版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.
6GFROMTHESKY
OFDM-BASEDWAVEFORMSIN6GNTN:
ACOMPARATIVEANALYSIS
tionsthateffectivelyandsmoothlyintegratewith
future6Gterrestrialtelecommunicationsystems
ABSTRACT
5Gnewradio(NR)hassupportednon-
terrestrialnetworks(NTN)toextendcoverageto
underservedregionsthroughminimalandneces-
saryadaptationstotheNRprotocolstack.Looking
ahead,6Gisenvisionedtointegrateterrestrial
networks(TNs)andNTNsfromdayone,estab-
lishingaresilient,unifiedwirelessinfrastructure.
However,thisconvergenceintroduceschallenges,
particularlyinthedomainofradioaccesstech-
nologies,suchastheidentificationofanNTN
compatiblewaveforminherentlymoreresilientto
thechallengesofsatellitecommunicationsystems.
Tothisend,thispapercomparesfourdifferent
waveforms,namelycyclicprefixorthogonalfre-
quencydivisionmultiplexing(CP-OFDM),discrete
Fouriertransform-spreadOFDM(DFT-s-OFDM),
block-filteredOFDM(BF-OFDM),andorthogonal
timefrequencyspace(OTFS),basedonproper-
tiesthatsupportNTNlinkcharacteristics.Thus,
thisworkconsiders:i)NTN-specificimpairments,
particularlydelayandDopplershiftimpairments
typicalofnon-geostationaryorbits,andii)the
nonlineardistortionsinducedbyhigh-power
amplifiers.Weassesstheimpactofthemen-
tionedimpairmentsonthewaveformsthrough
biterrorrate(BER)loss,powerspectraldensity
(PSD),adjacentchannelleakageratio(ACLR),and
totaldegradation(TD)inasingle-usersingle-beam
scenario.Furthermore,weconsiderafifthwave-
formthatcombinesfilteringandDFTspreading,
namelyDFT-s-BF-OFDM.Finally,weevaluatethe
peak-to-averagepowerratio(PAPR)ofDFT-s-
OFDMandCP-OFDMinamulti-usermulti-beam
scenarioconsideringbothfrequencyandspace
divisionmultiplexingtechniques.
INTRODUCTION
Theintegrationofnon-terrestrialnetworks(NTN)
into6G(6GNTN)isanticipatedtoplayapivotal
servicesandensuringscalableandresilientsolu-
roleinprovidinghighthroughputandlowlatency
[1],[2].Thesupportofsatellitelinksin5Gwas
firststudiedin3GPPReleases15and16,and
undertakestudiesaimedatidentifyingthetech-
nicalaspectsmostaffectedbyNTN-specific
characteristics.
continuedwiththenormativephaseinRelease
17,whichprovidedthebasicfunctionalityfor
NTNintegrationinto5Gnewradio(NR).Topre-
servecommonalitywiththeterrestrialnetwork
(TN),onlystrictlynecessarymodificationstothe
NRprotocolstackwereintroduced;inlinewith
thisprinciple,bothcyclicprefixorthogonalfre-
quencydivisionmultiplexing(CP-OFDM)and
discreteFouriertransform-spreadOFDM(DFT-s-
OFDM)wereretainedasthecorewaveformsfor
theNTNcomponent[3].CP-OFDM,however,
wasnotoriginallyconceivedfortheimpairments
characterizingsatellitelinks(i.e.,highdelayand
Dopplershift).Moreover,thesatellite-to-handheld
linksufferssubstantialpathlosses,duetothelong
propagationdistanceandthedeviceantennaloss,
whichcanbecompensatedbyraisingtheeffective
isotropicradiatedpowereitherinthedeviceorin
thesatellitethroughmoreinnovativeplatforms
andconstellationarchitectures[2].However,
CP-OFDMischaracterizedbyhighpeak-to-
averagepowerratio(PAPR),whichreducesthe
effectivenessofthehigh-poweramplifier(HPA),
resultingindecreasedpowerefficiency.
Preliminarydiscussionsonthe6Gwaveform
designwereheldat3GPPRAN1#122[4],where
CP-OFDMandDFT-s-OFDMwereendorsedas
asthebaselineforthedownlink,whileleavingthe
dooropentoenhancements,modifications,and
baselinewaveformsfortheuplinkandCP-OFDM
agreementsretainNRchannelcoding,modula-
tion,andframestructurewithpossibleextensions
additionalOFDM-basedvariants.Complementary
link).RegardingNTN,3GPPRAN1agreedto
(e.g.,1024-QAMinuplink,4096-QAMindown-
Withinthisframework,thepresentwork,which
isoneoftheoutcomesoftheSNS-JUfundedproj-
ect6G-NTN[5],comparesthetwowaveforms
OFDM,withtwofurtherwaveforms:orthogonal
timefrequencyspace(OTFS),proposedin3GPP
alreadyendorsedin3GPP,CP-OFDMandDFT-s-
toitsrobustnessinhigh-mobilityandNTNsce-
narios,andblock-filteredOFDM(BF-OFDM),
for5G[R1-162930]and6G[R1-2508336]owing
Thisworkwassupportedbythe6G-NTNProjectunderSNSJUthroughEuropeanUnion'sHorizonEurope
ResearchandInnovationProgramunderGrant
101096479.
DigitalObjectherntifier0.1109/MCDMSTD2026.3732522
CarlaAmatettiandAlessandroVanelliCorallirewiththeDepartmentofElectrical,Electronic,andInformationEngineering.
UniversityofBologna,40136Bologna,taly;MariusCaus,MusbahShaat,andMiguelAngelVazquezarewithCentreTecnologicDe
TelecomunicacionesDeCatalunya(CTTC)08860BarcelonaSpain;EduardoMedeiros,ChaoZhangPe-ErikEriksson,andSebastian
EulerarewithEricssonAB,16480Stockholm,Sweden;DorinPanaitopolandSoryaTongarewithThalesSIXGTSFranceSAS,Genneilliers
92230,France;EstefaniaRecayteiswithDeutschesZentrumfürLuft-undRaumfahrteV.(DLR),51147Koln,Germany.
IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine4.0License.Formoreinformation,see
/licenses/by/4.0/1
Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.
choseninthisstudyforitsspectralcontainment
andresourceblock(RB)-levelgranularityinband-
widthallocation.Thecomparisoniscarriedoutin
asingle-usersingle-beamscenario,accountingfor
thedominantimpairmentsencounteredinNTN
links,namelypropagationdelayandDopplershift,
andthenonlineardistortionsintroducedbythe
HPA.Wepresentadetailednumericalanalysis
thatquantifiestheimpactoftimeandfrequency
synchronizationerrorsandHPAnonlinearitieson
eachwaveform.Therobustnesstoresidualsyn-
chronizationerrorsisassessedthroughthebit
errorrate(BER)loss,whiletheresiliencytoHPA
nonlinearitiesisevaluatedthroughpowerspec-
traldensity(PSD),adjacentchannelleakageratio
(ACLR),andtotaldegradation(TD).Wefurther
investigateafifthwaveformthatcouplesRB-level
filteringwithPAPRreductionbycombining
BF-OFDMwithDFTspreading,andwebench-
markitsperformanceagainstDFT-s-OFDMwith
andwithoutadigitalpredistortion(DPD).Finally,
weassessthePAPRbehaviorofDFT-s-OFDMin
therelevantNTNscenarioofmultipleusersinthe
downlink.
Atthereceiver,theWignertransformandsym-
CONSIDEREDWAVEFORMS
Thissectionprovidesabriefoverviewofthecon-sideredwaveforms.
OFDM
InCP-OFDM,ablockofKsymbolsisusedto
modulateKsubcarriers.Thisisfollowedbyan
inversediscreteFouriertransform(IDFT)andthe
additionofaCP,whichshallbelongerthanthe
channelimpulseresponse.Asignificantadvantage
ofCP-OFDMisitsabilitytomaintaincomplete
orthogonalityfortransmissionsoverchannelsthat
aredispersiveonlyintime.Atthereceiverside,
afterthesignalpropagatesthroughthechannel,
theCPisremoved,andtheblockofreceived
symbolsundergoesaDFT.
DFT-s-0FDM
InDFT-s-OFDM,themodulationsymbolsarepre-
codedthroughaDFTblockbeforetheIDFT,so
thattheoutputisessentiallyasingle-carriersignal.
ThemappingoftheDFTprecoderoutputtothe
IDFTinputcanbelocalizedordistributed.Inthe
localizedcase,ablockofconsecutiveIDFTinputs
(subcarriers)isused.Inthedistributedcase,
uniformlyspacedsubcarriersovertheentireband-
widthareused.Distributedmappingprovides
frequencydiversity,whereaslocalizedmapping
ispreferableifchannelqualityinformationisavail-
ableonasub-bandbasis.
BF-0FDM
BF-OFDMispartofthefilterbankmulti-carrier
(FBMC)family.Thetransmitterconsistsofa
predistortionstagefollowedbyprecodingand
filterbank.ThereareMK/2carriersdividedinto
Msub-bandsandeachsub-bandisallocatedK
subcarriers,buttopreserveorthogonality,only
K/2subcarrierswithineachsub-bandareusedto
carrydata.Theprecodingschemeisperformed
throughanIDFTofsizeKperformedforeach
sub-band,followedbytheadditionofaCPto
maintainthecircularityofthereceivedsignal.
TheoutputsfromallMstagesarethenprocessed
throughafilterbank,whichisparameterizedby
aprototypefilterwithanoverlapfactorN.Apre-distortionprocessisappliedtoeachsubcarriertoensurethatthereceivercanrelyonasingle
tletrob,pinlrhial
distortions.Thankstothepredistortionstage,nofilteringisrequiredatthereceiversidewhichcanbereducedtoaMK/2-pointsDFTprecededbyaCPremoval.Thankstoitspredistortionstage,
e-ilo[]CP-OFDM
OTFS
OTFSencodesinformationinthedelay-Doppler
(DD)domaininsteadoftheconventionaltime-fre-
quency(TF)plane[7].Thisrepresentationis
effectiveinsparsemultipathenvironments,where
thechannelresponseintheDDdomainbecomes
compactandeasiertoequalize.OTFSmodula-
tioncanbeimplementedintwomainways.The
conventionalapproachinvolvesmappingDD-do-
mainsymbolstotheTFdomainviatheinverse
symplecticfiniteFouriertransform(ISFFT),fol-
lowedbytime-domainsignalgenerationusing
usingmulti-carriermodulationsuchasOFDM.
theHeisenbergtransform,typicallyimplemented
plecticfiniteFouriertransform(SFFT)areusedto
recovertheDD-domainsymbols.Alternatively,
OTFScanberealizedusingthediscreteZaktrans-
form(DZT),whichreformulatesthemodulation
anddemodulationprocessesina2Dperiodic
functionspace.ThisDZT-basedapproachoffers
lowercomplexityandfacilitatespulse-shaping
techniquesforimprovedspectralandtemporal
localization.
IMPACTOFTHESATELLITECHANNEL
Innon-geostationarysatelliteorbits(NGSO),
Dopplereffectsandpropagationdelayaremore
pronouncedthaninterrestrialnetworksduetothe
higherrelativevelocityanddistancebetweensat-
ellitesandusers.BothdelayandDopplershiftcan
becompensated.Thestandard-compliantsolution
reliesonthepre-compensationattheuserequip-
ment(UE)side.Indeed,toestablishaconnection
withasatellite,3GPPNTNUEsshallperform
delayandDopplershiftpre-compensationinthe
uplink,basedontheknowledgeoftheirown
positionacquiredthroughtheglobalnavigation
satellitesystem(GNSS)receiverandsatellitecom-
municationephemerisbroadcastbythenetwork
throughthesysteminformationblock(SIB)19
[3],[8].Otherapproachesuseproprietarymeth-
odsindownlinktocalculatecompensationvalues
forthebeamcenter.Inallcases,residualerrors
persist.Ontheonehand,intheuplink,theyare
causedbyGNSSreceiverinaccuracies;onthe
otherhand,inthedownlink,theydependon
thereducedcompensationaccuracyforusers
locatedawayfromthebeamcenterorerrorsin
thepost-compensationprocessattheUEside.
Althoughthesesynchronizationerrorsaresmaller
thantheinitialDopplershiftsandpropagation
delays,theycanstillsignificantlyimpairsystem
performance.
Indeed,carrierfrequencyoffsetcausesa
lossoforthogonalitybetweensubcarriersin
multi-carrierwaveforms,suchasCP-OFDM
andBF-OFDM,inducingSNRdegradationand
2IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine
Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.
IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine3
maximizingpowerefficiencyandthroughput
inter-carrierinterference(ICI).ForDFT-s-OFDM,
Dopplershiftsintroduceattenuation,phaserota-
tioninthereceivedconstellation,andinter-symbol
interference(ISI).InOTFS,theDDdomainrepre-
sentationoffersincreasedrobustnesstocarrier
frequencyoffset,butthefractionaloffsetcompo-
nentcausesinterferenceamongsymbolsinthe
delay-Dopplerplane.
Residualtimesynchronizationerrorscause
twokeyeffects:i)circularshiftsinthecomplex
basebandsignalwhentheerroriswithintheCP
protectionwindow,andii)SNRdegradationand
iSIwhenmisalignmentsexceedthiswindow.
TheeffectivenessoftheCPprotection
dependsonmultiplefactors,notablytheDFTwin-
length.
dowplacementatthereceiverandtheactualCP
IMPACTOFTHEHIGHPoWERAMPLIFIER
coverageunderhighpropagationlossesliesin
Akeydesignchallengeinenablingubiquitous
onbothserviceandfeederlinks.Tothisend,
HPAs,eitheronboardsatellitesoratusertermi-
nals,mustoperatenearsaturationwheretheir
Suchnonlinearitiesprimarilyinducetwoforms
ofperformancedegradation:out-of-band(OoB)
input-outputresponsebecomeshighlynonlinear.
emissionsandin-banddistortion,whichcanbe
tackledwithdifferenttechniques.
ToquantifyOoBemissions,twometricsaretypicallyused:i)thePSD,whichallowscompar-isonofspectralcontainmentacrosswaveforms,andii)ACLR,aconcisescalarmetricthatassessesfrequencyleakage,neglectingtheimpactofemis-sionsinfrequencyguard-bandsdesignatedtoprotectneighboringchannels.
Toevaluatein-banddistortionforagivenblock
errorrate(BLER),TD,ametricwidelyusedto
characterizetheperformanceofawaveformafter
theHPAstage[9],isintroduced.Indeed,itquanti-
fiestwotypesofperformancedegradation:i)the
increasedSNRneededtomeettheBLERtarget
duetoHPA-induceddistortion(relativetoanideal
linearamplifierandadditivewhiteGaussiannoise
(AWGN)channel),andii)thepowerlossatthe
HPAoutput(ie.,thebackoff)necessarytosustain
thesameBLER.Theabovelossesquantifiedby
theTDexhibtatrade-off.Indeed,anincreased
backoffreducestheadditionalSNRrequiredto
meettheBLERtarget,andconversely,alower
backoffresultsinhigherSNRpenaltiesdueto
increaseddistortion.Assuch,theTDcanbemini-
mizedtodeterminetheoptimalbackoffvaluethat
balancesthesecompetingeffects.
TheTDis,therefore,definedas[9]:
whereTDdBisthetotaldegradation,
istheSNRrequiredtoobtaintheBLERtarget
whenthenonlinearHPAisconsideredataback-
robustnessagainstsynchronizationerrors,we
offsuchthatthemeanoutputpowerisOBOdB
(i.e.,theoutputbackoff)belowthesaturationlevel
atitsoutput.istheSNRrequiredto
obtainthesameBLERtargetwhenaperfectlylin-earHPAisconsidered.TheTDisafunctionofthebackoffbothexplicitlyviatheOBOdBtermand
implicitlyvia.Generally,largerbackoffimpliesasmallerdistortionand,therefore,asmallerdifferencebetweentheSNRtermsintheaboveequation.
NUMERICALEVALUATION
Thissectionevaluatesthewaveforms'perfor-manceunderresidualsynchronizationerrorsandHPAnonlinearities.
WAVEFORMGENERATIONANDSYSTEMCONFGURATION
Forallwaveforms,thetransportblockisgenerated
inthesamewayfollowingtheNRspecifications
[10].Regardingnumerology,weadopta120
kHzsubcarrierspacing,atotalnumberof32
RBs,14OFDM/OTFSsymbolsperslot,andone
demodulationreferencesignal(DMRS)symbol
forCP-OFDM,DFT-s-OFDM,andBF-OFDM.For
OTFS,weconsiderasinglepilot,surroundedby
anumberofnon-dataresourceelementsequal
tothelengthoftheDMRSsequence.Intermsof
modulationandcodingscheme,weconsidera
QPSKwithcoderate379/1024.Thesynchroni-
zationerroranalysisisperformedasafunctionof
errorsthatremainafterpre-compensation,where
theresidualtimingandfrequencysynchronization
thefrequencyoffsetsarenormalizedtothesub-
carrierspacing(SCS)andspan[10-4,10-1],while
timeoffsetsrangefrom0to8192samples,ie.,
thelengthinsamplesofoneOFDM/OTFSsym-
bolwithouttheCP.TheSNRisvariedwithinthe
range[0,10]dB.
Thefollowingdetailsapplytotheimplementa-tionofthewaveforms:
usablesizecorrespondingtothenumber
·BF-OFDM:asub-bandwithaneffective
ofsubcarriersinaRB(i.e.,12)isadopted,
alongwithaGaussianpulseshapeoflength
NM(N=4,thefilter-bankoverlappingfac-
tor,MthenumberofallocatedRBs).Apre-
distortionstageisaddedtocompensatethe
distortioninducedbythetransmitfilter.
·OTFS:DZT-basedOTFSmodulationisadopted,withaCPappliedonaper-blockbasis.Asquare-rootraisedcosine(SRRC)pulse-shapingfilterwitharoll-offfactorof
0.1isemployed.InOTFSmodulation,infor-mationsymbolsaremappedontoa12M×Ndatagrid,whereMandNdenotethenumberofRBsandthenumberofsymbolsperslot,respectively.
DFT-s-OFDM:theDFTsizecorrespondstothebandwidthallocation.
·CP-OFDMisimplementedaccordingtotheNRspecifications[10].
Asymbol-leveldetectorisemployedfor
CP-OFDM,DFT-s-OFDM,andBF-OFDM,whilea
message-passingalgorithmisusedforOTFS.This
workfocusesontherobustnesstothesynchroni-
optimizationisperformed.Inparticular,toassess
zationerrorsandnonlinearities,thusnoreceiver
ingtheCPdurationandtheimpactoffilteringon
investigatedwaveform-relatedparameters,includ-
resiliencetotheseerrors.
Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.
IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine
BER
BER
10-05
10-0.5, 10-110-1.5 10-210-2.5, 10-³、10-3.5.
10-4
10
10-210-³
SNR(dB)
10-¹1
10-15
10~²
1035
10⁴
10-25
10⁻³
10-1
10-0.5
10-¹
10-1.5
10-2.5
10-³
10-3.5
10⁻⁴
atthehighestoffsets;however,thedegradation
FrequencyOffsetNormalizedtoSC
(a)CP-OFDMBERevaluatedunderdifferentSNRvaluesand
frequencyoffsets.
SNR(dB)
TimeOffsetNormalizedtoSymbolDuration
(b)CP-OFDMBERevaluatedunderdifferentSNRvaluesand
timeoffsets.
FGURE1ContourandsurfaceplotofCP-0FDMBERinthepresenceofa)residualfrequencyandb)timesynchroniza-
tionerrors.
RegardingtheHPA,weusedthemodelpro-posedin[11],whichisbasedonthegeneralized
memorypolynomialmodel.Inparticular,weconsiderthememorylessCMOSHPAresearchprototypeat28GHz.
ASSESSMENTOFRESIDUALTIMEANDFREQUENCYSYNCHRONIZATIONERRORS
1)ImpactofResidualFrequencyErrors:Toassess
waveformperformanceunderfrequencysynchro-
nizationerrors,theBERiscomputedforeach
waveform.Notably,thesensitivitytofrequency
offsetgrowswithSNR,asthenoisebecomesless
dominant.TakingasareferencetheuncodedBER
performanceofCP-OFDM,Fig.1(a)delineates
threeoperationalregions.RegionIcomprises
thenoise-limitedregion,whereperformanceis
unimpairedbyfrequencyoffset.Onthecontrary,
regionIlinvolvesperformancedominatedby
energylossandinterferencelinkedtothelossof
orthogonalityduetothefrequencyoffset.Finally,
regionIlrepresentsatransitionregion,where
bothnoiseandfrequencyoffsethaveasimilar
impactontheBER.
Regardingtheremainingwaveformvariants,Fig.2(a)showstheBERperformancerelativetothatofCP-OFDMintermsofBERloss(BERloss),whosepercentageiscomputedasfollows:
(2)
BERossmakesthecomparisonofthewave-
formswithrespecttoCP-OFDMimmediately
readable,bothinsignandinmagnitude.Indeed,
anegativeBERlossindicatesimprovedperfor-
mance,whileapositiveBERlossimpliesinferior
performancecomparedtoCP-OFDM.Thus,itis
possibletoobservethat:i)BF-OFDMdegrades
withincreasingSNRinregionsIandIlduetothe
impactoffilterdispersiononISI.Ontheother
hand,asevidenced,thestrictlypositiveandlow
BERlossathighfrequencyoffsetvaluesconfirms
thatIClisnotsignificantlyreducedbytheRB-level
filtering.Indeed,theBERlossremainsclosetozero
withinregionIastheinducedIClisdominated
bycontributionsfromimmediatelyneighboring
subcarriers,whicharenotsufficientlyreducedby
theimprovedfrequencylocalizationattheRB
level.ii)DFT-s-OFDMmayexhibitincreaseddeg-
radationfornormalizedfrequencyoffsetsabove
10-2withinregionIIduetotheinducedsymbol-
dependentphaseramp,inoppositiontothe
flatphaserotationobservedinCP-OFDM[12].
Despitethelatter,theBERlossremainsbelow5%
throughouttheevaluatedSNRandfrequencyoff-
setranges.Finally,ii)acrossregionI,OTFSshows
aslightlypositiveBERlossi.e.,aminimaldegra-
dation.InregionII,theBERlossexhibitsnegative
valuesbuttrendsupwardtowardzeroasthecom-
binedeffectsofnoiseandfrequencyoffsetgrow,
reinforcingOTFS'ssuperiorityoverCP-OFDMin
theBERossforOTFSshiftsintolowpositivevalues
thistransitionalregime.WhenenteringregionII,
remainsbounded.
2)ImpactofResidualTimeErrors:Forthisanalysis,thereceiverisassumedtobeabletoperfectlycompensateforthephaseshiftinthefre-quencydomaininducedbythetimedrift(whichresemblesacircularshiftduetotheCP).There-fore,weanalyzeandcomparetheabilityoftheconsideredwaveformstowithstandtheunavoid-ableISIandICIinterferenceduetoresidualtimesynchronizationerrors.Asinthepreviouscase,theBERiscomputedforallwaveformsundertheabove-mentionedtimeoffsetsandSNRvalues.
Fig.1(b)displaysthecontourplotofthe
uncodedBERforCP-OFDM,whichhelpsto
identifythesamethreeregionsobtainedinthe
previouscase.InregionI,theresidualtimesyn-
chronizationerrorisshorterthantheCPlength,
whileintheothertworegionsitislonger.
Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.
IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine5
BERloss(%)
p-
SNR(dB)
FrequeneyoffsetNormalizedtoSCS
7
1
SNR(dB)
FrequencyOffsetNormalizedtoscS
FrequeneyoffsetNormalizedtoscs
SNR(dB)
SNR(dB)
evaluated
TimeOffstNormalizedtoSymbolDuration
underdifferentSNRvaluestimeoffset.
(a)BERlossevaluatedunderdifferentSNRvalues
frequencyoffset.
DFT-s-0FDM
10⁻¹
TimeOffsetNormalizedtoSymbolDuration
(b)BERloss
and
TimeOffsetNormalizedtoSymbolduration
and
RGURE2.BERasundera)frequencyandb)timeofsets.CP-0FDMisconsideredashaselineforthecomputationotheBERI
ReferringtoFig.2(b),itispossibletoobservethat:
i)DFT-s-OFDMperformswellforoffsetsbelow
theCPduration;ii)BF-OFDMundergoesadet-
rimentduetoataperingaroundtheboundaries
oftheeffectiveCPprotectionwindowrelatedto
theinvolvedfilteringprocesses;iii)OTFSoutper-
formsCP-OFDMfortimeoffsetsexceedingthe
CPdurationofCP-OFDM.Thisenhancedrobust-
nessstemsfromthefactthatthereisoneCPin
OTFS,withalengthequivalenttothecumulative
CPsofallOFDMsymbolswithinaslot.Thissug-
geststhatperformanceisnotdegradedifthetime
offsetiswithintheCPblock.Insuchacase,the
performanceismoretiedtotheSNRregimeof
operationthantothetimemisalignment.
Therefore,albeitwithminordifferences,the
CPprotectsallconsideredwaveformvariants
fromtheimpactoftimesynchronizationerrors
roughlyuptoitsduration.
ASSESSMENTOFTHEHPAIMPACTONTHEWAVEFORMS
1)Single-UserSingle-BeamScenario:Wefirstana-
yzethePAPRandPSD(priortoamplification)to
betterunderstandthewaveforms'behaviorafter
amplification.SincethePAPRorderingofthefour
waveformsispreservedacrossmodulationschemes
andbandwidths[5],[13],thestudyfocusesona
ingthescenariowithoutdigitalpredistortion),
singlemodulationandcodingschemeandasingle
bandwidthwithoutlossofgenerality.
ReferringtoFig.3(a),asexpected,thePAPRdis-tributionofDFT-s-OFDMdifferssignificantlyfromthoseoftheotherwaveforms.Indeed,thePAPRgrowswiththenumberofsubcarriersK.Neverthe-less,DFT-s-OFDMspreadseachsymbolovertheavailablebandwidthbeforetheIDFT.RegardingOTFS,thePAPRdependsonthenumberofOTFSsymbols,sincetheIDFTisperformedalongtheDopplerdomain,andthepilotconfiguration[14].
ReferringtoFig.3(b),thePSDofthediffer-entwaveformsisreported.Inparticular,focusingonthebluelines,representingthePSDbeforetheamplification,itispossibletonotethat,asexpected,thefrequencyresponseoftherectan-gularpulseshape(intheCP-OFDMcase)leadstoahighOoBleakage.WhenitcomestoBF-OFDM,itachievesthebestOoBrejectionwithalmost45dBgaincomparedtoCP-OFDM.Infact,suchasubstantialgainisduetotheimprovedfrequencylocalizationofthefilterusedinthesynthesisfilterbankofBF-OFDM.OTFS(likeCP-OFDM)intro-ducesinterferencetotheneighboringbandsand,hence,anSRRCpulseshapingisadoptedherefortheOTFStoreducetheOoBinterference.
MovingtotheanalysisoftheOoBemission
afteramplification,Fig.4(a)reportstheACLR.
Observingthecurvesmarkedwithsquares(denot-
AnACLRthresholdof30dBisconsidered[15].
Thisarticlehasbeenacceptedforinclusioninafutureissueofthisjournal.Contentisfinalaspresented,withtheexceptionofpagination.
IEEECommunicationsStandardsMagazine
PSD
-10
-20
-30
-40
-60
-70
-80
-90
-100
-500
PAPR(dB)
(a)
CPandDFT-s-OFDMbeforePA
CPand
OTFSbeforePA
BF-OFDMbeforePA
-400-300-200-100100200
Frequency(MHz)
(b)
DFT-s-OFDMafterPA
OTFSafterPA
BF-OFDMafterPA
300400
FGURE3.Waveforms'performanceintermsofPAPRandPSD.a)PAPRcomparisonacrosstheconsideredwaveforms.
b)PSDcomparisonoftheifferentwaveforms.BlulinesrepresentthePSDbeforeamplification,blacklinesafteramplification.
DFT-s-OFDMdemonstratessuperiorperfor-mancecomparedtotheotherwaveforms.ThisadvantagestemsfromthestrongdependenceofHPA-inducednonlineardistortiononbothPAPRandbackoff,indicatingthatOoBemissionsaremostlydominatedbyHPA-inducednonlin-earities.ThisinterpretationisfurthersupportedbythePSDanalysisinFig.3(b)(blackcurves),whichshowsthatthespectralcontainmentben-efitsofBFOFDM,followingtheHPAstage,arelesspronouncedneartheallocatedbandwidth,whereadjacentchannels(themostsusceptibletointerference)lie.Infact,BF-OFDMachievesareductionintherequiredOBOtosatisfyACLRconstraintsbyonly0.5dBrelativetoCP-OFDM.
Conversely,DFTspreadingachieves
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 2025年人防工程管理考试真题及答案
- 2026年电子工程师高级职称评审强化训练模拟试卷及答案
- 2026年电子工程高级职称评审资格考试模拟试卷及答案
- 2026年电子CAD测试题及答案
- 2026年电网知识决赛试题及答案
- 2026年新疆货运从业资格证考试模拟题库(含答案)
- 2026年电梯安装维修工三级理论试卷及答案
- 2026年全国中小学教师资格考试结构化面试各地模拟题库汇编及答案
- 2026年产妇体质测试题库(含答案)
- 2026中国方便食品产业发展现状及消费者偏好与市场机会评估报告
- 2026秋小学人教版数学五年级上册第五单元学情测试练习卷含参考答案
- 大专护理专业毕业综合考试题(含详细答案)
- 工程力学 第2版 课件 第7章-扭转
- 试用期聘用合同范本6篇
- 2026年甘肃执法证考试题库及参考答案
- 成人留置导尿最佳实践指南解读
- 灵魂的拷问与觉醒:高中语文选择性必修上册第三单元教学设计
- 2025甘肃农信招聘官网笔试历年典型考题及考点剖析附带答案详解
- 合肥市完整社区建设实施方案及案例解析(2026~2026年)
- 湖南省2026年高考招生计划-历史类
- 消毒供应室降低纸塑包装物品灭菌后水迹发生率品管圈PDCA案例所有图表均可以直接点击编辑修改
评论
0/150
提交评论