Jiang Ge case 江歌刘鑫案英文版.ppt

JiangGeCase JiangGeJiangGe sMother LiuXinLiuXin sParents ChenShifeng JiangGeCase Group8 PartOneDescriptionPartTwoOpinions LiuXin PartThreeOpinions JiangGe PartFourLegalexplanationPartFiveIWanttoSay PartOne goodrelationship LiuXinmovedtoJiangGe shouse LiuXinwasharassedbyChenShifeng AccordingtoJiangGe smother LiuXinfearedthatChenShifengcameheretofindher JiangGethenrushedtothestationtotakeLiuXinback ChenShifengwaitedinfrontoftheapartment JiangGeletLiuXinentertheroom debatedwithChenShifengandstoppedhimfromenteringthehouse JiangSongcriedforhelp butLiuXindidnotopenthedoor LiuXincalledthepolice JiangGedied LiuXinliedandshedidn tattendJiangGe sfuneral AccordingtoLiuXin LiuXinenteredtheroomfirstlytolookforsanitarynapkin Sheheardthesoundof ah Shetriedtoopenthedoorbutfailed Shesuddenlycalledthepolice LiuXinattendedthefuneralbutcouldn tgetin Sinamicro blogInternetmasshunting 人肉搜索 InNovember BeijingNews Jumian sectionledtoameet ThismurdercasewillbeheardonDecember11 15 Somepeoplethinkliuxinshouldbeforgiven It stheanimal snaturethatprotectthemselvesfromdanger Oneshouldtrytoforgetthepainandbegintofacethenewlifeinsteadofcarryingonthepain Weshouldgiveapersonwhohadmadeamistakeachancetocorrectthemisbehavior TherealkillerisChenshifeng andLiuxinisalsoavictim Opinions LiuXin PartTwo Opinions JiangGe PartThree FromthepicturewecanseeJianggeisaoutgoingyounggirl WhenhermotherknewthethingthatherdaughterwaskilledbyLiuxin sex boyfriend shewassosadthatshesaidshewaswillingtogiveeverythinginexchangeforthelifeofherdaughter Thefermentationof Janggecase isderivedfrompeople smoralcognizance JianggewaskilledbecauseofLiuxin Inotherwords LiuxinwasindirectlykilledJiangge AndpeopledidnotcondemnthatLiuxindidnothingtosaveJianggefromruin Nooneknewwhathappened butliuxinrefusedtotestifyincourtafterJianggewaskilledbyherex boyfriend Herdisappearanceandherfamily sindifferencetoJiangge smother onceagain setanewperspectiveonpeople sthreeviews whichcausedatorrentofpublicopinions IrepresentthepeoplewhosupportJiangge smother Asamother herdaughterdiedforherfriendinnocentlyandshejustwantedtoknowthetruth ButLiuxindisappearedover200days Hermotherdoesnotblameherselfishness Thatistheweaknessofhumannature Afterall everyonewillbeafraidfacedwithbloodanddeath andshedidn tknowthathehadaknifeinhishand SoshecanunderstandthatLiuxindidn tgooutagainstthebaddie Butwhatletsheangryissheburnthebridgeaftercrossingit Whydidshesurviveandhavenofeelingofgratitude whydidshehidethetruthfromthefactthatthecasecan tbesolved Asinglemotherlostherdaughterandshedidn tknowwhathappened shefoundLiuxintheonlypersonwhoknewthewholethingtounderstandthesituation Forthehelplessmotheritistheonlynearwaytosupportherdaughter ThemotherbegtomeetLiuxinbecauseshewantedtoknowthetruth Liuxinmaynotbeabletosaythehelplessness butsheputoutadevil spose Heractionandherindifferencemakethesinglemotherloseallhope Wehopethesinglemotherwillcontinuetosticktothething Wealsohopethatjusticecandefeatevil firstcaseInrecentyears ChinesecriminalcaseshaveoccurredinNewZealand theUnitedStatesandotherplaces ThecaseofJiangGetriggeredaseriesofquestionsaboutjurisdictionofextraterritorialcriminalcases Opinions Legalexplanation PartFour Accordingtotherelevantprovisionsofterritorialjurisdiction acitizen scriminaloffenceinothercountriesshouldbedealtwithaccordingtotheprincipleofpriorityinthelawoftheplacewherethecrimeoccurs Thatistosay thecountrywherethecrimeoccursisentitledtohavepriorityjurisdiction Accordingtothecriminallawprovisionsofarticletenth whereintheoutsideofPeople sRepublicofChinaofthecrime inaccordancewiththislaw shallbearcriminalresponsibility Althoughthecriminalhasbeentriedinaforeigncountry hecanstillbeheldinaccordancewiththislaw CanChineselawberesponsiblefortheChinesecrime SecondstageInthisstage thecasehaschangedintotheconflictofmamaJiangwithLiu Therelationshipbetweenlawandmorality hasalwaysbeenahigh profileproblem Ingeneral moralityestablishesahigherstandardofadvocacyanddoesnothavetheforceofcoercion andthelawisestablishedasthebottomlineofthebehavior Someactsarecontrarytovirtuebutnotillegal Itdependsonwhetherthepartiesbearthedutyofassistance Theobligationofrescuecomesfromthreesituations First basedonstatutoryduties suchasthepolice sobligationtoprotectthepublic thedutyofkindergartenteacherstocareforchildren etc Secondly basedonlegalrelations suchasbetweenhusbandandwifeandbetweenfatherandson Third basedonthefirstbehavior suchastheadultwithaneighbor schildtoswim theadultisresponsibleforthechild Leavingsb inthelurchmaynotbeillegal Ingeneral leavingsb inthelurchdoesnotconstituteaviolationofthelaw ItseemstoshowthatLiuXindoesnothaveacriminalresponsibilityforthedeathofJiangGe Butthisisjusta criminalresponsibility Thereisalsoalegalresponsibilitycalled civilliability Jiang smothercanclaimtwoclaimsforcivilcompensation first thecivilclaimforthemurderer IfChenShiFengisunabletobeartheliabilityforcompensation LiuXinshallgivehimtherightcompensation Secondly hewillclaimformentaldamagetoLiuXin ThereasonistheprovisionsofArticle1oftheSupremePeople scourt sinterpretationofseveralissuesconcerningthedeterminationoftheliabilityfordamagesforciviltort Lawshouldbringjusticetothedead Whatreallyhappenedonthatmiserablenight Infact opinionsthatLiulockedthedoorandJiangdiedforLiuhavenotbeendefiniteconclusionsbynow Somostpeoplehavejudgeditbasedonunclearfacts andevenguesswork Insuchcircumstances whenwefeelsorryforJiangandhermother shouldn twebemorecarefulinjudgingLiu Themurdernarrativemaybeeasytounderstand buthumanityishardtofathom ForLiu sbehaviorandpsyche therecannotbetotallycorrectanswers WhatdidshedowhenthekillingtookplaceandwhyshewasrefusingtomeetJiang smother Shemayonlyknowthetruth SomemediaoutletsandpeopleaccuseLiuofbeingruthless butwhoreallyknowswhatsheactuallythinks Accusingsomeoneofhavingactedimmorallyiseasybutalsoirresponsible IWanttoSayPartFive Thesuspecthasbeencapturedandawaitstrial ToforgivethesuspectornotisuptoJiang smother AsforLiu sfamily wedonothavetherighttoforceanapology Actually weshouldrealizethatwecandonothingaboutit What smore weshouldnotpassamoraljudgmenttosowhatredbetweenthetwofamilies Infact Jiang smother sdisputewithLiuistheresultofthemurder Actua