格林斯潘回忆录

ONTHEAFTERNOONOFSEPTEMBER11,2001,IWASFLYINGBACKTOWASHINGTONONSWISSAIRFLIGHT128,RETURNINGHOMEFROMAROUTINEINTERNATIONALBANKERSMEETINGINSWITZERLANDIDBEENMOVINGABOUTTHECABINWHENTHECHIEFOFTHESECURITYDETAILTHATESCORTEDMEONTRIPSABROAD,BOBAGNEW,STOPPEDMEINTHEAISLEBOBISANEXSECRETSERVICEMAN,FRIENDLYBUTNOTESPECIALLYTALKATIVEATTHATMOMENT,HEWASLOOKINGGRIM“MRCHAIRMAN,“HESAIDQUIETLY,“THECAPTAINNEEDSTOSEEYOUUPFRONTTWOPLANESHAVEFLOWNINTOTHEWORLDTRADECENTER“IMUSTHAVEHADAQUIZZICALLOOKONMYFACEBECAUSEHEADDED,“IMNOTJOKING“INTHECOCKPIT,THECAPTAINAPPEAREDQUITENERVOUSHETOLDUSTHEREHADBEENATERRIBLEATTACKAGAINSTOURCOUNTRYSEVERALAIRLINERSHADBEENHIJACKEDANDTWOFLOWNINTOTHEWORLDTRADECENTERANDONEINTOTHEPENTAGONANOTHERPLANEWASMISSINGTHATWASALLTHEINFORMATIONHEHAD,HESAIDINHISSLIGHTLYACCENTEDENGLISHWEWERERETURNINGTOZURICH,ANDHEWASNOTGOINGTOANNOUNCETHEREASONTOTHEOTHERPASSENGERS“DOWEHAVETOGOBACK“IASKED“CANWELANDINCANADA“HESAIDNO,HISORDERSWERETOHEADTOZURICHIWENTBACKTOMYSEATASTHECAPTAINANNOUNCEDTHATAIRTRAFFICCONTROLHADDIRECTEDUSTOZURICHTHEPHONESONTHESEATSIMMEDIATELYBECAMEJAMMED,ANDICOULDNTGETTHROUGHTOTHEGROUNDTHEFEDERALRESERVECOLLEAGUESWHOHADBEENWITHMEINSWITZERLANDTHATWEEKENDWEREALREADYONOTHERFLIGHTSSOWITHNOWAYTOKNOWHOWEVENTSWEREDEVELOPING,IHADNOTHINGTODOBUTTHINKFORTHENEXTTHREEANDAHALFHOURSILOOKEDOUTTHEWINDOW,THEWORKIDBROUGHTALONG,THEPILESOFMEMOSANDECONOMICREPORTS,FORGOTTENINMYBAGWERETHESEATTACKSTHEBEGINNINGOFSOMEWIDERCONSPIRACYMYIMMEDIATECONCERNWASFORMYWIFEANDREAISNBCSCHIEFFOREIGNAFFAIRSCORRESPONDENTINWASHINGTONSHEWASNTINNEWYORK,WHICHWASONEBIGRELIEF,ANDVISITINGTHEPENTAGONHADNTBEENONHERAGENDATHATDAYIASSUMEDSHEWOULDBEATTHENBCBUREAUINTHEMIDDLEOFTOWN,HEAVILYINVOLVEDINCOVERINGTHENEWSSOIWASNTDEEPLYWORRIED,ITOLDMYSELFBUTWHATIFSHEDGONEONALASTMINUTEVISITTOSOMEGENERALINTHEPENTAGONIWORRIEDABOUTMYCOLLEAGUESATTHEFEDERALRESERVEWERETHEYSAFEANDTHEIRFAMILIESTHESTAFFWOULDBESCRAMBLINGTORESPONDTOTHECRISISTHISATTACKTHEFIRSTONUSSOILSINCEPEARLHARBORWOULDTHROWTHECOUNTRYINTOTURMOILTHEQUESTIONINEEDEDTOFOCUSONWASWHETHERTHEECONOMYWOULDBEDAMAGEDTHEPOSSIBLEECONOMICCRISESWEREALLTOOEVIDENTTHEWORST,WHICHITHOUGHTHIGHLYUNLIKELY,WOULDBEACOLLAPSEOFTHEFINANCIALSYSTEMTHEFEDERALRESERVEISINCHARGEOFTHEELECTRONICPAYMENTSYSTEMSTHATTRANSFERMORETHAN4TRILLIONADAYINMONEYANDSECURITIESBETWEENBANKSALLOVERTHECOUNTRYANDMUCHOFTHERESTOFTHEWORLDWEDALWAYSTHOUGHTTHATIFYOUWANTEDTOCRIPPLETHEUSECONOMY,YOUDTAKEOUTTHEPAYMENTSYSTEMSBANKSWOULDBEFORCEDTOFALLBACKONINEFFICIENTPHYSICALTRANSFERSOFMONEYBUSINESSESWOULDRESORTTOBARTERANDIOUSTHELEVELOFECONOMICACTIVITYACROSSTHECOUNTRYCOULDDROPLIKEAROCKDURINGTHECOLDWAR,ASAPRECAUTIONAGAINSTNUCLEARATTACK,THEFEDERALRESERVEHADBUILTALARGENUMBEROFREDUNDANCIESINTOTHECOMMUNICATIONANDCOMPUTERFACILITIESONWHICHTHEMONEYSYSTEMRELIESWEHAVEALLSORTSOFSAFEGUARDSSOTHAT,FOREXAMPLE,THEDATAOFONEFEDERALRESERVEBANKAREBACKEDUPATANOTHERFEDERALRESERVEBANKHUNDREDSOFMILESAWAYORINSOMEREMOTELOCATIONINTHEEVENTOFANUCLEARATTACK,WEDBEBACKUPANDRUNNINGINALLNONIRRADIATEDAREASVERYQUICKLYTHISSYSTEMWASTHEONEROGERFERGUSON,THEVICECHAIRMANOFTHEFED,WOULDBECALLINGONTHISDAYIWASCONFIDENTTHATHEANDOURCOLLEAGUESWOULDBETAKINGTHENECESSARYSTEPSTOKEEPTHEWORLDDOLLARSYSTEMFLOWINGYETEVENASITHOUGHTABOUTIT,IDOUBTEDTHATPHYSICALLYDISRUPTINGTHEFINANCIALSYSTEMWASWHATTHEHIJACKERSHADINMINDMUCHMORELIKELY,THISWASMEANTTOBEASYMBOLICACTOFVIOLENCEAGAINSTCAPITALISTAMERICALIKETHEBOMBINTHEPARKINGGARAGEOFTHEWORLDTRADECENTEREIGHTYEARSEARLIERWHATWORRIEDMEWASTHEFEARSUCHANATTACKWOULDCREATEESPECIALLYIFTHEREWEREADDITIONALATTACKSTOCOMEINANECONOMYASSOPHISTICATEDASOURS,PEOPLEHAVETOINTERACTANDEXCHANGEGOODSANDSERVICESCONSTANTLY,ANDTHEDIVISIONOFLABORISSOFINELYARTICULATEDTHATEVERYHOUSEHOLDDEPENDSONCOMMERCESIMPLYTOSURVIVEIFPEOPLEWITHDRAWFROMEVERYDAYECONOMICLIFEIFINVESTORSDUMPTHEIRSTOCKS,ORBUSINESSPEOPLEBACKAWAYFROMTRADES,ORCITIZENSSTAYHOMEFORFEAROFGOINGTOMALLSANDBEINGEXPOSEDTOSUICIDEBOMBERSTHERESASNOWBALLEFFECTITSTHEPSYCHOLOGYTHATLEADSTOPANICSANDRECESSIONSASHOCKLIKETHEONEWEDJUSTSUSTAINEDCOULDCAUSEAMASSIVEWITHDRAWALFROM,ANDMAJORCONTRACTIONIN,ECONOMICACTIVITYTHEMISERYCOULDMULTIPLYLONGBEFOREMYFLIGHTTOUCHEDDOWN,IDCONCLUDEDTHATTHEWORLDWASABOUTTOCHANGEINWAYSTHATICOULDNOTYETDEFINETHECOMPLACENCYWEAMERICANSHADEMBRACEDFORTHEDECADEFOLLOWINGTHEENDOFTHECOLDWARHADJUSTBEENSHATTEREDWEFINALLYREACHEDZURICHJUSTAFTER830PMLOCALTIMESTILLEARLYAFTERNOONINTHEUNITEDSTATESSWISSBANKINGOFFICIALSMETMEASIGOTOFFTHEPLANEANDRUSHEDMETOAPRIVATEROOMINTHEDEPARTURELOUNGETHEYOFFEREDTOSHOWVIDEOSOFTHETWINTOWERSCOMINGDOWNANDTHEFIRESATTHEPENTAGON,BUTIDECLINEDIDWORKEDINTHENEIGHBORHOODOFTHEWORLDTRADECENTERFORMUCHOFMYLIFEANDHADFRIENDSANDACQUAINTANCESTHEREIASSUMEDTHEDEATHTOLLSWOULDBEHORRENDOUSANDWOULDINCLUDEPEOPLEIKNEWIDIDNTWANTTOSEETHEDESTRUCTIONIJUSTWANTEDAPHONETHATWORKEDIFINALLYREACHEDANDREAONHERCELLPHONEAFEWMINUTESBEFORENINE,ANDITWASAGREATRELIEFTOHEARHERVOICEONCEWEDASSUREDEACHOTHERWEWEREOKAY,SHETOLDMESHEHADTORUSHSHEWASONTHESET,ABOUTTOGOONTHEAIRWITHANUPDATEOFTHEDAYSEVENTSISAID,“JUSTTELLMEQUICKLYWHATSHAPPENINGTHERE“SHEWASHOLDINGTHECELLPHONETOONEEARWHILETHESPECIALEVENTSPRODUCERINNEWYORKWASONHEREARPIECEINTHEOTHEREAR,ALMOSTSHOUTING,“ANDREA,TOMBROKAWISCOMINGTOYOUAREYOUREADY“ALLSHEHADTIMETOSAYWAS,“LISTENUP“WITHTHAT,SHEPUTTHEOPENCELLPHONEONHERLAPANDADDRESSEDTHECAMERASIHEARDEXACTLYWHATAMERICAWASHEARINGATTHATPOINTTHATTHEMISSINGUNITEDFLIGHT93HADCRASHEDINPENNSYLVANIAIWASTHENABLETOGETACALLTHROUGHTOROGERFERGUSONATTHEFEDWERANTHROUGHOURCRISISMANAGEMENTCHECKLIST,ANDJUSTASIDFIGURED,HEHADTHINGSWELLINHANDTHEN,WITHALLCIVILIANAIRTRAVELTOTHEUNITEDSTATESSHUTDOWN,ICONTACTEDANDYCARD,THEWHITEHOUSECHIEFOFSTAFF,TOREQUESTTRANSPORTATIONBACKTOWASHINGTONFINALLYIWENTBACKTOTHEHOTEL,ESCORTEDBYMYSECURITYDETAIL,TOGETSOMESLEEPANDAWAITINSTRUCTIONSBYDAYBREAKIWASAIRBORNEAGAIN,ONTHEFLIGHTDECKOFAUNITEDSTATESAIRFORCEKC10TANKERITMAYHAVEBEENTHEONLYAIRCRAFTAVAILABLETHECREWWASUSEDTOFLYINGREFUELINGSORTIESOVERTHENORTHATLANTICTHEMOODINTHECOCKPITWASSOMBER“YOULLNEVERBELIEVETHIS,“THECAPTAINSAID“LISTEN“IPUTMYEARTOTHEHEADSETBUTCOULDNTHEARANYTHINGOTHERTHANSTATIC“NORMALLYTHENORTHATLANTICISFULLOFRADIOCHATTER,“HEEXPLAINED“THISSILENCEISEERIE“APPARENTLYNOBODYELSEWASOUTTHEREASWECAMEDOWNTHEEASTERNSEABOARDANDENTEREDPROHIBITEDUSAIRSPACE,WEWEREMETANDESCORTEDBYACOUPLEOFFL6FIGHTERSTHECAPTAINGOTPERMISSIONTOFLYOVERWHATHADBEENTHESITEOFTHETWINTOWERSATTHESOUTHERNTIPOFMANHATTAN,NOWASMOKINGRUINFORDECADES,MYOFFICESHADNEVERBEENMORETHANAFEWBLOCKSFROMTHEREDURINGTHELATE1960SANDEARLY1970SIHADWATCHEDDAYBYDAYASTHETWINTOWERSWENTUPNOW,FROMTHIRTYFIVETHOUSANDFEET,THEIRSMOKYWRECKAGEWASNEWYORKSMOSTVISIBLELANDMARKIWENTSTRAIGHTTOTHEFEDTHATAFTERNOON,DRIVENWITHAPOLICEESCORTTHROUGHBARRICADEDSTREETSTHENWEWENTTOWORKFORTHEMOSTPART,THEELECTRONICFLOWSOFFUNDSWEREDOINGFINEBUTWITHCIVILIANAIRTRAFFICSHUTDOWN,THETRANSPORTATIONANDCLEARINGOFGOODOLDFASHIONEDCHECKSWEREBEINGDELAYEDTHATWASATECHNICALPROBLEMASUBSTANTIALONE,BUTONETHATTHESTAFFANDTHEINDIVIDUALFEDERALRESERVEBANKSWEREENTIRELYCAPABLEOFHANDLINGBYTEMPORARILYEXTENDINGADDITIONALCREDITTOCOMMERCIALBANKSISPENTMOSTOFMYTIMEINTHEDAYSTHATFOLLOWEDWATCHINGANDLISTENINGFORSIGNSOFACATASTROPHICECONOMICSLOWDOWNFORSEVENMONTHSBEFORE9/11,THEECONOMYHADBEENINAVERYMINORRECESSION,STILLSHAKINGOFFTHEEFFECTSOFTHEDOTCOMCRASHOF2000BUTTHINGSHADSTARTEDTOTURNAROUNDWEHADRAPIDLYBEENLOWERINGINTERESTRATES,ANDTHEMARKETSWEREBEGINNINGTOSTABILIZEBYLATEAUGUSTPUBLICINTERESTHADSHIFTEDFROMTHEECONOMYTOGARYCONDIT,THECALIFORNIACONGRESSMANWHOSELESSTHANFORTHCOMINGSTATEMENTSABOUTAMISSINGYOUNGWOMANDOMINATEDTHENIGHTLYNEWSANDREACOULDNTGETONTHEAIRWITHANYTHINGOFGLOBALSIGNIFICANCE,ANDIREMEMBERTHINKINGHOWINCREDIBLETHATSEEMEDTHEWORLDMUSTBEINPRETTYGOODSHAPEIFTHETVNEWSFOCUSEDMAINLYONDOMESTICSCANDALWITHINTHEFED,THEBIGGESTISSUEWEFACEDWASHOWFARTOLOWERINTERESTRATESAFTER9/11,THEREPORTSANDSTATISTICSSTREAMINGINFROMTHEFEDERALRESERVEBANKSTOLDAVERYDIFFERENTSTORYTHEFEDERALRESERVESYSTEMCONSISTSOFTWELVEBANKSSTRATEGICALLYSITUATEDAROUNDTHECOUNTRYEACHONELENDSMONEYTOANDREGULATESTHEBANKSINITSREGIONTHEFEDERALRESERVEBANKSALSOSERVEASAWINDOWONTHEAMERICANECONOMYOFFICERSANDSTAFFSTAYCONSTANTLYINTOUCHWITHBANKERSANDBUSINESSPEOPLEINTHEIRDISTRICTS,ANDTHEINFORMATIONTHEYGLEANABOUTORDERSANDSALESBEATSOFFICIALPUBLISHEDDATABYASMUCHASAMONTHWHATTHEYWERETELLINGUSNOWWASTHATALLACROSSTHECOUNTRYPEOPLEHADSTOPPEDSPENDINGONEVERYTHINGEXCEPTITEMSBOUGHTINPREPARATIONFORPOSSIBLEADDITIONALATTACKSSALESOFGROCERIES,SECURITYDEVICES,BOTTLEDWATER,ANDINSURANCEWEREUPTHEWHOLETRAVEL,ENTERTAINMENT,HOTEL,TOURISM,ANDCONVENTIONBUSINESSWASDOWNWEKNEWTHESHIPPINGOFFRESHVEGETABLESFROMTHEWESTCOASTTOTHEEASTCOASTWOULDBEDISRUPTEDBYTHESUSPENSIONOFAIRFREIGHT,BUTWEWERESOMEWHATSURPRISEDBYHOWQUICKLYMANYOTHERBUSINESSESWEREHITFOREXAMPLE,THEFLOWOFAUTOPARTSFROMWINDSOR,ONTARIO,TODETROITSPLANTSSLOWEDTOACRAWLATTHERIVERCROSSINGSTHATJOINTHETWOCITIESAFACTORINTHEDECISIONBYFORDMOTORTOSHUTDOWNTEMPORARILYFIVEOFITSFACTORIESYEARSEARLIER,MANYMANUFACTURERSHADSHIFTEDTO“JUSTINTIME“PRODUCTIONINSTEADOFSTOCKPILINGPARTSANDSUPPLIESATTHEPLANT,THEYRELIEDONAIRFREIGHTTODELIVERCRITICALCOMPONENTSASTHEYWERENEEDEDTHESHUTDOWNOFTHEAIRSPACEANDTHETIGHTENINGOFBORDERSLEDTOSHORTAGES,BOTTLENECKS,ANDCANCELEDSHIFTSINTHEMEANTIME,THEUSGOVERNMENTHADGONEINTOHIGHGEARONFRIDAY,SEPTEMBER14,CONGRESSPASSEDANINITIALEMERGENCYAPPROPRIATIONOF40BILLIONANDAUTHORIZEDTHEPRESIDENTTOUSEFORCEAGAINSTTHE“NATIONS,ORGANIZATIONS,ORPERSONS“WHOHADATTACKEDUSPRESIDENTBUSHRALLIEDTHENATIONWITHWHATWILLLIKELYGODOWNASTHEMOSTEFFECTIVESPEECHOFHISPRESIDENCY“AMERICAWASTARGETEDFORATTACKBECAUSEWERETHEBRIGHTESTBEACONFORFREEDOMANDOPPORTUNITYINTHEWORLD,“HESAID“ANDNOONEWILLKEEPTHATLIGHTFROMSHINING“HISAPPROVALRATINGSSOAREDTO86PERCENT,ANDPOLITICS,IFONLYFORASHORTPERIOD,BECAMEBIPARTISANLOTSOFIDEASWEREBEINGFLOATEDONCAPITOLHILLFORHELPINGTHENATIONBOUNCEBACKTHEREWEREPLANSTHATINVOLVEDPUMPINGFUNDSINTOAIRLINES,TOURISM,ANDRECREATIONTHEREWASARAFTOFPROPOSALSTOEXTENDTAXBREAKSTOBUSINESSESINORDERTOENCOURAGECAPITALINVESTMENTTERRORISMINSURANCEWASMUCHDISCUSSEDHOWDOYOUINSUREAGAINSTSUCHCATASTROPHICEVENTS,ANDWHATROLE,IFANY,DOESTHEGOVERNMENTHAVEINTHATITHOUGHTITURGENTTOGETCOMMERCIALAIRCRAFTFLYINGAGAIN,INORDERTOABORTALLTHENEGATIVERIPPLEEFFECTSCONGRESSQUICKLYPASSEDA15BILLIONAIRTRANSPORTRESCUEBILLBUTBEYONDTHAT,IPAIDLESSATTENTIONTOMOSTOFTHESEDEBATES,BECAUSEIWASINTENTONGETTINGTHELARGERPICTUREWHICHSTILLWASNTCLEARTOMEIWASCONVINCEDTHATTHEANSWERWOULDNOTLIEINBIG,HASTY,EXPENSIVEGESTURESITSTYPICALTHATINTIMESOFGREATNATIONALURGENCY,EVERYCONGRESSMANFEELSHEHASTOPUTOUTABILLPRESIDENTSFEELTHEPRESSURETOACTTOOUNDERTHOSECONDITIONSYOUCANGETSHORTSIGHTED,INEFFECTIVE,OFTENCOUNTERPRODUCTIVEPOLICIES,LIKETHEGASOLINERATIONINGTHATPRESIDENTNIXONIMPOSEDDURINGTHEFIRSTOPECOILSHOCKIN1973THATPOLICYCAUSEDGASLINESINSOMEPARTSOFTHECOUNTRYTHATFALLBUTWITHFOURTEENYEARSUNDERMYBELTASFEDCHAIRMAN,IDSEENTHEECONOMYPULLTHROUGHALOTOFCRISESINCLUDINGTHELARGESTONEDAYCRASHINTHEHISTORYOFTHESTOCKMARKET,WHICHHAPPENEDFIVEWEEKSAFTERITOOKTHEJOBWEDSURVIVEDTHEREALESTATEBOOMANDBUSTOFTHE1980S,THESAVINGSANDLOANCRISIS,ANDTHEASIANFINANCIALUPHEAVALS,NOTTOMENTIONTHERECESSIONOF1990WEDENJOYEDTHELONGESTSTOCKMARKETBOOMINHISTORYANDTHENWEATHEREDTHEENSUINGDOTCOMCRASHIWASGRADUALLYCOMINGTOBELIEVETHATTHEUSECONOMYSGREATESTSTRENGTHWASITSRESILIENCYITSABILITYTOABSORBDISRUPTIONSANDRECOVER,OFTENINWAYSANDATAPACEYOUDNEVERBEABLETOPREDICT,MUCHLESSDICTATEYETINTHISTERRIBLECIRCUMSTANCE,THEREWASNOWAYTOKNOWWHATWOULDHAPPENITHOUGHTTHEBESTSTRATEGYWASTOOBSERVEANDWAITUNTILWEUNDERSTOODBETTERWHATTHEPRECISEFALLOUTFROM9/11WOULDBETHATISWHATITOLDTHECONGRESSIONALLEADERSHIPINAMEETINGINTHEHOUSESPEAKERSOFFICEONTHEAFTERNOONOFSEPTEMBER19SPEAKERDENNISHASTERT,HOUSEMINORITYLEADERDICKGEPHARDT,SENATEMAJORITYLEADERTRENTLOTT,ANDSENATEMINORITYLEADERTOMDASCHLE,ALONGWITHBOBRUBIN,THEFORMERSECRETARYOFTHETREASURYUNDERPRESIDENTCLINTON,ANDWHITEHOUSEECONOMICADVISERLARRYLINDSEY,ALLMETINAPLAINCONFERENCEROOMATTACHEDTOHASTERTSOFFICEONTHEHOUSESIDEOFTHECAPITOLTHELEGISLATORSWANTEDTOHEARASSESSMENTSOFTHEECONOMICIMPACTOFTHEATTACKSFROMLINDSEY,RUBIN,ANDMETHEREWASGREATSERIOUSNESSTOTHEENSUINGDISCUSSIONNOGRANDSTANDINGIREMEMBERTHINKING,THISISTHEWAYGOVERNMENTSHOULDWORKLINDSEYPUTFORWARDTHEIDEATHATASTHETERRORISTSHADDEALTABLOWTOAMERICANCONFIDENCE,THEBESTWAYTOCOUNTERITWOULDBEATAXCUTHEANDOTHERSARGUEDFORPUMPINGABOUT100BILLIONINTOTHEECONOMYASSOONASPOSSIBLETHENUMBERDIDNTALARMMEITWASABOUT1PERCENTOFTHECOUNTRYSTOTALANNUALOUTPUTBUTITOLDTHEMWEHADNOWAYOFKNOWINGYETWHETHER100BILLIONWASTOOMUCHORTOOLITTLEYES,THEAIRLINESANDTHETOURISMINDUSTRIESHADBEENSEVERELYIMPACTED,ANDTHENEWSPAPERSWEREFULLOFSTORIESABOUTALLSORTSOFLAYOFFSYETONMONDAY,SEPTEMBER17,AMAZINGLY,THENEWYORKSTOCKEXCHANGEHADSUCCEEDEDINREOPENINGJUSTTHREEBLOCKSFROMGROUNDZEROITWASANIMPORTANTSTEPBECAUSEITBROUGHTASENSEOFNORMALCYBACKTOTHESYSTEMABRIGHTSPOTINTHEPICTUREWEWERESTILLPIECINGTOGETHERATTHEFEDATTHESAMETIME,THECHECKPAYMENTSYSTEMWASRECOVERING,ANDTHESTOCKMARKETHADNTCRASHEDPRICESHADMERELYGONEDOWNANDTHENSTABILIZED,ANINDICATIONTHATMOSTCOMPANIESWERENOTINSERIOUSTROUBLEITOLDTHEMTHEPRUDENTCOURSEWASTOCONTINUETOWORKONOPTIONSANDMEETBACKINTWOWEEKS,WHENWEDKNOWMOREIDELIVEREDTHESAMEMESSAGETHENEXTMORNINGTOAPUBLICHEARINGOFTHESENATEBANKINGCOMMITTEE,COUNSELINGPATIENCE“NOBODYHASTHECAPACITYTOFATHOMFULLYHOWTHETRAGEDYOFSEPTEMBER11WILLPLAYOUTBUTINTHEWEEKSAHEAD,ASTHESHOCKWEARSOFF,WESHOULDBEABLETOBETTERGAUGEHOWTHEONGOINGDYNAMICSOFTHESEEVENTSARESHAPINGTHEIMMEDIATEECONOMICOUTLOOK“IALSOEMPHASIZED,“OVERTHEPASTCOUPLEOFDECADES,THEAMERICANECONOMYHASBECOMEINCREASINGLYRESILIENTTOSHOCKSDEREGULATEDFINANCIALMARKETS,FARMOREFLEXIBLELABORMARKETS,AND,MORERECENTLY,THEMAJORADVANCESININFORMATIONTECHNOLOGYHAVEENHANCEDOURABILITYTOABSORBDISRUPTIONSANDRECOVER“INFACT,IWASPUTTINGABETTERFACEONTHESITUATIONTHANIFEAREDMIGHTBETHECASELIKEMOSTPEOPLEINGOVERNMENT,IFULLYEXPECTEDMOREATTACKSTHATFEELINGWENTMAINLYUNSPOKENINPUBLIC,BUTYOUCOULDSEEITINTHEUNANIMITYOFTHESENATEVOTES980FORAUTHORIZINGTHEUSEOFFORCEAGAINSTTERRORISTS,1000FORTHEAVIATIONSECURITYBILLIWASPARTICULARLYCONCERNEDABOUTAWEAPONOFMASSDESTRUCTION,POSSIBLYANUCLEARDEVICESTOLENFROMTHESOVIETARSENALDURINGTHECHAOSOFTHECOLLAPSEOFTHEUSSRIALSOCONTEMPLATEDTHECONTAMINATIONOFOURRESERVOIRSYETONTHERECORDITOOKALESSPESSIMISTICSTANCEBECAUSEIFIHADFULLYEXPRESSEDWHATITHOUGHTTHEPROBABILITIESWERE,IDHAVESCAREDTHEMARKETSHALFTODEATHIREALIZEDIPROBABLYWASNTFOOLINGANYBODY,THOUGHPEOPLEINTHEMARKETSWOULDHEARMEANDSAY,“ISUREHOPEHESRIGHT“INLATESEPTEMBER,THEFIRSTHARDDATACAMEINTYPICALLY,THEEARLIESTCLEARINDICATOROFWHATSHAPPENINGTOTHEECONOMYISTHENUMBEROFNEWCLAIMSFORUNEMPLOYMENTBENEFITS,ASTATISTICCOMPILEDEACHWEEKBYTHEDEPARTMENTOFLABORFORTHETHIRDWEEKOFTHEMONTH,CLAIMSTOPPED450,000,ABOUT13PERCENTABOVETHEIRLEVELINLATEAUGUSTTHEFIGURECONFIRMEDTHEEXTENTANDSERIOUSNESSOFTHEHARDSHIPSWEDBEENSEEINGINNEWSREPORTSABOUTPEOPLEWHODLOSTTHEIRJOBSICOULDIMAGINETHOSETHOUSANDSOFHOTELANDRESORTWORKERSANDOTHERSNOWINLIMBO,NOTKNOWINGHOWTHEYWOULDSUPPORTTHEMSELVESANDTHEIRFAMILIESIWASCOMINGTOTHEVIEWTHATTHEECONOMYWASNOTGOINGTOBOUNCEBACKQUICKLYTHESHOCKWASSEVEREENOUGHTHATEVENAHIGHLYFLEXIBLEECONOMYWOULDHAVEDIFFICULTYDEALINGWITHITLIKEMANYOTHERANALYSTS,ECONOMISTSATTHEFEDWERELOOKINGATALLTHEPROPOSEDPACKAGESOFSPENDINGANDTAXCUTS,ANDTHENUMBERSASSOCIATEDWITHTHEMINEACHCASE,WETRIEDTOCUTTHROUGHTHEDETAILSTOGAUGETHEORDEROFMAGNITUDEINTERESTINGLY,THEYALLFELLINTHEBALLPARKOF100BILLIONLARRYLINDSEYSINITIALSUGGESTIONWERECONVENEDINHASTERTSCONFERENCEROOMONWEDNESDAY,OCTOBER3,TOTALKAGAINABOUTTHEECONOMYANOTHERWEEKHADPASSED,ANDTHENUMBEROFINITIALJOBLESSCLAIMSHADGOTTENWORSEANADDITIONAL517,000PEOPLEHADAPPLIEDFORUNEMPLOYMENTBENEFITSBYNOW,MYMINDWASMADEUPWHILEISTILLEXPECTEDMOREATTACKS,THEREWASNOWAYTOKNOWHOWDEVASTATINGTHEYMIGHTBEORHOWTOPROTECTTHEECONOMYINADVANCEITOLDTHEGROUPTHATWESHOULDTAKESTEPSTOOFFSETTHEDAMAGEWECOULDMEASURE,ANDTHATITWASINDEEDTIMEFORACONSTRAINEDSTIMULUSWHATSEEMEDABOUTRIGHTWASAPACKAGEOFACTIONSONTHEORDEROF100BILLIONENOUGH,BUTNOTSOMUCHTHATITWOULDOVERSTIMULATETHEECONOMYANDCAUSEINTERESTRATESTORISETHELAWMAKERSSEEMEDTOAGREEIWENTHOMETHATNIGHTTHINKINGTHATALLIDDONEWASARTICULATEANDREINFORCEACONSENSUSTHE100BILLIONFIGUREHADFIRSTCOMEFROMLARRYSOIWASSURPRISEDTOREADTHEMEDIASSPINONTHEMEETING,WHICHMADEITSOUNDALMOSTASTHOUGHIWERERUNNINGTHEENTIRESHOWWHILEITWASGRATIFYINGTOHEARTHATCONGRESSANDTHEADMINISTRATIONWERELISTENINGTOME,IFOUNDTHESEPRESSREPORTSUNSETTLINGIVENEVERBEENENTIRELYCOMFORTABLEBEINGCASTASTHEPERSONWHOCALLSTHESHOTSFROMMYEARLIESTDAYS,IHADVIEWEDMYSELFASANEXPERTBEHINDTHESCENES,ANIMPLEMENTEROFORDERSRATHERTHANTHELEADERITTOOKTHESTOCKMARKETCRISISOF1987TOMAKEMEFEELCOMFORTABLEMAKINGCRITICALPOLICYDECISIONSBUTTOTHISDAY,IFEELILLATEASEINTHESPOTLIGHTEXTROVERT,IAMNOTOFCOURSE,THEIRONYWASTHATINSPITEOFMYSUPPOSEDPERSUASIVEPOWER,INTHEWEEKSAFTER9/11NOTHINGWORKEDOUTASIEXPECTEDANTICIPATINGASECONDTERRORISTATTACKWASPROBABLYONEOFTHEWORSTPREDICTIONSIEVERTIMEMAGAZINE,FOREXAMPLE,OPINEDONOCTOBER15,2001,“GREENSPANSSHIFTPROVIDEDTHEGREENLIGHTLAWMAKERSHADBEENWAITINGFORTHEWHITEHOUSEANDLEADERSOFBOTHPARTIESHAVEAGREEDWITHGREENSPANSASSESSMENTTHATNEWSPENDINGANDTAXCUTSSHOULDTOTALABOUT1OFTHECOUNTRYSANNUALINCOME,THATITSHOULDMAKEITSEFFECTSFELTQUICKLYANDTHATITSHOULDNOTTHREATENTOBALLOONTHEDEFICITSOMUCHDOWNTHEROADTHATITIMMEDIATELYRAISESLONGTERMINTERESTRATES“MADEANDTHE“CONSTRAINEDSTIMULUS“IHADSUPPOSEDLYGREENLIGHTEDDIDNTHAPPENEITHERITBOGGEDDOWNINPOLITICSANDSTALLEDTHEPACKAGETHATFINALLYEMERGEDINMARCH2002NOTONLYWASMONTHSTOOLATEBUTALSOHADLITTLETODOWITHTHEGENERALWELFAREITWASANEMBARRASSINGMESSOFPORKBARRELPROJECTSYETTHEECONOMYRIGHTEDITSELFINDUSTRIALPRODUCTION,AFTERJUSTONEMOREMONTHOFMILDDECLINE,BOTTOMEDOUTINNOVEMBERBYDECEMBERTHEECONOMYWASGROWINGAGAIN,ANDJOBLESSCLAIMSDROPPEDBACKANDSTABILIZEDATTHEIRPRE9/11LEVELTHEFEDDIDHAVEAHANDINTHAT,BUTITWASONLYBYSTEPPINGUPWHATWEDBEENDOINGBEFORE9/11,CUTTINGINTERESTRATESTOMAKEITEASIERFORPEOPLETOBORROWANDSPENDIDIDNTMINDSEEINGMYEXPECTATIONSUPSET,BECAUSETHEECONOMYSREMARKABLERESPONSETOTHEAFTERMATHOF9/11WASPROOFOFANENORMOUSLYIMPORTANTFACTOURECONOMYHADBECOMEHIGHLYRESILIENTWHATIDSAIDSOOPTIMISTICALLYTOTHESENATEBANKINGCOMMITTEETURNEDOUTTOBETRUEAFTERTHOSEFIRSTAWFULWEEKS,AMERICASHOUSEHOLDSANDBUSINESSESRECOVEREDWHATHADGENERATEDSUCHANUNPRECEDENTEDDEGREEOFECONOMICFLEXIBILITYIASKEDMYSELFECONOMISTSHAVEBEENTRYINGTOANSWERQUESTIONSLIKETHATSINCETHEDAYSOFADAMSMITHWETHINKWEHAVEOURHANDSFULLTODAYTRYINGTOCOMPREHENDOURGLOBALIZEDECONOMYBUTSMITHHADTOIN