




已阅读5页,还剩15页未读, 继续免费阅读
版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
MANAGEMENTOFCHANGEOFCHEMICALPROCESSCONTROLSYSTEMSPAPERH15MANAGEMENTOFCHANGEOFCHEMICALPROCESSCONTROLSYSTEMSABSTRACTMANAGEMENTOFCHANGEMOCHASBEENRECOMMENDEDTOBEANIMPORTANTPARTOFCHEMICALPROCESSSAFETYSINCETHEBRITISHINQUIRYBOARDSINVESTIGATIONREPORTOFTHE1974FLIXBOROUGHUKINCIDENT1THEUSAOCCUPATIONALSAFETYANDHEALTHADMINISTRATIONOSHAREGULATIONFORMALIZEDMOCASONEOFTHE14ELEMENTSOFITSPROCESSSAFETYMANAGEMENTREGULATIONIN19992HOWEVER,MOSTFACILITIESFOCUSEDTHEIRMOCPROGRAMONEQUIPMENTCHANGES,PARTICULARLYCHANGESTHATWOULDCHANGETHEPIDSOREQUIPMENTSPECIFICATIONSPROCEDURALCHANGES,ORGANIZATIONALCHANGESANDCOMPUTERCONTROLSYSTEMCHANGESARENOTUNIVERSALLYCONSIDEREDWITHINTHESCOPEOFTHEMOCPROGRAMEVENTHOUGHFORMALMOCISALSOAPARTOFTHEISO9000ANDISO14000GLOBALMANAGEMENTSTANDARDS,THENEEDFORCONTROLLINGCHANGESTOPLANTCOMPUTERSOFTWAREISNOTGENERALLYACKNOWLEDGEDSEVERALRECENTINCIDENTS,INWHICHADEGRADEDCONTROLSYSTEMHASBEENIDENTIFIEDASONEOFTHECONTRIBUTINGFACTORS,MOSTNOTABLYASALARMFLOODSORBYPASSEDSAFEGUARDS,HAVEPUTTHESPOTLIGHTONTHENEEDTOMAINTAINTHECONTROLSYSTEMEFFECTIVENESSTHEGAININGRECOGNITIONOFTHEFUNCTIONALSAFETYINSTRUMENTEDSYSTEMSTANDARDS,ISA8401ANDISO61511,WITHMOCASAPARTOFITSSAFETYLIFECYCLECONCEPT,HASHELPEDTHEABNORMALSITUATIONMANAGEMENTCONSORTIUM,THEWORKOFTHEBRITISHHEALTHANDSAFETYEXECUTIVEONALARMMANAGEMENTANDTHERECOMMENDATIONOFSCADASYSTEMASSESSMENTBYTHEUSAOFFICEPIPELINESAFETYAREAMONGTHEPOSITIVEINDICATORSTHATREGULATORSANDSAFETYPROFESSIONALSAREATTEMPTINGTOADDSOFTWARECHANGESTOTHEVERYIMPORTANTMOCPROGRAMKEYWORDSMANAGEMENTOFCHANGE,MOC,SCADA,DCS,SIS,OSHA,ABNORMALSITUATIONMANAGEMENT,ALARMMANAGEMENTINTRODUCTIONMANAGEMENTOFCHANGEMOCPROCEDURESWEREFIRSTFORMALIZEDINTHEFLEDGLINGNUCLEARPOWERINDUSTRYWEST,1992ANDQUICKLYSPREADTOTHEDEFENSEINDUSTRYMILSTD973SEVERALDIFFERENTNAMESWEREUSEDTODESCRIBEMOC,INCLUDINGCONCURRENTENGINEERING,PROCESSCHANGECONTROL,ANDCONFIGURATIONMANAGEMENTMOCPROCEDURESHAVERECEIVEDINCREASEDATTENTIONDUETOTHEINTRODUCTIONOFREQUIREMENTSWITHINTHENEWOSHAANDEPAPROCESSSAFETYMANAGEMENTREGULATIONSOSHA1992EPA,1998INTHEUSATHEMORERECENTISO9000QUALITYINITIATIVESISO9000HAVEPROVIDEDFURTHERSIGNIFICANCETOTHENEEDFORPROCESSCHANGECONTROLMANAGEMENTHOWEVER,MANYFIRMSAPPLIEDMOCONLYTOEQUIPMENTANDFIELDOPERATIONALPROCEDURECHANGESTHEINTENTOFALLMOCSTANDARDSANDREGULATIONSCLEARLYINCLUDESPROCESSCONTROLSYSTEMSMOCSPARKEDBYCATASTROPHICINCIDENTSABSENCEOFMANAGEMENTCONTROLOVERPROCESSCHANGESHASRESULTEDINSEVERALCATASTROPHICFAILURESONEOFTHEFIRSTCATASTROPHICINCIDENTSTOHAVEIDENTIFIEDMOCASAROOTCAUSEWASTHEFLIXBOROUGHACCIDENTIN1974THEUKROYALCOMMISSIONFLIXBOROUGH,1975RECOMMENDEDTHATCHEMICALPLANTSINSTITUTEMOCPROCEDURESTOAVOIDSUCHDEVASTATINGACCIDENTSALMOSTEVERYMAJORINCIDENTCANBELINKEDTOACHANGETHATWASNOTSUBJECTEDTOAPROPERSAFETYREVIEWASREQUIREDBYMOCSANDERS,1993KLETZ,1988FOLLOWINGTHEBHOPALINCIDENT,THEFORMATIONOFTHECENTERFORCHEMICALPROCESSSAFETYBYTHEAMERICANINSTITUTEOFCHEMICALENGINEERSAICHELEADEVENTUALLYTOTHEPUBLICATIONOFTHEMAJORPRINCIPLESOFPROCESSSAFETY,INCLUDINGMOCTHEAICHEDEFINITIONAICHE1992OFMOCISATEMPORARYORPERMANENTSUBSTITUTION,ALTERATION,REPLACEMENTNOTINKIND,MODIFICATIONBYADDITIONORDELETIONOFCRITICALPROCESSEQUIPMENT,APPLICABLECODES,PROCESSCONTROL,CATALYSTSORCHEMICALS,FEEDSTOCKS,OPERATINGLIMITS,MECHANICALPROCEDURES,ELECTRICALPROCEDURES,SAFETYPROCEDURES,EMERGENCYRESPONSEEQUIPMENTFROMTHEPRESENTCONFIGURATIONOFTHECRITICALPROCESSEQUIPMENT,PROCEDURES,OROPERATINGLIMITSINTHEAFTERMATHOFTHE1989PHILLIPSPOLYETHYLENEPLANTDISASTER,OSHAPUBLISHEDTHEPROCESSSAFETYMANAGEMENTREGULATIONWITHTHEFOLLOWINGEXCERPTDEFININGMOCIN29CFR1910119SECTIONLTHEEMPLOYERSHALLESTABLISHANDIMPLEMENTWRITTENPROCEDURESTOMANAGECHANGESEXCEPTFORREPLACEMENTSINKINDTOPROCESSCHEMICALS,TECHNOLOGY,EQUIPMENT,ANDPROCEDURESAND,CHANGESTOFACILITIESTHATAFFECTACOVEREDPROCESSTHEPROCEDURESSHALLASSURETHATTHEFOLLOWINGCONSIDERATIONSAREADDRESSEDPRIORTOANYCHANGEITHETECHNICALBASISFORTHEPROPOSEDCHANGEIIIMPACTOFCHANGEONSAFETYANDHEALTHIIIMODIFICATIONSTOOPERATINGPROCEDURESIVNECESSARYTIMEPERIODFORTHECHANGEANDVAUTHORIZATIONREQUIREMENTSFORTHEPROPOSEDCHANGEEMPLOYEESINVOLVEDINOPERATINGAPROCESSANDMAINTENANCECONTRACTEMPLOYEESWHOSEJOBTASKSWILLBEAFFECTEDBYACHANGEINTHEPROCESSSHALLBEINFORMEDOF,ANDTRAINEDIN,THECHANGEPRIORTOSTARTUPOFTHEPROCESSORAFFECTEDPARTOFTHEPROCESSIFACHANGECOVEREDBYTHISPARAGRAPHRESULTSINACHANGEINTHEPROCESSSAFETYINFORMATIONREQUIREDBYPARAGRAPHD,SUCHINFORMATIONSHALLBEUPDATEDACCORDINGLYIFACHANGECOVEREDBYTHISPARAGRAPHRESULTSINACHANGEINTHEOPERATINGPROCEDURESORPRACTICESREQUIREDBYPARAGRAPHF,SUCHPROCEDURESORPRACTICESSHALLBEUPDATEDACCORDINGLYTHETENETSOFQUALITYMANAGEMENTALSOCONTAINAMANAGEMENTELEMENTESSENTIALLYIDENTICALINPHILOSOPHYASTHEPROCESSSAFETYMOCSECTION88OFTHEISO9004ANSI/ASQCQ94ISO9000ISENTITLED“DESIGNCHANGECONTROLCONFIGURATIONMANAGEMENT”SECTION116ISENTITLED“PROCESSCHANGECONTROL”THEREFORE,THETOTALQUALITYMANAGEMENTINITIATIVEHASACHANGEMANAGEMENTREQUIREMENTEXTREMELYSIMILARTOTHEMOCPRINCIPLESDEFINEDHEREINTHEFIRSTSPECIFICMENTIONOFMOCCONCEPTSINTHEPETROLEUMPRODUCTIONSAFETYANDLOSSPREVENTIONLITERATUREWASTHEAPIRECOMMENDEDPRACTICE,MANAGEMENTOFPROCESSHAZARDSAPI1990THECULLENREPORTCULLEN1988RECOMMENDATIONSLEDTOBRITISHREGULATIONSINTHENORTHSEATHATALSOINCLUDEDMOCREQUIREMENTSMOCAPPLIESTOCONTROLSYSTEMSNOTETHATPARAGRAPH4OFTHEOSHAREGULATIONABOVELINKSMOCTO“PROCESSSAFETYINFORMATION”,WHICHINTURNMENTIONSSAFETYSYSTEMSANDCONTROLSYSTEMSHENCE,OSHAINCLUDESTHEENTIRECONTROLSYSTEMWITHINTHEJURISDICTIONOFPROCESSSAFETYREGULATIONSMANYOSHAOFFICIALINTERPRETATIONLETTERSALSOREINFORCEVIEWPOINTTHEAICHEDEFINITIONABOVECLEARLYDEFINESPROCESSCONTROLWITHINTHEAREASTOBEWITHINMOCCONTROLPROCEDURESTHESAFETYINSTRUMENTEDSYSTEMSSISSTANDARDS,SUCHASISA84ANDIEC61511AICHE1993ISA1996IEC61511DEFINEASAFETYLIFECYCLECONCEPTFORSAFETYCONTROLSYSTEMCOMPONENTSINWHICHMOCISHIGHLIGHTEDMANYOTHERRECENTLYUPDATEDORREVISEDSTANDARDSCROSSREFERENCETHENEEDFORMOCTHEEUROPEANATEXRULESONHAZARDOUSAREACLASSIFICATIONAREBUTONEEXAMPLETHEUSOFFICEOFPIPELINESAFETYISSUEDANADVISORYTHATSTRONGLYSUGGESTSPIPELINESCADASYSTEMSBESUBJECTEDTOMOCPROCEDURESTHISRECOMMENDATIONRESULTEDFROMTHEANALYSISOFTHEBILLINGHAMPIPELINECATASTROPHICACCIDENT,WHICHLISTEDREDUCEDCONTROLSYSTEMRESPONSETIMEASAROOTCAUSEOFTHEINCIDENTTHEREFORE,MOCMUSTBEAPPLIEDTOALLCHANGESINTHEPROCESSCONTROLSYSTEMELEMENTSOFPROCESSCONTROLSYSTEMSSOMEOFTHEMAJORELEMENTSOFATYPICALMODERNPROCESSCONTROLSYSTEMSINCLUDEHARDWAREFIELDINSTRUMENTATIONDATAHIGHWAYLOGICSOLVERSCOMPUTERS,ELECTRONICDEVICESPOWERSUPPLIESSOFTWAREOPERATINGSYSTEMDCS/SCVADA/PLCSYSTEMSOFTWAREAPPLICATIONSOFTWAREALARMSYSTEMAPPLYINGMOCTOHARDWARECHANGESISSIMILARTOTHEEQUIVALENTPRACTICESFORCHANGESTOOTHERPROCESSEQUIPMENTTHREEAREASHAVEPROVEDTOBEMOREDIFFICULTTOBRINGWITHINMOCJURISDICTIONCONFIGURATIONLIMITVALUESOPERATINGSYSTEMSCHANGESTOTHEPROCESSCONTROLCONFIGURATION,SUCHASADDINGALARMS,APPEARSTOBEABENIGNCHANGE,HOWEVER,THECUMULATIVEEFFECTOFADDINGTOOMANYALARMSCANCAUSEALARMFLOODSCHANGESTOLIMITVALUES,EVENTEMPORARYCHANGES,CANLEADTOSAFETYPROBLEMSSEVERALINCIDENTSHAVEBEENATTRIBUTEDTOTEMPORARYCHANGESTHATHAVENOTBEENRESTOREDTOTHEIRORIGINALINTERLOCKLIMITVALUESCHANGESTOOPERATINGSYSTEMSAREEVENMORECHALLENGING,SINCEMINORSOFTWAREPATCHES,LARGERSYSTEMUPGRADES,OREVENMAJORVERSIONUPGRADESAREPOSSIBLETHEONLYWAYTOBESURETHATNOIMPACTONTHECONTROLSYSTEMHASBEENMADEISTOCONDUCTANOTHERSITEACCEPTANCETESTPLANFORCONTROLSYSTEMSCHANGEWHILEPROCESSEQUIPMENTISTYPICALLYDESIGNEDFORA2030YEARPROJECTLIFE,SCADA,SISANDDCSSYSTEMSAREMORELIKELYTOBEREPLACEDORSERIOUSLYUPGRADEDONA10YEARCYCLEORLESSTHEREFORE,MAJORFUTURECHANGEOUTOFTHECONTROLSYSTEMMUSTALSOBECONSIDEREDINTHEORIGINALPROJECTPLANWHEREAS,FORWARDTHINKINGPROJECTDESIGNERSPLANNEDFORFUTURECHANGEOUTBYSPECIFYINGPOWERSUPPLIESWITHADDITIONALPARALLELLOADCAPABILITY,JUNCTIONBOXESWITHLARGESPARECAPACITY,PLCSWITHADDITIONALSPARECONTACTCAPABILITY,ANDTELEMETRYWITHADDITIONALFREQUENCYPAIRS,THEEVOLVINGEXPANSIONOFOPERATIONSOVERTHEYEARSSOMETIMESSCAVENGESTHECHANGEOUTCAPABILITYIFTHEORIGINALPROJECTDOCUMENTATIONHASIDENTIFIEDTHESPARECAPACITYASRESERVEDFORFUTURECHANGEOUT,THENTHEMANAGEMENTOFCHANGESYSTEMSHOULDKEEPOPERATIONSMANAGEMENTAWAREOFENCROACHMENTSONTHENEXTCONTROLSYSTEMUPGRADEPROJECTDIGITALBABELINHISLETTERTOTHEEDITOROFTHEISAINTECHMONTHLYMAGAZINE,INTERNATIONALLYNOTEDCONTROLSYSTEMAUTHORBELALIPTAKLIPTAK,2004WARNEDOFTHESAFETYIMPLICATIONSOFTHECHAOTICSTATEOFTHECURRENTLY8DIFFERENTDIGITALDATAHIGHWAYSWITHTHECONCOMITANTPROBLEMSOFMESSAGETRANSLATIONHEALSODEPLOREDTHECONTROLSYSTEMVENDORPRACTICEOFNOTINCLUDINGTESTEDWORKINGCONTROLSOFTWARE,LEAVINGTHEUSERSTOSELECTAMONGMANYINDEPENDENTSOFTWARESUPPLIERSAPPLYINGMOCLESSONSLEARNEDTOPROCESSCONTROLTHEMOSTIMPORTANTLESSONLEARNEDINAPPLYINGMOCPROCEDURESINTHEEARLIEREXPERIENCESWASTOCATEGORIZEFACILITIESINTOSAFETYCRITICALANDNONSAFETYCRITICALSYSTEMSIFNONSAFETYCRITICALEQUIPMENTARESUBJECTEDTOSAFETYREVIEWATTHELEVELOFDETAILREQUIREDBYSAFETYCRITICALITEMS,THENTHEMOCSYSTEMBOGSDOWNINITSOWNPAPERWORKWHILETHISMAYWORKFORPROCESSAREASTHATARENOTSAFETYCRITICALORINSTRUMENTLOOPSTHATARECONTROLLINGNONHAZARDOUSSYSTEMS,THEREMAYBEMANYCONTROLSUBSYSTEMSDATAHIGHWAY,OPERATINGSYSTEMS,ETCWHICHCOMINGLESAFETYANDNONSAFETYCRITICALSYSTEMSITISINTERESTINGTONOTETHATEACHRECOMMENDEDPRACTICEORREGULATIONDELEGATESTHELEVELOFSAFETYREVIEWDETAILTOTHEAPPLICABLEFACILITYMANAGEMENTWHILESOMEOFTHEMANAGEMENTPRACTICESESPOUSEDINTHERECENTMOCSTANDARDSHAVELONGBEENPRACTICEDBYMANYFIRMS,ITISTHEFORMALIZATIONOFMOCANDTHEABILITYTOAUDITTHEPROGRAMTHATISRELATIVELYNEWTOTHEPETROLEUMANDCHEMICALINDUSTRYTHISTRANSLATESINTOPAPERWORK/DOCUMENTATIONOFCHANGESAPPLIEDTOTHECONTROLSYSTEMOPERATORSANDENGINEERSCONCLUSIONSMANAGEMENTOFCHANGEISREQUIREDTOMAINTAINTHESAFETYINTEGRITYOFTHECHEMICALPROCESSFACILITYADMINISTRATIONOFACOSTEFFECTIVEMANAGEMENTOFCHANGEPROGRAMREQUIRESCAREFULPLANNINGSINCETHEBRUNTOFMANAGEMENTOFCHANGEOPERATIONALEFFECTIVENESSISDEPENDENTONTHEFIRSTANDSECONDLINEPROCESSSUPERVISORS,ASIMPLEMANAGEMENTOFCHANGEPROCEDURALWORKFLOWANDADOCUMENTMANAGEMENTSYSTEMAREPRACTICALNECESSITIESFURTHERMORE,VARIOUSSCREENINGTECHNIQUESHAVEBEENUSEDTOOPTIMIZESCARCETECHNICALRESOURCES,PARTICULARLYBYALLOWINGSMALLHAZARD/LOWRISKCHANGESTOBEANALYZEDANDAUTHORIZEDWITHOUTTHENEEDFORUNNECESSARYREDTAPEFREQUENTVERIFICATIONOFACTUALPRACTICEISPARTICULARLYCRITICALUNTILMANAGEMENTOFCHANGEBECOMESPARTOFTHECORPORATECULTUREACKNOWLEDGMENTSTHEAUTHORSWOULDLIKETOTHANKOURCOLLEAGUESFORTHEMANYDISCUSSIONSANDPROJECTS,WHICHASSISTEDINTHEEVOLUTIONOFTHEIDEASANDCONCEPTSPRESENTEDHEREINBIBLIOGRAPHYPROCESSSAFETYMANAGEMENTOFHIGHLYHAZARDOUSCHEMICALEXPLOSIVESANDBLASTINGAGENTSFINALRULE,29CFRPART1910,DEPARTMENTOFLABOR,OCCUPATIONALSAFETYANDHEALTHADMINISTRATION,WASHINGTON,DC,FEBRUARY24,1992,FEDERALREGISTER,VOLUME57,NO36THEFLIXBOROUGHCYCLOHEXANEDISASTER,HERMAJESTYSSTATIONERYOFFICE,LONDON,1975TAKLETZ,PLANTOPERATIONSPROGRESS,VOL5,3,AMERICANINSTITUTEOFCHEMICALENGINEERS,JULY1986,P136PLANTGUIDELINESFORTECHNICALMANAGEMENTOFCHEMICALPROCESSSAFETY,CENTERFORCHEMICALPROCESSSAFETYOFTHEAMERICANINSTITUTEOFCHEMICALENGINEERS,NEWYORK,1992ISO9000,QUALITYMANAGEMENTOFINDUSTRIALFACILITIES,LONDON,UK,LATESTEDITIONREVIEWSAFETYQUESTIONSINTHENUCLEARPOWERINDUSTRY,10CFR5059,DEPARTMENTOFENERGY,NUCLEARREGULATORYCOMMISSION,WASHINGTON,DCMILITARYSTANDARD973,CONFIGURATIONMANAGEMENTATGOVERNMENTFACILITIES,MILSTD973,DEPARTMENTOFDEFENSE,WASHINGTON,DCRISKMANAGEMENTPROGRAMSFORCHEMICALACCIDENTALRELEASEPREVENTION,TITLE40CFRPART68SECTION6836PREVENTIONPROGRAMMANAGEMENTOFCHANGE,ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONADMINISTRATION,WASHINGTON,DCRECOMMENDEDPRACTICESFORDEVELOPMENTOFASAFETYANDENVIRONMENTALPROGRAMFOROUTERCONTINENTALSHELFOCSOPERATIONSANDFACILITIES,APIRECOMMENDEDPRACTICE75,AMERICANPETROLEUMINSTITUTE,WASHINGTONDCLATESTE
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 【正版授权】 IEC 62676-4:2025 EN Video surveillance systems for use in security applications - Part 4: Application guidelines
- 甘肃课件音频配音
- 2025合同终止协议模板示例
- 基于分类存储策略的流式货架分配存取算法的创新设计与实践
- 节段拼装方案
- 爱网页课件教学课件
- 爱牙知识体系培训内容课件
- 诗尼曼产品知识培训心得
- 2024年7月母婴护理中级考试题
- 2025年2月热工仪表检修工练习题库含答案
- 2025年国企财务招聘笔试题和答案(基础知识测试题)
- 2025年人教版新教材数学二年级上册教学计划(含进度表)
- 供应商分级管理办法
- 广州小升初密考数学试卷
- 赠送公司股权协议书范本
- 医院清洗服务方案-清洗项目实施方案设计完整流程
- 美睫培训课件模板
- 交警大队保密管理制度
- 2025年数据治理及数据应用优化服务项目需求
- 快递车车辆管理制度
- 心理健康考试题及答案
评论
0/150
提交评论