G7777,9:9?CR4WFJ0JA11#N#,779k?4PT,7777l,#9JgW&#kW?=|CW1F(GE-9.D0pG+X,CW1F#J2jl#Ct#jJ#|Ci+X#LbCi+X#=Ci+X#0;#&l#F9 Q#1y)077CW1FAGLNJ9+X(G,?F _W6)F W77FJE_4*663/jEF9i1y1y4.2 r!Q6#*6r!Q6# ( The analytic Hierarchy Process10 AHP#_5-:=F1iQW T.L.Saaty 3qO*,_0/+X,JIA#9+XW3+5W1#1W1yH& 1r!Q6#,*M#565,8TZE0; 136E0;_76LN3+54s3PL$,3+6LN%F*03+5,FBLfr!Q5 7 144.2.1 r!Q6#,k?(&(1)G+X 9 ,7D%Cj6ECO?,(,4/W 14(&_TZA3PA6l,0j3P$-() B,G?j&%-()$,G?j 1/7(2)90,P# AHP *,T.Lej)0 .Le(ijj08$WP(3)F28)=r3+5 AHP ,3+5Wj3+7)=rLNGF59Ej0W(4)?rp4*6,LNr!Q5$5|64!040ZII111 BCF , 2002G6#-AW*(x/n1 102 N?CR4WFJ0JA12L$=-(644B6j0Zr!QFJh5-7rIrxr9Zr!Q*50QrL$r0r,FBLfr!Q5D!0r!Q4Ip_G,7708=?CEZFga0ZFBLfr!Q,773+1FPET.LeT.Le/jJ):0rs3P69,43P,-()G?W 7FJEZ8f,BF|A6T.Le,*0:F 6E0;+aWE$QGir!Q6#7*6AA67; 4.1p/jn 4.1 9 A7 ija y1 i3PM3PnG?7 i3PM3PG?,J9 i3PM3P5)G? 8 j:TTL$,L$(1),7lB 9M3PL3PETlj jia =1/ ija , iia =1)9QZI,Ir0ZT.Le A = ( ija nfija 0 ,D ija = 1/ jia , ija jia = 1!jB$L:0r1NZIkB ,s3P ia s3P ja 0Z$G?)ja -(,G?0;D ija 0 iia =1, ija = 1/ jia FJh ija lj 1- 9,F,B ia ja ,-()G?0;6j4+a!.Le$j!.Le19r!Q)1LZIF77;,775F|:0!PE,s3P)0I,-()sG108$WP 08$WW*6jXFPT.Le&M5$?1FC_W08$W 79.Le08$&T.LeX maxO =n6n+X ( maxO - n)FZlW?P08$W,0;+XCI08$W 908$W77 CI(Consistency Index)A1?max1nCInO n jT.Le A ,Lf 4.3 max j.Le,0W(i n j.Le,LfCI C?/j08$WCXPT.Le_V9E%?W&F6 CIwLj08$W77 RIF|E*P CR9?r CR9 4.2-(,wLj08$W77 RI(Random Index)l0A108$W) CR(Consistency Ratio) :()CICRRIn 4.4n 4.2u%6 RInLf 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8RI 0 0 0.52 0.89 1.12 1.26 1.36 1.41Lf 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 RI 1.46 1.49 1.52 1.54 1.56 1.58 1.59 CR |08$WP ,!& :ii ii11,mmiiCI aCI RI aRI 4.5 : ia jkr!Q,:0r1LZ3P,sG , iCI iRI 6j:0r1 iZA3P, CI CRl?CR4WFJ0JA144.3 r!Q6#XN-A,+X4.3.1 N-r!Q5 Qir!Q6#*6p*,A773+*N-r!Q5 Q. 4.310r$jk-71r%j047719r&j477AB1 B2 B3C1 C2 C3C4 C5 C6 C7 C8 C9 C104 4.3 r!Q5 Q4.3.2 FPET.LeA177sAGP08$W)1r-7%k-7$,-(A1F|E*TTE.Le/nJx,4#x,_+eoN-FGW,G?)p/nJx,4#x,5,8x,-(_nG?,/nJx,4#x,-(0=G?!FP;MFZTTET.Le131154135141sAG11 12 13( , , ) (0.9048,0.4038,0.1352)TTB BBBW WWW max 3.0858O CI=0.0429,RI=0.52,CR=CI/RI=0.08 0.1, CI 0.1T.Le,08$W%?19r-7&1r!Z-7%,-(A1 1234,CCCC)0477 1B ,77sGsAG61234,CCCCTTEFPT.Le131311153313351131131sAG1(0.8720,0.3337,0.3337,0.1304)TCBW max 4.0435O ,CR=CI/RI=0.04353 0.89u =0.016 0.1,T.Le08$W%? 5678,CCCC)0477 2B ,77sGsAG6?CR4WFJ0JA155678,CCCCTTEFPT.Le112211144311241124131sAG2(0.6508,0.6508,0.3621,0.1477)TCBW max 4.0206O ,CR=CI/RI=0.02063 0.89u =0.01 0.1,T.Le08$W%? 9 10,CC)0477 3B ,77sGsAG6 9 10,CCTTEFPT.Le15151sAG 3 (0.9806,0.1961)TCBW max 2O T.LeLfj=M0?P08$W19r4Z-7-()k-7,77sGsAG CiW 123111213000 0000.8720 0.6508 0.9806 0.9048 0 00.3337 0.6508 0.1961 0 0.4038 00.3337 0.3621 0 0 0 0.13520.1304 0.1477 0BCB CB CB BBWWWWWWu u CiW 1CW 2CW 10CW T)k,TF|08$WP19r,-(77j 12 33 333CI (CI CI CI )0.0145 0.007 0 0.9048 0.4038 0.13520.016BTW u 12 33 333RI ( I RI RI )0.89 0.89 0 0.9048 0.4038 0.13521.165BTRW u 3323CI 0.016CR CR 0.01 0.024RI 1.165 0.1FG, ikCI ikCR 6jX k-1r1LZI;T.Le,08$W77wLj77+a CR4=0.024 0.1AjBFBLfr!Qk:9%?,08$W?CR4WFJ0JA165 65.1 FP1.Le+eoN-j)+eoN-FGx,A773+9477,F|B3LfL-(,Ct