6G 非地面网络中基于正交频分复用的波形:对比分析_第1页
6G 非地面网络中基于正交频分复用的波形:对比分析_第2页
6G 非地面网络中基于正交频分复用的波形:对比分析_第3页
6G 非地面网络中基于正交频分复用的波形:对比分析_第4页
6G 非地面网络中基于正交频分复用的波形:对比分析_第5页
已阅读5页,还剩15页未读, 继续免费阅读

下载本文档

版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领

文档简介

Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.

6GFROMTHESKY

OFDM-BASEDWAVEFORMSIN6GNTN:

ACOMPARATIVEANALYSIS

tionsthateffectivelyandsmoothlyintegratewith

future6Gterrestrialtelecommunicationsystems

ABSTRACT

5Gnewradio(NR)hassupportednon-

terrestrialnetworks(NTN)toextendcoverageto

underservedregionsthroughminimalandneces-

saryadaptationstotheNRprotocolstack.Looking

ahead,6Gisenvisionedtointegrateterrestrial

networks(TNs)andNTNsfromdayone,estab-

lishingaresilient,unifiedwirelessinfrastructure.

However,thisconvergenceintroduceschallenges,

particularlyinthedomainofradioaccesstech-

nologies,suchastheidentificationofanNTN

compatiblewaveforminherentlymoreresilientto

thechallengesofsatellitecommunicationsystems.

Tothisend,thispapercomparesfourdifferent

waveforms,namelycyclicprefixorthogonalfre-

quencydivisionmultiplexing(CP-OFDM),discrete

Fouriertransform-spreadOFDM(DFT-s-OFDM),

block-filteredOFDM(BF-OFDM),andorthogonal

timefrequencyspace(OTFS),basedonproper-

tiesthatsupportNTNlinkcharacteristics.Thus,

thisworkconsiders:i)NTN-specificimpairments,

particularlydelayandDopplershiftimpairments

typicalofnon-geostationaryorbits,andii)the

nonlineardistortionsinducedbyhigh-power

amplifiers.Weassesstheimpactofthemen-

tionedimpairmentsonthewaveformsthrough

biterrorrate(BER)loss,powerspectraldensity

(PSD),adjacentchannelleakageratio(ACLR),and

totaldegradation(TD)inasingle-usersingle-beam

scenario.Furthermore,weconsiderafifthwave-

formthatcombinesfilteringandDFTspreading,

namelyDFT-s-BF-OFDM.Finally,weevaluatethe

peak-to-averagepowerratio(PAPR)ofDFT-s-

OFDMandCP-OFDMinamulti-usermulti-beam

scenarioconsideringbothfrequencyandspace

divisionmultiplexingtechniques.

INTRODUCTION

Theintegrationofnon-terrestrialnetworks(NTN)

into6G(6GNTN)isanticipatedtoplayapivotal

servicesandensuringscalableandresilientsolu-

roleinprovidinghighthroughputandlowlatency

[1],[2].Thesupportofsatellitelinksin5Gwas

firststudiedin3GPPReleases15and16,and

undertakestudiesaimedatidentifyingthetech-

nicalaspectsmostaffectedbyNTN-specific

characteristics.

continuedwiththenormativephaseinRelease

17,whichprovidedthebasicfunctionalityfor

NTNintegrationinto5Gnewradio(NR).Topre-

servecommonalitywiththeterrestrialnetwork

(TN),onlystrictlynecessarymodificationstothe

NRprotocolstackwereintroduced;inlinewith

thisprinciple,bothcyclicprefixorthogonalfre-

quencydivisionmultiplexing(CP-OFDM)and

discreteFouriertransform-spreadOFDM(DFT-s-

OFDM)wereretainedasthecorewaveformsfor

theNTNcomponent[3].CP-OFDM,however,

wasnotoriginallyconceivedfortheimpairments

characterizingsatellitelinks(i.e.,highdelayand

Dopplershift).Moreover,thesatellite-to-handheld

linksufferssubstantialpathlosses,duetothelong

propagationdistanceandthedeviceantennaloss,

whichcanbecompensatedbyraisingtheeffective

isotropicradiatedpowereitherinthedeviceorin

thesatellitethroughmoreinnovativeplatforms

andconstellationarchitectures[2].However,

CP-OFDMischaracterizedbyhighpeak-to-

averagepowerratio(PAPR),whichreducesthe

effectivenessofthehigh-poweramplifier(HPA),

resultingindecreasedpowerefficiency.

Preliminarydiscussionsonthe6Gwaveform

designwereheldat3GPPRAN1#122[4],where

CP-OFDMandDFT-s-OFDMwereendorsedas

asthebaselineforthedownlink,whileleavingthe

dooropentoenhancements,modifications,and

baselinewaveformsfortheuplinkandCP-OFDM

agreementsretainNRchannelcoding,modula-

tion,andframestructurewithpossibleextensions

additionalOFDM-basedvariants.Complementary

link).RegardingNTN,3GPPRAN1agreedto

(e.g.,1024-QAMinuplink,4096-QAMindown-

Withinthisframework,thepresentwork,which

isoneoftheoutcomesoftheSNS-JUfundedproj-

ect6G-NTN[5],comparesthetwowaveforms

OFDM,withtwofurtherwaveforms:orthogonal

timefrequencyspace(OTFS),proposedin3GPP

alreadyendorsedin3GPP,CP-OFDMandDFT-s-

toitsrobustnessinhigh-mobilityandNTNsce-

narios,andblock-filteredOFDM(BF-OFDM),

for5G[R1-162930]and6G[R1-2508336]owing

Thisworkwassupportedbythe6G-NTNProjectunderSNSJUthroughEuropeanUnion'sHorizonEurope

ResearchandInnovationProgramunderGrant

101096479.

DigitalObjectherntifier0.1109/MCDMSTD2026.3732522

CarlaAmatettiandAlessandroVanelliCorallirewiththeDepartmentofElectrical,Electronic,andInformationEngineering.

UniversityofBologna,40136Bologna,taly;MariusCaus,MusbahShaat,andMiguelAngelVazquezarewithCentreTecnologicDe

TelecomunicacionesDeCatalunya(CTTC)08860BarcelonaSpain;EduardoMedeiros,ChaoZhangPe-ErikEriksson,andSebastian

EulerarewithEricssonAB,16480Stockholm,Sweden;DorinPanaitopolandSoryaTongarewithThalesSIXGTSFranceSAS,Genneilliers

92230,France;EstefaniaRecayteiswithDeutschesZentrumfürLuft-undRaumfahrteV.(DLR),51147Koln,Germany.

IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine4.0License.Formoreinformation,see

/licenses/by/4.0/1

Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.

choseninthisstudyforitsspectralcontainment

andresourceblock(RB)-levelgranularityinband-

widthallocation.Thecomparisoniscarriedoutin

asingle-usersingle-beamscenario,accountingfor

thedominantimpairmentsencounteredinNTN

links,namelypropagationdelayandDopplershift,

andthenonlineardistortionsintroducedbythe

HPA.Wepresentadetailednumericalanalysis

thatquantifiestheimpactoftimeandfrequency

synchronizationerrorsandHPAnonlinearitieson

eachwaveform.Therobustnesstoresidualsyn-

chronizationerrorsisassessedthroughthebit

errorrate(BER)loss,whiletheresiliencytoHPA

nonlinearitiesisevaluatedthroughpowerspec-

traldensity(PSD),adjacentchannelleakageratio

(ACLR),andtotaldegradation(TD).Wefurther

investigateafifthwaveformthatcouplesRB-level

filteringwithPAPRreductionbycombining

BF-OFDMwithDFTspreading,andwebench-

markitsperformanceagainstDFT-s-OFDMwith

andwithoutadigitalpredistortion(DPD).Finally,

weassessthePAPRbehaviorofDFT-s-OFDMin

therelevantNTNscenarioofmultipleusersinthe

downlink.

Atthereceiver,theWignertransformandsym-

CONSIDEREDWAVEFORMS

Thissectionprovidesabriefoverviewofthecon-sideredwaveforms.

OFDM

InCP-OFDM,ablockofKsymbolsisusedto

modulateKsubcarriers.Thisisfollowedbyan

inversediscreteFouriertransform(IDFT)andthe

additionofaCP,whichshallbelongerthanthe

channelimpulseresponse.Asignificantadvantage

ofCP-OFDMisitsabilitytomaintaincomplete

orthogonalityfortransmissionsoverchannelsthat

aredispersiveonlyintime.Atthereceiverside,

afterthesignalpropagatesthroughthechannel,

theCPisremoved,andtheblockofreceived

symbolsundergoesaDFT.

DFT-s-0FDM

InDFT-s-OFDM,themodulationsymbolsarepre-

codedthroughaDFTblockbeforetheIDFT,so

thattheoutputisessentiallyasingle-carriersignal.

ThemappingoftheDFTprecoderoutputtothe

IDFTinputcanbelocalizedordistributed.Inthe

localizedcase,ablockofconsecutiveIDFTinputs

(subcarriers)isused.Inthedistributedcase,

uniformlyspacedsubcarriersovertheentireband-

widthareused.Distributedmappingprovides

frequencydiversity,whereaslocalizedmapping

ispreferableifchannelqualityinformationisavail-

ableonasub-bandbasis.

BF-0FDM

BF-OFDMispartofthefilterbankmulti-carrier

(FBMC)family.Thetransmitterconsistsofa

predistortionstagefollowedbyprecodingand

filterbank.ThereareMK/2carriersdividedinto

Msub-bandsandeachsub-bandisallocatedK

subcarriers,buttopreserveorthogonality,only

K/2subcarrierswithineachsub-bandareusedto

carrydata.Theprecodingschemeisperformed

throughanIDFTofsizeKperformedforeach

sub-band,followedbytheadditionofaCPto

maintainthecircularityofthereceivedsignal.

TheoutputsfromallMstagesarethenprocessed

throughafilterbank,whichisparameterizedby

aprototypefilterwithanoverlapfactorN.Apre-distortionprocessisappliedtoeachsubcarriertoensurethatthereceivercanrelyonasingle

tletrob,pinlrhial

distortions.Thankstothepredistortionstage,nofilteringisrequiredatthereceiversidewhichcanbereducedtoaMK/2-pointsDFTprecededbyaCPremoval.Thankstoitspredistortionstage,

e-ilo[]CP-OFDM

OTFS

OTFSencodesinformationinthedelay-Doppler

(DD)domaininsteadoftheconventionaltime-fre-

quency(TF)plane[7].Thisrepresentationis

effectiveinsparsemultipathenvironments,where

thechannelresponseintheDDdomainbecomes

compactandeasiertoequalize.OTFSmodula-

tioncanbeimplementedintwomainways.The

conventionalapproachinvolvesmappingDD-do-

mainsymbolstotheTFdomainviatheinverse

symplecticfiniteFouriertransform(ISFFT),fol-

lowedbytime-domainsignalgenerationusing

usingmulti-carriermodulationsuchasOFDM.

theHeisenbergtransform,typicallyimplemented

plecticfiniteFouriertransform(SFFT)areusedto

recovertheDD-domainsymbols.Alternatively,

OTFScanberealizedusingthediscreteZaktrans-

form(DZT),whichreformulatesthemodulation

anddemodulationprocessesina2Dperiodic

functionspace.ThisDZT-basedapproachoffers

lowercomplexityandfacilitatespulse-shaping

techniquesforimprovedspectralandtemporal

localization.

IMPACTOFTHESATELLITECHANNEL

Innon-geostationarysatelliteorbits(NGSO),

Dopplereffectsandpropagationdelayaremore

pronouncedthaninterrestrialnetworksduetothe

higherrelativevelocityanddistancebetweensat-

ellitesandusers.BothdelayandDopplershiftcan

becompensated.Thestandard-compliantsolution

reliesonthepre-compensationattheuserequip-

ment(UE)side.Indeed,toestablishaconnection

withasatellite,3GPPNTNUEsshallperform

delayandDopplershiftpre-compensationinthe

uplink,basedontheknowledgeoftheirown

positionacquiredthroughtheglobalnavigation

satellitesystem(GNSS)receiverandsatellitecom-

municationephemerisbroadcastbythenetwork

throughthesysteminformationblock(SIB)19

[3],[8].Otherapproachesuseproprietarymeth-

odsindownlinktocalculatecompensationvalues

forthebeamcenter.Inallcases,residualerrors

persist.Ontheonehand,intheuplink,theyare

causedbyGNSSreceiverinaccuracies;onthe

otherhand,inthedownlink,theydependon

thereducedcompensationaccuracyforusers

locatedawayfromthebeamcenterorerrorsin

thepost-compensationprocessattheUEside.

Althoughthesesynchronizationerrorsaresmaller

thantheinitialDopplershiftsandpropagation

delays,theycanstillsignificantlyimpairsystem

performance.

Indeed,carrierfrequencyoffsetcausesa

lossoforthogonalitybetweensubcarriersin

multi-carrierwaveforms,suchasCP-OFDM

andBF-OFDM,inducingSNRdegradationand

2IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine

Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.

IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine3

maximizingpowerefficiencyandthroughput

inter-carrierinterference(ICI).ForDFT-s-OFDM,

Dopplershiftsintroduceattenuation,phaserota-

tioninthereceivedconstellation,andinter-symbol

interference(ISI).InOTFS,theDDdomainrepre-

sentationoffersincreasedrobustnesstocarrier

frequencyoffset,butthefractionaloffsetcompo-

nentcausesinterferenceamongsymbolsinthe

delay-Dopplerplane.

Residualtimesynchronizationerrorscause

twokeyeffects:i)circularshiftsinthecomplex

basebandsignalwhentheerroriswithintheCP

protectionwindow,andii)SNRdegradationand

iSIwhenmisalignmentsexceedthiswindow.

TheeffectivenessoftheCPprotection

dependsonmultiplefactors,notablytheDFTwin-

length.

dowplacementatthereceiverandtheactualCP

IMPACTOFTHEHIGHPoWERAMPLIFIER

coverageunderhighpropagationlossesliesin

Akeydesignchallengeinenablingubiquitous

onbothserviceandfeederlinks.Tothisend,

HPAs,eitheronboardsatellitesoratusertermi-

nals,mustoperatenearsaturationwheretheir

Suchnonlinearitiesprimarilyinducetwoforms

ofperformancedegradation:out-of-band(OoB)

input-outputresponsebecomeshighlynonlinear.

emissionsandin-banddistortion,whichcanbe

tackledwithdifferenttechniques.

ToquantifyOoBemissions,twometricsaretypicallyused:i)thePSD,whichallowscompar-isonofspectralcontainmentacrosswaveforms,andii)ACLR,aconcisescalarmetricthatassessesfrequencyleakage,neglectingtheimpactofemis-sionsinfrequencyguard-bandsdesignatedtoprotectneighboringchannels.

Toevaluatein-banddistortionforagivenblock

errorrate(BLER),TD,ametricwidelyusedto

characterizetheperformanceofawaveformafter

theHPAstage[9],isintroduced.Indeed,itquanti-

fiestwotypesofperformancedegradation:i)the

increasedSNRneededtomeettheBLERtarget

duetoHPA-induceddistortion(relativetoanideal

linearamplifierandadditivewhiteGaussiannoise

(AWGN)channel),andii)thepowerlossatthe

HPAoutput(ie.,thebackoff)necessarytosustain

thesameBLER.Theabovelossesquantifiedby

theTDexhibtatrade-off.Indeed,anincreased

backoffreducestheadditionalSNRrequiredto

meettheBLERtarget,andconversely,alower

backoffresultsinhigherSNRpenaltiesdueto

increaseddistortion.Assuch,theTDcanbemini-

mizedtodeterminetheoptimalbackoffvaluethat

balancesthesecompetingeffects.

TheTDis,therefore,definedas[9]:

whereTDdBisthetotaldegradation,

istheSNRrequiredtoobtaintheBLERtarget

whenthenonlinearHPAisconsideredataback-

robustnessagainstsynchronizationerrors,we

offsuchthatthemeanoutputpowerisOBOdB

(i.e.,theoutputbackoff)belowthesaturationlevel

atitsoutput.istheSNRrequiredto

obtainthesameBLERtargetwhenaperfectlylin-earHPAisconsidered.TheTDisafunctionofthebackoffbothexplicitlyviatheOBOdBtermand

implicitlyvia.Generally,largerbackoffimpliesasmallerdistortionand,therefore,asmallerdifferencebetweentheSNRtermsintheaboveequation.

NUMERICALEVALUATION

Thissectionevaluatesthewaveforms'perfor-manceunderresidualsynchronizationerrorsandHPAnonlinearities.

WAVEFORMGENERATIONANDSYSTEMCONFGURATION

Forallwaveforms,thetransportblockisgenerated

inthesamewayfollowingtheNRspecifications

[10].Regardingnumerology,weadopta120

kHzsubcarrierspacing,atotalnumberof32

RBs,14OFDM/OTFSsymbolsperslot,andone

demodulationreferencesignal(DMRS)symbol

forCP-OFDM,DFT-s-OFDM,andBF-OFDM.For

OTFS,weconsiderasinglepilot,surroundedby

anumberofnon-dataresourceelementsequal

tothelengthoftheDMRSsequence.Intermsof

modulationandcodingscheme,weconsidera

QPSKwithcoderate379/1024.Thesynchroni-

zationerroranalysisisperformedasafunctionof

errorsthatremainafterpre-compensation,where

theresidualtimingandfrequencysynchronization

thefrequencyoffsetsarenormalizedtothesub-

carrierspacing(SCS)andspan[10-4,10-1],while

timeoffsetsrangefrom0to8192samples,ie.,

thelengthinsamplesofoneOFDM/OTFSsym-

bolwithouttheCP.TheSNRisvariedwithinthe

range[0,10]dB.

Thefollowingdetailsapplytotheimplementa-tionofthewaveforms:

usablesizecorrespondingtothenumber

·BF-OFDM:asub-bandwithaneffective

ofsubcarriersinaRB(i.e.,12)isadopted,

alongwithaGaussianpulseshapeoflength

NM(N=4,thefilter-bankoverlappingfac-

tor,MthenumberofallocatedRBs).Apre-

distortionstageisaddedtocompensatethe

distortioninducedbythetransmitfilter.

·OTFS:DZT-basedOTFSmodulationisadopted,withaCPappliedonaper-blockbasis.Asquare-rootraisedcosine(SRRC)pulse-shapingfilterwitharoll-offfactorof

0.1isemployed.InOTFSmodulation,infor-mationsymbolsaremappedontoa12M×Ndatagrid,whereMandNdenotethenumberofRBsandthenumberofsymbolsperslot,respectively.

DFT-s-OFDM:theDFTsizecorrespondstothebandwidthallocation.

·CP-OFDMisimplementedaccordingtotheNRspecifications[10].

Asymbol-leveldetectorisemployedfor

CP-OFDM,DFT-s-OFDM,andBF-OFDM,whilea

message-passingalgorithmisusedforOTFS.This

workfocusesontherobustnesstothesynchroni-

optimizationisperformed.Inparticular,toassess

zationerrorsandnonlinearities,thusnoreceiver

ingtheCPdurationandtheimpactoffilteringon

investigatedwaveform-relatedparameters,includ-

resiliencetotheseerrors.

Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.

IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine

BER

BER

10-05

10-0.5, 10-110-1.5 10-210-2.5, 10-³、10-3.5.

10-4

10

10-210-³

SNR(dB)

10-¹1

10-15

10~²

1035

10⁴

10-25

10⁻³

10-1

10-0.5

10-¹

10-1.5

10-2.5

10-³

10-3.5

10⁻⁴

atthehighestoffsets;however,thedegradation

FrequencyOffsetNormalizedtoSC

(a)CP-OFDMBERevaluatedunderdifferentSNRvaluesand

frequencyoffsets.

SNR(dB)

TimeOffsetNormalizedtoSymbolDuration

(b)CP-OFDMBERevaluatedunderdifferentSNRvaluesand

timeoffsets.

FGURE1ContourandsurfaceplotofCP-0FDMBERinthepresenceofa)residualfrequencyandb)timesynchroniza-

tionerrors.

RegardingtheHPA,weusedthemodelpro-posedin[11],whichisbasedonthegeneralized

memorypolynomialmodel.Inparticular,weconsiderthememorylessCMOSHPAresearchprototypeat28GHz.

ASSESSMENTOFRESIDUALTIMEANDFREQUENCYSYNCHRONIZATIONERRORS

1)ImpactofResidualFrequencyErrors:Toassess

waveformperformanceunderfrequencysynchro-

nizationerrors,theBERiscomputedforeach

waveform.Notably,thesensitivitytofrequency

offsetgrowswithSNR,asthenoisebecomesless

dominant.TakingasareferencetheuncodedBER

performanceofCP-OFDM,Fig.1(a)delineates

threeoperationalregions.RegionIcomprises

thenoise-limitedregion,whereperformanceis

unimpairedbyfrequencyoffset.Onthecontrary,

regionIlinvolvesperformancedominatedby

energylossandinterferencelinkedtothelossof

orthogonalityduetothefrequencyoffset.Finally,

regionIlrepresentsatransitionregion,where

bothnoiseandfrequencyoffsethaveasimilar

impactontheBER.

Regardingtheremainingwaveformvariants,Fig.2(a)showstheBERperformancerelativetothatofCP-OFDMintermsofBERloss(BERloss),whosepercentageiscomputedasfollows:

(2)

BERossmakesthecomparisonofthewave-

formswithrespecttoCP-OFDMimmediately

readable,bothinsignandinmagnitude.Indeed,

anegativeBERlossindicatesimprovedperfor-

mance,whileapositiveBERlossimpliesinferior

performancecomparedtoCP-OFDM.Thus,itis

possibletoobservethat:i)BF-OFDMdegrades

withincreasingSNRinregionsIandIlduetothe

impactoffilterdispersiononISI.Ontheother

hand,asevidenced,thestrictlypositiveandlow

BERlossathighfrequencyoffsetvaluesconfirms

thatIClisnotsignificantlyreducedbytheRB-level

filtering.Indeed,theBERlossremainsclosetozero

withinregionIastheinducedIClisdominated

bycontributionsfromimmediatelyneighboring

subcarriers,whicharenotsufficientlyreducedby

theimprovedfrequencylocalizationattheRB

level.ii)DFT-s-OFDMmayexhibitincreaseddeg-

radationfornormalizedfrequencyoffsetsabove

10-2withinregionIIduetotheinducedsymbol-

dependentphaseramp,inoppositiontothe

flatphaserotationobservedinCP-OFDM[12].

Despitethelatter,theBERlossremainsbelow5%

throughouttheevaluatedSNRandfrequencyoff-

setranges.Finally,ii)acrossregionI,OTFSshows

aslightlypositiveBERlossi.e.,aminimaldegra-

dation.InregionII,theBERlossexhibitsnegative

valuesbuttrendsupwardtowardzeroasthecom-

binedeffectsofnoiseandfrequencyoffsetgrow,

reinforcingOTFS'ssuperiorityoverCP-OFDMin

theBERossforOTFSshiftsintolowpositivevalues

thistransitionalregime.WhenenteringregionII,

remainsbounded.

2)ImpactofResidualTimeErrors:Forthisanalysis,thereceiverisassumedtobeabletoperfectlycompensateforthephaseshiftinthefre-quencydomaininducedbythetimedrift(whichresemblesacircularshiftduetotheCP).There-fore,weanalyzeandcomparetheabilityoftheconsideredwaveformstowithstandtheunavoid-ableISIandICIinterferenceduetoresidualtimesynchronizationerrors.Asinthepreviouscase,theBERiscomputedforallwaveformsundertheabove-mentionedtimeoffsetsandSNRvalues.

Fig.1(b)displaysthecontourplotofthe

uncodedBERforCP-OFDM,whichhelpsto

identifythesamethreeregionsobtainedinthe

previouscase.InregionI,theresidualtimesyn-

chronizationerrorisshorterthantheCPlength,

whileintheothertworegionsitislonger.

Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.

IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine5

BERloss(%)

p-

SNR(dB)

FrequeneyoffsetNormalizedtoSCS

7

1

SNR(dB)

FrequencyOffsetNormalizedtoscS

FrequeneyoffsetNormalizedtoscs

SNR(dB)

SNR(dB)

evaluated

TimeOffstNormalizedtoSymbolDuration

underdifferentSNRvaluestimeoffset.

(a)BERlossevaluatedunderdifferentSNRvalues

frequencyoffset.

DFT-s-0FDM

10⁻¹

TimeOffsetNormalizedtoSymbolDuration

(b)BERloss

and

TimeOffsetNormalizedtoSymbolduration

and

RGURE2.BERasundera)frequencyandb)timeofsets.CP-0FDMisconsideredashaselineforthecomputationotheBERI

ReferringtoFig.2(b),itispossibletoobservethat:

i)DFT-s-OFDMperformswellforoffsetsbelow

theCPduration;ii)BF-OFDMundergoesadet-

rimentduetoataperingaroundtheboundaries

oftheeffectiveCPprotectionwindowrelatedto

theinvolvedfilteringprocesses;iii)OTFSoutper-

formsCP-OFDMfortimeoffsetsexceedingthe

CPdurationofCP-OFDM.Thisenhancedrobust-

nessstemsfromthefactthatthereisoneCPin

OTFS,withalengthequivalenttothecumulative

CPsofallOFDMsymbolswithinaslot.Thissug-

geststhatperformanceisnotdegradedifthetime

offsetiswithintheCPblock.Insuchacase,the

performanceismoretiedtotheSNRregimeof

operationthantothetimemisalignment.

Therefore,albeitwithminordifferences,the

CPprotectsallconsideredwaveformvariants

fromtheimpactoftimesynchronizationerrors

roughlyuptoitsduration.

ASSESSMENTOFTHEHPAIMPACTONTHEWAVEFORMS

1)Single-UserSingle-BeamScenario:Wefirstana-

yzethePAPRandPSD(priortoamplification)to

betterunderstandthewaveforms'behaviorafter

amplification.SincethePAPRorderingofthefour

waveformsispreservedacrossmodulationschemes

andbandwidths[5],[13],thestudyfocusesona

ingthescenariowithoutdigitalpredistortion),

singlemodulationandcodingschemeandasingle

bandwidthwithoutlossofgenerality.

ReferringtoFig.3(a),asexpected,thePAPRdis-tributionofDFT-s-OFDMdifferssignificantlyfromthoseoftheotherwaveforms.Indeed,thePAPRgrowswiththenumberofsubcarriersK.Neverthe-less,DFT-s-OFDMspreadseachsymbolovertheavailablebandwidthbeforetheIDFT.RegardingOTFS,thePAPRdependsonthenumberofOTFSsymbols,sincetheIDFTisperformedalongtheDopplerdomain,andthepilotconfiguration[14].

ReferringtoFig.3(b),thePSDofthediffer-entwaveformsisreported.Inparticular,focusingonthebluelines,representingthePSDbeforetheamplification,itispossibletonotethat,asexpected,thefrequencyresponseoftherectan-gularpulseshape(intheCP-OFDMcase)leadstoahighOoBleakage.WhenitcomestoBF-OFDM,itachievesthebestOoBrejectionwithalmost45dBgaincomparedtoCP-OFDM.Infact,suchasubstantialgainisduetotheimprovedfrequencylocalizationofthefilterusedinthesynthesisfilterbankofBF-OFDM.OTFS(likeCP-OFDM)intro-ducesinterferencetotheneighboringbandsand,hence,anSRRCpulseshapingisadoptedherefortheOTFStoreducetheOoBinterference.

MovingtotheanalysisoftheOoBemission

afteramplification,Fig.4(a)reportstheACLR.

Observingthecurvesmarkedwithsquares(denot-

AnACLRthresholdof30dBisconsidered[15].

Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.

IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine

PSD

-10

-20

-30

-40

-60

-70

-80

-90

-100

-500

PAPR(dB)

(a)

CPandDFT-s-OFDMbeforePA

CPand

OTFSbeforePA

BF-OFDMbeforePA

-400-300-200-100100200

Frequency(MHz)

(b)

DFT-s-OFDMafterPA

OTFSafterPA

BF-OFDMafterPA

300400

FGURE3.Waveforms'performanceintermsofPAPRandPSD.a)PAPRcomparisonacrosstheconsideredwaveforms.

b)PSDcomparisonoftheifferentwaveforms.BlulinesrepresentthePSDbeforeamplification,blacklinesafteramplification.

DFT-s-OFDMdemonstratessuperiorperfor-mancecomparedtotheotherwaveforms.ThisadvantagestemsfromthestrongdependenceofHPA-inducednonlineardistortiononbothPAPRandbackoff,indicatingthatOoBemissionsaremostlydominatedbyHPA-inducednonlin-earities.ThisinterpretationisfurthersupportedbythePSDanalysisinFig.3(b)(blackcurves),whichshowsthatthespectralcontainmentben-efitsofBFOFDM,followingtheHPAstage,arelesspronouncedneartheallocatedbandwidth,whereadjacentchannels(themostsusceptibletointerference)lie.Infact,BF-OFDMachievesareductionintherequiredOBOtosatisfyACLRconstraintsbyonly0.5dBrelativetoCP-OFDM.

Conversely,DFTspreadingachieves

温馨提示

  • 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
  • 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
  • 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
  • 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
  • 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
  • 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
  • 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。

评论

0/150

提交评论