关于中学考试练习试卷的反馈

关于中学考试练习试卷的反馈SchoolLeaders’BriefingSession5March20xxHKDSEPracticePapersPapersfor24CategoryAsubjectsproducedtofamiliariseteachersandstudentswiththeformatandrequirementsoftheHKDSEexamsFundedbyEDBDeliveredtoschoolsundersecureconditionsinearlyJanuary,withprovisionalmarkingschemesuploadedthenextdayforteachers'referenceAllpapersandmarkingschemesavailableonHKEAAwebsitefrommidFebruary(.hk/tc/HKDSE/Practice_Papers/index.html)23ResearchStudy(CoreSubjects)20schoolsselectedbasedon2010HKCEEresults;stratifiedsamplingbutonvoluntarybasisAbout2,800students'scriptscollectedCEMLpracticepaperstakenasschoolmockexamsunderstandardexamconditions,withHKEAAobserverAnswersscriptsscannedandmarkedonscreenMarkingstatisticsandsamplesofperformanceanalysedResearchStudy(ElectiveSubjects)About100to400scriptscollectedfromarangeofschoolsMarkedandsamplesofperformanceanalysedValuableinformationaboutactualperformanceofstudentsGoodlearningopportunityforHKEAAstaffandexampersonnelTrialrunofmarkingandgradingsystem4FeedbacktoSchoolsOver50briefingsessionsconductedforsubjectteachersbetweenmidJanuaryand29FebruaryExamrequirements,assessmentcriteriaandstandards,andannotatedsamplesofperformanceprovidedCommentsonstrengthsandweaknessesofcandidatesandadvicegivenInformationavailableonHKEAAwebsite

56LimitationsoftheResearchStudySamplesizeStudentreadinessMarkingdonebyasmallproportionofexperiencedCE/ALexaminers/markersMarksforspeakingpaperscollectedfromschoolsforreference,notstandardisedOnlypaper-levelstatisticsavailableatthisstageStatisticaldatatobeviewedwithcaution中国语文科8中国语文科设有五卷：卷一﹕阅读能力(20%)，全部试题均须作答卷二：写作能力(20%)，要求考生写长文一篇或 短文二至三篇卷三：聆听能力(10%)，全部试题均须作答卷四：说话能力(14%)，分为「朗读」及「口语 沟通」两部分卷五：综合能力考核(16%)，全部试题均须作答9整体表现数据卷分数平均分(%)标准差(%)18434.111.2220653.812.438450.010.9510038.69.610卷一阅读能力:篇章取材与人生和亲情有关《目送》、《认识一个十八岁的人》与中国文化、文学有关《史记．儒林列传》结构较紧密手法能凸显文章的主旨和立意具思考空间11卷一:考生的整体表现及常见错误主要考核考生的阅读能力，包括理解、分析、感受、鉴赏、运用不同策略等能力；重视思维和分析能力，并考核考生对中国文化、文学的认知和素养。考生一般于直接考问内容重点的考题或客观问题表现甚佳；于辨识写作和修辞手法的考题则表现中规中矩表现有欠理想的题目，包括综合全文主旨、分析结构和手法作用，以及理解文言字词或句式。总括而言，考生对处理比较说明或发挥个人见解方面，仍须多加努力。今次所选的篇章有白话文及文言文，考生一般于文言篇章表现欠理想。

12卷二写作能力设题要求：考生宜透过审题，思考写作立意，选取材料，书写文章。审题第一题：「抉择」与「了解自己」第二题：「快乐」与「富庶的物质生活」；「基础」与「难以」第三题：「纷争源于不自知」与图片寓意立意为文章定下主题或主旨，以确立文章的写作方向。选材从个人亲身经历、生活见闻、书本知识、时人隽语去想象、联想，再作出分析、比较，然后选取一些具深刻意义和动人情韵的题材。

表达、组织、书写13卷二:评分重点内容表达结构标点字体立意深刻、选材切当或独特立意明确、选材恰当立意未明、选材芜杂用词精确、文句简洁流畅、表达手法纯熟灵活用词恰当、文句尚通顺、表达手法平稳用词欠准确、文句冗赘、表达手法拙劣结构紧密、有条不紊、轻重有致上下文见关联、尚具条理、详略尚可上下文没关联、交代紊乱、详略失衡标点运用准确、字体端正美观标点运用平稳、字体端正标点运用错误、字体难以辨认14错别字一般评分原则0-1个给3分2-4个给2分5-7个给1分8个或以上不给分重错不计15卷二:考生整体表现题目选题分布(%)平均分(%)标准差(%)一：面对重大抉择而了解自己49.656.212.7二：「快乐」与「富庶的物质生活」的关系47.951.411.5三：纷争源于人的不自知2.551.714.116卷二:考生整体表现立意与选材：一般能掌握题目要求。部分考生立意平凡、选材芜杂。词句与表达手法：表达大致恰当，文句基本达意，偶有口语或潮语入文。未能做到用词精确，文句简洁扼要。少用修辞及表达技巧。文章组织：边写边想，没刻意布局。少有做到不枝不蔓。标点字体：标点大致恰当，但变化较少。字体较潦草，笔划模糊。17卷三聆听能力第一段录音场境：同学一起讨论有关神话的戏剧主题：神话的分类和作用第二段录音场境：戏剧演员跟观众交流主题：演员分享演戏的心得和体会第三段录音场境：课堂讨论主题：神话的意义和价值18卷三:考生整体表现考核考生辨明说话者立场、观点、论据、说话技巧、语气等聆听能力。考生一般于撷取信息的题目甚佳；综合整理、归纳分类的题目表现中规中矩。但若试题要求考生依据语境推论分析，并须简略说明或发挥个人见解，一般表现较弱。部分考生审题不周、答非所问；又或于答题时词不达意、概念不清、脱离语境或理解错误。

19卷五综合能力考核题目试以学生会候选内阁主席文尔雅或武娉娉的身分，撰写一篇演讲辞，在学生会选举咨询大会上发表，提出所属内阁的竞选口号。考核理解、思考、组织、文字表达等能力。考生须聆听录音、阅读文字图表后，再写作。此卷试题多与生活事务有关。1920卷五:考生整体表现

考生于演辞格式方面鲜见犯错，对理念立场亦十分清晰；惟多有忽略大会背景，于撰写竞选口号表现中规中矩，偶见潮语英文。至于措辞语气方面，考生多只能做到有基本礼貌，得体者少。于整合拓展资料方面，考生多能整合政纲名称、措施项目，但整合资料颇见脱漏，不少漏引调查数据；少引用精确数据解释措施之好处。一般考生答题内容字数多惟讯息少。考生于见解论证方面，一般能依聆听所指示之方向批评对手政纲，少数表现佳者意见中肯，有理有据。表现中规中矩的考生，一般论述未深，理据不多；表现较弱者则只照抄聆听考材，而理据薄弱。考生答题组织大多稳妥，起承转合，段落分明，但不少考生时间分配不善，整合拓展多，而见解论证少，以至结构失衡。考生一般答题时用词平实，偶有语病，错别字逾六个者，为数不少；较少考生能做到文字清通，修饰得宜。EnglishLanguage22AssessmentFrameworkComponentWeightingDurationPublicexamPaper1Reading Paper2WritingPaper3Listening&IntegratedSkillsPaper4Speaking20%25%30%10%1hr30mins2hours2hours20minutesSchool-basedassessment15%23SummaryStatisticsPaperMaxmarkMean(%)S.D.(%)18638.219.2221044.021.0310442.722.524Paper2WritingPartA(10%)Short,guidedtaskAbout200wordsSituation,purpose&relevantinformationprovidedPartB(15%)Longer,moreopen-endedtask About400words Choiceofoneoutof8questions Eachbasedononeofthe8modulesintheElectivePart25MarkingDoublemarkingbyquestionThreedomainsforassessment:Content,LanguageandOrganisation,withequalweightingforeach26Paper2RawMarkStatisticsPaperMarksawardedpermarkerMean(%)S.D.(%)2A218.8(41.9)4.5(21.4)2B219.8(46.7)4.4(21.0)27Paper2BRawMarkStatisticsThemePopularityMean(outof21)S.D.(outof21)No.ofcands.%Drama2107.396.965.54Shortstories2097.356.334.72Poems&songs1013.5510.775.13Popularculture1746.127.294.828Paper2BRawMarkStatisticsThemePopularityMean(outof21)S.D.(outof21)No.ofcands.%Sportscomm.47916.8511.024.08Debating33411.7512.054.2WorkplaceEnglish85229.979.474.08Socialissues48417.0510.914.5529AdviceforCandidates(1)ReadthequestionscarefullyandtrytofulfilalltherequirementsofthetaskDevelopideaswithexamplesandsupportingdetailsPayattentiontowhothewriterandtheintendedreadersareDon’tusepreparedsentences,paragraphsandstockphrasesMemorisedparagraphs/essayswillbedisregardedandnotawardedanymarks.Zeromarkswillbegiventototallymemorisedessays30Candidatesshouldnotwastetimecountingtheno.ofwordswritten.Asageneralguide,+or–10%isacceptable(sobetween360to440for‘about400words’).Qualityismoreimportantthanquantity.

AdviceforCandidates(2)31Paper1ReadingConsistsoftwoparts: PartA-Compulsory PartB-Section1(easier) Section2(moredifficult)CandidateschooseeitherSection1or2CandidatesattemptingSection2canattainuptoLevel5**CandidatesattemptingSection1canattainuptoLevel4only32Paper1Reading

Numberofscripts PartA 2,839 PartB1 1,431(~50%) PartB2 1,419(~50%)*11studentsansweredbothB1andB233ResultsinPartAPartAFullMarkMean(%)SD(%)ReliabilityMCQ957.1823.330.59Non-MCQ3144.8322.340.90Total:4047.6134ResultsinPartB1PartB1FullMarkMean(%)SD(%)ReliabilityMCQ735.3820.140.27Non-MCQ3635.3720.100.89Total:4335.3735ResultsinPartB2PartB1FullMarkMean(%)SD(%)ReliabilityMCQ1248.8320.330.56Non-MCQ3439.4818.040.86Total:4641.9236Paper3ListeningandIntegratedSkillsConsistsoftwoparts: PartA(compulsory)PartB -Section1(easier) -Section2(moredifficult)CandidateschoosetodoeitherSection1or2CandidatesattemptingSection2canattainuptoLevel5**CandidatesattemptingSection1canattainuptoLevel4only37Paper3ListeningandIntegratedSkills

Numberofcandidates:Part3A:2,845Part3B1:1,332(46.74%)Part3B2:1,513(53.26%)38Paper3AResultsFullMarkMean(%)SD(%)Reliability5049.0424.530.9539Part3AScoreDistribution40Paper3PartB1ResultsTaskFullMarkMean(%)SD(%)Reliability51240.2524.830.8361834.1324.380.8971829.2224.840.8741Paper3PartB2ResultsTaskFullMarkMean(%)SD(%)Reliability81854.7118.930.8191853.914.830.69101844.8720.310.8142Papers1and3:GradedApproachNeedtoconvertB1scorestothesamescaleasB2scoresAfterequating,scorescanbecomparedacrossthesetwopartsofthepaper,eventhoughtheydifferinnumberofitems,difficulty,etc.Paperscore=PartAscore+PartBscore43Part3AScoreDistribution44How3B1StudentsPerformedin3A45How3B2StudentsPerformedin3A46Equating(e.g.Paper3)3B1Scores3B2scores5448.............0047Equating3B1Scores3B2scores5448.............0048Equating3B1Scores3B2scores5448.............0049Equating3B1Scores3B2scores5448.............0050PartB1toPartB2ConversionFactorPaperB1convertedtoB2score1Multiplyby0.6523Multiplyby0.73551PartB1toPartB2ConversionFactorExample:Paper3 Candidate’sscorein3B1=26 Candidate’sscoreafterconversion =26x0.735=1952PartB1toPartB2ConversionFactor Inliveexam

Carriedoutwith70,000+candidatesMoresophisticatedmethodused(seepage19of‘GradingProceduresandSRR’booklet)‘Conversionfactor’willvaryfrompapertopaperandfromyeartoyear,dependingonthedifficultyoftheitemsineachpartMaximumlevelacandidatewhoattemptedB1cangetisLevel4intherelevantcomponent数学-必修部分54试卷一:考试形式考试时间:2小时15分钟占必修部分65％

本卷分为两部，全部题目均须作答甲部题目范围为必修部分之基础课题及初中课程基础部分乙部题目范围为必修部分及初中课程基础部分与非基础部分55满分平均分标准差10542.6%23.2%学生表现5656试卷二:考试形式考试时间:1小时15分钟题目类型：多项选择题占必修部分35％

本卷分为两部，全部题目均须作答甲部占本卷分数的2/3乙部占本卷分数的1/3

5757试卷二:考试形式甲部题目范围为必修部分之基础课题及初中课程基础部分乙部题目范围为必修部分及初中课程基础部分与非基础部分58满分平均分标准差4551.7%17.5%学生表现59学生应注意下列各点：审题要小心，表达要清晰及有条理详细列出所有算式及清楚解释如何从前提得出结论掌握一些基本的数学课题，如指数、主项转换、因式分解、百分数、线性方程及坐标等一般建议60对数据处理范畴的名词及其应用有更好的理解发展较强的空间感，如在立体图形中分辨出直角三角形与非直角三角形在解三角题过程中充分利用计算机的记忆空间去储存较多的有效数字探索题目不同部分的相互关系一般建议LiberalStudies6262PaperStructurePaper1(50%):Data-responsequestions3questionsAllcompulsoryPaper2(30%):Extended-responsequestions3extended-responsequestionsAnsweronequestiononly6363MarkingMarkedbyquestionDoublemarkingThirdmarkingandfourthmarkingwhenevernecessaryCriterionfor3rdmarking:>3marksdifferencebetweenthefirsttwomarkersCriterionfor4thmarking:afterthirdmarking,noclosestpairoccurs4thmarkingbyChief/AssistantExaminer6464Paper1:Data-responseQuestionsAllquestionscompulsoryFullmarksofeachquestion:Q1(18marks),Q2(20marks),Q3(20marks)Mean:Q